DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?
General Data
Names:
All Elite Wrestling (2019 - today)
Abbreviations:
AEW
Owners:
Shahid Khan & Tony Khan (2019 - today)
Logos:
 (06.03.2024 - today) (06.03.2024 - today)
 (09.10.2023 - 05.03.2024) (09.10.2023 - 05.03.2024)
 (2019 - 08.10.2023) (2019 - 08.10.2023)
AEW Women's Tag Team Cup AEW Women's Tag Team Cup
AEW Rampage (06.03.2024 - today) AEW Rampage (06.03.2024 - today)
AEW Rampage (13.08.2021 - 05.03.2024) AEW Rampage (13.08.2021 - 05.03.2024)
AEW House Rules AEW House Rules
AEW Dynamite (06.03.2024 - today) AEW Dynamite (06.03.2024 - today)
AEW Dynamite (2019 - 28.02.2024) AEW Dynamite (2019 - 28.02.2024)
AEW Dark: Elevation AEW Dark: Elevation
AEW Dark AEW Dark
AEW Collision AEW Collision
AEW Battle Of The Belts AEW Battle Of The Belts
80.47.74
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 1379
Number of comments: 510
10.0 611x
9.0 321x
8.0 193x
7.0 142x
6.0 42x
5.0 29x
4.0 16x
3.0 13x
2.0 5x
1.0 3x
0.0 4x
Average rating: 8.74  [1379]
Average rating in 2026: 9.00  [215]
Average rating in 2025: 8.57  [223]
Average rating in 2024: 8.53  [219]
Average rating in 2023: 8.68  [195]
Average rating in 2022: 8.72  [176]
Average rating in 2021: 8.88  [170]
Average rating in 2020: 8.55  [104]
Average rating in 2019: 9.26  [77]
Your Options:
Other:
All Elite World wrote on 16.11.2026:
[10.0] "AEW is the greatest wrestling company in the world right now, with incredible storylines and unbelievable matches. Its only downside is the excessive risk-taking, which can lead to serious injuries and potentially shorten wrestlers' careers. But overall, it's an outstanding company, and without a doubt, AEW is where the best wrestle."
Open The Vault wrote on 14.11.2026:
[10.0] "[9.6] AEW in 2026 is the best WRESTLING promotion in the world currently. Dynamite has put on some of the best weekly wrestling we've seen maybe EVER! The streak they've been on when it comes to weekly shows and pay-per-views are unmatched. Consistently great matches and shows and they sign in so much talent that make their shows stand out. They make american wrestling feels like it matters and each show feels like it's made for the passion of professional wrestling."
CurtisCollings wrote on 29.10.2026:
[10.0] "Every single Wednesday night I get to sit down with my Dad and my Brother and enjoy wrestling. I'm 23, my brother is 26, and my dad ain't getting younger, we will only have so much time to share together and AEW gives us the best excuse to get together as a family weekly. My dad grew up watching wrestling in the 80s and 90s and then stopped in the late 2000s and 2010s, we'd watch occasionally but I was raised on old wrestling. AEW is the only modern wrestling that he'll watch weekly and I'm just a small version of my dad. I love AEW and I love that I get 2+ hours with them weekly. Now they just gotta add collision to TSN!"
RichDaviesUK wrote on 23.10.2026:
[10.0] "AEW has made me love professional wrestling again, and in my honest opinion the best professional wrestling company out there."
SavageDylanHRDZ wrote on 16.10.2026:
[5.0] "Let me be clear, I did give them a chance. I was aware of AEW as soon as they announced Double or Nothing 2019, and that was one hell of a PPV. At long last we found a competitor/alternative for WWE since 2001. Fast forward to 2026 - yes, I knew this would happen. I still hear people saying that AEW is the best promotion in North America, that they have the best matches and wrestlers, and that their product is high quality. No, respectfully, but no. I'd like to differ with total honesty. Since 2022 I've noticed cracks and issues within their organization and the more I looked and investigated it the more I realized that they have a lot to account for, and I haven't seen any solution to the matter - the biggest of which involves their identity. Yes, identity - NJPW has strong style because they believe in having legit and real matches, AJPW (and by extension, NOAH) have King's Road because they believe in long-term story telling and a patient build up that explodes with a cathartic climax. This is not the case with AEW, who are suffering the same fate as Ring of Honor and any other indie promotion out there - and that is that they have no distinctive style of wrestling that separates them from the rest of the promotions; they are the same as everyone else, but on a larger financial scale. Their matches are literally thrown in and are either hardcore, silly or wannabe Puro Lite, and unfortunately also overrated. If I were less merciful than I am today I would say they are, regrettably, slop, too... which some of their matches are, 60 to 75% of the time. So how do they solve this issue? They need a style of wrestling that combines realism (grappling, submission moves and real-life aspects/personas from the wrestlers), dramatic spots (that not only make sense regarding the workers of the match, but also the rivalry/story behind that specific moment, take for example the Tiger Suplex on 03/01/03, it makes sense because Kobashi drove Misawa to limits unknown to himself, and knowing that the former could win, he needed to step things up and stop him, so he suplexed him from the ramp to the floor), and an infectious wrestling idea that drives the wrestlers insane: Being Elite, finding perfection in their own way but also being at the tip of the parabola and never going to the other side, meaning that the need for a gimmick is not necessary and they would drive each other nuts as the time limit for a title match is drawing its end. And while Tony Khan's relationship with his wrestlers is better than Vince McMahon's (and the rest of WWE), he needs to understand that hardcore matches usually involve flirting with death, and while it sounds cool, it really means that they are seconds away from tragedy. Therefore, they need to get rid of it. Not to mention, the roster. I like some of the wrestlers, but I feel that the locker room is bloated and it needs to thin out. And they also need to get rid of Collision, as I find it unnecessary and it reminds me of WCW Thunder. This is me scraping the iceberg, but you can see the issues that stem from this promotion, and I hope that Tony Khan realizes this and works on it right away. Not for immediate solutions but for those that would help the promotion in the long run. 6/10 is my score for AEW."
Phenomfr wrote on 15.10.2026:
"All Elite Wrestling is a blessing for our passion. The amount of incredible matches, storylines, wrestlers, tag teams and crews this company produces is amazing. 10/10."
Fusionblaster wrote on 12.10.2026:
[4.0] "AEW's position is both a blessing and a curse. There are plenty of good wrestlers, similar to the WWE, but also similarly, the AEW roster is incredibly bloated. They used less than a quarter of their roster on their biggest pay-per-view of the year, and the average AEW wrestler is lucky to show up once every other week, if not once a month. The promotion's booking is bad as a result - a tremendous amount of unnecessary 6 or 8-man matches almost every Collision or Dynamite. AEW does give their talent significantly more flexibility than the WWE, and Tony Khan seems to care more for his roster than the suits at WWE do - you have to try to get fired. They have relationships with a slew of independent promotions (unlike the WWE) and have the potential to turn around from their own downward spiral due to Tony Khan being THE man in the promotion - if he wants to make a change, no one can get in his way to stop him."
Kzaimlime004 wrote on 10.10.2026:
[10.0] "AEW Deserves all the Love Specially The Matches , Every Single Match Feels Like a Premium Event Quality Match , Other Major Promotion Only Use their Television Time into Promo's & BS , But AEW Always Gets the Best out of Everyone in television time & PLE'S are Even Better than WWE"
RagingRich wrote on 10.10.2026:
[8.0] "All Elite Wrestling will go down in history as one of the most important moments in North American wrestling and wrestling as a whole. Tony Khan had the moment all dream of, being able to book wrestling with almost unlimited money and the cornerstones of professional wrestling. All Elite Wrestling came around at the right time, World Wrestling Entertainment was in the midst of slump in the world of wrestling, many people tuned away and found companies like New Japan, Ring Of Honor, PWG, Pro Wrestling NOAH, and on and on. A wrestling surge was happening and Tony Khan, Kenny Omega, the Young Bucks, Cody Rhodes and more brought us the ultimate escape. However, in the overwhelming positive things that can be talked about, AEW has some really large downs. Some championships mean almost nothing for their lineages, weird business decisions, sometime unprofessional problems (i.e Matt Hardy almost dying, the All Out Brawl, etc.). The womens division has never been where it would be with its roster. The tag team division is "Young Bucks/FTR win belt, lose belt, some tag team have it for a bit, and it comes back around to Young Bucks vs FTR". The Death Riders bubble of early 2025 may be some of the weirdest viewing experiences I have ever sat through. But man, All Elite Wrestling, even at its worst, is still an above average viewing experience. AEW has only really one underwhelming pay-per-view experience and has been hitting it ever since. In such their short time being a company, it has created multiple memorable moments.Even if you are just finding out or been here since the beginning, you are in for a hell of a time."
The Clean Finish Pod wrote on 09.10.2026:
[10.0] "No wrestling promotion is perfect, but I'm elevating a strong 9 to a 10 because there are seriously people out there that deem this company worthy of a 0. Yeah, wrestling is beautiful, but wrestling fans can be incredibly stubborn and nearsighted."
tdetoni99 wrote on 09.10.2026:
"AEW it's a great option! They do wrestling their way and it clic with the way I like it. Great matches on TV, Top Tier PPV's, there is a lot of passion in the work they put for us and I really love that. Give it a try!"
AnotherNumbersGuy wrote on 06.10.2026:
[9.0] "I've poked my head into lots of different promotions and can't reasonably give them a fair shake, I just have a very incomplete picture from my less-than-three shows or very-few-matches that I've observed from these people in a very narrow slice of their history. Whereas WWE I've watched a big chunk of their weekly content from a specific era and a huge swath of their pay per views over the last half century, I have watched every single Dynamite, Rampage, Collision, and Battle of the Belts, plus every pay per view and I did most of that at the end of 2023 into 2024, and am in the midst of an abridged rewatch with somebody who I'm trying to onboard in time for the next C2 (just nine months of shows to go and probably a month and a half before that starts). I love AEW, and I'm very pleased with their product as a whole. There's definitely less on Collision that's worth watching, and I definitely understand the women's division needs to be given much better attention. It's a bit disappointing in that regard, but the highs in the men's division are VERY high. I hope one day AEW's women's division becomes more on the level of Toni vs Mariah for the world championship, their inaugural Blood and Guts match, and Mercedes for the TBS title vs Statlander and Willow across the board, rather than the glimpses of genius that float in and disappear far too rapidly. Still, I feel comfortable giving a 9 to AEW."
iWonder wrote on 05.10.2026:
[10.0] "The best pro wrestling company of today! I can't believe it's been 7 years of being All Elite and to look back and see the amazing work every performer has done for the company is beyond commendable. Thank you Tony and The Elite for saving pro wrestling."
rlrvox wrote on 01.10.2026:
[10.0] "This show touched my heart immediately and never slowed down. The tributes to Pac as a man were wonderful. The tributes to Pac as a wrestler were visually stunning. The pair of surprise appearances in the main event were stunning. And the final image of the Death Riders surrounding Pac's chair will stick with me for a long time. That video package at the end was phenomenal. I would give this show 1000/10 if I could."
disorganizedchair wrote on 30.09.2026:
[10.0] "AEW is, quite simply, the best wrestling promotion you can watch right now if what you want is wrestling that actually feels like wrestling. It's not perfect, and no promotion ever will be, but the sheer amount of talent, variety, match quality and creativity consistently outweighs its flaws. I appreciate most about AEW is that it feels like a company built by people who genuinely love the history and different styles of professional wrestling. You can get world-class American wrestling, strong-style influences, lucha libre, hardcore wrestling, technical wrestling and the best of the independent scene all under the same roof. And with a roster this stacked, there is always another wrestler, another rivalry or another match worth getting invested in. The match quality is obviously the biggest strength, but it's not just about having great matches. AEW has given me moments, rivalries and wrestlers that have made me care about wrestling again. AEW is one of the very few promotions that can still make me genuinely excited to see what happens next. It's not flawless, but when it's firing on all cylinders, there's simply nothing else quite like it."
Thing In The Woods wrote on 29.09.2026:
[10.0] "AEW is absolutely the best you can currently get with mainstream wrestling. It's by no means perfect, as is any promotion, but its flaws are far outshined by its strengths, and it currently has one of the most stacked rosters of all time."
MoonRover64 wrote on 23.09.2026:
[10.0] "I remember being exposed to the independents when I was younger through those MMVs (like, I don't know, a highlight reel of Adam Cole vs Kyle O'Reilly with Disturbed or Three Days Grace playing in the background) and I couldn't believe that type of wrestling existed. I love how the Indie operate with their matches so, seeing the most current most popular company (outside of WWE) being this unadulterated display of Indie wrestling makes a joy to watch week-to-week. Now, of course it's not a constant display of great matches every Dynamite and/or Collision but it IS super consistent when have those matches that have you the edge of your seat. Been a fan for a good month and I can say that AEW got me back into wrestling."
okasanlamar wrote on 21.09.2026:
[8.0] "This is a great wrestling promotion, it has its amazing moments, it has its downs too, this is the promotion that introduced me to wrestling and after watching a lot of them i still find AEW to be the one i end up liking the most simply for being a fan the longest, but with being a fan comes recognizing its flaws and sadly one of the biggest flaws in AEW for me is the female division You look at the men side and how they are booked and you see amazing stories with long term story arcs and character driven moments meanwhile the women's division is booked like how i expect someone who only watched WWE his whole life to book a women's divison, which to me screams that Tony Khan is the one running it, and while the division can hold itself up because it has amazing fucking wrestlers, the problem still remains, if amazing wrestlers can sometimes get a good story what does that leave for the girls who aren't as good? they get next to nothing, riho's last match was a year ago, nyla rose is nowhere to be seen, yuka sakazaki is on ROH for some reason im not saying its a bad division, or that it's the girls fault, im just saying that maybe someone else should be at the head of the booking, personally i really like RJ City and think he can work perfectly with them since the one time where RJ worked on a storyline, it ended up being the HOLLYWOOD ENDING, which is probably (along with the whole golden lovers saga) the thing that made me fall in love with professional wrestling, i see women in this division and i know they are amazing because i see them in the ring and i see what they do in other promotions (megan bayne is an absolute killer in Stardom and GCW idk why she doesn't get any singles gold) and it pains me to see how most of them are handled outside of that, AEW is a great promotion and im happy to be a fan and for this one to be the one to introduce me to wrestling"
0megaJoe wrote on 18.09.2026:
[8.0] "Im giving AEW an 8 there PPV are really good and I say they are better then WWE's. I dont watch AEW anymore because I got sick of watching wrestling almost every day of the week. From the short time I did watch it I liked it. Also I did not like there long PPVs on Sundays when I have to wake up for work at 5am (another reason I quit watching). Other then that I do wish all the ex WWE stars that do go there the best."
El Espectador wrote on 17.09.2026:
[6.0] "This is a company where only the ppv are worth watching; their weekly shows tend to be quite boring and consist of nothing but thrown together matches. The few storylines featured this year have left a lot to be desired. While Dynamite is a decent show, Collision isn't worth watching, it's a show filled with people who are irrelevant to the company."
rayanMEK00 wrote on 15.09.2026:
[10.0] "AEW is exactly what wrestling needed. Incredible matches, a stacked roster, different styles, great rivalries and a real love for wrestling history. It feels like AEW is at its best, and nobody can do it better."
CobainintheMembrain wrote on 10.09.2026:
[10.0] "Providing Quality Matches and Content for its Price-point. Respects Wrestling History and its current generation. Matches & Rivalries / match history are used for storytelling along with Promos and Backstage angles. Knowledge of Wrestling history and lineage and independent promotions and rivalries is rewarded but sometimes the reference can go over more casual viewers. If you are familiar with the rise pre AEW of its wrestlers expect to be rewarded in storyline / matchups for your attention to such a wrestlers path. If you Enjoy wrestling as a whole From Japan to Mexico to the UK expect to see a mix of multiple styles from each."
prayforicecream wrote on 07.09.2026:
[10.0] "AEW basically brought me back to watching wrestling again due to the creative drought that was WWE at the time. Started watching from then Punk arrived. Throughout the years I have noticed the quality of matches have retained their high quality while the creative has slowly crept up to where it is now, the company is s-tier in my opinion. A real great selection of male and female wrestlers. I can safely say this is where the best wrestle."
cactu wrote on 04.09.2026:
[10.0] "The company that made me a wrestling fan again, in an era where I lost all faith in WWE. AEW stands on its own as an incredible wrestling promotion, but even compared to its biggest competitors, WWE and TNA, they simply don't compare to the consistent enjoyability of AEW. This is wrestling for wrestling fans, and while it isn't perfect, it's definitely the best."
TheDoomCJ wrote on 03.09.2026:
[10.0] "The best wrestling promotion in the world right now, shoulder to shoulder with Stardom and CMLL. We are so lucky to have incredible wrestling every week. When AEW gets it right, no one does it better. They've earned the nickname and with a quickly evolving history and mythos, I am excited for the many years to come."
majorasmask12 wrote on 03.09.2026:
[8.0] "Previously I gave it 6 due to inconsistent booking over the last couple years but have they improved? Damn sure they have. It's getting back to the levels it was on back in 2021-2022. Main event scene is awesome and tag team division is the best it has ever been in this promotion. They just need to let some feuds last longer than they do. A title holder goes through different story every month. Not to mention unnecessary amount of titles they have right now. If it was up to me, I'd definitely retire National and Continental titles. These are the reasons I'm giving it 8 and it's me being generous tbh. Overall, very good product with awesome talent."
marvelxstorm23 wrote on 01.09.2026:
[6.0] "Thid company is very enjoyable the way they book their matches so fast paced and full of risks but I wish they booked the women better. Putting them in 6, 8, 10 womens tag matches every single weeks is ignorance."
Aditya wrote on 01.09.2026:
[6.0] "It is a good alternative but is not close currently to becoming a viable no. 1 company.Their partnership with NJPW has only been useful for them and not NJPW.They have had great matches and stories but as of now the stories do not have proper build or are convoluted and the matches feature too much emphasis on moves at the expense of selling and pacing"
iamjericho78 wrote on 31.08.2026:
[6.0] "Good alternative to WWE. Similar to NJPW and NOAH. Had a hot start but recent years have lacked in depth stories. And the matches have lost the urgency to get the win and nore just a lot of moves and no selling. 2k Attendance weekly is a worry for the future."
GoneFishing wrote on 27.08.2026:
"The run AEW has been on is up there with prime ROH and NJPW for the best ever. Have you thanked Tony Khan today?"
middlerope wrote on 24.08.2026:
[3.0] "AEW gets points from me based on a few things: the respectful handling of Brodie Lee's death, having a tournament in Owen Hart's honour and bringing CM Punk back to pro wrestling. Beyond that, I felt burned as a fan given that back in 2019, Tony Khan promised AEW would have a sports based feel and would feature no ridiculous angles, but has since gone back on that promise ten fold. While AEW has held great wrestling matches, such as the excellent two out of three falls tag team match between Jay White and Juice Robinson and FTR, far too many of their matches fall in to the silly PWG indie wrestling style, which I find embarrassing to watch. I simply can't stand seeing wrestlers do every move under the sun, stand right back up, raise their arms up, do a move back, repeat that a few times, and then collapse for two minutes. Ultimately, AEW isn't the alternative I expected, or hoped, it would be. There's some great talent under the AEW banner, however with the poor booking, practically non-existent engaging storylines and an unfortunate percentage of talent displaying a lack of basic pro wrestling psychology, it feels like any growth or chances to excel are stifled."
DanielBrain wrote on 22.08.2026:
[0.0] "On paper Im the kind of person AEW should appeal to. Ive seen Danielson in ROH in his first run. Been to Dominion in Osaka Jo Hall. Been to Arena Mexico. I dont like AEW. I can sum it up in one sentence: nothing means anything. Ill all caps the sections since you cant make paragraphs here. BELTS MEAN NOTHING. There are 4 mid card titles with no material difference or purpose. So I dont care about any of them. WRESTLERS DONT MEAN ANYTHING. Omega needs 30 minutes to beat Knight. Ospreay gets his ass kicked by Davis (and mid carder Davis kicks out of Ospreay's finish). Everyone goes a 15+ minute 50/50 match with everyone. So no one is special. MOVES MEAN NOTHING. Because everyone has to hit their checklist of moves before a match is over, moves dont mean anything. The one winged angel is probably the only move that means anything. GIMMICK MATCHES MEAN NOTHING. Mid card throw away feuds get gimmick matches on the B show. "Texas death" isnt even a Texas death match (pin plus 10 count). So why do I give a shit when someone challenges someone to a dog collar or whatever? WEAPONS MEAN NOTHING. Because of the proliferation of gimmick matches and the dumb way they work these where, instead of trying to get 1-3 weapons over as dangerous or someone having a signature weapon, all weapons and even yarder-level dumb shit is used. Jack Perry won the same match he was Set. On. Fire. In. These morons have made FIRE not mean anything. BLOOD MEANS NOTHING. Blood is used no matter how insignificant a feud is so it doesnt add weight to matches that could use it. FEUDS MEAN NOTHING. Swerve burns Hangmans house down. Hangman uses a syringe (BTW in a feud that started with a gimmick match) to put him out....Swerve illogically helps Hangman vs Mox. Hangman vs Mox has this great payoff at All In...and then they have a regular 1x1 match on Dynamite a few weeks later. Just to make you feel liker an idiot for getting invested. AND EVEN OVER LOOKING THAT nothing matters because you still have the Bucks, Ricochet, and Perry doing the incredibly stale 2010s indie "play along with us wink wink" style of wrestling. At this point the promotion is a 2010s nostalgia act except unlike NJPW in the 2010s, NOTHING MEANS ANYTHING. Super sad that the one person who could challenge WWE is running such a terrible promotion. No psychology, no progressive selling, they run yhe homogenous lucharesu hybrid "get your shit in" indie style with generic 5'9" 160 pounders. AEW is essentially one of those B-tier Marvel movies where city blocks get destroyed and dudes are getting lasered and shot but you dont remember the movie because the acting and story sucks and nothing of consequence matters. At least we have NJPW. Although I fear AEW is going to contaminate CMLL even further."
Spaced wrote on 21.08.2026:
[3.0] "Do you like a roster consisting of 85% sub 6 footers bloviating their self-importance constantly and everyone wrestles the same indierific, psychology-bereft style? Then AEW is for you. I'm not saying small wrestlers are inherently bad or wrestlers must be big to be successful, there are plenty of legendary smaller wrestlers, but when everyone basically has the gimmick of "I am a good wrestler" with no flair or hook, fitting into the same body type and size, it becomes immensely boring, lacking in any variety whilst still breaking the suspension of disbelief that wrestling relies on because they're too keen to wink to the camera and appeal to the wrestling nerd crowd than a broader audience. And very few of these smaller wrestlers in AEW successfully convey any legitimacy to anyone but a subculture that has surrendered all pretence to the illusion pro-wrestling tries to maintain. These wrestlers are the kind of people even TNA would have turned their noses up at for their X-Division, yet they're constantly in the main-event scene, presented as the biggest stars of the show despite having limited character, charisma or aura. Add to that these wrestlers attempting edge and bite that comes across as cringey at the best of times, at least 5 needless championships, and an unwillingness to try and appeal to a wider audience which is curbing growth, suffice to say, I never think AEW will grow to genuinely challenge WWE, and will remain a niche sub-cultural project."
arisenby wrote on 11.08.2026:
[8.0] "[8.1] For my money, the best promotion in the world at its scale. They've only been around for about seven years now and they feel like they've not just been around, but been a mainstay for twenty. Has some of the most prestigious belts in wrestling right now, a legitimate claim to the most stacked roster in history, usually fantastic weekly TV, and a damn near spotless track record for TV specials and PPVs. That said, it's not perfect, far from it. There's one big complaint to make and it's that the way the women's division is booked is way, way, way, way, *WAY* too consistent of a pain point. It's genuinely fucking laughable, to the point where I honestly think Tony Khan would actually just not have a women's division if he thought he could run a major promotion in North America without one. The women's tag champs will get five minutes and then they won't even give them time to linger on the victory, but 'oh yeah, we can totally show off an ESPN article on Darby and have a two minute segment illustrating a character detail you could only miss if you were watching on mute with your eyes closed.' I don't care if the lack of time is down to network meddling and that time is with Tony fighting to get them more or what, if he can only get them less than 10% of a three hour block, he's not fighting hard enough. They'll rotate the same six to twelve women around for the 20 minutes they get on TV if they're lucky for months at a time, leave pairings to be completely forgotten if one of the women get injured, give the women a TV main event what feels like once every other month and then cram as much fluff in the mens division as they can before it, put some of their massively talented women on ice for months for no good reason, which usually leaves them to work elsewhere, but there, they probably get more time to actually work and do their jobs. It is just inexcusably pathetic that it's been like this for so long, you can find reviews from 2020, their first full calendar year, that say the womens division is a weak point and it hasn't changed. The high rating I give is in spite of that. Outside of that big issue, I feel like it falls into pitfalls of lacking a distinct identity, they're kind of being overly burdened by the vision of what wrestling on TV *has* been in America under the WWE monopoly they broke, occasionally feeling the need to overcomplicate things, especially regarding championships (looking at you, whatever the hell was going on with the unified championship, ) and also like Tony Khan has issues saying no to people, especially when those people are AEW Originals or legends with some respect. When it's good, it's fucking great. To give you an idea of how much I love this promotion at its best, I just spent over half of this 3, 000+ character review bashing them, longer than a lot its *negative* reviews, and still said its an 8/10. But when it's bad, it's one of the most frustrating wrestling products on the planet because you have both seen how high the peaks are and know they are capable of better. [Previously: 8.4 on April 6 2024, 8.6 on March 2 2025, 8.5 on March 1 2026]"
BuckshxtLariat wrote on 01.08.2026:
[9.0] "AEW made me fall in love with pro wrestling. A true alternative to WWE, not like TNA or WCW who wanted to be like WWE.. AEW does their own thing, their main focus being good in-ring wrestling rather than long segments and promo battles (which they do from time to time for huge PPV matches) as AEW talent are more than capable of telling a story in the ring, so instead they rely more on quick backstage segments and video packages. Their PPVs are must watch stuff, they already have good to great matches on weekly shows but that goes up to a whole different level in their PPVs. If there was something to criticize it would be the fact that they are guilty of sometimes doing too much in their matches, not everyone has to always get their stuff in every match. I also like that AEW fans are mostly chill but they will defend the promotion from haters. If you enjoy the wrestling aspect of pro wrestling, I'd suggest you give AEW a chance."
JediSaiyanMaster1203 wrote on 01.08.2026:
"Gonna leave only comments on promotions since its too hard to rate promotions, personally, due to a variety of reasons such as how every company has its highs and lows (for the most part) and it's hard to balance out. Before I start, I want to make it clear that I don't consider myself a supporter of promotions as I think that support should be directed towards the talent no matter what, tribalism is lame. Positives: This company kept me from falling out of love with wrestling, 2021 is the companies best year along with 2019 & 2025, some of my favorite matches, PPVs, moments, etc. have happened in this company, there's a ton of creative freedom for the wrestlers, anybody can wrestle whatever style they want, the company listens to their fans. (I'm sure there's more to add, but I'll come back and add more when they come to mind). Negatives: 2023 and 2024 were pretty bad years due to it felt like they lost their identity during that time, while great that wrestlers get a lot of freedom, it doesn't always land well and some matches and promos end up being pretty bad, the company has had it's fair share of controversies (I assume I shouldn't get into it), their commentary team can be lacking at times. (I'm sure there's more, but I'll come back and add them when I remember them) I'll admit, I was struggling to come up with some cons for this company, likely since it's still young and the bad years this company has had is very small. Current thoughts: I have been loving AEW again since 2025, I'm so glad AEW finally snapped out of it whatever the hell they went through during 23/24, AEW is currently the only wrestling company I try to watch on a weekly basis (when I have time), so that should give you an idea of how I have been feeling about the product."
PPVAddict wrote on 28.07.2026:
[10.0] "AEW is on an incredible run right now and has become one of the best wrestling promotions in the world. The roster is stacked, the matches are consistently great, and the PPVs have been absolutely insane. The weekly shows also feel more important than ever, with strong storylines and some of the best in-ring action you can find anywhere. AEW is delivering at an extremely high level."
Sol24 wrote on 20.07.2026:
[9.0] "After attending Revolution 2025 in person, I went from a casual viewer to a dedicated fan. The build up of storylines for All In 2025 was genuinely one of my favorite summers ever and I still think about how amazing it felt for Hangman to win the World Championship that ppv. Since then, being an AEW fan has felt incredibly rewarding as they keep giving us amazing matches and storylines every week and every month. This year's ppv run has been especially good, with each card somehow being able to top the last one. Despite all this love there's still something that I think AEW can work on or develop better to truly make the company as good as it can possibly be. Their women's division has a real feud and rivalry drought right now that seems to be caused by a lack of any women left who haven't already had a storyline together in the past year. The shortage of women wrestlers is especially affecting the new women tag team champions Divine Dominion whose only option for any real competition are the Brawling Birds. Besides my issues with the recent booking for the women's division, any concerns or issues that I've had with a decision that TK makes for a storyline typically turns out to be something really interesting or great given time to fully pay off."
part-timehater wrote on 19.07.2026:
[8.0] "I think it's the best american promotion I have seen lately. Great PPVs and amazing matches. My only complaint is that while the men's division is solid and well booked, the women's division has been terribly managed."
spicyjuniormint wrote on 04.07.2026:
[10.0] "I have been an AEW watcher from day 1, I was say in front of my TV for Double or Nothing 2019 and the first episode of Dynamite. I can't claim to have watched every AEW show or match but I've watched most of them. AEW has had its ups and its downs, like any company. But in 2026, AEW's on nothing short of the greatest run any wrestling company has ever has. They simply do not miss. The roster is stacked with unbelievable levels of talent, with the men's main event scene being so stacked that wrestlers like Andrade who are crazy over are conceivably 4th or 5th in line for the championship because of how many top level guys are ahead of them. The weekly episodes of Dynamite are must see, consistently delivering great storylines (the "AEW doesn't tell stories" is an embarrassingly outdated relic of it's first few years), great promos and most of all incredible matches. Even Collision is starting to become appointment viewing for me, recently putting on a show with multiple 4 star matches and good storyline development as well. But the real shining crown of AEW are the PPVs. The PPVs in 2025 were inconsistent but with some incredible highs, but in 2026 they've gone on the greatest run of PPVs in wrestling history. If you think I'm being hyperbolic that's fine, but I know full well what I'm saying and nothing tops this run from Revolution to Forbidden Door, and Redemption and All In London I'm sure will be amazing too. It's truly astounding when every new AEW PPV gets called the greatest PPV of all time, but it just keeps happening. Forbidden Door was main evented by three 5 star quality matches in my opinion, and I can't recall any wrestling company doing that before. Tribalism persists in wrestling, but I actually feel bad for the people that can't enjoy AEW because what they are doing this decade will go down in the history books next to 80's AJW, 90's AJPW and 2010's NJPW as one of the greatest runs of all time. Enjoy it now because these kinds of runs don't last forever."
ultravioletshiroi wrote on 03.07.2026:
[6.0] "My opinion on this company has changed, in both positive and negative ways. AEW's problems are their lackluster booking, overly predictable outcomes and over use of jobber matches to protect and showcase talent. Much of their roster is rarely utilized well, and matches just 'happen' with no story behind them. Full cards are already known beforehand so there's little randomness to anything. On the positive side AEW has an incredible roster full of so many great wrestlers and the action itself is rarely boring. But there seems to be a major lack of story progression, and many wrestlers are just stuffed into factions just to give them something to do. The women's division is also very poorly utilized as a whole, with many great women just coming, maybe having their short moment and going, although Divine Dominion has been a dominant force in the women's tag division which is something at least. I watch for the great matches but rarely feel truly fulfilled by an AEW show."
Skull Reaper wrote on 21.06.2026:
[10.0] "Does it have flaws? Absolutely every company does but AEW overall is the best company out there & has the least amount of flaws. There main flaw honestly is how they are booking the women's division but the men's & tag scene those two are hands down booked incredibly well. They truly have the best wrestlers in the world & there partnerships make that even better"
Killerhustle2008 wrote on 11.06.2026:
[7.0] "I enjoy AEW I really do but their main issue is that there sign to many wrestlers and only use them for a couple weeks before benching them and having them wrestle on ROH not there anything wrong with ROH but barely anyone watched it anymore. My other issue is the belts there so many of them like all you need is a world title for men and women mid card belt for men and women and tag belts for the men and women. Like do we need a trios belts do we need a national championship or international championship? My other main issue is how he books the female roster I feel like he only cares about Toni Storm and Mercedes Moné."
ElJericho wrote on 09.06.2026:
[6.0] "06.02.2025 AEW brought my love for Wrestling back and the first couple years have been a breath of fresh air to say the least. Sadly this company and it's leadership have lost touch of what made them special. So many bad decisions in leadership and booking have made the product a shell of it's former self. The In-ring product is still really good and the best in America, but that only gets you so far when the booking is so poor that it doesn't get you emotionally invested in your talents and storylines. Most talents are cold because of it, no matter how big their names are. Some who had been popular like Ricky Starks, Wardlow etc. are just gone without any explanation. The low ratings and poor attendence speak for themselves but the booker has his head in the sand and continues to deliver a half baked product. The promise to deliver a reality based, sports-like product hasn't been kept. Most feuds, storylines and pairings are a lazy, thrown together mess that don't make sense most of the time. I could add so many more issues but all of this has been a problem for years and has gotten worse and worse. I desperatly hope that they finally wakes up and improve the product significantly. I hope they pivot from the whole Death Riders gimmick because it's so uninteresting and pulls the show down. The MVP of AEW is currently Toni Storm imo. She's a star with an interesting character and one of the few reasons why I watch the show. Update (08.06.26): My rating hasn't changed, but I have to add a few things that bother me about the current product. The overreliance on interference and BS finishes is quite obvious and incredibly annoying. It's pretty clear that they're doing this to protect the wrestlers' momentum, but it's reached the point where it's just silly. There's absolutely no issue with guys like Mark Davis losing clean to Will Ospreay or Speedball losing clean to Knight. In fact, I'd argue that these constant BS finishes actually hurt the wrestlers more in the long run. Both of those examples, by the way, happened on the same show, complete with interferences and ref bumps. Another related issue is predictable booking. Being predictable isn't always bad, but too often the booking is just too obvious. Take the world title matches on TV, for example. The title has been defended multiple times in just a few months, yet instead of booking competitive matches with proper build-up, they pit the champion against opponents who either haven't appeared on AEW TV in a long time or have zero momentum going into the match. It feels like they're just padding the champ's stats so he can lose the title on the next big PPV. Another related issue is the overbooking of matches. AEW delivers some excellent wrestling, but they often overcompensate by booking every match as if everyone is on the exact same level, when that simply isn't the case, nor should it be. There are too many matches that go 20+ minutes that have no business going that long. No-selling or underselling finishers happens way too often. Not only does it make the person who hit the finisher look bad, it also makes the previous 15-20 minutes feel pointless. It looks phony and insults the audience's intelligence.Wrestlers disappearing with no explanation is still a big issue. Sometimes you eventually hear the reason, but too often you hear nothing, or the talent is simply shipped off to ROH when they're actually needed on AEW TV.The booking of talent is still too inconsistent. Take Andrade, for example. He had a great start to the year, beating Omega and Swerve and losing to Adam Page (which was fine). But then he spent the next 4 months in six-man tag matches and meaningless bouts, and we're somehow supposed to believe he's a viable title contender again? This happens far too often, wrestlers build momentum, only for it to cool off completely, with no consistent direction. Collision for the most part has been booked like a C-Show. It obviously doesn't help that you have so many injuries but there are still quite a lot of underutilized names, titles and storylines to create which could give reasons to watch it. So far it's not really worth it. AEW also needs to show more video packages explaining what happened in the last shows because some can't watch every show and are left confused. The same goes for foreign talents who are not a big name in the US yet. I'm surprised why they don't do hype packages for them."
Swain808 wrote on 07.06.2026:
"Seems to be getting better and better in 2026. Incredible run so far hopefully it continues. MJF best in the business."
Zeyadgamal423 wrote on 06.06.2026:
"Aew is where the best wrestle with great wrestlers like osprey, okada, omega and many more. Great drama and storylines. And what a PLEs! Just incredible.."
Keithnelson18 wrote on 03.06.2026:
[10.0] "AEW was the company that brought some wrestling fans their passions back for wrestling and I'm one of those people. After watching WWE for years without watching any other company "which I regret now." It felt like a breath of fresh air with a style of wrestling I haven't seen before. Some of my favorite wrestlers went to this company, but not just that, some people in this company became my favorites, like MJF, Adam Page, Kenny Omega, Will Ospreay, Mark Briscoe, Kris Statlander, Willow Nightingale, Darby Allin, and more. Some of my favorite matches, moments and more are from this company. I just wanna thank AEW for bringing my love for pro wrestling back before it died between 2020-2022. However, this also has negatives as well. Like overdoing moves, having blood in almost every match, poor booking choices, bad matches, and overly done dangerous spots. It has negatives, but also has positives as well."
LeviA wrote on 26.05.2026:
"A dream match - they did it all, this match gets a 9/10 for me just the "nope" spot and the Styles Clash. Rematch please. 9/10"
Reprise wrote on 25.05.2026:
[10.0] "It's hard to rate AEW at the moment. I have been a fan of pro wrestling for most of my life and have watched a lot of promotions over the years. I didn't pay a whole lot of attention to AEW until some point in early 2020 and then I got hooked during the pandemic. The consistently strong PPVs and excellent matches are what I enjoy the most, however their weekly television is a little more inconsistent. They mostly produce solid television each week, but there have been periods where I haven't been so into particular stories or feuds, and find inconsistent booking frustrating (particularly stop-start pushes and individuals disappearing from television frequently). Overall though I really do enjoy AEW and even during rough patches, they always draw me back in."
notstretchmarksghost wrote on 25.05.2026:
[10.0] "I will let this rating fluctaute, but there's been a magic in the air since Darby won the title. The build to Double or Nothing, and the show itself were both excellent. Ospreay and the Death Riders, the Callis Family erosion, Darby's perpetual burnout but unwillingness to stop giving it his all.. The company is in a tremendous position, with the Owen Tournament set to conclude at Forbidden Door and All In shortly after, I have to say that there has never been a better time to watch AEW. The weekly product is firing on all cylinders, both Revolution ans Double or Nothing have been all-time classics, and it's not hardly June yet. The rating can always change, but I would always like to keep it centered and averaged. If this was a middling promotion on a tear, it would be worthy of a 7 or an 8. But as a longtime viewer, AEW finally has my trust and can produce consistency across the board. They have been the best promotion in the world all year, for the better part of last year as well if you ask me, and that's no easy task. For me this months long run at the top has to result in nothing short of a 10.."