| Timeframe | Title | Duration | Details |
| 15.07.2018 - 03.09.2018 | WWE RAW Tag Team Champion (2x) (with Bo Dallas as The B-Team) | 50 days | Matches |
| 16.06.2013 - 18.11.2013 | WWE Intercontinental Champion | 155 days | Matches |
| 23.05.2011 - 22.08.2011 | WWE Tag Team Champion (as Michael McGillicutty; with David Otunga) | 91 days | Matches |
| 15.07.2010 - 16.07.2010 | FCW Florida Tag Team Champion (4x) (as Michael McGillicutty; with Kaval) | 1 day | Matches |
| 14.01.2010 - 13.03.2010 | FCW Florida Tag Team Champion (3x) (as Joe Hennig; with Brett DiBiase as The Fortunate Sons) | 58 days | Matches |
| 26.02.2009 - 19.03.2009 | FCW Florida Heavyweight Champion (as Joe Hennig) | 21 days | Matches |
| 11.09.2008 - 30.10.2008 | FCW Florida Tag Team Champion (2x) (as Joe Hennig; with Sebastian Slater) | 49 days | Matches |
| 12.07.2008 - 15.07.2008 | FCW Florida Tag Team Champion (as Joe Hennig; with Gabe Tuft) | 3 days | Matches |
| Title | Duration |
| FCW Florida Heavyweight Championship | 21 days |
| FCW Florida Tag Team Championship (4x) | 111 days |
| WWE Intercontinental Championship | 155 days |
| WWE World Tag Team Championship (2x) | 141 days |
