[8.0] "Underrated, one of the better modern tag teams. Their AEW world title tag belt reign was absolutely wasted in my opinion. They have the ability to entertain and put on great matches. Their gimmick, if you've ever been around that life; it's done believably. If there's ever been a team where I'll never understand why they aren't as over to the masses as they are with me, this is them; they are it."
[7.0] "Private Party is a great tag team with a lot of potential in the future, but there AEW Tag Title reign was nothing stellar and was actually pretty disappointing. They have really good in-ring chemistry and are very over with the crowd, I just wish they'd be booked more and booked better, but still a good team nonetheless."
[8.0] "Gutes Tag Team, solide Jungs. Wrestlerisch gut, am Mikrofon nicht schlecht, Charisma ist vorhanden. Ich bin froh dass die beiden mittlerweile den AEW-Tag Titel gewinnen durften, definitiv überfällig gewesen."
[6.0] "Zwei AEW-Eigengewächse, die immer einen gewissen Charme hatten und auch im Ring mit dem typischen Spot-Stil abgeliefert haben. Trotzdem muss man nach fünf Jahren auch konstantieren, dass sie sich nie wirklich weiterentwickelt haben, weder individuell noch als Team."
[3.0] "Die Beiden haben sich seit ihrer Ankunft bei AEW merklich kein Bisschen weiterentwickelt, tendenziell sind sie eher schlechter geworden. Sie waren in allem was sie tun immer sehr Indie, sowohl beim Charakter als auch noch viel offensichtlicher ihrem Wrestling. Und nach all dem Jahren sollte man meinen, dass sie mehr zu bieten haben als elend langweilige Spot-"Matches". Aber anscheinend können sie es nicht besser oder wollen es nicht besser. Gerade Kassidy ist nervig. Gefühlt will er nur für irgendwelche "Memes" bei Twitter sorgen anstatt ein auch nur im Ansatz ernstzunehmender Wrestler zu sein. Ich finde drei Punkte noch sehr großzügig und bin nicht überrascht, wenn ich die Punkte in Zukunft weiter nach unten korrigieren sollte."
[6.0] "Private Party has a lot of potential. They seem to get lost in the shuffle due to the lack of a presence. In the ring they have a good high-flying style but have room to improve in the other aspects. They constantly keep getting put into stables that have not helped them at all."
[6.0] "These guys had a lot of potential as a young babyface tag team or a cocky heel upstart team, But they have suffered many problems during their run, First we have seen the party group before with the street profits and such so they weren't sticking out that much, and second their pairing with matt hardy many would think being paired with a veteran tag expert like matt hardy would be beneficial for a career. but when that pairing is the HFO then that will ruin them in the end as not a single person who was with the HFO are in a better spot than they were before and that includes Private party. They go from heel to babyface to heel and are just stooges and they need to get far away from Hardy."
[5.0] "Horrible theme song. Seemed to have potential, but kind of plateaud when more seasoned teams signed. Not nearly as charismatic as The Acclaimed, who have a similar look and attitude. Still waiting for a comeback run to prove they can hang in the upper echelons."
[6.0] "Isiah and Marq have a lot of potential but all the Family Office stuff ruined them, and now they are stuck again in The Firm with Matt Hardy... They'd be better off being just a tag team honestly."
[7.0] "A tag team that absolutely should not be wasting away in a faction right now. I don't mind them as heels, in fact, it comes off as more natural for them with Quen's cockiness and Kassidy's arrogant mannerisms and demeanor. I don't know if they did something to piss off everyone backstage but you have this tag team coming in hot to AEW, beats the Young Bucks, has a decent run in the tag team division, joins the AFO, and then...nothing. It's a shame really, they're really talented in-ring."
[5.0] "It's quite sad to see Private Party fall so far from the potential they showed and the favouritism they appeared to receive from AEW early on. They were the first established high-flying team in the company not named 'The Young Bucks', and they were given a strong push to establish them as the future faces of the company, even receiving a win over the Bucks in effort of that. Sadly, it appeared that they used up all their tricks within the first few months, as their performances plateaued because it appeared that their creative juices were used up. Both guys could still hit some cool aerial attacks and bump really well, but they would also have a few sloppy moments and wouldn't have their character work figured out yet. Their arrogant displays were alright, but they didn't really have their confidence nor the skills at a higher enough level to pull that off properly (unlike, say, Swerve, who is both impressively arrogant and very smooth in the ring). It didn't help that they'd also indulge in some overly goofy things, like Isiah with his lame high-pitched squeals (who the hell told him *that* was a good idea for a supposedly cool babyface to do? ). They slowly lost both the fans' as well as AEW's appreciation, which was the impetus to pair them with a deceitful manager in Matt Hardy and then repackage them as heels. They've now leaned more into their arrogance, which thankfully comes off a lot more convincingly and naturally, but they've had to introduce generic heel brawling and beatdown work into their arsenal at the same time, which doesn't suit them. They're still natural high-flyers, but they haven't yet found a sweet spot of mixing spectacular high-flying spots with compelling heel work (à la Pac, for example). Their joining of the HFO/AHFO did nothing to benefit them apart from giving them some experience as working full heels, so their value in the company has only declined. They still have the naturally flashy style to appeal to fans if ever given another worthwhile babyface push again, but they definitely need to find a way to become more creative and refined, since there are just so many good tag teams in AEW now that merely being a slight step above your generic indy high-flyers is no longer a meaningful selling point."
"Nice up-and-coming tag team, I just wish they wouldnt be trapped in that doomed Hardy's stable. They need to align themselves with a better mouthpiece and/or singles wrestler. Lio Rush would be a perfect fit for them."
[5.0] "They're ok. Sometimes they can pull off sensational athletic displays, and sometimes they botch those athletic displays. Their gimmick is pretty dead-end, like a joke that isn't really funny when you first hear it and then gets repeated endlessly. Turning heel didn't do much for them, except now Isiah Cassidy's piercing screeches are funny instead of grating."
[4.0] "Bringen irre viel mit, aber müssen auch noch irre viel lernen. Abseits des Rings läuft da noch nicht viel zusammen und im Ring sind sie halt wirklich gerne mal grün unterwegs. Natürlich ist die Athletik und die Chemie da, aber noch können sie nicht seriös arbeiten."
[5.0] "An average highflyer team. Nothing special about them. They fly a lot, and they sometimes botch. Also their gimmick is so cheap. I don't like them."
[6.0] "Private Party can fly, but from a character perspective they just don't do it for me. Like, what is their gimmick? They like to party and... they smile a lot? They need a lot more development there."
[6.0] "Private Party has a lot going for them. They have a really unique moveset, are undeniably charismatic, and are fun to watch. They're also really clean and consistent in the ring. While they are fantastic athletes though, their matches can be hit or miss (with the miss column still being fun). I feel they need more time to wrestle against a wider pool of wrestlers, and in particular veterans of pro wrestling. They're definitely not at their fullest potential yet, and that will take time, but when they get there, they'll be among the best today."
[6.0] "Tauchten für mich aus dem Nichts bei AEW auf, da ich sie vorher nicht kannte. Private Party haben direkt Eindruck hinterlassen, Talent ist vorhanden, arbeiten sauber im Ring und haben Ausstrahlung. Nach einigen Monaten habe ich mich jetzt aber etwas satt gesehen an ihrem Stil. Sind für mich aktuell die "flippy dudes", die bis auf ihre Spot(-matches) wenig zeigen. Da muss jetzt ganz einfach mehr kommen, wenn sie über ihre aktuelle Underdog-Rolle hinauskommen wollen. Die Matches sind leider fast immer gleich. Es gibt Spots. Private Party müssen jetzt beweisen, dass sie den nächsten Entwicklungsschritt machen wollen und sich über das Spotwrestling hinaus weiterentwickeln."
[7.0] "Ziemlich gutes Tag Team. Für meinen Geschmack deutlich zu spotty und beide können einfach überhaupt kein long-term selling, aber als Team ganz nett und harmonisch. Ich hasse den Theme Song (wie die meisten der AEW-WrestlerInnen auch), aber die Ansage von Roberts ist recht witzig."
[9.0] "This team is just a blast to watch. They can get a crowd behind them like it's nothing, and their tandem moves are fantastic. It's no surprise that they are basically the Young Bucks' proteges."
[8.0] "A very fun and exciting tag team. Complete baby faces. They just know how to get the crowd going. They are easily the 2nd best tag team in House of Glory which is nothing to fret at, they hold their own against more experienced teams like LAX. They are both good coming off the top rope, and I can see a long title run in their future."
