 # | Champion(s) | Since | Duration | Location | Note | Details |
| 6 | Darius Carter | 18.03.2023 | 1319 days | Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA | Matches | |
| VACANT | 18.03.2023 | <1 day | ||||
| 5 | Marina Shafir | 19.03.2022 | 364 days | Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA | Matches | |
| 4 | Darius Carter | 09.11.2018 | 1226 days | New York City, New York, USA | Matches | |
| 3 | Azrieal | 09.03.2018 | 245 days | New York City, New York, USA | Matches | |
| 2 | Joe Gacy | 10.11.2017 | 119 days | New York City, New York, USA | Matches | |
| 1 | Mike Orlando | 29.07.2017 | 104 days | New York City, New York, USA | 1 | Matches |
