[6.0] "It was a decent PPV featuring good matches, such as the tag team bout between The Legacy and DX, and the ECW Championship match between William Regal and Christian--an underrated gem of the event--along with a solid United States Championship match between The Miz and Kofi Kingston. The Randy Orton vs. John Cena match had a good build-up but ended in a rather odd way; much like at SummerSlam--though that was a genuinely bad match--this finish felt very forced and rushed. Speaking of rushed and poorly booked moments, there was the night's main event: The Undertaker vs. CM Punk. A match that could have been entertaining ended with one of the worst things you could do to the audience--whether they were watching from home or had paid for a ticket--but what's done is done. The Jeri-Show vs. MVP & Mark Henry match was merely decent. I probably don't need to mention the insistence on dragging out the Great Khali vs. Kane feud across two PPVs; while the Kendo Stick stipulation made this match slightly less terrible than the previous one, it remained completely unwatchable."

[6.0] "Giving this a 6 mainly for the tag team match between Legacy and DX which was match of the night by far -Christian Regal had a very underrated match aswell - On paper the two world title matches look excellent but both underdeliver for me with a really weird finish in the main event"

[4.0] "Much lower on this show than the average, mainly because I don't think the DX/Legacy or Orton/Cena matches are anywhere near their billing. Opener is fine, Kofi & Miz have a surprisingly solid US Title match, and MOTN is Christian vs. Regal in a classical undercard wrestling match. The Kane/Khali match is God awful per usual, and the main event had potential to be good but the finish is pretty atrocious and they barely got any time."

[5.0] "I don't know... There was some pretty good stuff on this show, but once again the main event scene was dragged down by overbooking, and the overall quality dropped off after the first few matches. It says a lot that the best bouts came from the ones I had the lowest expectations for. The opener was a great tag match with a hot crowd, and Miz vs Kingston was a fast-paced, well-received contest. Legacy vs DX also picked up nicely as it went along and Regal vs Christian was a very solid match - the kind I wish they'd run at SummerSlam. Sure, Kane vs Khali happened in between, but at least it was short. Then came the world title matches, and that's where things started to fall apart. I'm just not a fan this Orton vs Cena match. It lacked blood, didn't feel nearly as brutal as it should have - even with the kendo stick welts on Cena's chest - and it ended with the typical Cena comeback out of nowhere. And the main event felt rushed, despite some very good in-ring work. Punk and Taker seemed to have solid chemistry, but it was ruined with a terrible finish - a worked Montreal Screwjob. It felt like a slap in the face to the live crowd."

[5.0] "When this event is good, it's outstanding. The Tag match, ECW title, and, U.S. title matches are all very strong standouts that are all worth repeated watches. Both World title matches are an absolute joke in one way or the other. It ends up being average overall when you consider all of these things, but if the main event matches were booked better and held their weight more, this would have been a show for the ages. Still, there's plenty worth seeing here. For a one off show, I was pretty happy with the end result."

[2.0] "Awful show. Total waste of time. not single fight worth of watching. Disappointing title matches and stupid submission stipulations. Christian and William wrestled only watchable match on the show but this is not enought for PPV of biggest wrestling organisation in the world"