[3.0] "His voice and speaking cadence is devoid of any enthusiasm and emotion. He sucked during week 1 of college football in the 2025 season during the Alabama/Florida State game. He sucked on MNF especially during the wild Rams/Chiefs game in 2018. WWE has gone through a lot of rotten announcers in the last 5 years and he's included. He's no different than Adnan Virk who is also unpopular in college football circles. I dunno, maybe hire someone who gives a shit about wrestling. He sounds more like an old game show host announcer telling the contestants their consolation prizes than an excited commentator."
[5.0] "The most competent but generic announcer I've possibly ever heard. I've never heard him have a stand out calling of a match, never heard him have entertaining banter with his color commentator or have really given him much thought to be honest. But he's never screwed up from what I can remember and has never been annoying like several other past and present WWE commentators. The most average commentator to possibly ever exist."
[5.0] "This guy just never sounds like he cares about the match he's commentating. Something crazy could happen and he'd just calmly say "wow! ". He really kills my mood whatever match he's in to be honest. Not a good commentator"
[4.0] "He's definitely not bad at all, but I feel like he's just very monotone and boring on the mic. He's very "serious" when doing commentary, and it definitely works in some aspects but more often than not I find it to be very rough to listen to. A lot better than the other commentators they've shoe horned into the role before, but I feel like WWE are still missing a very good balance to Wade Barrett on SmackDown commentary."
[7.0] "For someone who hasn't even been doing WWE commentary for 2 years I think he's pretty good. He clearly has a passion for it and is trying his absolute best to be good, which is clearly showing on TV. I think he does sound a bit robotic at times but like I said, he's still so new to this. I'm not expecting him to be JR levels of good."
[9.0] "Really love his chemistry with Wade Barrett. So much better than the so-called "voice of the WWE" Michael Cole. He's a great addition to the commentary team, has a lot of knowledge about wrestling and doesn't come off as pretentious as an outsider."
[8.0] "He has been a pleasant surprise. He started off on the wrong foot when I read some poor comments he made years prior about the wrestling industry before signing. But it seems like he genuinely no longer believes those comments. So that's water under the bridge for me. I remember thinking he sounded somewhat subdued on his first night. But hearing him some months after, I think he's come a long way in a short time. He sounds like a pro & isn't over the top with his yelling the way that Michael Cole is."
[8.0] "UPDATE FROM 10/15/24: Joe Tessitore has been a welcome commentator on RAW, constantly increasing his knowledge about the sport and knows when to time his reactions and keep the crowd engaged into any match. Hopefully this momentum keeps going and he stays for a long time."
[8.0] "I can tell the guy is really trying. He's not amazing, but each week he is improving. Not sure if someone backstage is giving him feedback because if they are, it's working. First few weeks were a little off, but it is clearly his first time commentation pro wrestling. As time goes on, I don't see him being a perminant fixrue in wwe, but for now, I have no issues with him and he has my trust in commentation raw for the near future... plus, him on Raw means no Pat Mac anywhere in sight :)"
[8.0] "Very quickly found his feet - I was worried after his first RAW, where he was very flat, but he's had some fantastic calls in his so-far short career, with a highlight being his words following Jey Uso's IC win. Hope he has a long tenure with the company, and I hope he's kept paired with Wade Barret, as their rapport is fantastic."
[10.0] "His knowledge of pro wrestling is very accurate and complete. His voice in the reporting section is very classic and reminds me of the old days and makes me very emotional. He is currently the best WWE reporter after the legendary Michael Cole."
[8.0] "I really enjoy Joes commentary and have loved the energy he brings. For being so new to the world of wrestling hes done a good job and I expect he will get better in years to come."
"I cannot get myself to get behind Tessitore yet. His commentary is awkward and it seems he often forgets he is supposed to do the play-by-play. His vocal tone is good for a commentator, but he just doesn't know enough about professional wrestling to be on WWE's flagship show at this point."
[3.0] "Very dry and monotone delivery and seems to have zero knowledge of wrestling. Maybe things will change later but I have my doubts. Brings no energy or excitement to the show. As of right now he just doesn't belong on RAW in my opinion"
[8.0] "Monday Night RAW has been through a turntable carousel of play-by-play commentators over the past 5 years since 2019. A majority of the commentators that have been hired to do their job on RAW haven't worked out; But I feel like this time around, WWE has hit a ball out of the park with Joe Tessitore. Joe has only been commentating on RAW for a few weeks and he has been killing it and doing phenomenal with his reactions and commentary work. His commentary of Jey Uso getting a crowning moment on RAW was epic and I don't think anyone (not even Michael Cole) could have done it any better than Joe did. I know Joe is only going to be on RAW until the year is over when RAW goes to Netflix but I hope WWE keeps this guy around and makes him the Smackdown play-by-play guy, he has proven that he belongs at a WWE announce desk."