 # | Champion(s) | Since | Duration | Location | Note | Details |
| INACTIVE | 12.11.2023 | |||||
| 10 | Tyler Matthews | 06.08.2022 | 463 days | South Bend, Indiana, USA | Matches | |
| 9 | Jayden Quick | 26.02.2022 | 161 days | Elkhart, Indiana, USA | Matches | |
| VACANT | 26.02.2022 | <1 day | ||||
| 8 | Celtic Nightmare | 20.08.2021 | 190 days | Elkhart, Indiana, USA | Matches | |
| 7 | Theo Storm | 26.09.2020 | 328 days | Elkhart, Indiana, USA | Matches | |
| VACANT | xx.09.2020 | ? | ||||
| 6 | Jason Page | 17.08.2019 | ? | South Bend, Indiana, USA | Matches | |
| 5 | Jeff Steeples | 18.05.2019 | 91 days | South Bend, Indiana, USA | Matches | |
| 4 | The Celtic Nightmare | 10.11.2018 | 189 days | South Bend, Indiana, USA | Matches | |
| 3 | DW Kelley | 12.05.2018 | 182 days | South Bend, Michigan, USA | Matches | |
| 2 | Sadon | 29.04.2017 | 378 days | Buchanan, Michigan, USA | Matches | |
| 1 | Rock Langston | 27.08.2016 | 245 days | South Bend, Indiana, USA | Matches |
