| 1 | 12.09.2026 | KennyOmegaMan | 10.0 | |
| 2 | 22.08.2026 | KENTAfan | 10.0 | Look, obviously Vince is a controversial character, especially these days. A horrible man in a variety of ways, and there are countless examples of toxic behavior. But that being said, from a perspective of simply what he did for the business, Vince in his prime was a genius and perhaps the most influential figure in wrestling history. The Attitude Era and Ruthless Aggression Era would've never existed without him, and I admit I'm extremely biased towards that because the Attitude Era was in my opinion the peak of wrestling. So for what he did for the business in that respect, and now that his time in wrestling is concluded, I just have to give him a 10. |
| 3 | 14.08.2026 | OnAPole | 5.0 | 5 is really only ideal rating for ol' VKM, he really is a man that had highs and lows, both as a person and as wrestling personality. He was behind some of the best, and some of the worst wrestling TV ever as well. His genius lies in taking other people's ideas and turning them into money making TV. He is indeed the greatest wrestling promoter ever, with accent being on word promoter, not a booker or creative mind. He was a promoter, only one who managed to turn one wrestling company into global household name and money making machine. On the other side, when he used his creative mind, we got stuff like Trish barking and hundred other examples of bizarre and weird scenes somehow fit into the wrestling TV. When he used his business mind, we got stuff like XFL, TKO and even in just wrestling world, things like Luger on first Nitro and many other blunders. He had a gift to create stars out of nothing (Cena, Reigns, Rock, Batista etc.) but also had a gift to waste great talent (list of examples wouldn't fit into character limit here) and to fumble easy layups, like Flair/Hogan in 1991 and Invasion in 2001. He doesn't care about wrestling as many of his defenders claim, memories of WCW and territories and non-existent wrestling unions stand as witnesses to that, but he did care about WWE, all up until he got kicked out of that company because the truth about little part of his wrongdoings came out, sold his shares to TKO and whoever else and in ironic way, main reason for Vince's 2023 departure was because Slim Jim threatened to pull out their sponsorship. It's hard to separate his personal life from his WWE work because in many ways those two overlapped each other. He projected a lot of his personality on his and other gimmicks on WWE TV, practically creating himself a bizarro world with all these crazy characters and stories. It's interesting how someone can be the mind behind Rock/Austin and Savage/Hogan and also be behind Roman/Corbin and Katy Vick and Miz/Priest match with the zombies. I can't go without mentioning sports entertainment thing, which is Vince's main original idea that he envisioned as term that's gonna replace dirty 'rasslin word that North Carolina part of him hates so much. Obviously there is less than 5 people on Earth that use sports entertainment instead of wrestling. He made wrestling a worldwide phenomenon at the cost of erasing a lot of wrestling's traditional values and replaced them with polished TV reality show elements. Strictly as a performer, he was a solid announcer (yes I don't think he was that bad), incredible promo, top tier heel, and for a guy that was limited and started wrestling in his 50s, passable in ring. He was never going to do Canadian Destroyer but he knew how to get heat and that's all that matters. Commentors below and above had already listed his exact right and wrong doings in personal life so I won't go over all that. Safe to say, he left behind a complicated legacy. |
| 4 | 12.08.2026 | Matzen | | |
| 5 | 30.07.2026 | moonwater805 | | |
| 6 | 27.07.2026 | EvieSonicFan124 | 10.0 | |
| 7 | 26.07.2026 | Captain Cheese | 8.0 | |
| 8 | 23.07.2026 | Oste | 9.0 | |
| 9 | 20.07.2026 | SSEighty7 | 5.0 | As far as the positives, he's a foundational guy, and without him, wrestling wouldn't be where it is today. When the heat is on, he's one of the greatest minds in the business, and if he sees you as a money maker, he has your full support. He's also always been willing to make himself like silly and stupid for the betterment of the company, and in-ring, if you're in a feud with him, he'll allow you to get your comeuppance. As far as the negatives (wrestling wise), he's held major grudges, held down people unjustly, and played a part in one of the biggest money blunders in history (Invasion). He played a major role in killing off potentially year's worth of storylines due to massive ego and pettiness. Also, he's steadfast in pushing what he wants pushed, regardless of how both the fans and the wrestlers feel. He basically makes the TV product to entertain him first and foremost instead of the fans. Now as far as outside of wrestling goes, he's a complete piece of garbage that should be rotting in jail for a host of reasons. My rating more reflects the totality of his TV wrestling existence, cause if I included outside wrestling endeavors and controversies more, he'd probably be a 0/10, but I'm trying to be fair to the purely wrestling aspect. Like Punk said, he's a multi-millionaire that should be a billionaire, and he's done a LOT to damage wrestling regardless of the positive things he did bring. In NFL terms, he's basically a coach that won two Super Bowls early on, and has barely sniffed the playoffs ever since, and still relying on Super Bowls he won a LONG time ago. |
| 10 | 19.06.2026 | Ado82nis | 6.0 | |
| 11 | 11.06.2026 | Sonny Karado | 8.0 | Vince made and didn't made very much in this business, he was successful at getting over his dad's and granddad's company, and made it the biggest company in the wrestling world, but don't forget all the crap that he did too, how we were in the pain of watching, how Vince ruined talent after talent, I don't really like TKO, but I don't prefer Vince neither. I give him an 8, because of all the crap that he did, but I can't rate him low for being part of making WWE successful for decades and being of the best heels in wrestling history |
| 12 | 08.06.2026 | DaWay | 7.0 | Oh, Vince, Vince, Vince... fuck the guy in real life, let's get that straight. And even inside of the WWE, he had so many lows, especially in his final ten years, and I don't think he should come back, but those highs... mamma MIA, those highs, though. Star-marker, and he was at the head of it all, in his prime, as a lunatic boss who was one of the best promos in his own company. Such a scumbag, but such a legend. It pains me to say. |
| 13 | 08.06.2026 | KadenW0201 | 10.0 | |
| 14 | 03.05.2026 | boubou79 | 6.0 | |
| 15 | 20.04.2026 | Felden | 7.0 | |
| 16 | 29.03.2026 | bungo | | |
| 17 | 22.03.2026 | Hose | 6.0 | Ich bin sehr zwiegespalten. Es gab Matches, die nicht gut, die sogar ziemlich unnötig waren - und es gab viele unvergessliche Momente, die Vince geprägt hat. Ob nun in Fehden mit Austin oder Rock, ohne ihn wäre vieles wesentlich weniger intensiv gewesen. Sein Mitwirken hat die WWE zu dem gemacht, was viele lieb(t)en. Seine Skandale hingegen, hui... |
| 18 | 21.03.2026 | Raditz Flair | 0.0 | He gets a lot of credit for things he didn't do or invent. Including the concept of the big event like Wrestlemania, naming it, the Royal Rumble, naming it, and Hulkamania. Hogan began cultivating that character and movement after Rocky III in AWA. He didn't come up "attitude", that was ECW. The only thing this guy pioneered was using monetary resources to build a huge roster of stars even when he had no intentional of using them meaningfully. When Bischoff did it in the 90's McMahon had a tantrum and cried foul. The Mr. McMahon character in 1998 was really good, no doubt. That's it. Beyond 1998 it was stale and useless. Then he made out with women on camera, made them strip, wrestle in pudding, gravy, or mud. Now we know for a fact he's a sadist with a humiliation kink and dabbled in light human trafficking. Admiring someone like that definitely makes me think less of people. |
| 19 | 18.03.2026 | Icenberg | 6.0 | |
| 20 | 24.02.2026 | AJ Styles was better than your favorite | 0.0 | Man, I don't even know where I should start with this rating because I have quite a bit to say. Let's not forget the disgusting stuff he did behind the scenes while WWE was becoming a big thing. Let's not forget how out of touch he was in 2017-2022. Raw was unwatchable, smackdown was inconsistent, PLES were boring, he had already begun to decline from 2010-2016, but he then became even worse. He's had some of the worst ideas in pro wrestling history and has zero respect for some of the wrestlers in his company. I do not want to see him anywhere near a wrestling promotion in 2026, it's only going to be worse than it already is. |
| 21 | 20.02.2026 | shawnwrestling | 10.0 | I'm rating Vince McMahon strictly as the on screen Mr. McMahon character, not the real life person. As a character, he is one of the greatest heels ever. He was willing to do anything for the story, from humiliating himself to playing the evil, power hungry boss perfectly. He could be funny, ridiculous, cruel, or completely unhinged depending on what the angle needed. The corrupt authority figure abusing his employees created the perfect villain and opened the door for someone like Austin to rise. That dynamic helped create one of the biggest storylines in wrestling history and pushed WWE to another level. As a character, Mr. McMahon was genius level heel work. |
| 22 | 15.02.2026 | JD7907 | 9.0 | Obwohl Vince sein Produkt ab der PG-Ära gekillt hat, hat er sein non-PG Mindset zum Glück nie verloren. Dank ihm gab es das beste No Holds Barred-Entertainment dass das Mainstream-Wrestling je gesehen hat und je sehen wird (Attitude- und Ruthless Aggression-Ära). Die Gegenwart und die Zukunft werden immer durch selbst gesteckte Grenzen eingeschränkt bleiben. Man darf außerdem nicht vergessen, dass er einer großen Wrestling-Promoter Dynastie abstammt und er diese für die Geschichte in unerreichbare Größeneinheiten gehoben hat. Zeitweise hätte ich nie geglaubt je diese Worte zu benutzen aber: God bless Vince! |
| 23 | 08.02.2026 | Mutoism | 0.0 | Okay, where I shall begin? He has been acused of being a rapist, using WWE money to cover his crimes, next he also cover a murderer and inducted him into his Hall of Fame, then he is the main reason why women wrestling is not as advanced as it should be, there is so much to say and too much to write about this despicable man, he is for sure in the E files, and he should be banned from everything related to wrestling, just disgusting all he has done, the philias he has projected across all his years in charge of the biggest pseudo wrestling company in the United States, he deserves nothing from the fans |
| 24 | 05.02.2026 | AndrewWish | 9.0 | Vince McMahon is the greatest heel in WWE history. It felt real, how he was this big evil boss man. Everyone hated him and that's what made him great, he wasn't one of those heels who you think is cool, he's one where you are cheering to loose, additionally his feud with stone cold might be the greatest feud in professional wrestling history. |
| 25 | 23.01.2026 | Jimmywrasslin2387 | 8.0 | |
| 26 | 13.01.2026 | Jonny Dubya | 10.0 | Say what you will about Vince McMahon personally, no one, and I mean NO ONE can deny the impact that Vince McMahon had on not just World Wrestling Entertainment, but ALL of professional wrestling. He made the WWF/WWE into a multi billion dollar company that's still going strong today. So, yeah Vince McMahon, regardless of his personal life, is THE single greatest promoter in professional wrestling. |
| 27 | 12.01.2026 | vincictor33 | 3.0 | |
| 28 | 06.01.2026 | SoundwaveAU | | |
| 29 | 01.01.2026 | btgc33 | | |
| 30 | 30.12.2025 | goldenbasket | 8.0 | |
| 31 | 22.12.2025 | daichi | 6.0 | |
| 32 | 12.12.2025 | Desmond33 | | |
| 33 | 11.12.2025 | RemyLeBeau | 7.0 | |
| 34 | 03.12.2025 | jaletta | 4.0 | He was able to get himself over as the most hated man in wrestling history while embodying exactly that in everything to do with his outside life. The last decade of his career was a stumbling mess both in and out of the ring. Awful human being, bad booker, and a personality that deteriorated consistently. There was nothing desirable about him being on the screen for the majority of his career, and the best portions involved riffing off stone cold. |
| 35 | 29.11.2025 | Aliiadwana | 8.0 | No one, again. No one can deny the work he did to the business, he did a lot of things, he's a good booker and also he changed the game in a way or another, I don't care about him as human. I'm rating his work for the business and he did a lot, so you should consider that, one of the best heels ever, oh definitely. He really changed the game. |
| 36 | 24.11.2025 | SharplyHate | 10.0 | |
| 37 | 09.11.2025 | Redisonsashuisosi | | |
| 38 | 29.10.2025 | chaqudemus | 6.0 | |
| 39 | 19.10.2025 | ILoveKyleFletcher | 0.0 | Let's go back to 2017-2019 shall we? The Jinder Mahal reign? The Brock-Kofi squash match? The start of the Saudi deal? The excessive Shane McMahon push? The 2019 HIAC match? Whose ideas were those? What about the attitude era? The bra and panties matches? The unneeded Austin heel turn? The weak invasion storyline? Whose ideas were those? HUH? Couldn't have been Trips. Couldn't have been TKO. Oh what a surprise! IT'S VINCE MCMAHON! NEVER utter the words "Good booking" and "Vince" in the same sentence. Need further help convincing yourself that this guy sucks? Look up "Vince McMahon lawsuit." Paul Heyman was on to something when he cut that "death to sports entertainment" promo. |
| 40 | 03.10.2025 | King of Strong Style | 10.0 | |
| 41 | 27.09.2025 | kennymmg | 10.0 | How can you rate this high Chris Benoit, who killed his own famil (wife and kids included) and then drag down Vince McMahon the following year he got pursuits when he had an average of 8.20? You're nothing but hypocrites with no brains and you've got no excuse. Vince McMahon has the kind of leadership Triple H will never have. He revolutionized and popularized wrestling by putting his own fortune on the line for WrestleMania 1. Attitude Era, Ruthless Agression, une qualité de booking que Tony Khan n'aura jamais de savie. He even made it a family product by lowering ticket prices, while TKO is now stuffing their faces with your money. Zero IQ, period. Firm opinion, and I mean every word i'm saying. |
| 42 | 23.08.2025 | Bockelito | 1.0 | This comes down to "do you sepparate the art from the artist". The answer to that debate should be no, because art is deeply connected to its creator and therefore should not be considered as distinct. Vince McMahon is the most important man in wrestling history. He helped creating two gigantic boom and created a worldwide monopoly which seems unreachable for any rival promotion. He was an awesome tv character and great foe to steve austin. But he was a horrible person, destroyed multiple promotions, careers and most importantly lives. He is the napoleon of wrestling. U.deniable impact, but belongs in the trash. |
| 43 | 21.08.2025 | Akitoshi | | A Critical Look at Vince McMahon's Controversies and Legacy Vince McMahon's impact on professional wrestling is undeniable--he transformed WWE from a regional promotion into a global entertainment empire. However, his legacy is not without significant controversy, often clouded by decades of troubling behavior, questionable creative decisions, and serious allegations. Racially Insensitive Storylines and Actions McMahon has been widely criticized for promoting racially insensitive content over the years. From stereotypical gimmicks assigned to Black, Asian, and Latino performers, to the infamous segment where he used the N-word on live television in a 2005 sketch involving John Cena and Booker T, McMahon's record on race is deeply problematic. Critics argue that many of these decisions reflect a tone-deaf or exploitative approach to racial identity for shock value or ratings. Sexism and Treatment of Women Throughout WWE's history under McMahon, women were often portrayed through a hyper-sexualized lens, especially during the "Attitude Era." Women were frequently booked in degrading segments like bikini contests, "bra and panties" matches, or forced to strip in the ring. Numerous female performers have spoken out about the toxic backstage culture and lack of respect for women as athletes. In recent years, WWE has attempted to move toward a more respectful presentation of its female talent, but much of that shift occurred after McMahon's influence began to wane. Allegations of Sexual Misconduct In 2022 and 2023, McMahon stepped down as WWE CEO following investigations into hush money payments allegedly made to suppress claims of sexual misconduct. Reports indicated he paid millions of dollars to multiple women to silence allegations of coercion and inappropriate workplace relationships. While McMahon denied wrongdoing, these allegations were enough to prompt investigations by WWE's board and damage public trust. Homophobic Content WWE under McMahon has also aired content that many considered homophobic, particularly during the 1990s and early 2000s. Segments mocking LGBTQ+ individuals or using slurs as punchlines were not uncommon. While the company has since made attempts to be more inclusive, the past damage and lack of apology for some of these portrayals still linger. Problematic Storylines Involving Minors There have been creative choices under McMahon's leadership that many fans found deeply inappropriate, including storylines involving minors or age-inappropriate romantic angles. While these weren't criminal actions, the tone and nature of some of these segments have drawn criticism for poor taste and lack of ethical oversight. Final Thoughts Vince McMahon may be hailed as a business visionary, but the darker side of his reign--marked by racist, sexist, and exploitative content, as well as serious misconduct allegations--cannot and should not be ignored. His legacy is a reminder of how power, left unchecked, can foster a culture that marginalizes and exploits others. As WWE evolves into a new era, many fans hope that the next generation of leadership learns from these failings rather than repeats them. |
| 44 | 20.08.2025 | Blacker | 8.0 | |
| 45 | 18.08.2025 | Luj | 10.0 | |
| 46 | 07.08.2025 | fkrs1829 | | |
| 47 | 30.07.2025 | OnyxGuard | 8.0 | |
| 48 | 23.07.2025 | getsworkedintoshoots | 7.0 | |
| 49 | 12.07.2025 | TrueJugoBetrugoNo1 | 9.0 | |
| 50 | 10.07.2025 | gk lad0902 | 0.0 | "Vince McMahon is the most influential man in wrestling".So you mean to tell me without Vince McMahon we wouldn't have wrestling being accepted as the 4th priority in a WRESTLING company and we wouldn't have a ton of sexual abusers walking free and making money from the industry. You mean to tell me I have to suck this guys dick because he poisoned a whole generation to believe any wrestling other than the WWE is inferior and that they shouldn't think about the product and just blindly consume? I don't know man, maybe this guy should never have been born, thats just me though. And I haven't even covered half of the reasons why this guy is a piece of shit. Most of the people here are either blinded by nostalgia or are one of those "seperate the art from the artist" type of folks. Well when a guy says the n word on pay per view and forces one of his employees to bark like a dog on national television and then goes ahead and runs an illegal sex trafficking ring, then no I can't really do that because the art matches the artist, if you can even call it that. Fuck this guy. Utter disgrace. |
| 51 | 05.07.2025 | TERRYFUNKFANATIC | 6.0 | |
| 52 | 11.06.2025 | Mark4Lyfe | 7.0 | Vince McMahon is one of the most influential figures in professional wrestling history--both for better and worse. As a promoter and businessman, his vision undeniably transformed WWE into a global powerhouse. The Attitude Era, WrestleMania's growth, and the ruthless expansion of WWE all happened under his watch. But his legacy is complicated. While he created stars like Austin, Rock, and Taker, he also famously micromanaged talent and often stifled organic crowd favorites. His in-ring work as "Mr. McMahon" was iconic in its own right, playing one of the greatest heel authority figures ever. However, creative stagnation in later years and serious real-world controversies have rightfully tainted how many view his contributions. A polarizing figure, but a titan nonetheless. |
| 53 | 26.05.2025 | JRMac | 8.0 | |
| 54 | 18.05.2025 | snowfall | 4.0 | - Terrible human - Barely competent booker since at least the end of the ruthless aggression era - Consistently held down guys who got over own their own - His goal was always the disneyfication of wrestling, and on the path to attaining that goal, he destroyed any speck of believability the business still had - The only positive about him is that he caused the WWE to make shit tons of money, which I couldn't care less about, but some of that money went towards paying the boys, which is wonderful. |
| 55 | 17.05.2025 | CO9000 | 3.0 | There is no doubt that without this man, WWE or professional wrestling in general wouldn't be where it is today. We wouldn't have had stars such as Hulk Hogan, The Rock, Steve Austin, The Undertaker, John Cena, etc. And we wouldn't have had some of the most memorable moments in WWE history. However, his questionable decisions (especially during his later years), combined with the fact that he's a shit human being, essentially drown out all the positive things. And don't get me started on all the sexual allegations that he's went through. Again, you gotta give him props for all the contributions he made with WWE and the entire pro wrestling scene, but Vince McMahon as a human being? Genuinely disgusting. |
| 56 | 16.05.2025 | Olympus19 | 10.0 | |
| 57 | 12.05.2025 | bherbert1980 | 0.0 | Vince McMahon will always be the man who took wrestling global, but history needs to stop pretending that makes him some untouchable genius. The truth is he was a visionary in the 80s, an accidental beneficiary of a red-hot roster in the 90s, and an anchor dragging WWE down through most of the 2000s and 2010s. By the mid-2000s, Vince became the very thing he once rebelled against -- an out-of-touch, egomaniacal gatekeeper who stifled creativity, forced his bizarre fetishes onto programming, and micromanaged the life out of his product. His creative vision post-Attitude Era was rotten with juvenile humor, corporate-safe characters, and cringe-worthy storylines that undermined talent at every turn. His obsession with controlling every word, every gesture, every camera angle suffocated stars like Bray Wyatt, Rusev, Cesaro, and countless others who could have thrived if left to their own devices. Vince didn't just fail to adapt. He actively sabotaged anyone who didn't fit his narrow mold. And beyond the creative failures, the man's personal conduct is indefensible. His alleged use of hush money, sexual harassment, and reported connections to trafficking-level abuses paint a dark, ugly shadow over his entire legacy. Vince didn't just foster a toxic work culture. He was the toxic culture. He manipulated, exploited, and cast aside countless employees, women, and talent while propping himself up as the king of the circus. Yes, he made wrestling what it is. And yes, he very nearly killed it in the process. It took his forced exit to allow WWE to breathe again. His departure was not a tragedy. It was an overdue purge. |
| 58 | 11.05.2025 | Moranjeboom | 8.0 | |
| 59 | 21.04.2025 | Weberklaus00 | | |
| 60 | 20.04.2025 | JackWatchesWrestling | 6.0 | One of the best heels of all time, and one of the worst people. Never good in ring but could always cut a great promo. He was best when he was barely around |
| 61 | 19.04.2025 | ryderj | 8.0 | |
| 62 | 18.04.2025 | yamom | 10.0 | |
| 63 | 07.04.2025 | kingofdrew | 3.0 | Vince McMahon is a great figure. He is clearly someone who contributed greatly to the rise of the professional wrestling industry, but on the other hand, he is also someone who has many horror stories. So, I think Vince during the Attitude Era was a great person, but the current Vince is like a broken clock that is sometimes right. He certainly created megastars like Hogan, Austin, and Rock Cena, but he also buried countless wrestlers. And his later years were filled with bizarre scripts that were too much to handle, and he ended up stepping down from his position as president due to a sexual harassment scandal. |
| 64 | 07.04.2025 | MikEagle54 | 10.0 | Elevated the business to a billion dollar industry is extraordinary. For me he is the best heel in WWE history. He has done so much for this business, a lot of sacrifices.This man is my spiritual father. If I could only have one match at WrestleMania, it would be with or against Vince McMahon. You can do whatever you want with him. He's turned wrestling into a mainstream media. He's very, very difficult to get close to, even physically because he has 2 bodyguards and he's very intimidating, but if he starts to like you, if he starts to trust you, he can become a spiritual father. Vince McMahon is a genius who revolutionized the wrestling industry. |
| 65 | 22.03.2025 | ICtheFourthColour | 10.0 | Vince McMahon is the greatest promoter to ever live. A quintessential American success story and one of the most interesting people of the late 20th and early 21st centuries. Innovative and a definitive big picture guy. An unparalleled middle-aged emergence as on-screen superstar.. He has no criminal record despite a litany of slander against the man most responsible for the genre as we know it today. |
| 66 | 21.03.2025 | LariatOfFire | 9.0 | |
| 67 | 21.03.2025 | Justdawg | 6.0 | |
| 68 | 05.03.2025 | AnB | 7.0 | How do you even rate someone like Vince McMahon? He's arguably the most important character in pro wrestling history. As time went on it seemed like he wasn't so much playing a character as he was allowing his inner self loose on the big screen. While he's done a lot for the growth of the industry he's also done a lot to make sure the less productive and positive aspects of the industry kept going strong. It doesn't help that he's just an absolutely terrible human being. Any purist will hate him with a passion, and I think that's a completely legitimate opinion to have. I can't stand the guy, but I certainly enjoyed having such an obviously awful person to root against every week. |
| 69 | 05.03.2025 | Wunderkid | 9.0 | The Greatest. You can see all these negative reviews, but that's life as the owner of a wrestling company. From Bischoff to Heyman to Gagne, every promoter has their imperfections, and people will hate them for it. You'll never find a wrestling promoter who is universally loved, unlike wrestlers, where the majority can agree that stars like Austin or Shawn are among the greatest despite their flaws. It's no coincidence that the greatest is the most hated. There's simply too much for promoters to handle to be judged solely on every wrestler they've wronged. Wrestling is an unpredictable business, and perfection is impossible. Yet, despite the challenges, he managed to transform a regional wrestling territory into a global monopoly in just 40 years while being responsible for some of the greatest television in wrestling history. On top of that, he's also one of the greatest on-screen characters of all time. He was just as important as Austin when it came to the Attitude Era. -1 point for his booking of WWE in the latter years, though. |
| 70 | 28.02.2025 | JediSaiyanMaster1203 | 10.0 | |
| 71 | 27.02.2025 | piotrusjasigma | 8.0 | |
| 72 | 26.02.2025 | hadpeasbfo | | A complete psychopath and mental case, and the greatest wrestling promoter who has ever lived. One of the most interesting and consequential people in post-war American history. Could not wrestle. |
| 73 | 21.02.2025 | schnuff ecks | 6.0 | Undeniably the greatest promoter of all time, and one of the best heel characters ever. With that being said, he was a good booker, until he wasn't anymore and overstayed his welcome. Also a pretty mediocre worker, even if he was willing to take every bump and run every blade imaginable. Vince was one of the best things that ever happened to wrestling, and then he became the worst thing that ever happened to wrestling |
| 74 | 20.02.2025 | MEDamine | 0.0 | All I'm gonna say is may he soon rest in piss, terrible human being and a cancer to wrestling industry (no matter how much good thing he did for it), and the bigger problem is that a lot of stupid and terrible things he did in WWE has damaged a lot of "wrestling fans" brain and wrestling knowledge, I don't care about attitude era or his feud with Stone Cold or about the "funny moments", sure he did a lot of memorable things for WWE and that "he made wrestling famous and popular", but you must all know that Vince didn't even like wrestling, in fact he hated it, and he wanted (and succeed) to turn WWE/WWF into sports entertainement instead of wrestling, so he should not take credit for "making wrestling famous", he is one of the worst personalities in wrestling and I didn't even need to talk about his criminal record |
| 75 | 20.02.2025 | Rosya | 9.0 | We estimate characters, don't we? Mr. McMahon's been the greatest heel ever so far. No influentional biss McMahon - no wrestling in USA would develope |
| 76 | 19.02.2025 | TwiggyShark | 1.0 | Leaving aside his growing criminal record, I have never liked Mr. McMahon's character in WWE, because I knew it would end in a mediocre match full of tricks so that his inexperience would not be so evident, people remember with great nostalgia his segments (where Stone Cold did everything) that were not as good as they think. Creatively it was noted that without Patterson and others he is not the creative genius that he made us believe (this idiot almost cancelled the Royal Rumble and many of the good things that happened in WWE were despite him, and not thanks to him). Whether he is good or not in business is not the point on this page... anyway I give him 1 point for his match against Shawn Michaels at Wrestlemania 22. Vince will be remembered as the man who formed the image of what current wrestling is, just because that is how he portrayed himself on his own show... sad that many fall for it and continue preaching that lie. |
| 77 | 14.02.2025 | darkflame4527 | | |
| 78 | 13.02.2025 | Cappone-ceraio | 6.0 | |
| 79 | 02.02.2025 | YuuRiTK | 8.0 | |
| 80 | 17.01.2025 | Skitzlee247 | 1.0 | A heel inside and out of the ring.... Vince McMahon may have changed the face of wrestling, but his legacy is now buried under scandals, hush-money payments, and allegations that make even his worst storylines seem tame..... His obsession with control stifled talent, while his questionable ethics disillusioned employees and fans alike.... His wrestling was dreadful. Clunky and being carried by other performers. I guess he could have the crowd in the palm of his hand as a heel and would give his all to his performance...... If he's aiming to be remembered as the ultimate villain, he's nailed it -- but this time, it's not scripted..... I agree this mans rating needs to be brought down, it surely must be nostalgia that carries his rating....... |
| 81 | 12.01.2025 | dizzied | 0.0 | How is this guy over an 8 in average? His average definitely needs to be brought down. He is a criminal, narcissist, and deviant. Also he was a murderer leading Owen Hart to his death (it was noted well in Dark Side of the Ring that he didnt want to do that stunt). Even as a wrestler, he was horrible. Yes, he brought WWF/WWE to the forefront but he ruined many peoples lives and refused to go with the times. Even as a promoter, He was notorious for pushing bigger wrestlers even if they weren't the best workers and failing to push smaller wrestlers until he was forced to do so (i.e. Bryan Danielson). He also demeaned his employees (i.e. Trish Stratus, Hornswoggle, etc). Fortunately it seems like his son-in-law has a better head for the times. People that would've never made it to the Hall of Fame such as Bull Nakano get in now. Funny, how this platform is saying my comment is too low for the rating I am giving this piece of garbage. |
| 82 | 03.01.2025 | Your5Guy | 1.0 | Oh boy, Vince McMahon Jr... If it was not for this man, wrestling would not be where it is today, he built the largest company in the world (as of now) whose legacy is a combination of excellence, but also of abuse and degeneracy. People only give him any praise and recognition because he founded and lead the WWF, now WWE, for 42 years, and the WWF/E had many heights which embodied the best parts of wrestling. However, Vince McMahon himself, was not a good booker, I firmly do not believe that Wrestling was all downhill since 2001, but the cracks began to show, and in 2016-2021, Vince's booking was so bad that WWE felt unwatchable. Is it a surprise that since 2023, when Vince lost his power, WWE started getting better? But all of the above is about how he was as a booker, but Vince as a person was one of the worst human beings in Wrestling. He would very famously put wrestlers and figures into embarrassing storylines specifically to humiliate them, and would regularly mistreat some of his best employees, like Jim Ross. However, his misdeeds cross from assholery to flat out illegal degeneracy, in the early 80s he covered up a murder, to preserve the image of one of his wrestlers (Jimmy Snuka), his negligence and desire to humiliate the wrestler, Owen Hart, ended up leading to his preventable death, allowing misconduct, and now we know, he's a rapist. He may have started the biggest wrestling company in the world, but he is, and always was, a deplorable human being, and I am glad he's getting the dishonour he deserves. |
| 83 | 02.01.2025 | Gold Fists | | |
| 84 | 02.01.2025 | Isyys | 6.0 | |
| 85 | 30.12.2024 | Shainy | 10.0 | |
| 86 | 20.12.2024 | SupaKool | 8.0 | |
| 87 | 11.12.2024 | Leth99 | 0.0 | The mainly bad things happened in the wrestling world because of this guy. And I CAN'T about all of those things. Just find them. Everyone knows how bad he was as a promoter, booker, human being and the horrible things he did to people's lifes. Not talking about to what he did to the girls, but the WRESTLERS. Think about the wrestlers that lost years of their lives in a company that has no ability to do things right. For how bad Vince Russo was, at least he was trying to be somewhat innovative booking things and not being boring. I see no redeeming qualities about Vince in the wrestling world. And the only reason he won is because guys like Bischoff were controlling WCW. Plus, just to remind you, many of the stars of WWE were HATED by Vince and were mainly kept by guys like JR, Heyman and Brisco. Vince was good at surrounding himself with people, not at being a promoter. Once he got Johnny Ace by his side WWE totally lost themselves for 20 years. |
| 88 | 06.12.2024 | HulkaMania Never Dies | | Unable to rate at the moment due to being a new account, but I would give Vince McMahon a 9/10 booking wise, and a 10/10 character wise. Controversies aside, the man propelled pro wrestling from dying territorial days to what it is today and had the vision to make it what it is. Personally, I favor Vince's booking better than the current product because of how much more corporatised its become today. Not to say that his booking was always good 100% of the time, though. His peak booking came during the Attitude/Ruthless aggression era and his peak character came during the Austin/McMahon feud. |
| 89 | 04.12.2024 | AJN7 | | |
| 90 | 01.12.2024 | EasyLink | 10.0 | |
| 91 | 26.11.2024 | AceHagann | 1.0 | I am sure the high rating Vince has is because of his work as an executive, promoter, and the many other things he did across the decades he spent building the immense empire that WWE is today. That is understandable, because yes, all of that is true. The world of wrestling as it is today would be entirely different had he not stepped in. However, he was far from perfect. As years passed by, some of his booking choices became more and more flawed, if not outright wrong. Many potential stars with bright futures came to WWE only for their reputation and credibility to be dragged through the mud. Him no longer leading WWE is a blessing for fans of the business. Now, as for the thing I am actually reviewing here. He was indeed willing to take crazy bumps and risk his body for a good show, but he simply wasn't a good wrestler. At all. And while his heel work is good, it was best suited for a non-wrestler, an authority figure. That's when he truly shone. |
| 92 | 18.11.2024 | MMSuperBoyo | | |
| 93 | 25.10.2024 | Phrygo | 3.0 | Spent years and years building WWF/E, and then spent years and years wrecking it. Years of decent to brilliant decisions followed by years of dud after dud, all wrapped up by being ousted from his own company. The fact the best thing Vince-related that happened to the WWE in years was him being forced out due to his disgusting actions (which could have legitimately been the ending of the company in general if the people that picked it up were of the same mentality as him booking wise) says it all. |
| 94 | 23.10.2024 | lukasmgc | 8.0 | |
| 95 | 22.10.2024 | TNBG2381 | 10.0 | |
| 96 | 19.10.2024 | Zak22 | 3.0 | Let's ignore what a real world dickhead he is and focus on the pro side. Vince has had a huge impact on the industry but not a good one in my opinion, Vince violently went after any and all competition from national companies to small territories and as a result Vince gained a near monopoly on pro wrestling in the US, and with this Vince promoted a style of pro wrestling which I frankly dislike. Vince also made far more awful decisions than good decisions, he buried lots of good talent, fucked up the invasion storyline over tribalistic bullshit, held women back, ruined the potential gold the ECW revival could have given us. I hate the WWF Golden Age, its just not my thing, the attitude and ruthless aggression eras were hit and miss, everything after 2007/8 was shit. Bad decision maker, poor commentator, mediocre in-ring, damaged the industry. |
| 97 | 17.10.2024 | socktherapy | 9.0 | |
| 98 | 14.10.2024 | Prokrastynator | 8.0 | Professional wrestling would look entirely different or even be completely forgotten without this guy. He's definietly a father of pro wrestling. |
| 99 | 08.10.2024 | Itterbob | 7.0 | |
| 100 | 05.10.2024 | LT | | Vince McMahon kann man kein Rating geben. Ich wüsste wirklich nicht welches. Er hat Wrestling, wie wir es heute kennen, erschaffen. Er ist einer der größten Buisnessmänner aller Zeiten und hat Wrestling zu dem Mainstream Phänomen gemacht, was es heute ist. Er ist aber auch ein unglaublich abgefuckter Mensch, was allerspätestens die Anklagen gegen ihn bezüglich S*xhandels bestätigen sollten.Die Netflix Doku gibt da einen guten Einblick. Außerdem hat er zwar modernes Wrestling erschaffen, es aber in seinen späteren Jahren auch kreativ fast komplett gekillt. WWE von 2017-2022 ist das schlechteste Produkt der Firmengeschichte und auch mit das schlechteste Mainstream Wrestlingprodukt, an das ich mich erinnern kann. Wären die Anklagen nicht gewesen hätte McMahon die Company vermutlich irgendwann gekillt, aber da jetzt Triple H das Sagen hat geht es WWE besser denn je. Ich unterscheide normalerweise zwischen Künstler und Werk, aber da Vince McMahon sowohl als Wrestligpersona, als auch als Mensch extrem spaltet ist er der einzige Eintrag auf dieser Seite, den ich irgendwie nicht bewerten kann. Einfach ein ? /10. |
#