[8.0] "the apex of comedy wrestling right now. its incredibly to watch and their highlight reels have definately gotten some of my more anti wrestling friends into the genre."
[8.0] "Mystery Wrestling feels like a promotion where you never really know what you're going to get, and that's a big part of the appeal. The atmosphere and crowd interaction add a lot, while the local talent gets a chance to stand out. Not every idea lands, but it's definitely different."
[7.0] "Mystery Wrestling is a fun concept with a unique identity. The comedy and surprise matches can be entertaining, though the overall quality feels a bit inconsistent. Still, it's a nice change of pace from regular wrestling shows."
"A striking alternative in a wrestling zeitgeist which takes itself increasingly seriously. Genuinely funny, Mystery Wrestling exists as much as parody as it does comedy wrestling. This does not though detract from a core roster of very capable talent, paticularly the team of Fresh Air. Evil Uno is one of the most creative emerging minds in wrestling and I look forward to seeing Mystery grow and progress."
[10.0] "If you don't take wrestling too seriously, it's the greatest. Absolutely adore watching Mystery Wrestling. You can tell it's booked, and made by people that are very passionate about wrestling."
[8.0] "This is a fun promotion to watch and it definitely has its own and unique identity. It's also great to see them giving local Canadian talent a chance to shine even if obviously not all of them are top internationnal wrestlers."
[8.0] "Possibly the closest we have to a modern equivalent of Chikara while providing its own unique twist with most of the matches being surprise matches, and some of the wrestlers having gimmicks that definitely look like they belong in Chikara. Couple that with the fact that Evil Uno was also a Chikara wrestler under the name Player Uno as part of the Super Smash Brothers tag team and during intermission, he often gets to interact with the chat on Twitch. In fact, I'd say they've managed to beat Maple Leaf Pro to numerous cities in Canada and could be considered as the #1 promotion in the country if it comes down to presence as they've been outside Gatineau many times."
[9.0] "This has to be one of the best comedy promotions in North America at the moment, because it's the only one to do it right. I wasn't around for PWG, or Chikara, but I'm grateful to be around to witness this great promotion."
[8.0] "A very fun little promotion that's about relaxing and embracing all the silliness of wrestling. As they continue to grow, the mystery of who is on the card isn't as much fun as it was early on. Cecil Nyx, Stu Grayson, and Psycho Mike are going to be there. At this point they should just advertise those 3. They also can only afford to run one tiny venue in Quebec. On the lighter side of gripes, the theme song is a miss. "Mystery Wrestling, it's the best thing" what a fumble. "Myster Wrestling, it's the bestling" was right there. I hope they continue to grow and are able to take it on the road some time."
[10.0] "Everything I need in wrestling. Surprises, good matches, ridiculous and original comedy characters, really bad match gimmicks done shockingly well, Evil Uno taking his shirt off on commentary. The shows are a blast, the shows are also completely unhinged. The only downside to it is that its not running every week."
[9.0] "Can we swear here? Who knows. MYSTERY Wrestling is one of the most fun promotions I've attended. Streams live on twitch with special guest commentators. Some of the most fun you'll have watching a show. Only downfall is it's venue's location."