Seth Rollins

[10.0] "One of the best in this company. All these years he achieved so many championships and other things like. mitb and Royal Rumble win. He deserve to be called , , The GOAT of WWE"."

[10.0] "UNDENIABLY one of the greatest to ever do it. Ring skill, promo skills selling, acting, you name it he was one of the best at everything he did."

[9.0] "He's not perfect, but overall Seth has been one of the better parts about modern WWE over the past 10 years. Amazing work rate, constantly improves or reinvents himself, and is always interesting to watch. His charisma is overall pretty great, though sometimes hit or miss. His in ring psychology is perhaps the greatest amongst the current roster aside from Punk."

[4.0] "Honestly one of the most overpushed wrestlers of modern times. In ring, Seth is athletic and can be adept at wrestling really good sprints in the mid card (see: His 2018 IC title reign). But his track record of big main event matches is pretty...mixed? At best. He only seems to know how to wrestle one type of match and unless the opponent and/or storyline is really good he doesn't get fans interested just by himself. Whenever he gets a push in the main event whether as a face or heel the result is always the same. Boring monotonous promos, fans disinterested in his lengthy main event matches. See the aforementioned 2018 (otherwise his best year) where his big PPV matches against Dolph Ziggler and Dean Ambrose both went down like a lead balloon. He gets a rating as high as 4 for being a good athlete and a really good tag wrestler and that's honestly it. Anything beyond that he just loses me."

[10.0] "Rollins is the workhorse of the WWE. He is one of the most exciting athletes but is also consistently innovating his character work and elevating his game."

"Seth Rollins does not connect with me. The presentation feels forced. The character work is irritating rather than compelling. Very difficult to enjoy."

[9.0] "His in ring skill is above almost anyone in history. Him 2015 might have been the greatest prime I've ever seen."

[6.0] "I feel like they don't know what to do with his character since trying to make him either a face or a tweener (not a good sign that I can't tell). May also just be a casualty of them wanting to have Roman be a face but still having him act like a heel."

[9.0] "Back in the dark days of WWE in 2017-20, Seth Rollins was the one big bright spot that the WWE main roster had. Especially on Monday Night Raw when the world champion was absent, Monday Night Rollins would step up and often be the best part of the show. He has continued this role for the past 5 years and always been a consistent talent who can deliver amazing matches and be a great character worker. If he hadn't been injured in 2015 I think he would genuinely be considered a Shawn Michaels-level worker."

[3.0] "Enjoyed his work as Tyler Black in ROH and some of his earlier stuff in WWE, but as of late Seth has been disappointment after disappointment. Now, I can't blame the man himself for not trying as countless injuries and some bad creative have let him down, but all of this still makes for a wrestler who is more often than not brutally painful to watch with his sluggish offence and overall very poor in-ring work. A couple of years ago I might have rated Seth a 7, maybe Tyler an 8, but in the current day Seth is no more than a 3 in my mind."

"Seth Rollins is undeniably one of the most complete performers of his generation. His ability to constantly reinvent his character--from The Architect to The Monday Night Messiah and The Visionary--shows a deep understanding of wrestling psychology and gimmick work. In the ring, his moveset is incredibly dynamic and crisp, perfectly blending high-flying agility with technical precision. What truly sets him apart is his commitment to storytelling during his matches. He paces his offense logically, his physical selling is mostly on point, and he constantly takes bumps that make his opponents look devastating. He has carried the company on his back through various eras and consistently delivers main-event caliber performances regardless of his spot on the card. A true modern-day great who understands every nuance of the industry."

[10.0] "First ballot hall of famer and one of the greatest of all time, easily. Even now, being all banged he's capable of having one of the best matches of any card, while also being perfectly capable of making also any kind of angle, no matter how bad its premises, work."

[10.0] "He is one of the best of the modern era, stretching from his days in Ring of Honor, to his current status in WWE, Seth Rollins has been one of the all time greatest. He will go down in the pantheon of all-time greats."

[5.0] "Seth Rollins is a good wrestler who suffers from terrible gimmicks and no charisma what so ever. He's the least interesting member of the shield and ruins every feud he enters not to mention his inability to talk for 2 minutes without doing his stupid laugh"

[10.0] "One of WWE's brightest stars, he's a blast in the ring and on the mic. Watching him perform is a joy."

[9.0] "8/10 from me personally, Accomplishments - 9.5, Charisma/Character Work - 9.5, Cultural Significance - 8.5, In-Ring Skills - 9.5, Longevity - 10 and Move-Set - 9 = 91 rounded down to 9/10."

[10.0] "Seth Rollins has been working his ass off ever since he joined WWE, only injuries have been able to stop him, betrayed the shield, treated as a main eventer, injured 2 years later, came back, worked his way to the top for 3 years, carried the raw roster midcard division on his back, winning the intercontinental championship, winning tag team championships with Dean Ambrose and freaking Jason Jordan for crying out loud, won the royal rumble, beat Brock Lesnar twice in 2019 in Brock's peak years, and when there was nothing else for him to give as a face, he turned heel again, played second fiddle in the entire pandemic era, and when that ended, he rose up to main event level again after becoming the inaugural world champion, and do not get me started on his wrestling abilities, fucker can put up a good match with a dead horse. Seth Rollins is one of the best workers of this generation and people will only understand it after he's gone..."

[8.0] "as i may struggle with most of his storylines, his personas, i still think he's among the very best in the actual era, he's stunning in the ring even though he has severely restrained himself after all these knee problems. he's just the right mix of charisma and athleticism while being a true workhorse for his company"

[6.0] "All the goofy outfits, sunglasses, and strange laughs can't cover up the fact that none of it feels connected to who he really is. He perpetually looks like he's wearing a costume for a themed frat party. None of his promos sound genuine except the ones about CM Punk which are a work but sound real so good on him for that. He was a lot better in the ring before the constant injuries and now he just takes up space on the roster. It's a shame WWE operates the way it does because letting someone like him work elsewhere for a while would make him interesting again."

[8.0] "Rating Seth in the present time is hard because unfortunately he has lost a lot of what him great. He was a good performer in The Shield then stepped up even more after they broke up, leading to an amazing 2015 for him. Sadly though his knee injury killed off a lot of his momentum and he's never really been at the same level since. Good as a cocky heel but a bit weak as a babyface. Once he started doing his weird cartoony gimmick wearing the silly suits I lost all interest and I am still not interested in his character and in-ring work these days"

[6.0] "Seth has in-ring skills to put on decent matches. However, the problem with seth is his promo sound more like acting them him actually saying something and since after the monday night messiah character, he has not have good character work."

[0.0] "character' change from around 3/4 years ago. Its fucking unbearable. From the stupid over the top clothing, idiotic facial expressions, irritating nasal promos and general vibe that screams 'this is all fake, don't take any of it seriously' - it's go away heat for me. It's not good heel heat, it's just shit. To make matters even worse his wife now has exactly the same character, so we have two of these fake fucks to tolerate Seth Rollins is the worst wrestler I've ever seen -- even worse than Shawn Michaels. His wrestling style is supposedly all-rounder, but he clearly has no understanding of what that actually means. He confuses being "all-rounded" with having no style at all and just throwing random moves. A true all-rounder knows how to control a match based on psychology -- adjusting his style (technical, brawler, etc.) depending on the match and using a contrasting style for the finish. Rollins, on the other hand, does everything without any sense. His finisher is the Curb Stomp, which should mean he works on the opponent's head and exploits their weaknesses. But he just randomly targets the entire body with no logical progression -- like a book that talks about everything but has no real subject. He doesn't even follow basic ring psychology -- for example, corner combat. When he gets his opponent into the corner, he doesn't use it to shift momentum or take full control. He just throws random punches with no structure. As for character work, he's terrible too. His only decent gimmick was the Messiah. Bottom line: He's not a good wrestler."

[10.0] "I'm not a WWE fan, but I really love Seth's work. He was an absolute beast as a youngster, and now that he's almost 40, he carries every event or episode he's part of. Had bangers for over a decade now, made almost every gimmick bigger than life and, in terms of in-ring storytelling, he might be the best in the world. As an outsider, I look at him as the face of the company."

[6.0] "Seth Rollins can feel frustrating to watch. The main issue is how his matches focus too much on flashy sequences instead of struggle and realism. Puro fans usually want every move to feel heavy and meaningful, but Rollins often jumps from big spot to big spot without letting the damage really matter. The selling is another big problem. In puro-style wrestling, if a wrestler's knee or back gets targeted, it usually affects the entire match. With Rollins, he might sell for a moment but then suddenly move like nothing happened so he can continue the next sequence. That breaks the sense of realism many puro fans value. His pacing also feels very different. Instead of slowly building intensity, Rollins matches can feel like they rush toward big moments too quickly. The match becomes more about highlights than about tension or endurance."

[6.0] "Seth Rollins is often praised, but a lot of his work lands in the middle. Solid athlete, reliable performer, yet rarely truly great. Many matches blur together, promos swing between loud and forced, and big moments sometimes feel manufactured rather than organic. Consistent, yes--but consistency alone doesn't make him exceptional."

[8.0] "I wanna like Seth more, but I feel like something is missing. He's still really good in the ring, but not as dynamic as he once was. He can have a good match with just about anyone. Promo and character work have neen inconsistent and I wish he'd be more serious. All the laughing he does ruins it for me sometimes. Working like he's a face, but acting like a heel makes it confusing to figure out what he's going for."

"He exists as an example of someone getting rammed down the WWE fan's throats so much that it actually worked, this is probably why his heel work comes naturally and is believable. His promo skills are great, his in-ring work is greater; but he still never reached that true "Top Guy" status for whatever reason. I'd have to follow up with saying that he is underappreciated for the most part, as he's definitely (to me) the best all-rounder that the WWE has had for the better part of a decade, but his lows have been absolutely awful."

[9.0] "Rollins is an excellent in ring worker as well as a great characte worker. His MITB cash in at WM 31 was one of the best moments in WWE history and since then he has kept on improving, always changing his in ring style and his character. I personally loved the Visionary character with his jester like qualities and his flamboyant and outrageous attire. His in ring work speaks for itself, he has been consistently putting on some of the best matches in the main roster since his debut. Despite being such an incredible talent, Rollins hasn't had the best World Championshis Reigns, his 316 days reign as the World Heavyweight Champion was very good but it ended up being completely overshadowed by Cody Rhodes' story at the finish line making Rollins' champion reign feel less significant than it should have been. Still, even without a World Title, Seth Rollins always feels like a top star, the main event and he always puts on excellent work."

[6.0] "He has had some bright points in his career and he was a highlight in the ring during the early 2010s but he has never quite clicked as a top guy and has actually had some awful runs as the top. Extra characters."

[7.0] "Unbelievable in ring before his many injuries, but never was that good of a promo and his in ring style since 2017 is just not for me, doesn't mean I dont rate him tho he's still a very good wrestler all round, but I would consider him as an all time great"

[6.0] "It's not easy for me to have a favorite of mine a 6 but he hasn't been good for so long "in the ring" his character work still elite though. I wanna see him back in Royal Rumble and I hope his in ring work will get back to where he was once was"

[9.0] "Seth Rollins is one of the most complete wrestlers of his generation--elite in-ring, great storyteller, insane stamina, and always evolving his character. He can have a banger with anyone and carry a main event or midcard feud easily. Only thing keeping him from a 10 is consistency in long-term booking, not talent."

[8.0] "Seth Rollins is a great wrestler and really good on the mic, but there can be times where he's just insufferable. The crowd ruins his theme song for me, they ruin certain promos cause they wanna sing this guys song. His song isn't terrible, I just hate what the fans do during it."

[7.0] "When the bell rings, Rollins is a beast. A real physical and athletic man with a great look. However everything else is incredibly cringe and his body is starting to catch up with him a bit. His promos and social media game are both awful and I think he's one of the people that would benefit massively by jumping ship to AEW, just to freshen things up a bit and not be pigeonholed and having your weaknesses highlighted by WWE booking. A bit like Ricochet."

[7.0] "He probably would've been a 9 or a 10 for me if this was 2018 but I gotta say, his last handful of years have been rough. I just can't get into his overly weird and silly characters and I think his matches have suffered. That being said, 2008-2019 Seth Rollins is top tier."

[9.0] "This guy, Seth, Tyler whatever you wanna call him. He's everything, the only thing holding him back is his injuries and promo ability"

[10.0] "- Burning it down everyday, every show since 2010s - Pushed and backed by the company but is able to handle all the pressure being a heel or face. - Can change character from time to time. - Modern Day Mix of HHH and HBK for me"

[7.0] "Among the best in-ring performers for WWE since the 2010s. He can put up 5-star matches if given a good script to cook up a storyline, no doubt about that. But Seth is still piggybacking off his legendary 2015 run with the Authority, great feuds with John and Randy. He made the Money in The Bank briefcase matter so much more. The iconic "Heist of the Century" was a bolt from the blue, one of the greatest moments in wrestling history. Now looking back at it, that really was a magical run. He was an incredible slimy heel who played his part perfectly, but ever since that injury in late 2015 - he's gotten lost and has drifted across the upper-middle card and main event sometimes. After Triple Cocaine took over, the music larp era started where he's now just his theme song and a lame-ass catchphrase. Its sad, really. He could've been something much more than what he is today, many still think he's in Reigns' shadows - its true but he could've been a much bigger star and just remained a "what if? " because of the terrible, lame, stagnant booking."

[7.0] "I think a seven is a good place to put Rollins all time, I really don't know how much important profound wrestling he has left in his career considering he's suffered another major injury. I think during his prime he was a phenomenal wrestler and has put on some great matches. It makes me wonder where his career would be if he hadn't suffered injuries and had been given a different creative direction. As of his injury I've been apathetic towards his flamboyant presentation and I hope when he returns that he's given something else, though judging by the place that he works at I doubt this will happen. In my eyes his careers peaks were against Cody Rhodes in HIAC and had a few great matches with and against Danielson."

[6.0] "I like elements of Seth and I detest the others. He feels like a time traveler in the wrong time and place for him to shine the brightest. His work can be great, but I dislike his character and trying to be a clown that is taken seriously."

[10.0] "Seth might be the best athlete of this generation, the only ones I prefer at least are Danielson and Styles. Seth has taken characters which are meh on paper and made them entertaining, aka the messiah but then WWE ruined that.. at one point in time he was ROH world champ, he was great then. He came to WWE and eventually joined the shield, an all-time faction so he was great there. He then became the authority's boy, which he was awesome there and imo the 2nd best work he's had in his career, I'll get there in A minute. Then he got hurt and turned face, it was not as good as they wanted it to be until his IC title run which ruled so much. His main event run was A dud, but at first it was great.. then he feuded with Corbin LOL! And then he turned heel and became the messiah, which was good until WWE ruined it. And now he's the visionary, which is my favorite work of his career. Whether its his feud with Cesaro, Roman, Riddle, Cody or now Logan Paul you can always expect A great segment and match from him. So yeah Seth is the 3rd best wrestler of this generation imo, he's an all-time worker. And his segments at times could be lackluster, but currently they are gold as is he in general right now. EDIT: Sucks to see him get hurt, but I wanted to double down on this. I stand by essentially everything I said, and his run in 2025 has been hit or miss when it comes to just.. reception. But I'm on the better side of this, cause I've really enjoyed it, repetitive booking aside he's had great matches, and hit or miss promos. Either way, I hope he heals up soon because I look forward to seeing him return with hopefully a slightly different character this time."

[5.0] "Rollins is... very hard to judge. Not a huge fan of his gimmick, think he can be very annoying, and I don't think he works well as a face. But I won't deny how much of a rockstar Rollins can be in the ring. The Phoenix Splash is up there with one of the coolest finishers I've ever seen, and him cashing in at WM 31 was such an awesome moment. Probably at his best when in the Shield. His current run w Heyman and Bron Breakker certainly has me interested but think I need to see more before changing my grade too much. *Update* Wow did that Vision thing fall flat on it's face. Rollins is just soooooo bland as a main eventer, him in the IC title picture is fine and all but the dude has been a void of charisma and is only good at getting the crowd to chant his opponent's name out of boredom."

[3.0] "10 years ago he looked like he could be one of the top guys for years to come. Injuries played a part in altering that, but the biggest issue for me is the 'character' change from around 3/4 years ago. Its fucking unbearable. From the stupid over the top clothing, idiotic facial expressions, irritating nasal promos and general vibe that screams 'this is all fake, don't take any of it seriously' - it's go away heat for me. It's not good heel heat, it's just shit. To make matters even worse his wife now has exactly the same character, so we have two of these fake fucks to tolerate."

[7.0] "Seth is a very weird wrestler to rate for me. He feels like a high b to low a tier guy who people try and claim is s. In ring wise he can be very good and this is no more apparent than before his injury in 2015. If you go back and watch matches before that he was way more explosive and able to pull off much more impressive moves. Ever since then though it feels like he has unfortunately slowly regressed every year and is a shell of his former self. When it comes to his character work he has had so many different roles with some being bad and some being good but none of them have really lasted long enough in my opinion to make him stand out or been memorable enough besides maybe his time with the shield. On the mic he can be somewhat hit or miss and has cut some fairly good promos but they are very few and far between. I feel like at the end of the day the fact that Seth has never been pushed as the true number one guy in WWE is proof enough that he is a good #2 or 3 guy and a solid hand but not nearly as good as many claim he is."

[8.0] "Seth is such an odd case for me. At times, I love his character. I think when he works for himself, and he's the #2 or #3 guy on a show and he's just a massive prick/instigator he's great. Then, there are times like right now, where his character is easily one of the worst in the company. There is no depth, no entertainment to it, he comes out and cuts the same promo every week going off about "This is the future of the industry ! " (while I do like Breakker, saying that in reference to Bronson Reed is incredibly funny). Then, you get to the actual wrestling and he's still an odd ball. His run as Tyler Black was great, some incredible matches in ROH that are definitely worth watching even if you don't really like Rollins. His run up until 2016 was great in the ring, while obviously there were some questionable character choices outside of the shield, you couldn't deny the guy could go. Then he got hurt, and while he took a drop in performance he was still great. Then the injuries kept piling up and he changed his style into something...not so great. Seth wrestles like a guy who wants to be an Omega or Ospreay type, but isn't fully committing to it/isn't good enough. He goes for these finisher fest battles, and tries to go for that big match feel in a lot of his matches. But it just doesn't work because he isn't built or at least tuned for that style and he's just not good enough to have those type of matches anymore. I feel something when Omega & Ospreay have those matches, I'm emotionally invested and I get hyped at the teased finishers or when they actually hit them. With Seth it's just a 'meh' feeling. He's a B+ wrestler all time who people put in all-timer conversations. Also, his never-ending feud with Punk is boring as hell."

[9.0] "One of the most exciting, and technically sounds wrestlers to ever grace the ring. I appreciate his willingness to reinvent his character to ensure that he isn't just the same, though his mic work doesn't do much for me."

[10.0] "Im not gonna make this long, or try to much to justify my rating. I think its pretty obvious by now. But let me just say since Seth made his debut somewhere around 2013/2014 with The Shield he has been the most consistent wrestler on the roster. You can have him as a midcard champion elevating up and coming stars, you can throw him into a dying fued to get some attention and hype back into the fued, you can have him be the heel that always loses to make wrestlers look dominant, you can have him in a random tag team to elevate his partner, you can have him as your first new title holder, you can have him be the fall guy in 2 back to back Wrestlemania main events, you can have him turn heel and have a banger of a mainevent in a triple threat match, you can have him cashin on your biggest stars twice to make things interesting and he has shown repeatedly for the past 10 years he can not only fulfull what you expect from him, but he will set a new golden standard while doing so. Seth is easily top 5 ever. And the day he decides he is done everyone who hasn't already will notice how this man has been carrying wrestling on his shoulders for over 10 years. Absolute GOAT and one of the best to ever grace our vision. Fucking phenomenal and one of the easiest 10/10s I ever had."

[10.0] "I started watching wrestling for the first time in 2014 because a friend of mine was talking about it a ton, and I was curious to see what it was all about. Seth is the reason I stuck around. I love a villainous character and at the time he was the dastardly, cowardly MITB holder, so I was quickly hooked. His in-ring work did nothing but impress me, and I'm still always excited to see a Seth match. The changes to his gimmicks are all clearly transformations of the same overarching character. To me, he's great at everything. He is the Architect, he is the Future, he is the Visionary, he is Seth "Freakin" Rollins. (please stop using "Freakin" though, it sucks)"

[0.0] "Seth, there's no doubt that you're one of the most gifted athletes in WWE history. Your in-ring ability is almost unmatched, and your resume speaks for itself -- multiple-time world champion, MITB winner, Royal Rumble winner, and more. You've proven time and again that you can deliver big matches on the biggest stages. But as a long-time fan, I have to be honest -- there are some areas where things could be better. Your character direction often feels confusing. One week you're burning things down, the next you're wearing colorful suits and dancing to the ring. It's hard to connect emotionally when the character lacks consistency or depth. Promos are another aspect where I think there's room for growth. You've shown flashes of brilliance on the mic, especially during feuds with The Authority or Cody Rhodes. But too often your promos rely on laughter or noise instead of substance. Fans want to hear why you're fighting, not just how loud you can talk. Also, sometimes it feels like you're more focused on the performance than the story. Great wrestling is about making us feel something. The moves matter, but the moments matter more. You have the talent to create those moments -- we've seen it before -- but lately, it feels like they're missing. I say this not out of hate, but out of respect. You're too good to coast on what you've already accomplished. If you can align your character, promos, and storytelling into a clear and compelling path, there's no reason you couldn't go down as one of the absolute greatest of all time -- not just a top-tier performer, but a legend with legacy. We want to cheer for you, we want to believe -- but we also want to feel something real."

[0.0] "Seth Rollins is the worst wrestler I've ever seen -- even worse than Shawn Michaels. His wrestling style is supposedly all-rounder, but he clearly has no understanding of what that actually means. He confuses being "all-rounded" with having no style at all and just throwing random moves. A true all-rounder knows how to control a match based on psychology -- adjusting his style (technical, brawler, etc.) depending on the match and using a contrasting style for the finish. Rollins, on the other hand, does everything without any sense. His finisher is the Curb Stomp, which should mean he works on the opponent's head and exploits their weaknesses. But he just randomly targets the entire body with no logical progression -- like a book that talks about everything but has no real subject. He doesn't even follow basic ring psychology -- for example, corner combat. When he gets his opponent into the corner, he doesn't use it to shift momentum or take full control. He just throws random punches with no structure. As for character work, he's terrible too. His only decent gimmick was the Messiah. Bottom line: He's not a good wrestler."