[10.0] "One of my favorite events Ive ever attended, Im sad that I cant rate the dark match as it was FUCKING AWESOME. The crowd was electric all night, and I just cant get over how well this card was made. There was only one mid match, the others were worth the price of admission for sure."

[7.0] "The post-Elite ROH is still clearly hurting badly, as shown by the meager buyrate for this event, but in and of itself what was presented here was actually pretty good. The main event was perhaps Taven's best singles match in ROH to date and resulted in a more dynamic babyface, international champion being crowned who may be able to help revive some interest in the company. We also had a good Tag Title bout, another strong chapter in the Gresham vs. Lethal rivalry which may be a breakout victory for the former, a fun hardcore match in Bouncers vs. Young/Marseglia and two solid bouts in the contendership tournament (a good grappling match in Scurll vs. Cabana, and a pretty fun brawl in PCO vs. King)."

[8.0] "A surprisingly good show with many matches that are worth watching, Gresham vs Lethal was my top pick. The tv title match was fun. The two last matches are also good."

[7.0] "I really enjoyed this show. The last 2 matches especially were great, also check out the King/Cobb and the Lethal/Gresham match. Probably Matt Taven's best singles match of his career and they solidified Rush as a star. The rest of the matches were decent to good, although having two no-dq matches on one show is a bit much. Also the TV title match seemed like it had its time cut short."

[7.0] "In my book, this was the best of ROH's four PPVs thus far in 2019. Scurll vs. Cabana was a solid opener (***1/4). PCO vs. King wasn't much of note (**3/4). The women's match was bad, as per usual for both Women of Honor matches and Angelina Love matches (*1/2). Gresham vs. Lethal was great, with just the right amount of them switching it up between technical wrestling and brawling, all while telling a really good story (****1/4). The Barroom Brawl wasn't all that good for a hardcore match these days, but I give it a full half-star extra just for including the never-before-seen human dartboard spot, which was incredibly creative and extreme (***3/4). The TV Title match was really good for the relatively short amount of time it was given, and Taylor retaining surprised me because I was leaning towards thinking the Taylor vs. ROH story was legit; I suppose this confirmed it's a work (***3/4). The tag team title match was about as good as you'd expect it to be, although it was predictable because at no point in that 20+ minutes did I ever think Lifeblood had a chance at winning (****). The main event was unquestionably the best Matt Taven match I've ever seen, and it's a great thing that they FINALLY took the title off of him, ending a title reign which never should have started in the first place. Great match and even better booking to have Taven finally lose (****1/4)."

[5.0] "Pretty weak show. Cabana/Scurll was a solid technical match. PCO/King was your standard sloppy PCO trash brawl. Love/Klein was a perfectly average match. Gresham/Lethal was a fun technical match and my personal highlight of the show. The hardcore tag match was your normal modern hardcore match. TV title 4-way was solid but ended quite abruptly. Briscoes/Lifeblood was solid. Just not a very interesting show overall and then you cap it off with yet another boring Taven match. Weak."