 # | Duration | Champion(s) | Amount | Timeframe | Rating | Votes |
| 1 | 1798 days | Brooklyn Brawler | 1 | 03.04.1998 - 06.03.2003 | 6.43 | 167 |
| 2 | 563 days | Chris Sabin | 1 | 06.03.2003 - 19.09.2004 | 8.12 | 473 |
| 3 | 454 days | Petey Williams | 1 | 17.04.2005 - 15.07.2006 | 6.67 | 236 |
| 4 | 420 days | Otis Apollo | 1 | 23.06.1995 - 16.08.1996 | ||
| 5 | 210 days | Alex Shelley | 1 | 19.09.2004 - 17.04.2005 | 8.90 | 553 |
| 6 | 98 days | Terry Richards | 1 | 16.08.1996 - 22.11.1996 | 7.10 | 535 |
| 7 | 84 days | Gene Miller | 1 | 29.03.1997 - 21.06.1997 | ||
| 8 | 64 days | Professor Maxwell | 1 | 24.11.1996 - 27.01.1997 | ||
| 9 | 54 days | Canadian Destroyer | 1 | 27.01.1997 - 22.03.1997 | ||
| 10 | 7 days | Bo Lewis | 1 | 22.03.1997 - 29.03.1997 | ||
| 11 | <1 day | N8 Mattson | 1 | 15.07.2006 - xx.xx.2006 | ||
| 12 | <1 day | Larry Destiny | 1 | 27.01.1997 - 27.01.1997 |
