[3.0] "Maybe I'm just missing something but I do not understand the appeal of this stable at all. I feel like they literally cut the same promo and had the same tag match every week for like 3+ years. The Dominik and Rhea Ripley dynamic was fun at first and sort of carried them but I really don't think anyone else in the group did anything to add to it. Balor is just a guy. Priest is just a guy. McDonagh is just a guy. They don't really have any unique personality or reason to want to watch them. And my god were they overexposed. Judgment Day vs some pairing of Cody, Uso, Owens and Zayn was the main event of what felt like every Raw for a year and not a single one of the matches was even slightly memorable."
[7.0] "Fun stable, I like the fact it went from being overly serious to more of a comedy but still not being a complete "joke." It has absolutely helped elevate Dom, Rhea & Priest. Unfortunately, it doesn't do so much for Balor aside from at least showing people he's more than the stale version WWE portrayed since his debut."
[8.0] "They've 100% lost some steam since they're fantastic 2023 and first half of 2024, but they still form a pretty important heel core to RAW, and seeing all the teenage-esque hijinks and backstabbing they get up to never really gets old."
[9.0] "The OG Judgement Day had a very weak start with Edge starting off as the groups leader only to be kicked out after the group's first couple of months and the spooky gimmick didn't do well either, but once they finally got Edge out of their way, went more into a gothic punk bully vibe and finally won more big matches and championship gold, they became one of the best stables in modern WWE that wasn't The Bloodline. It became one of the best things on Raw in it's duration for a long while and every member of the group had some the better. if not, best runs of their WWE career's, particularly Ripley, Priest and Dom. A fantastic stable that benefit everyone part of it when it finally got track."
[3.0] "Okay, so time has passed and now this version of Judgement Day has came to an end months ago, and I can still say with certainty that I HATE this faction. Look, I'm a fan of everyone in this faction (except Dominik, still don't get the appeal), but I felt this faction was very weak. My main issue was how overexposed they were and how they felt like pretend heels who didn't feel authentic. While some of these people have shown to be great heels in the past, this group was just boring and had nothing interesting going for them, constantly opening Monday Night Raw with the same promos every week, always having the tag team titles around their waist, etc. I seriously don't miss this version, but the newer version is, somehow, much worse... Ugh! Can Triple H end this Judgement Day nonsense already, for fuck sakes?"
[9.0] "Judgment Day started off badly, very badly, and ended up with one of the best evolutions, thanks in particular to the presence of Rhea Ripley. Each member of the team grew in stature and credibility, and found their place. The writing never stopped improving and the team became solid, with titles arriving without the kind of elected clan history that might have been the case with Bloodline or Undisputed Era. Things happened almost naturally, with characters gaining in skill and relationships between members evolving. This clan is surely one of the best of this generation, especially as despite betrayals and new members, the clan endures, something rare in recent years. Recent events are intriguing and, even if the new form of the clan seems less pleasant, I prefer to give them a chance. Indeed, the whole point of Judgment Day is to kick out the members who take the lead and recruit new ones. It's coherent. And above all: it puts Rhea and Damian OVER, makes them grow and shine even more, and leads to a richly deserved Face Turn."
[10.0] "Judgment Day deserves a 10 for their exceptional character evolution, compelling heel dynamics, and in-ring excellence. Initially doubted under Edge, the faction found its stride after his ousting, with Dominik Mysterios transformation being particularly noteworthy. Their engaging storylines, like the recent R-Truth angle, showcase versatility. Each member has been elevated, with Rhea Ripley and Damien Priest becoming main event players, and Dominick developing into a great heel. The latest events and addition of new members convinced me of upping my previous score. Their consistency, cohesion, and future potential, including title pursuits and possible new members, solidify them as one of the best modern wrestling factions."
[10.0] "The best faction that was everywhere on RAW and basically carried half the show on their back in the past year. They can be dominant while extremely funny, having arguments here and there but still remain a family. Priest, Rhea and Dom's career are elevated to heights they would never achieve by themselves only (especially Dom), while I cannot wait to see what Finn is capable of after his turn on Summerslam."
[9.0] "writing this on the day after what appears to be the final day of this group. This group is incredible. At first it looked like it never would last even a year. But the addition of balor and dom really helped A LOT. Very happy i was able to watch this group start to finish. Now there feuds with eachother after are going to be generational as well. This group made me a giant fan of dom and priest and even more balor. You know youre a great faction when u start out hated but end beloved. One day this group deserved a hall of fame induction. Hate to see the group go."
[8.0] "Awesome stable that has developed into one of the best bits of Monday Night Raw over the past two years despite a bit of a rocky start with Edge. Done its job perfectly as every member of the JD has ultimately become a bigger star for their involvement in it."
[8.0] "Ich mag das Stable eigentlich ganz gerne. Viel Talent und es gibt ihren Mitgliedern endlich mal wieder was interessantes zu tun. Aufbau und Storylines waren nicht immer optimal, aber insgesamt unterhaltsame Nummer."
[9.0] "Dreadful when Edge was in charge, they've become more and more watchable since ousting him. Dom is a great addition and they've been very entertaining as of late."
[7.0] "Very intriguing group at the beginning with Edge at its head. It remained relevant for the following months, and are arguably the companys MVP for 2023. It skyrocketed Dominik Mysterios and Rhea Ripleys status as main event players for the next decade, established and re-established Damian Priest and Finn Balor as present day threats. However, its been going for too long with so many repetitive matches, storylines and finishes. They should have broken up before the JD McDonagh and R-Truth storyline because Im afraid itll tarnish their legacy as a group."
[8.0] "I'm glad to see that Edge is looking to reinvent himself at such an late stage in his career, but overall the faction as a whole hasn't really impressed me, given it's sheer lack of originality. Hopefully this improves in time and this group of very talented individuals can properly make an impact rather then just go around wearing dark suits trying to be (no pun intended) edgy. Edit: Hours after writing this post Edge would be kicked out of the group, whether this is for better or worse remains unknown. Ultimately this decision did pay off very well in the long run as with the addition of Dominik Mysterious and the overall cool misfit outcast gimmick these guys are very entertaining."
"All rise for the Judgment Day! Seriously, this group is amazing. Balor, Priest, Mysterio, and Ripley all had a career resurgence thanks to this group. Ask yourself if you saw any of these four as main-eventers in WWE just three years ago. Any of these four could jump into the main event role as a heel and the fans would pay to see them lose."
[9.0] "Judgement Day was interesting when Edge started it as it seemed like it could help get Priest and Ripley when they joined. Edge being replaced as the leader was very unexpected and unneeded but Balor has done a good job making the stable feel relevant. Hoping they get booked strong and help elevate the three talented superstars in the stable. UPDATE: They have gotten much better booking and the addition of Dom was perfect. Judgement Day has becoming one of the best thing on WWE TV in 2023"
[7.0] "I like Judgment Day, they have every element that a good heel stable needs and are one of the biggest hits WWE produced recently. It's a shame that the booking is sometimes lazy and repetitive, but everyone does their job greatly."
[4.0] "I'm not gonna lie, I was a huge fan of Judgment day when it first started last year. Or was I just a huge Edge fan? Who knows. But moving on, Judgment Day became stale fast, especially when Edge got kicked out. It just became dry. And now they either start or main event RAW every single week. Sometimes they do both. It gets highly annoying. Plus them holding all the titles basically is not fair to the wrestlers who actually deserve them. Like Dominik isn't even an NXT superstar. Overall very annoying and I hope they break up soon."
[2.0] "One of the most boring and overrated (i don't know by who) stables ever. Let's start by saying that this stable has ZERO main eventers in it, Priest is a good mid-uppercarder but will never be more than that, Balor is great in the ring but is a total charisma vaccuum and Dominik simply can't wrestle and can't talk on a microphone, being probably the worst wrestler WWE has today. Their matches, promos and segments are always the same, boring stuff, they get over exposed while a lot of other guys is on the catering doing nothing for months. This is a total HHH's obsession who is making me want to stop watch WWE."
[9.0] "It's cool they all have gold on their shoulders. But no matter they have or not, as for me they would be cool without it. There can be different oppinions about this stable, but everyone must agree that Finn, Rhea, Damian and Dom are having the best time in their WWE career. From the begging there were arguments they are just a worse WWE version of House of Black. But now they are much much better than Malakai's group. And thanks to WWE for that, too. Wrestlers are making an excellent job to represent themselves, but people behind all of these, who believed in their success, deserve ovation, too."
[8.0] "They don't do it as a unit for me. I like pretty much everyone of them more when they are alone and without that group (except for Dom, haven't seen much from him as a singles guy). The group has done wonders for Rhea especially and it will probably help Dom get more confident as a wrestler, so it's not useless. EDIT: I was proven wrong. The faction is way better now and I love the goofyness of Dom's gimmick."
[8.0] "After a really bad start, since the addition of Dominik the Judgement Day has become a really good attraction for weekly TV. It needs more stables to feud with and is indirectly making Rhea give a average (sometimes bad) Women's Championship reign. Aside from that it is full of star power and is on the right track to have really good storylines if booked well."
[8.0] "Der Judgment Day wird einfach immer besser! Rhea Ripley gehört jetzt schon zu einer meiner Lieblingswrestlerinnen, Dominik Mysterio als Heel gefällt mir so gut wenn man bedenkt wie farblos er im Tag Team mit Vater Rey war, Damian Priest hoffentlich ein zukünftiger World Champion und Finn Balor naja Finn interessiert mich am wenigsten von den 4 da hat mir Edge vorher besser gefallen."
[9.0] "yall crazy with this rating, finally some fresh air and finally a stable that makes sense and can push some stars that were left behind, i hope it will last forever edit: after some time people are starting to realize it's a good stable (mainly because wwe started to care about them lol)"
[5.0] "I liked them a lot at one point. But then they started being the focal point of TV every week, and they got overexposed big time. None of them are particularly great at promos, which is why it's baffling that they open RAW every week with boring, long-winded promos with the same content every single week, being interrupted by the same 4 or 5 people on rotation and setting up some sort of main event tag match that they usually end up losing. They try and try to make them credible but every time they get cut off at the legs. Rhea Ripley's booking in particular has been atrocious, spending far too much time as a valet than a wrestler despite being a champion. She also has more confrontations and promos with men than she does women, which is also a problem as WWE cannot book intergender matches. Finn Balor feels like a shell of his former self, although he's still solid in the ring. Damian Priest is decent but unremarkable. Rhea is a good wrestler but is not good at anything else. Dominik gets great heat in his promos, but then the bell rings and he's sloppy and uncoordinated with only brief flashes of potential. Overall, I have grown to loathe their presence on TV, and now it seems they'll be NXT regulars as well. I'd like to see something new, but that doesn't seem likely as Triple H is obsessed with them. They were better with Edge as the leader."
[9.0] "Really rough start when Edge was their leader but the moment he got kicked out and Dom came in, this group became the second best faction in WWE"
[10.0] "The addition of Dominic and his fun chemistry with Rhea, as well as the general family dynamic of the group, has propelled this into a top tier stable. Every member is unique and fun, and in a varied point in their career."
[10.0] "Judgment Day really is one of the best things going on in wrestling today. Absolutely love the different dynamics each member brings to the group, and as a weekly Raw viewer, I can say that the past 12 months, Seth Rollins and the Judgment Day have carried Raw. Love each member and who would've thought Dom would be a generational heel? As Rhea would say, The Judgment Day, runs Monday Night Raw"
[8.0] "Was ein wilder Ritt für die Truppe. Edge war ein nachvollziehbarer Anführer und das galt auch für den Story-Ansatz. So ganz klickte dies aber nicht und auch der Tausch Balor-Edge sorgte nicht dafür, dass die Gruppierung durchstarten konnte. Was dann folgen sollte, kann man schwer beschreiben. Rhea wird zu Mami, Dom landet im Gefängnis und Priest entdeckt den Punisher in sich. Balor verlor nicht nur die Fehde gegen Edge, sondern büßte auch seinen Leader-Status, aber die flachen Hierarchien stehen der Truppe gut und alle funktionieren auf ihre Art und Weise. Dominik ist der Heat-Magnet 2023, Rhea ist Champ, Priest legt sich mit Ex-Kumpel Bunny an. Peak Judgment Day im Mai 2023. Nun ist Rhea schon bald zu cool, um langfristig Heel zu bleiben und Balor kann gerne einen Schritt Richtung Main Event machen, daher ist Bewegung wohl absehbar, aber nach den letzten Entwicklungen kann man sich darauf wohl freuen."
[8.0] "Its funny how much things can change within the span of a year. Around this time last year, Edge was at the helm of the new faction, taking Damien Priest and Rhea Ripley under his wing as dark, brooding, omnipresent beings casting judgement on all those who dare stand in their way. While supernatural factions or gimmicks are nothing new in the world of professional wrestling, Edges character was. It was unlike anything he had done since The Brood and helped to prolong Edges return to the industry. With that said, it was not a perfect start. The Judgement Day struggled to take off with this angle, even through cutting scathing promos to the audience. Even with an initial push, something seemed missing. When Edge was cast aside for Finn Balor, it felt like the writing was on the wall for the fledging stable, especially after they lost to the Mysterios during SummerSlam 2022. And then Dominik turned heel and almost overnight, it was like the group transformed for the better. As if once Dominik joined, their identity was solidified. Gone were the supernatural references and powers. In its place was a group of edgy, disrespectful, gothic outcasts who would cause nothing but chaos for anyone who dare stood in their way. This evolution has been one of the best the industry has seen in recent memory and its a testament to what happens when time is given for performers and writers to figure things out. If it wasnt for Imperium or Bloodline, Id argue theyd be the top heel faction in WWE. Their chemistry, their skillset and their willingness to push the gothic angle to its limit has made Judgement Day a constant highlight of WWE programming."
[10.0] "What took 2 of my favorite wrestlers in Priest and Ripley, and two that I really just wanted to see something different of in Dominik and Finn has turned into one of my favorite groups of all time. I love the heat Mysterio gets, I love this version of Finn who is a cocky little ass who flexes and taunts the crowd in the funniest ways after a big hit on someone like edge. Rhea as mami and Priest just being the workhorse of the group who can give you good singles and tag team matches and has improved a lot on the mic has made this thing just work so well. It's hard to imagine a time when I thought Finn leading and Edge leaving would turn it into nothingness"
[9.0] "What are RAW trainers now? Rollins and the judgement day. This faction Is much better than was thinked. Every member Is essential, Balor Is an awesome leader and Dominio could be great. ****1/2"
[9.0] "While I was already a fan of Edge's incarnation of Judgement Day as a gothic, Ministry esque cult, they've come into their own even more so since Finn Balor has taken the helm. Rather than all that hokey, black magic stuff and long philosophical promos, Judgement Day is like the modern day Raven's Flock. A bunch of Gothic/Alt punks who hate everyone and cause trouble, they really are just bullies dressed in all black lol. While these guys maybe aren't gonna win any world titles any time soon, they've done an amazing job helping fill out the midcard and tag divisions with legit heels. Dom's character shift from "Rey Jr" into this spiteful little punk hiding behind Mama Rhea's boots has also been creative gold."
[8.0] "It started well, after Edge fired it was worse, and now with Dominik joining in it's okay again. There is no need to delude yourself - JD will not be the ruling stables of WWE, they will not threaten The Bloodline, although at first you could think so. The protracted feud with Mysterios hurt them, but now it's quite interesting again. They are okay midcard stable, but nothing more. (February 14, 2023) It's been a while and I find JD to be one of the most interesting and fun elements of every RAW"
[7.0] "easily one of the most fun parts of WWE right now, although i do think they still have ways to go before theyre cemented as a serious stable for me."
[0.0] "Judgement Day absolutely stinks. Their promos are terrible and their matches are absolutely mediocre. This faction has made me think less of Finn Balor, that is how bad it is. Dominik Mysterio has no right being on national television this much. He is terrible on the mic and absolutely disgusting in the ring. How is it possible to be so terrible when you are the son of the greatest luchador of all time?"
[7.0] "This stable was started very poorly but thanks to Triple H's work it has managed to gain credibility. However, I still see Finn Balor a little out of place in this stable but I am happy with the work they are doing."
[6.0] "It? s going there, it? s almost there. They? ve been doing pretty great lately, the addition of Dom is a double edge sword. The kid? s terrible with the mic but the storyline they got themselves into with him is pretty entertaining. If this feud with the OC would land, then WWE has established a pretty dope stable."
[10.0] "The best thing about Raw. Go and watch the segment where people are just booing and they are soaking it all in. That was so freakin good. I love their chemistry, and these guys are just phenomenal. Awesome to see"
[9.0] "Not gonna lie - I was shocked, when I saw the overall rating of the Judgment Day. For a while now, everyone does their job pretty well, even Dominik with some "heel" antics, like provoking his father to hit him with a chair. Priest and Rhea's work is also fun to watch and last but not least - Finn Bálor. He's finally becoming a major RAW star and honestly I can't wait for his match against Edge at Extreme Rules."
[0.0] "Judgement Day are the absolute pits, they may even have surpassed New Day as my most hated, most go away heat inducing faction of all time, they are absolutely rotten. They are by far and away the low point of Raw, which is extremely damaging to my overall enjoyment of the episodes because every week they are featured in multiple segments and matches. Their promo segments are horrific and seem to go on forever, Balor is a good talker, but his promos as part of this faction are just rambling nonsense. On the other hand, Ripley and in particular Priest are trash on the mic. Priest drones on and on with a wooden delivery and the majority of the time looks scared and lost. Balor is of course very good in the ring, but Priest is lumbering, awkward, basic, slow, boring and a terrible seller to boot. Ripley seemingly doesn't wrestle any more, she just interferes in matches, attacking male wrestlers who apparently aren't allowed to retaliate. The less said about the addition of Dominik Mysterio the better, but it's very clear that if it wasn't for his last name, he wouldn't even have a developmental contract, let alone be a heavily featured act on WWE's flagship show."
[10.0] "I love Judgment Day, I know they aren't booked very well but still, I really love their work they are putting in, I am very interested in what's gonna happen later and I love this stable, I hope to see them now sucessful with HHH in charge"
[6.0] "People here seem to like calling them a house of black ripoff like they invented the cult esque factions. I hate to be the bearer of bad news but Kevin Sullivan, Raven, The Undertaker and Bray Wyatt have all done it before. The faction was at its best so fast with edge but its seemingly getting back on track. Somewhat generic promos but overall theyre ok"
"I ain't giving a Rating, as I don't like to rate a stable when they're still in their early stages, but it's been a bumpy start for Judgment day, as the debut was decent, and it was fairly good up till Edge got kicked out. Then Rhea got injured, and they've been in a slump. But it could go smooth sailing again since Rhea's back and a Feud with Edge is now happening. I'd rate a 5/6 as of now, but i expect that to be higher in a few months"
[4.0] "Okay, Edges original idea for the team to essentially punish those for allowing the fans to cheer for them wasnt awful. Generic and uninspired, but not awful. Its when they started with the horseshit supernatural crap. What is there about Edge that makes him even remotely able to do any of the spooky things Undertaker could ever do? Absolutely nothing. I liked the idea of adding people like Priest and Rhea to the group as they needed direction and didnt have any, but as soon as the group begins showing promise, they butcher it. Edge has already been outed as leader and replaced with Balor because he has the demon gimmick. So they can get away with the stupid Hollywood crap they want to. Its so cringe. Did they even really explain why Balor joined? Or how he convinced the others to kick Edge out? Damien spent the better part of a month attacking Finn, now hes loyal to him? Its so dumb. I dont doubt WWE will push them to the moon and its good to see Finn finally having direction and simply having something to do, but Im not excited for the long term future of this group unfortunately. Maybe a name change to something less corny will help?"
[4.0] "They are essentially a House of Black knock-off (Same look/intro presentation and Priest tells the audience to rise in their presence just like Malakai does) but they come across as a comedy faction. The group has this whole dark/sinister/spooky/otherworldly feel and then Edge gets the mic and begins to ridicule the local sports team, like any generic heel, with some cryptic nonsense thrown-in that goes on way too long. I would rate them lower but the whole betrayal of Edge was interesting and unexpected for sure; even if it did make no sense at all. I mean; Finn Balor comes out says he wants to join them, though he does not seem too sure why, they then cut another nonsensical promo ending with them saying something like 'time to cast off the only thing holding us back.' And then Edge is surprised when they finally add some substance to their cryptic nonsense and reveal that what is holding them back is him! I thought it was hilarious. They are quite funny; I am just not sure it is comedy that they are going for though. Maybe with Edge gone the group will gain some direction; but I somehow doubt it."
[5.0] "I found this faction quite worthy and had potential with a hall of famer, multi time world champion and countless other achievements of Edge being the leader bringing in Damian Priest and Rhea Ripley. I like the plot twist of the Edge betrayal as no one saw that coming however I am decreasing the rating that I was initially going with considering it makes no sense of the change of leader. Finn Bálor has achieved quite minimal in his WWE career compared to a Hall of Famer like Edge who has bust down barriers and opened up doors for new talents therefore confuses me. Nevertheless, this stable gets a balanced and standard rating of 5."
[5.0] "This group didn't particularly make Edge look good - he decides to be evil against AJ Styles, then recruits Damian Priest and then Rhea Ripley to help his cause... only for them to be working in secret with Finn Bálor to overthrow Edge? The booking clearly makes no sense, although it did give the three current members something to do, and Bálor knows a thing or two about running a major faction. I can change the rating if things improve with The Judgment Day going forward, but right now the booking of their formation and leadership change leaves a lot to be desired."
[0.0] "Shitty cheap stable with no idea, in fact I don't think there's anything worse to stables than having no idea, just tell me why they were formed in the first place? Yes Edge attacked Styles dream match come true! but why! ? Why does Edge want Styles to be at his best and he doesn't want Styles to be humiliated by a low quality wrestlers Just why? What does Edge have to do with him and why does this lead him to turn into a dark character? Even the content currently being offered by the stable looks really childish and irritating, turning the hall lights blue, exaggerated facial expressions during promo, overbooking during matches, nothing about this faction calls to be good."
