[5.0] "Cena and JBL had a good promo, and the Battle Royal had solid moments, but the show fell apart with bad booking, a weak main event setup, and the awful Angle/Sharmell storyline dragging it down."

[5.0] "this show wasn't very good John Bradshaw and cena had a good promo other than that not much here ., ,"

[5.0] "This show had a really good first hour, highlighted by the tag title match, but a really bad second hour, "highlighted" by Kurt Angle choosing to wrestle Sharmell next week. Not John Cena, the WWE Champion, but Sharmell. Terrible."

[4.0] "The ending completely ruins this Smackdown for me. I enjoyed the Battle Royal for what it was and the show built up well to it. I also really enjoyed how it was used to continue the excellent Rey Mysterio vs Eddie feud. Rey and Angle as the last two was great with a lot of good near eliminations before Angle getting the cheap win. The whole thing setting up Angle choosing to wrestle Sharmell is a complete waste of time and WWE insisting on beating a dead horse with this awful storyline is really obnoxious. The only other match of any real length here was the MNM vs Holly/Hass match which was an okay follow up to the good PPV match they had but the DQ finish was lame. There's also a big moment where Matt Morgan takes out the Big Show with an F5 through an annonce table and this honestly could have been a solid push for him because being the back up to a charismatic guy like Carlito is a pretty good spot normally, but the stuttering gimmick is absolutely killing him. The Cena/JBL segment wrapping up their feud is fine enough, but Cena comes off a bit of a dick with that video package. It's a mixed bag of a show because the storylines are all over the place but the terrible ending knocks it below average for me."