"phenomenal bell to bell. very memorable main event. not much to complain about this show besides the starks match"

"Truly one of the greatest shows of all time, featuring four matches that I would rate over an eight. Also very solid booking and mostly clean finishes."

[7.0] "this ia a decent enough show that has some mediorce matches that kinda just end out of nowhere and seem quicker then they were, but the good on this card really shines well MJF v Danielson is a classic, HOB v Elite is pretty good, Texas Deathmatch 1 is fantastic. and a few other shiners on this card. i felt let down by wardlow v joe and also the womens title match the most as i expected jericho v starks to be middle of the road as its 49 yo jericho"

[7.0] "An entertaining PPV overall. My favorite matches were the trios with House of Black killing it and the Iron Man match. Still have to say I was very disappointed in the Texas Death match-up which I personally think is overrated with some downright stupid spots; barbwire moonsault, gtfo; Mox crushes Hangman's right hand and then the latter proceeds to lariat him like it's nothing, please stop! Overall enjoyable PPV, maybe a tad bit overrated."

[7.0] "Two of the best matches Ive seen in a while in the Texas death match and especially the iron man, unfortunately let down by some bad filler. Opened great with a solid Jericho match and a really great buried alive match, but the six man tag, the womens three way, and especially that four way tag really brought things down. Thankfully the last hour of this was some of the best wrestling Ive seen in a while."

[9.0] "This PPV was incredible, the build had its problems, but when it mattered, they've absolutely delivered and told cool stories with Mox/Hangman and MJF/Bryan, two incredible matches and all-timer classics. The low card had some fillers, some matches below the average, but we also had a cool one between Elite and HoB. Incredible event, one of AEW's best."

"10.0 This definitely ranks in my top five favorite shows of all time. I still probably think about both the Danielson/MJF and Moxley/Hangman matches at least a couple times a month even a year and a half later. The first three matches, especially the Trios title match, get the show off to a strong start."

[10.0] "AEW Revolution (2023) is definitely one of the most bloodiest and goriest PPVs the company has done. Most of the undercard was great particularly The Final Burial and Elite Vs HOB, the Texas death match was phenomenal, the iron man match is just god-tier and there were so many satisfying wins. Overall AEW Revolution (2023) is such a phenomenal show and definitely one of AEW's best ever."

[6.0] "Four hours that felt like seven. Maybe live it feels better but watching on a vacuum this feels like a chore to get through. It doesn't help that I didn't like the supposed good parts of the show. The first two opening matches were very good but after that the whole night was disappointing or mediocre for me. Main event was good but it's well documented on my posts in here that I despise the Iron Man match because it's literally the same shitty draw that leads to sudden death every fucking time, so I couldn't even like that,"

[9.0] "An utterly brilliant event without a dull match on the card and featuring an all time classic as the main event. Wow!"

"Great PPV most of the matches were top tier with some matches that were okay but not so great. I felt that Starks vs Jericho could have been better but the final burial followed and capped off a long rivalry. MJF vs Danielson were able to entertain me throughout the entire match, potential match of the year this will be match I come back to years from now. The other matches were also fun, I am not a big fan of death matches so I didnt follow the entire match but Page and Mox have great chemistry together."

[10.0] "The build-up of this event was decent but also mediocre at times however I still had a lot of hype fot the show because the card looked pretty damn good and I wasn't dissapointed. The opener was really good and the women's triple threat was satisfactory as well as the tag team title match. I'm happy to see Starks finally win in a PPV, turn Ruby Soho heel it's the right choice and I'm very happy for the FTR's rerturn. The final burial was nice match and a defying moment for Jungle Boy. Joe vs. Wardlow it's the only bad match of the show, it had a bad ending and a nonsense title change. The trios match was fantastic and I'm very happy to see HOB become champions. Moxley vs. Page was an absolute war, a tremendous match with some brutal spots and a perfect finish. The main event is one of the greatest matches off all time and one of AEW's best match ever. Overall: the show was perfect with three fantastic matches and all the other that were good or decent."

[6.0] "this event is rated too high. the main event was great, but this was a show built around a 65 minute main event and the rest of the show wasnt a 9/10 show. Main event was very good. So was Adam Page defeats Jon Moxley. Hard to rate an entire PPV high with 2 standout matches and nothing else. Check out those 2 matches, skip the rest i guess. i give the show overall a 6/10"

[7.0] "I think a 7/10 is a fair rating for this event. No idea how it can be currently rated at 9.24/10. Starks vs Jericho was nothing special, a TV match at best, Jericho is very sluggish in the ring in 2023 (I guess that's why he is being protected in tag matches recently), sad to see as Jericho is one of my all-time favourites, but it happens to everyone. I thought Perry vs Cage was decent, again nothing special and just an okay gimmick match (certainly not as good as the 7.54 rating it has on here). I thought the trios match was good. The women's match was okay. Page vs Mox was good but nothing spectacular (same old bumps we always see in these extreme type Mox matches). Joe vs Wardlow was an average TV match at best. Four way tag match was fun, but did not feel important, like a TV match with not much heat. Main event was very good but not fantastic, maybe a 4 star rating, 8/10 match. A lot of the match was showboating, MJF drinking and throwing water, and the first 4 pin falls/DQ were kinda meh, but then no DQ for using a table or the eye poke in front of the ref with 4 minutes to go? MJF's blade job was badly timed, as Danielson's Diving Headbutt landed on MJF's shoulder, not his head, so it looked silly and was done badly. The last 10 minutes of the match were a slugfest as expected in an Iron Man match, but this does mean that about 30/60 minutes were showboating, water antics and sluggish back and fourth chops/punches, would have liked to have seen more actual wrestling in a 60 minute Iron Man match personally."

"I thought this was an excellent PPV. It had a variety of very good matches including the Texas Death Match, the trios match and then the masterpiece that was the main even Iron Man match. What was really noticeable about this event was how the newer or lesser fancied wrestlers and teams tended to get the wins: Starks, Jungle Boy, House of Black, Hangman and MJF all went over more established or more favoured to win opponents which was great. All in all one of the better AEW PPVs from my perspective."

[10.0] "Hell you want me to say? Probably the best AEW show ever and MJF-Danielson is certainly my pick for best AEW match. Not every match absolutely rips but nothing totally sucked and the highs are just astronomically high. That Texas Death match? Absolute fire. I'm a Moxley naysayer sometimes when it comes to his need to constantly bleed and yet he made me a believer with that absolute horror show. Trios title match also ruled crazy hard. Forbidden Door 2022 is still probably the most consistent show AEW's run but no other event they've done has had 3 matches on the level of those 3."

[9.0] "Best AEW PPV of the last year comfortably, a couple of weak matches but it more than made it up for it with an incredible main event and a strong midcard. Poor buildup does not always lead to a bad show as we've seen from WWE."

[7.0] "Solid show with some match of the year contenders. TNT title match did not need to be on the show and drags it down a bit."

[9.0] "Strong PPV all round and despite hating Moxley vs Hangman as it's not for me, the rest of the card made up for it and the main event was INCREDIBLE."

[9.0] "Two match of the year contenders in Hangman vs Mox and MJF vs Danielson, as well as an excellent trios title match, and a cathartic, if a little late, final chapter for Christian and Jungle Boy, hold up this show. This show is excellent because of these 4 matches. As for the rest: Ricky and Jericho have a pretty alright match with the right winner, finally a Jericho feud that ends when it should. Wardlow vs Joe was a little rough, Wardlow has cooled off a lot. Women's title match was perfectly serviceable but unexciting. The Gunns are heat magnets and medicore workers, the tag title match was fine. Probably my show of the year thus far because of how good the highlights are, without any truly bad matches as well."

[9.0] "Great PPV. I loved that for the most part, the younger or less established wrestlers like Jungle Boy, Starks, Hangman etc all won against better known guys. It set a good tone for the event. HOB winning unexpectedly it was great. Main event was one of my favourite matches I've seen in a long time. All round classic PPV and one I'd watch again."

[6.0] "The definition of a one match show. It was very rough up until the main event, with the entire undercard plagued by bad storylines as opposed to bad work but as a result nothing was engaging and the pressure on the main event to deliver was immense but they did so in spades. Coming off Full Gear it was looking really good for a month or so but the booking had fluffed its lines one too many times by the time this rolled around."

[9.0] "This was an extremely good show. I highly recommend it. My 2 favorite matches we're the Texas Deathmatch and the Iron man matches."

[8.0] "This show is an example of "if the show's end is good, the ppl will remember it as good". It is a good PPV. not perfect. I guess not the best of the year. It reminds me of Revolution 2021. I think both are in the same level. but 2023 had a perfect end that ppl will remember. and 2021 had a sloppy end which ppl will make fun of forever."

[9.0] "Great show worth catching up on if you missed the initial broadcast. It left me feeling hopeful about where AEW seems set to move towards for the foreseeable future and the main event truly felt like a masterpiece"

[7.0] "Good show! Highlights include the incredible Iron Man match main event between MJF and Bryan Danielson as well as the Texas Death Match between Hangman Page and Jon Moxley. There was a boring stretch before the main event that docks a few points from the show, but still mostly good overall."

"A very good show especially considering how up and down aew has been lately and I hope this is the start for a better year for them. but it was an all around fairly consistent show with there being some bad matches but nothing so overtly bad that it takes away from the good of which there was a lot. Mox and pages violent brawl was sometimes a little much but still good and mjf and danielson iron man match was my personal favorite of the stipulation. The rest was good but not great the trios match stands out as the best non deathmatch or main event. All and all good way to get the year started for Aew 9/10"

[10.0] "Excellent AEW PPV, perhaps the best they have put on since Forbidden Door 2022, if not in the entirety of the company. The matches were all around excellent, with even the worst matches on the card likely being the best match on any given Dynamite. 100% would recommend this PPV to anyone wanting to get into AEW or who may be a lapsed fan."

[10.0] "This was the show AEW needed to get the year off strong, after a pretty shaky 2022. There wasn't necessarily a bad match with Wardlow's match being somewhat disappointing. Nevertheless, the Final Burial and the Texas Dearth Match were incredible with the main event alone being enough to make the show a top tier PPV."

[10.0] "This was a fantastic PPV from AEW, who have been a bit hit and miss, to say the least, over the last year or so. Pretty much every match was good, and some where just fantastic, namely the main event which is probably the best match in company history (and considerably better than that overrated Omega/Page vs. Young Bucks match form the 2020 PPV): Jericho vs. Starks ***1/2, Christian vs. Jungle Boy ****, Elite vs. House of Black ****3/4, Hayter vs. Saraya vs. Ruby ***1/4, Hangman vs. Moxley ****3/4, Joe vs. Wardlow **, Four Way Tag Title Match **3/4, MJF vs. Danielson *****."

[9.0] "AEWs 2023 for the PPV schedule has kicked off in style! It was a scintillating night of action from all varieties high-speed sprints, brutal fights, bloodbaths, betrayals, entertainers, and game changers! Everything was explored in all of the matches, and I thoroughly enjoyed it to the core. Had a couple of matches been more refined (womens 3-way, Joe/Wardlow), this PPV couldve been an all-timer but that doesnt change the fact that AEW has indeed gone through a revolution from this event & Im enthusiastic to see whats in store for the brand."

[7.0] "Other then the main event, Hangman vs Mox and the trios title match, the rest of the show was quite average for me. Hangman vs Mox was a classic match."

[10.0] "I would be surprised if this isn't one of AEW's best overall PPVs in the company's entire span, future included. MJF/Danielson has set the goal for every ironman match to attain in the landscape of modern wrestling, Mox/Hangman was on all accounts brutal (as most of AEW's deathmatch-esque matches are), and the burial match was great to watch even if the angle was kinda dead in the water."

[8.0] "Two really great matches here, including a great main event that was one of the better Iron Man matches in recent memory and certainly will be a career-defining moment for MJF. The Elite vs. House of Black Trios Tag Title match was also a great watch for fans of that fast-paced style. I wasn't as enamored by the Page-Mox match as most seem to be; it was a decent enough brawl but sometimes came off as violence for violence's sake, and also wasn't a true Texas Death Match (that match type has a ten-count after pinfalls or submissions; this was treated as just a hardcore Last Man Standing match). There was also some solid stuff on the rest of the show, including most notably the Starks-Jericho opener, the Jungle Boy-Christian match (though I'm not sure I'm crazy about AEW using something so close to a previously-WWE-exclusive match type as Buried Alive), and really nothing outright bad. While the main event will almost certainly be looked back on as a classic, I'm not sure how much else from the show will be in the long term - but it is an enjoyable watch nonetheless."

[9.0] "Revolution 2023 was surely the PPV that hyped me the least, but damn, I was caught by surprise. That wasn't perfect at all, but we had two instant-classics in their very own style. The Elite vs. HOB was a stellar bout as well while Jericho vs. Starks is gonna be an underestimated gem. And maybe a slight card played in AEW's favor."

[7.0] "Really good show, at a time AEW really needed it. The last few months have felt like a creative lull for AEW and that included the buildup to this show. However, the big starts delivered excellent performances and made for a PPV than overdelivered in a lot of ways The undercard was not as stacked as other PPVs but it doesn't really matter since this is a show built on three pillars (Mox/Hangman, trios match and main event) and all three deliver. The rest of the show isn't bad though, although I think the Tag Team title match be the comedy match is a terrible move, and moves along at a brisk pace due to the 60+ minutes allotted to the main event. The iron man is generational, one of the best of it's kind and a new blueprint on what that type of match should and could be"

[9.0] "It was a fantastic show where the hits really hit and the misses were forgotten about. Overall the show was a solid 9/10. It was really well paced with two classics and other great matches scattered throughout. Here is what I rated the matches star wise: Jericho vs Starks 3.0 JB vs CC 4.0 HOB vs The Elite 4.5 Hayter vs Saraya vs Ruby 3.5 Hangman vs Mox 5 Joe vs Wardlow 2.75 4 way tag 2.25 MJF vs Dragon 5"

"What an absolute blast. This show was so much fun through and through. The main event lived up to expectations and both Bryan and MJF gave it their all and it shows. Overall great ppv, highly recommend."

[10.0] "This was AEWs best PPV to date. This PPV was as flawless as a PPV could possibly get. The match card, the length of matches, the pacing for each match and of course the matches themselves were all almost perfect. They start off the show by showcasing their young talent like Ricky Starks and Jungle Boy putting on stellar performances against the wrestling legends like Jericho and Christian Cage. Trios match was a fantastic bout that I felt elevated both The Elite and House of Black towards the next level. The 3 way womens match was great with a shocking swerve that furthered the womens division storyline. Moxley and Paige was a bloody death match masterpiece. The TNT and tag team matches were decent fun matches as well. MJF vs Danielson was the greatest professional wrestling match from a wrestling standpoint and was by far the greatest iron man match of all time. The crowd was fantastic all night, they never felt flat or tired and kept the PPV lively even throughout the entire 60+ min match with MJF and Danielson. With the bar set so high for AEW, Im very curious to see what they do for DoN to top this."

[9.0] "The best show of the year so far, and an instant classic in our eyes, AEW starts the year off again with a show that will go down in history."

"Outstanding PPV with 2 MOTY candidates. Not perfect but pretty close. Easily best show of the year, so far."

[9.0] "AEW's best PPV basically since All Out, huge hopes for the coming months after this show. The matches were great, even with the bad buildups some of them had. The pre-show was suprisingly fun, better than I expected. The main event was absolutely incredible and I think having less matches because of it worked in the show's favour. The three-way match between Jamie Hayter, Saraya and Ruby Soho was a little wonky as well as the TNT title match, which is why im not rating the show a perfect ten."

[10.0] "A great preshow, well paced & ballanced event throughout. 3 matches that you would recommend to non-wrestling fans. A MOTYC main event that lasted over an hour. A wide variety of styles. What more could you ask for? Sure the build could've been better but as a 1 night event this is a perfect 10."

[10.0] "One of if not the best AEW PPV I've ever seen. Not a single match that I didn't enjoy. Chris Jericho vs Ricky Starks: Great match with a great continuation of the storyline between the 2, Starks should be considered for a World Title run (***1/4). Jack Perry vs Christian Cage: Really well executed match, Jack Perry with a bittersweet victory well and truly deserved (***1/2). House Of Black vs The Elite: Exceeded my expectations, absolute banger of a match, lots of cool moments and physical as hell (****1/2). Jamie Hayter vs Saraya vs Ruby Soho: Another great title defense for Hayter, all 3 looked incredible (***). Adam Page vs Jon Moxley: Incredible match, I liked the persistence of Page despite what Moxley threw at him (****3/4). Samoa Joe vs Wardlow: decent match, surprised at the ending (***1/4). 4 Way Tag Team Match: decent but entertaining, quite a few funny moments (***3/4). MJF vs Bryan Danielson: An absolute instant classic, 60+ minutes of brilliant wrestling and should be a candidate for MOTY (******)"

[4.0] "Listen. I really wanted to like this show. I wasn't into this card at all but I wanted to give it a shot since I really like a lot of the guys and gals they got on the show.... and oh boy. To me this was one of the more weaker AEW PPV's where I only really enjoyed HOB vs The Elite and the Texas Deathmatch. The Iron Man match was disappointing for the first 30 minutes and I didn't get into it until the last 15 minutes of the match. Everything else was weak and I found myself distracted by other stuff."

"Incredible PPV, with arguably the best 60-minute Iron Man match ever. Just too much in-ring action for a show which has that type of main event."

[9.0] "Excellent show. One of AEW'S best. AEW all Out 2021 remains my favourite AEW show at this time but this one is definitely top 5. None of the matches were bad , the main event was a 5 star classic and probably the best singles match produced by this young company. Other notable matches are the Elite Vs House of Black Trios (****3/4) which was my second fav of the night and the Burial match (****) which was a big moment for Jake perry. Another notable match was the Texas Death match, I don't particularly liked this type of match but the fans ate it up. Anyway, excellent show, AEw once again does a great job of maintaining a consistently good show with a more balance card."

[10.0] "Exception outing for All Elite Wrestling on PPV. From start to finish I was incredibly engaged by this show. Jericho vs. Starks was a solid opener with Starks going over and looking strong in the process. Christian vs. Jungle Boy was a war and I ended with one of the most cathartic and emotion finishes you'll ever see. The Elite and House of Black was a sprint and a half with some of the best offence on the show. That knee Buddy Matthews did to counter the Meltzer Driver will go down as one of the most memorable spots from the PPV. The women's title match was solid and I was glad Hayter retained. The Texas Death match between Mox and Page was easily a 5* match with some really creative spots and just as much violence as you'd expect from these two. Hangman Page going over was the right call. The tag team title match was a lot of fun and finally MJF vs. Danielson will go down as one of the best Iron Man matches in history. My personal MOTN and a strong MOTY contender rounding out an excellent PPV for AEW."

[8.0] "Tough to rate this one. The main event and the trios titles match were the only matches I thought were a real cut above average, but the card itself didn't feel too long and had little time to get boring. The main event had very good storytelling but falls into that category of good matches I'll probably never watch again because of the sheer length. This was a real 'Sum of its parts' kind of card. It's made by a varied undercard and a good main event. My enjoyment of Moxley vs Hangman was quite a bit below the average here and that was something I was looking forward to. An easy watch and a mostly entertaining show but this could have done with one or two more high points for me, and likely would have if I had liked Moxley vs Hangman more. Even if I think most of this card fell on the average side, I still think it was a pretty fun show. Edit: I think I'll bump it up a point because the average level of most matches wasn't enough to lower my feeling by the end of the show and they really did end on a dramatic high point."

[9.0] "75% of the build of this show f#cking SUCKED, but two MOTYC in the Texas Death and the Iron Man matches, a great Trios match, a really fun opener and while I wasn't the biggest fan of the Final Burial, still was good, the rest of the card... Those divisions need some work, how can they book a better 4 way for F#CKING Rampage than at Revolution, the Women are still getting the worst and while not bad, the TNT Title is still being a hot potato (and Hobbs should beat)"