Naomi

[7.0] "My rating is mainly based on her Impact run, where she was presented like a star. I thought she was able to put on decent matches, but not great ones. Her talking is decent. She's also clearly a hard worker, and seems to be popular in the locker room. Overall, not someone whose matches you'd be really excited to see, but was perfect in her role in 2023."

[5.0] "Personally not a fan of her heel work which the fans clamoring about, idc about what's behind the curtain i only judge on what's being presented to me on tv, the thing is she constantly breaking character, also putting her on the same zone as iyo and rhea is a big mistake, making the sd title picture a shitshow, and she bites more than she can chew with these two, not surprising that the ss match is the worst compared to mania and evo, just wished she can stay on sd and put jade on her place instead wwe decided to do the opposite, never looked strong against jade and suddenly she shits on iyo and rhea, yeah no"

[3.0] "No idea why Naomi is so suddenly exonerated. She's plodding in the ring, she can't cut a promo and her character work is tryhard and cringe. Anyone else with these characteristics and the IWC would be handing her a pink slip themselves. I will give her some credit like I do the Bella's of coming from a different world and a different era and managing to somewhat pivot into a career but that's her ceiling unfortunately."

[10.0] "Naomi is underrated, underappreciated , she is on the same level as the horse women, Asuka, Bianca iyo etc. But her booking allows people to think she Is bad when she is truly top 10. A history maker, future Hof and a future 3x world champion! Always changing her moves, ring gear and is loved by the so many outside and inside of the wwe. Wish people would stop hating on her. Naomi rating is way too low on here. She is 10/10! She is now the current women's world champion! After a shocking cash in. She is absolutely killing it! Naomi is a top at character, promos and wrestling. Her bag is insanely deep. She is now pregnant! Her 2027 royal rumble win will be iconic"

[5.0] "Very average in my opinion yet gassed up like she's one of the best in WWE, she can keep up with the best but it will be very evident when watching her that she's not that good"

[10.0] "Honestly, she's the only female wrestler who can really make me laugh. I love her heel work and her skills in the ring. She's definitely unique and special in her own way, which makes me want to watch her more."

[8.0] "I posted a comment before she turned heel and in it I mentioned the women Naomi has inspired, how she is average to me but has always had the potential to be more, and how I want her to utilize her move-set a lot more. But I have to say after reading some of these comments and seeing what some on Reddit and Twitter have said in regards to her it's so weird to say the least. There are some wrestlers people have a ceiling for and she's one of those wrestlers. Those same people have their minds up about her no matter what she does as well so if they think she isn't good they're gonna think that no matter what. It was a whole thing on Twitter like a week or two ago about her being sloppy, slow, and moves just don't look as if they hurt or are effective. Not only that but she doesn't have any great moves in her move-set. I feel as if this also goes to show that not many people actually watch the product or have watched her because there's people that still think she uses the "Rear View" as her base finisher. She has so many variations of her FTG/Slayomission submission finisher. The other day I saw a compilation from @ThatT_R_E_N_N_O on Twitter and she has so many variations of her moves and finishers it's insane. My biggest critique for her though like I said in the beginning is that she needs to start utilizing her move-set more.The splits were good for the GLOW era but now she needs to change gears. She's done a lot different moves especially in TNA that she hasn't done in WWE yet however, this heel run I want her to be the most grittiest heel with the move-set to go along with it. I don't know about her being sloppy or uncoordinated I'm still waiting to see that actually. And lastly, yes you can acknowledge that she's slowed down but she isn't slow as if she goes a turtles speed as people make it seem like she is. I recently saw that she's been dealing with health issues since 2018 - 2019 I know it had something to do with fibroids."

[9.0] "She is way too overlooked and underrated imo, she is always the MVP that sparks the interests in women's wrestling. I am glad now she is finally having another reign, and proves her worth, hope they don't screw her this time."

[10.0] "Naomi as a heel is so much damn fun. She is absolutely hamming everything up, making everything super campy and fun. Her matches still show off her athleticism and a fun moveset. She's so fresh as a heel and her last few months have been among the best of her career"

[9.0] "Naomi has built one of the most quietly resilient careers in WWE. From her beginnings in NXT and as a Funkadactyl, she has undergone multiple reinventions, often with little creative backing but a lot of fan support. Her athleticism has always set her apart--she's one of the most naturally gifted women to ever step in a WWE ring. Smooth transitions, explosive speed, and an innovative moveset helped her stand out even when she wasn't getting the spotlight. Her "Feel the Glow" era was a turning point. It wasn't just a catchy entrance--it was Naomi fully embracing her individuality, and fans responded with genuine support. She became a two-time SmackDown Women's Champion, including a title win at WrestleMania 33 in her hometown, a rare and well-earned moment. Still, her booking has often felt inconsistent, and there were long stretches where WWE didn't seem to know what to do with her. Despite this, she stayed relevant through sheer talent and connection with the audience. Her heel run in 2025 shows yet again her ability to adapt, evolve, and stay interesting over a decade into her career. Naomi isn't just a strong performer--she's a symbol of perseverance, versatility, and underappreciated greatness in WWE's women's division."

[10.0] "I am very pleased that Naomi, fully in her prime, is getting the push she deserves. She has been incredible for her entire career and should be given more credit. An excellent athlete with strength and speed, also fantastic on the mic and currently doing her best character work as a heel."

[10.0] "Naomi's current heel character is one of the most convincing, emotionally charged, believable heels on the planet right now in any company anywhere. Do I believe WWE is capable of booking her as such? Absolutely not. But she is a great worker and a FANTASTIC character actor. I was sold out of the gate from her initial heel vignette and if she doesn't get a world title out of this run with the briefcase it will be yet another injustice done to her. There is nobody that talks like her and nobody that looks like her and I mean that in the best way possible. As a face she could carry the division. As a heel she has the capacity to be one of the most unnerving and psychologically unstable characters the division has ever had. After being disrespected time and again it feels like Naomi is finally on the verge of getting her dues."

[10.0] "One of the most underrated modern day talents I was always a huge Naomi fan I always preferred her heel persona more than her baby face. I am so glad she's finally working as a heel and she's is killing it I just hope they give her one more run as champion because she completely deserves it."

[4.0] "Seeing all these tens for Naomi is blowing my mind. She is an adequate performer but far from anything special. Her sloppiness in the ring for someone this far along in her career is truly astounding. I do give her some points for her athleticism and her character work in her recent heel run. However, her offense never has looked impactful and despite being rather athletic, she rarely does moves that are overly impressive. Hopefully she can clean up the sloppiness before cashing in her MITB briefcase."

[9.0] "Very good in the ring, has a natural feel for wrestling despite never wrestling anywhere else prior to WWE (and before TNA), she was always talented and from some reason she was always also slept on during the majority of her time in WWE, i'm glas she's finally getting an actual chance to show people what she's worth after 13 years of being ignored and overlooked by the fans, i will say that her cons are her promo skills that lack authenticity and sometimes she can be a little slow in the ring (despite her insane amount of talent) which is why it did not feel right for me to give her a 10"

[9.0] "Naomi is the best success story out of the divas era. She has improved so much over the last 10 years, from just being the dancer for Brodus Clay, to a world champion. Her current run is probably the best work of her career character wise. She's very solid in ring, though sometimes not as consistent as you'd like (which is why she's not a 10)"

[10.0] "She is so underrated. She had some heat when she first won the Smackdown titles, and had always stayed a constant. I think she and Mercedes (Sasha) did an amazing thing walking out, she improved vastly in TNA where she became the Knockouts champion, then coming back she immediately became the third wheel in the tag team of Bianca Belair and Jade Cargill, she eventually turned on Jade secretly and took one half of the tag titles. Her heel turn has been amazing, and she's been the best heel of the year by far, glad she won Money in the Bank!"

[9.0] "Super underrated, I knew she was special since her match with AJ Lee during NXT's game show era. Has a cool entrance and move set and should honestly get more opportunities. Still can't believe WWE punished her by having to put over anti vax Lacey during a time when fans were really liking her. And she represents Orlando too"

[10.0] "She was the last female wrestler to be part of the Divas before 2016 when they changed fighters; Although she is very underestimated she's very athletic and agile and it's also strong when I lift a heavy wrestler as if she were an Amazon. She'd be an important female wrestler with good matches like Kairi Sane or Bull Nakano 5-star style, She would be the best black woman fighter in history and also the WWE face of women. but well, time has passed. even though it's not relevant, but well I gave it a 10, It's just my opinion."

[5.0] "A solid hand with an occasional entertaining spot in a Royal Rumble. Zero promo skills and just average in-ring. Just a serviceable midcarder."

[6.0] "I have love for Naomi but she is one of these women that didnt break their own glass ceilings. Ever since coming up with the glow gimmick, that's all she's been stuck doing with no success outside the tag titles. Athletic and a good wrestler but can also be bland and one dimensional. I wish she stayed more in TNA to establish herself rather than leaving after one feud with Alisha Edwards. I do appreciate her work with Cameron, Team BAD and currently with Bianca."

[10.0] "Naomi's talent is undeniable, yet she remains one of the industry's most underrated superstars. Her wrestling prowess is exceptional, a blend of athleticism and finesse. Coupled with her vibrant charisma, she captivates audiences effortlessly. It's a mystery why she isn't consistently in the spotlight. She possesses the complete package: in-ring skill, mic presence, and an undeniable connection with fans. A true gem, deserving of far greater recognition."

[9.0] "She's finally starting to get the flowers she deserves for not only the influence she has for a lot of the girlies in the business today, but for what she has done as well. Left WWE after a disagreement with creative and took a chance on herself to not only show WWE why she's better than how she was being treated at the time but that she is also one of the best women's wrestlers in North America. Became the face of the women's division in tna within a second of her debut and had one of the best runs of her career. Came back to the WWE an even bigger star and now she's a consistent part of tv and putting on some of the best matches we see in the women's division. Real ones know Naomi rocks and her cagematch score is not a reflection of that. She rocks"

[4.0] "Sorry i dont see the hype. She is a good worker, but the rest is absolutely nothing. Is adeguate in the style of WWE today, maybe 4/5 years ago it was so much better than this rate. But that's my opinion on her in 2025. Maybe a future turn hell can change things"

[9.0] "Trinity/Naomi just has IT. She has that it factor that can't be taught along with being very entertaining in the ring. She's such a rootable baby face but can also slay as a heel. She came into the division at a time when women were not taken seriously and she was 100% a driving force in american women's wresting starting to be taken seriously. She's very in tune with the audience as well which helps her performances stand out even more. All in all she's an extremely valuable part of the roster."

[8.0] "Some people might not be ready for this conversation, but Naomi really is a legend of this business. A real pioneer for women in wrestling. Consistently puts on great matches and has a very likeable babyface character."

[4.0] "I'll start by saying she gets the 4 points for being a very genuinely likeable character who is easy to get behind as a baby face and is capable of having an ok match once in a blue moon when paired with the right opponent (surprisingly Nia is her best dance partner). But in general, she is really bad in the ring. She wrestles at 0.25x speed and like she is trying to remember the spots. There is no rhythm or flow to her matches."

[5.0] "She appeals to kids and people who are easily impressed, but has a horribly stupid gimmick, one of the dumbest finishers in wrestling history, and is just about average in the ring. If she wasn't dating an Uso she'd be cut years ago"

[6.0] "Naomi is one of the best women athletes WWE has. Her booking in WWE has been a mixed bag and she had more success in TNA for that reason. In the ring she is pretty good at using her athleticism to wow the fans. On the mic she is good, but she does have room to improve."

[5.0] "Naomi's work is just past mediocrity. She stands out, but not much. Her in-ring skill is average (and brought down by a terrible finisher), her personality doesn't stand out much, and while her "Feel The Glow" thing is unique, it's not that entertaining."

[8.0] "Naomi is the most creative woman on the WWE roster. She has brand new gears almost every weeks, her promos are ok, her in ring is very original. Naomi is just creative on every point, always a great challenger and, I believe, would be a great champion."

[3.0] "There's not much to say here ..... she's okay on the mic but a terrible worker who puts almost no effort into anything she's doing in the ring. I'd say she's one of the most overrated female wrestlers of today and really not sure why she's still getting pushes."

[9.0] "I've always liked Naomi since I started watching WWE, it's impressive to me that she has a "low" average here, she's very good in the ring, she has a funny charisma, she's not like Zoey Stark for example, she knows how to do promos well, and she deserves to be women's champion in the future, her heel turn will soon be fire. Glow Time!"

[7.0] "I have always felt that Naomi was a great wrestler who has been held back by her place in WWE, her run in TNA has recently proven that given the chance she really can be an important part of any company. Despite said run in TNA, it appears she has returned to the mid-carder role and I do not see her having a title run anytime soon (even if I'm down to see it). Decent all-round with a good aura."

[10.0] "I believe that Naomi is underestimated, because she delivers a lot to the world of wrestling, she is athletic and has all the potential that she has achieved throughout her years of career, she deserves much more knowledge and without a doubt she can show this when she left WWE and joined TNA for a short period she showed that she deserves much more than what was offered to her, among the current women she is among the best and for me she is the best African-American woman we have ever had to date, she is simply incredible."

[4.0] "Naomi, though very supple and capable of amazing physical prowess, is sorely lacking in ring intelligence. Her signature holds are ridiculous or lack impact, and could do with a change from the Divas era. Her mic skills are really limited and it's hard for me to be interested by what she's telling in the ring. She masters the basic level expected of a wrestler, but has great difficulty selling moves and being credible with her own. Her characters are rather bland, as is her movepool. Especially next to today's talented athletes. The coolest thing about her is her entrance and the fluo. The only place for her seems to be as a team partner in the mid-card."

[7.0] "Very underrated wrestler. She can go in the ring, she can have the crowd behind her very easily and she's ok when it comes to mic skill. The only issue with Naomi right now is her gimmick, she really need a second heel run to refresh her aura and career."

[5.0] "I think Naomi is a decent talent. She's not the best in-ring performer, she's also not the most charismatic performer but she definitely has an aura about her that makes you want to watch her matches or have her on your roster. She's a solid hand, if nothing else."

[4.0] "The whole blacklight thing was kinda cool, but the whole thing was wasted on someone with lackluster in ring work, mid promos, and just an overrated figure in her work. The whole rearview thing is aweful, and when you look at all her tag team acts, Sasha is the only good one of the team. And then there was her return, they keep utilizing her as if she is still as "cool" as she was in her first run, but every time she walks out she seemed to fall flat other than her initial pop during the rumble."

[6.0] "Naomi is not the best bell to bell wrestler which is fine her athleticism creates some great exciting moments and sequences in matches and I think she has good charisma her promos are pretty flat but when shes in the ring she has good charisma overall Im glad she got her deserved flowers in TNA and while shes not my personal favorite shes far from bad"

[6.0] "I hope she's genuinely happy to be back in WWE. I'm sure she's making a ton of money so more power to her. However, her time in Impact did wonders for her career. They bent over backwards for her and made her look like a really big deal. She's not undeserving of that either. In 2016-17 on Smackdown she was doing really well and having decent matches. Now that she's back she's just another face in the crowd. If your name is not Rhea, Becky, or Bayley, you're not getting a lot of tv time or title matches."

[6.0] "I believe Naomi is a decent talent. Is she a main event level top-of-the-mountain wrestler? No, not close. But Naomi has a good amount of athleticism and can get a crowd behind her, I remember seeing her wrestle in-person before RAW Reunion in 2019 and I and many others were chanting positively for her. She is also one of the few 'Divas Era' wrestlers to have transitioned well into the new era of Women's wrestling. I don't ever recall hearing a good nor memorable Naomi promo. I think if WWE announces a mid-card women's title, Naomi should be one of the top talents in that division as I think she's better as a mid-carder than a main-eventer."

[6.0] "Never really understood Naomi. She debuted at an early age and looked somehwat good in comparison with her fellow Divas... but as women's wrestling evolved she just got caught in the wave. Now, Naomi is a serviceable midcard superstar but nowhere near the "star" she was booked as in Impact."

[6.0] "Wow, who knows what happened to her? ¿Maybe age? ¿Maybe working with new performers? But her in-ring work decreased a bit, she moves really slow. Yes she can give some hard kicks and strikes, but out of that she seems to be lost nowadays, hope she can recover"

[10.0] "Naomi is someone that is AMAZING! I can't even begin to tell you how happy I am every time she is in the ring. I'm always entertained by her moves and matches, and feel like WWE really needs to spend more time showcasing her just like TNA Impact did. She deserves to have another World Title reign, and feel that it would be better than her 2017 reigns since she has grown so much since!"

[7.0] "She's definitely not a major draw but she's very athletic and good in the ring, and her matches are a treat to watch, definitely a bit above mid for me. She just lacks the star power that Becky, Rhea, Charlotte etc have."

[6.0] "Naomi is a good wrestler, I personally am not a big fan of her gimmick but still she persevered. Her first run in WWE had its ups and downs. She was part of the Funkadactyls which was just Brodus Clay's cheer section, she became a main event after Tons of Funks broke up, won the SmackDown women's championship but she didn't feel like the main event star. Left WWE after being snubbed as Tag Champions with Sasha Banks, made her Impact Debut and became one of the biggest female stars outside of WWE and was among the best women's wrestlers of 2023."

[5.0] "Trinity has a strong look and presentation and that is about it. Her run in Impact/TNA seems to have been positively received but I have no idea why, the match quality was considerably lower with her on top and by and large she is someone whose matches never really land much higher than ***1/4 even when put with someone much stronger than her. I don't know if people just have low standards or if I am going insane because I won't miss her now she appears to be heading back to WWE"

[10.0] "Y'all crazy if you think Trinity can't go, she set out to prove that time and time again but she don't get the recognition she deserves and I don't wanna say why but y'all know why I'm looking at some of these ratings and I see that y'all don't remember she came in at a time when women's wrestling wasn't looked at in the same light as it is today and she has stood the test of time and reinvented herself when needed, prime examples would be her match with Charlotte on SD live, her I'm assuming last match in the TNA run. I put a 10 so that her average could come up because ain't not way she ain't at least an 8 point rating or higher. I hope that her return to the WWE brings more light to what can do and what she is capable of"

[8.0] "Trinity has been great for years and is sneaky under rated. She does good high flying and has a great look and entrance. WWE really messed up not resigning her and now she's tearing up TNA's knockout division. Even though I like Bryan Alvarez his constant hating on Trinity gave a certain kind of fan brain worms on the topic of Trinity. I used to be like that too, but I've since seen the light and now know Trinity is awesome."