Big E

[8.0] "E should have been pushed to the moon IMO, such a shame what happened to him. He should have been one of those guys who pushed WWE to be next-gen, but back-stage hates seeing a man succeed."

[10.0] "Very underrated, under appreciated, and underutilized during his career as a pro wrestler. He has everything a pro wrestler needs to be excellent. Charisma, athleticism, believability... He was genuinely the total package. I just wish he could've had more of a chance to demonstrate it."

[8.0] "Big E is fantastic! One of those guys that has charisma, can still go in the ring and is just so incredibly likable. I feel like Big E is one of those people that's impossible to dislike."

[8.0] "It well and truly sucks that not only was his career cut short but in a nothing match against a really shitty wrestler. He started out as one of the blandest characters but he developed with the New Day and we saw his personality. HIs title run should've been longer."

[9.0] "Big E is really good and I feel sorry for him because of his injury. I want him back so badly, but I don't know... Big E already did so much in his career and he was capable of doing even more, but this injury stopped him unfortenately. Prime Big E - is gold"

[8.0] "To me, Big E was the most important member of the New Day which should get him a high rating based on their run. But he also did great with Ziggler, in the midcard and as a main eventer. His booking as champion was unfortunate but at no fault to him. He was always capable of good matches with his power & athleticism"

[9.0] "Big E has obviously been thrown a massive roadblock in his wrestling career with his neck injury, but for the time he was active, he was undeniably one of the most entertaining and BEEFY wrestlers on the planet. I'll forever been an admirer of his work."

[8.0] "Big E is one of the most beloved wrestlers of his era. He was good in the ring and has shown a ton of charisma and mic skills. Obviously got the most over with the New Day where he became the beloved fun character. Unfortunately, near the height of his popularity a bad accident occurred with him breaking his neck off an overhead belly to belly ending his in-ring career but he is still an enjoyable preshow analyst."

[6.0] "Really sad how his career ended. Whilst he wasn't anything incredible in-ring, his charisma was off the charts and, dare I say it, The New Day wouldn't have been anywhere near as popular as they were if it wasn't for his presence. Whilst those two were the workhorses of the group, Big E was the one who really captivated the audience with his amazing mic work and aura. His run as WWE Champion is completely forgettable however, I had to actually double check he won the title before finishing the rest of this rating. Overall, he wasn't amazing in-ring but he had the ability to be really fun to watch given his antics and ability on the mic. Rating him a 6 because if it wasn't for his mic work, he would be pretty forgettable."

[5.0] "Big E is alright. His work with the New Day was great, but that's it. There is not much depth to him. Not great, but not awful either. Much like Kofi Kingston, he didn't prove his worth as champion. Kofi at least had a great buildup and a memorable (bad, but memorable) end to his reign. Can't say the same about Big E's."

[10.0] "Big deserves a better rating. He was perfect all throughout his career a fantastic manager who squashed anyone who tried to hurt AJ lee or dolph ziggler. Great single competitor when he won the IC title. And he was in one of the best tag team storyline and stables of all time 10/10"

[8.0] "The best member of the New Day and that's saying something. It took time for him to really flourish on his own but it's deserved. Great on the mic, good in-ring. I miss him and i hope that one day he will be back in the ring;."

[8.0] "Charisma, hilarious on mic, likeable, great look and also is pretty, well, very good for a powerhouse in the ring, and a great tag team wrestler too, be is Mr Have it all really."

[7.0] "Big E isn't the best in-ring performer of the three New Day members, but he's undoubtedly the funniest and the most charismatic. I was delighted that he enjoyed a solo run with a secondary title, but thought it was overkill that he won the world title. His build-up was never in that direction and his victories over prestigious opponents made no sense. In fact, his reign was quite boring. His reign aside, his average in-ring qualities are more than made up for by his physique, his presence and his entertaining, catchy promos. I hope to see him back in fighting or managerial form one day, but in a position suited to his abilities."

[9.0] "Super charismatic powerhouse who was (is? ) apart of one of the greatest tag teams of all-time in The New Day. A one-time World Champion who could get any crowd behind him once he got with his brothers in the New Day. That was a major breakthrough for him, as he was trying to find his footing, but once he did, he became one of the most over parts of every show that he was on. An unfortunate injury has ended his run as of now, but hopefully hell be able to continue as an on-screen character at some point, because he was must-watch television whenever he was on screen."

[6.0] "Big E is a very solid powerhouse, he always look imposing in the ring and have an interesting arsenal of moves. He was the muscle in the New Day, but it's also a very charismatic wrestler. I really like his power moves."

[7.0] "One of the better Powerhouse wrestlers from the 2010s. Big E had a very good career in both singles and tag team (The New Day) action, Big E had some very memorable promos with The New Day as well and was (by technicality) the de-facto leader of the group. His wrestling wasn't bad either as he had a very decent move-set and could get a crowd hyped up in a match, he also won singles gold and held the Intercontinental and WWE Championship, although both reigns were somewhat short (both actually being 110 days each), they were decent reigns. Of course a bulk of Big E's career title reigns came with the Tag Titles, which were fitting when he was a member of The New Day. Big E's career has been on the shelf due to a seriously tragic injury he suffered in 2022, it's sad if he has to retire because of that, I believe there was still a lot of career left in him."

[9.0] "Can't believe his rating is so low. Big E is an amazing wrestler. He is great on the mic. He is great in the ring. He has a great physique. What more could you want? He definitely deserved a longer reign as WWE Champion, only 110 days was too short. Hoping to see him in the ring again!"

[10.0] "this rating is crazy. Big E is one of the most charismatic and entertaining wrestlers in history. he has been underrated by his company and smart fans for years. he would be a world champ in any era and its great WWE finally realized it. one of my favs of all time and i hope he comes back healthy. if not, he still is HOF worthy."

[7.0] "E was a decent enough worker. He wasn't spectacular in any way, he had decent enough mic skills, decent enough ring work, he is capable of having good matches with the right partner. His gimmick has had many changes although his best work has been as a member of the New Day, he also had a decent run as WWE Champion during which we saw what he was capable of as a singles main event competitor. Unfortunately, he got injured and it seems that's the last we see of him as an in ring competitor. Good worker overall."

[6.0] "Decent big man, but would have never gotten the world title run he did if his stable wasn't over. Charismatic, but average in the ring, his finisher "The Big Ending" is one of the dumbest finisher's in WWE history, picking up his opponent on his shoulder and driving them down on top of himself, it ALWAYS looks like it hurts him more than his opponent."

[7.0] "I agree with the claim that Big E's WWE title reign didn't deserve to have been cut short just to set up a useless Winner Take All match at WrestleMania. The Muscle of The New Day is a reliable worker with a lot of charisma, and had good matches with Roman Reigns, Drew McIntyre among others. Arguably the best match of his career was the HIAC tag match against The Usos. 7.25 rounded down."

[5.0] "The 2nd best member Of New Day. The muscle of the group who could do the goofy comedy act then when he had to, drop some bodies."

"Big E deserves a higher rating considering how talented and charismatic he is, I really enjoyed his world title run and hope to see many more once he is cleared."

[10.0] "Why is he rated so low? 1/3 Of the best stable of at least the modern era, and A great singles guy in his own right. I for one, I actually enjoyed his title reign unlike many."

[8.0] "Why is E's rating so low. Omg Big E is one of the greatest tag team wrestlers of all time and also had a very succesful singles run becoming WWE Champion, NXT Champion, and an IC Champion. He is also one of the most charismatic wrestlers of all time. I love Big E and you should too. 8/10 / Recommendations: vs Lashley, Owens, & Rollins (1/3/22), vs Sheamus (9/10/20), vs Reigns & Lashley (9/20/21)"

[9.0] "Big E is so awesome. Great human, great wrestler, great mic skills. So likeable and charismatic. He deserved his world title run even if it wasn't booked well. I hope to see him back in the ring one day."

[6.0] "Maybe he can be better than what he is now, but he isn't that interesting for now, i didn't really like his reign as the champion even Brock winning was better for me, but he is not bad, still he is good on the mic and he was good in NXT, he is ok/satisfactory"

[7.0] "I like Big E. Good in NXT & start of his main roster run, but really found his footing in the New Day. Average WWE title reign, but it had some good matches. He? s an athletic big man & is great on the mic. Extremely popular, he? s practically the whole package"

[8.0] "I really like Big E, I always dream that if New Day disappeared I'm sure they could do a great job with him, because he has talent to spare."

[10.0] "Big E is a fantastic wrestler, he is always entertaining in the ring, with theatrics and physical domination. In the current roster, he is one of the most talented in ring " big guys" . He works great tag-matches, and shines in 1 v 1, when with the rest of the new day their natural collaboration allows, Big E to consistently hit in his New Day promo's."

[7.0] "Big E is powerful. Unfortunately, I've only been watching wrestling since 2015 so most of the time I saw him as a member of The New Day and he was very good in that role, but he really shines in 1 vs. 1. He was a really good IC and WWE champion and I'm glad that he won this championship. His fighting style combines strength and speed. I really strongly believe that he will come back after an unfortunate injury and we will see him with more than one championship."

[8.0] "a fantastic promo and solid in ring worker, big e is one of the best wrestlers wwe has to offer in terms of their big men."

[9.0] "This guy better get a mega push when he gets back from injury. Deserves it after how his title reign ended. I think he's far from done with his WWE run. Dudes hopefully still got a bright future."

[5.0] "An awful performer with a very limited moveset and a stupid gimmick, undoubtedly the worst out of three New Day members. Which makes me furious is WWE would rather put prestigious belts like the IC title and WWE title on him instead of giving it to much more talented wrestlers like Sami Zayn."

[3.0] "Absolutely one of the worst world champions in recent memory. I guess finally making Big E world champion was fulfilling Vince's long time coming dream since Big E debuted with Ziggler, but really. Just really. He and the Old Day are some of the most stale acts in all of professional wrestling hands down. Sure, he's alright in ring but he is just not a main-event level talent. His promos suck, his character sucks, and his look is meh at best. And even though he does have in-ring skills he can't seem to put that together to put on a decent match. His comedic acts and just general antics are the equivalent of the old adage, change the channel."

[7.0] "He's good and way more charismatic after being a part of the New Day for so long. That helps overcome his ability in the ring which is where he is weakest. Still, he's pretty athletic and has gotten much better over the years. I can see why WWE gave him the MITB briefcase and I have come around to him as a singles star. I admit, I was hesitant on Big E and their investment, but I think it worked out ok. His title run wasn't great but that's more on WWE than Big E. He's great in a tag team role though. When he made his debut, I would have rated him much lower, but I am amazed at how much he has improved over the years. Solid, above average star that isn't main event level but a strong supporting player."

[6.0] "Big E has solid looking power moves, and he's had a solid career with the New Day. Big E's character never developed as a singles guy, and unfortunately, they hot shotted his title win, and booked it so poorly to the point it was unsalvageable. Big E, from all accounts, is a great guy, but in no means is he a top guy."

[5.0] "Probably a wrestler who is just not for me. He is the wrestler in the New Day I like the least, I didn't find him interesting as a generic heel when he started out as Ziggler's muscle and my mileage of him in the New Day varies. He's got enough charisma to get by and looks like a legit powerhouse with a moveset that complements it however, for me I find him too irritating that I will turn off the TV when he starts making silly facial expressions and gyrating. It nullfiies the whole of wrestling when he cannot take it seriously. One of the least deserving WWE champions of all time whose reign was mercifully cut short."

[9.0] "I think Big E has it all. He's got a great hoss look, has a ton of charisma and knows how to connect with the crowd to make money. I have been a fan of Big E since NXT and it was nice to see him finally get a world title reign and I hope he can get another in the future."

[9.0] "A wrestler with enormous charisma. He is good in the ring but his strength is in duos. He performs well when teamed with more acrobatic wrestlers like Kofi or Woods. His last 2 solo reigns (2021) were a bit disappointing. He should turn Heel to gain credibility, he has a gimmick too freindly to be a main champion."

[7.0] "Great character and very charismatic; I am sometimes amazed that Vince lets him come out with some of the stuff he does. Ok at best wrestler though, not many moves and the Big Ending is a well below average finisher. AEW's Hobbs and Stardom's Maika have much better variations of the move and the latter has several higher finishers in her arsenal."

[8.0] "By a comfortable margin the most charismatic man in mainstream modern American pro wrestling. It should be the biggest star in the world as his ring work is plenty good enough for the top of the card in WWE. Big E is ace."

[10.0] "Big E earned a hall of fame caliber career BEFORE winning the WWE title. Happy he has the spotlight now to add to an amazing career."

[9.0] "It's unfortunate his reign as champ is at a nadir of WWE, but it's still great to see. In an ideal world he would be pushed as the top guy with his charisma and strength."

[10.0] "How can you not love Big E' He's one of the most charismatic wrestlers in WWE history and great in the ring. The fact that he's rated so low is a crime."

"I personally think Big E can be one of the most entertaining parts of the of the WWE and pro wrestling world on any night also while his movement might be somewhat limited what he does do has a lot of pop to it. Definitely a guy who deserves the spot he's in, although in his reign so far his fued with Drew Mac has been kinda nothing"

[10.0] "He's so charismatic and impressive in the ring but I think we haven't even seen what all he can do, and I'm hoping this world title run will really elevate him to the top like he deserves."

[7.0] "Not crazy about this dude as WWE Champion. Feels like a glorified midcarder holding the belt. The fact that he's still gonna act like a clown instead of getting serious won't help. Compare him with a BIG TIME world champ like Roman Reigns; it's not even close. His in-ring work is decent I guess."

[8.0] "With him winning MITB now he's more interesting. I'm looking forward to him winning World championship, he's talented. WWE should pull the trigger on him."