| 26 | Joshua Kavod | 07.12.2024 | 156 days | Langley, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 25 | Lou Martin (3) | 03.12.2022 | 735 days | Langley, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 24 | J-Ru | 16.07.2022 | 140 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 23 | Anthony Alexander (2) | 07.12.2019 | 952 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 22 | Dennis Gregory | 01.12.2018 | 371 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 21 | David Lawless | 11.08.2018 | 112 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 20 | Mitch Napier (2) | 03.12.2016 | 616 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 19 | Jay Flash | 10.09.2016 | 84 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 18 | Kris Kash | 05.12.2015 | 280 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 17 | Shawn Blanchard (6) | 28.03.2015 | 252 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 16 | Shane Starr | 07.12.2013 | 476 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 15 | Lou Martin (2) | 03.12.2011 | 735 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 14 | Mitch Napier | 03.12.2011 | <1 day | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 13 | Ali Kaida | 09.07.2011 | 147 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 12 | The Latin Assassin | 01.05.2010 | 434 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 11 | Shawn Blanchard (5) | 11.07.2009 | 294 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 10 | Anthony Alexander | 01.12.2007 | 588 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 9 | Shawn Blanchard (4) | 20.01.2007 | 315 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 8 | La Lucha | 02.12.2006 | 49 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 7 | Shawn Blanchard (3) | 01.04.2006 | 245 days | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 6 | Lou Martin | 24.01.2004 | 798 days | Bloomfield, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 5 | Mike Malachi | 09.11.2002 | 441 days | Bloomfield, Pennsylvania | | Matches |
| 4 | Shawn Blanchard (2) | 21.09.2002 | 49 days | Bloomfield, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 3 | Tommy Faime | 28.04.2001 | 511 days | Bloomfield, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 2 | Shawn Blanchard | 04.08.2000 | 267 days | Bloomfield, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 1 | Skippy Hawk | 01.01.2000 | 216 days | | | Matches |
#