| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 10.04.2021 |  |
Three Way: Ironbeast (KTB & Shane Mercer) defeat The ExerGuys (JP & M3) and Rohit Raju & Tye Hyll (9:47) IWTV Tony Deppen's Bier Haus - Online Stream @ 81Bay Brewing Company in Tampa, Florida, USA |
| 2 | 17.11.2017 |  |
Robbie E & The ExerGuys (JP & M3) defeat Foxx Vinyer & The Street (Angel Kross & Elite Terrell) Dynasty To The Moon - Event @ Elks Lodge #645 in Port Jervis, New York, USA |
| 3 | 20.05.2016 |  |
PPW Tag Team Title Four Way: All That Cinema (Keita Murray & Stevie Shields) (c) vs. South Philly's Finest (Jimmy Konway & Luca Brazzi) vs. The Cash Masters (Clay Drasher & Shawn Andrews) vs. The ExerGuys (JP & M3) - No Contest PPW Code Of Honor - Event @ Hazleton, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 4 | 19.03.2016 | |
PPW Tag Team Title: All That Cinema (Keita Murray & Stevie Shields) defeat The ExerGuys (JP & M3) (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PPW Attitude - Event @ Holy Family Academy in Hazleton, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 5 | 27.02.2016 |  |
The L And F Express (Ricky Landell & Tommy Face) & Shawn Sheridan defeat The ExerGuys (Johnny Moran, JP & M3) TRUE Retribution - Event @ Salvation Army in Berwick, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 6 | 20.02.2016 | |
Four On Two Handicap: South Philly's Finest (Jimmy Konway & Luca Brazzi) defeat All That Cinema (Keita Murray & Stevie Shields) & The ExerGuys (JP & M3) PPW Uprising - Event @ Holy Family Academy in Hazleton, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 7 | 16.01.2016 | |
PPW Tag Team Title: The ExerGuys (JP & M3) (c) vs. All That Cinema (Keita Murray & Stevie Shields) - Double DQ PPW Outlawed - Event @ Holy Family Academy in Hazleton, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 8 | 09.01.2016 |  |
MF Cup Tournament 2016 First Round: ExerGuys (JP & M3) defeat Matthew Riddle & Nick Comoroto MFPW MF Cup 2016 - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 9 | 09.01.2016 | |
MF Cup Tournament 2016 Semi Final: Kongo & Mikey Webb defeat ExerGuys (JP & M3) MFPW MF Cup 2016 - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 10 | 19.12.2015 |  |
Glacier & Iceberg defeat The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) WrestleMerica TV-Taping - Event @ Barnesville Academy Gym in Barnesville, Georgia, USA |
| 11 | 19.12.2015 | |
The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) defeat The Beautiful Bald Besties (Michael Stevens & Zac Edwards) WrestleMerica TV-Taping - Event @ Barnesville Academy Gym in Barnesville, Georgia, USA |
| 12 | 18.12.2015 | |
Two On One Handicap: Iceberg defeats The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) WrestleMerica Toys For Tots - Event @ Mamas Country Showcase in Griffin, Georgia, USA |
| 13 | 17.12.2015 | |
The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) & Zane Riley defeat The European Syndicate (???, ??? & ???) (9:28) WrestleMerica Christmas Chaos - Event @ Rockhouse Bar & Billiards in Gastonia, North Carolina, USA |
| 14 | 12.12.2015 | |
MFPW Tag Team Title Three Way Elimination: Gifted Punishment (Punisher Martinez & QT Marshall) (c) defeat The Down Boyz (Steve Gipke & Tony Scorese) and ExerGuys (JP & M3) MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 15 | 28.11.2015 | |
Three On Two Handicap: The ExerGuys (JP & M3) defeat Blaze Daniels, Shogun Machette & Tom North TRUE 'Twas The Fight Before Christmas - Event @ Salvation Army in Berwick, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 16 | 20.11.2015 |  |
The Rock 'n' Roll Express (Ricky Morton & Robert Gibson) defeat The ExerGuys (JP & M3) BTW - Event @ Norfolk Scope Exhibition Hall in Norfolk, Virginia, USA |
| 17 | 17.10.2015 | |
PPW Tag Team Title: The ExerGuys (JP & M3) defeat South Philly's Finest (Jimmy Konway & Luca Brazzi) (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PPW 4 Life - Event @ Holy Family Academy in Hazleton, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 18 | 19.09.2015 | |
PPW Tag Team Title: South Philly's Finest (Jimmy Konway & Luca Brazzi) (c) defeat The ExerGuys (JP & M3) PPW Hard Knocks - Event @ Holy Family Academy in Hazleton, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 19 | 13.06.2015 | |
Six Team Turmoil: The ExerGuys (JP & M3) defeat Adrenaline Rush (Aaron Arbo & Andy Harner) and The World Class Gentlemen (Blaze Daniels & Johnny Moran) and Team Infamous (??? & ???) and Bull Hightower & Tommy Valor and Quinton Smith & Van Valley PPW Code Red - Event @ Holy Family Academy in Hazleton, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 20 | 16.05.2015 | |
Adrenaline Rush (Aaron Arbo & Andy Harner) defeat The ExerGuys (JP & M3) PPW All In - Event @ Holy Family Academy in Hazleton, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 21 | 18.04.2015 | |
The ExerGuys (JP & M3) & Robbie E defeat Keita Murray, Sean Carr & Travis Dorian PPW Showdown - Event @ Holy Family Academy in Hazleton, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 22 | 21.03.2015 | |
PPW Tag Team Title #1 Contendership Three Way: Main Event Hustlas (JT Nyce & MH Hustla) defeat Adrenaline Rush (Aaron Arbo & Andy Harner) and The ExerGuys (JP & M3) PPW Danger Zone - Event @ Holy Family Academy in Hazleton, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 23 | 07.02.2015 | |
Dante Falcon, Fungus, Joe Caldo & Tom North defeat The ExerGuys (JP & M3), Foxx Vinyer & Worst Case Cal BTW - Event @ Newburgh Armory Unity Center in Newburgh, New York, USA |
| 24 | 04.10.2014 |  |
The ExerGuys (JP & M3) defeat Diamond Inc. (Jason Gotti & Joey Ace) FWE ReFueled - Tag 2 - Pay Per View @ St. Patrick's Gym in New York City, New York, USA |
| 25 | 20.09.2014 |  |
Antonio Rivera & Dirtbag Dan defeat The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) WOW Red, White & Bruised 2014 - Event @ Funstation USA in New York City, New York, USA |
| 26 | 06.09.2014 |  |
The Punk Rock All Stars (Drake Carter & Shaun Cannon) defeat The ExerGuys (JP & M3) WXW C4 A Family Tradition - Event @ Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 27 | 09.08.2014 | |
Muscle And Mayhem (Napalm Bomb & Solo) defeat The ExerGuys (JP & M3) WXW C4 When Karma Calls - Event @ Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 28 | 20.07.2014 | |
The Automatic Weapons (Callo & Ortiz) defeat The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) WXW C4 Sportsfest 2014 - Event @ Cedar Beach Park in Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 29 | 03.05.2014 | |
MFPW Tag Team Title: AC Roc (Marc Cruz & Shaheem Ali) (c) defeat The ExerGuys (JP & M3) MFPW - Event @ Arena Monster Factory LLC in Paulsboro, New Jersey, USA |
| 30 | 26.04.2014 | |
The Samoan Dynasty (Afa Jr., Alofa, Lance Anoai & Samu) defeat Team Havoc (Gene Snitsky, Havoc, JP & M3) PPW Aftershock - Event @ Holy Family Academy in Hazleton, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 31 | 29.03.2014 | |
Team CK (Kage & Sean Carr) defeat ExerGuys (JP & M3) PPW March Mayhem - Event @ Freeland Event Center in Freeland, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 32 | 15.03.2014 |  |
The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) defeat Team CK (Kage & Sean Carr) 2CW 101 - Event @ Moosic, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 33 | 01.03.2014 | |
WXW Elite Tag Team Title: The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) defeat First Class (Kevin Graham & Punisher VanSlyke) (c) by DQ WXW C4 March Madness - Event @ Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 34 | 23.02.2014 |  |
Three Way Tag Team Warfare: The ExerGuys (JP & M3) defeat The Roc City Warriors (Mattick & Milliman) and The Rich Kidz (Georald Geofferies & Martin Prescott III) Xcite 2nd Anniversary - Event @ American Legion Post 80 in Binghamton, New York, USA |
| 35 | 01.02.2014 | |
The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) & Travis Dorian defeat Axel Lennox, Kyle Reynolds & Sgt. RJR WXW C4 The Calm Before The Storm - Event @ Mountainville Hall in Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 36 | 18.01.2014 | |
ExerGuys (JP & M3) defeat Team CK (Kage & Sean Carr) PPW Redemption - Event @ Freeland Event Center in Freeland, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 37 | 11.01.2014 | |
Three Way Elimination: The First Class (Kevin Graham & Punisher VanSlyke) defeat South Philly's Finest (Jimmy Konway & Luca Brazzi) and The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) WXW C4 Memorial Mayhem - Event @ Veterans Memorial Building in Orwigsburg, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 38 | 21.12.2013 | |
PPW Tag Team Title Turmoil Match (vakant): Main Event Hustlas (JT Nyce & MH Hustla) defeat Team CK (Kage & Sean Carr) and ExerGuys (JP & M3) and South Philly's Finest (Jimmy Konway & Luca Brazzi) and Fallen Angels (Kanzer Giddeon & Kryimm Giddeon) and Gus Green & IB Green and Rise Up (Mark Maverick & TJ Masters) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PPW Miracle On Fern Street - Event @ Freeland Event Center in Freeland, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 39 | 02.11.2013 | |
The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) defeat South Philly's Finest (Jimmy Konway & Luca Brazzi) WXW C4 Final Conflict - Event @ Mountainville Memorial Hall in Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 40 | 19.10.2013 | |
Rise Up (Mark Maverick & TJ Masters) defeat Team CK (Kage & Sean Carr) and Gus Green & IB Green and The ExerGuys (JP & M3) PPW Asylum - Event @ Freeland Event Center in Freeland, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 41 | 05.10.2013 | |
First Class (Kevin Graham & Punisher VanSlyke) defeat The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) WXW C4 The Boss is Back - Event @ Mountainville Memorial Hall in Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 42 | 14.09.2013 | |
Two On One Handicap: The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) defeat The Dynamic Sensation WXW C4 - Event @ Mountainville Memorial Hall in Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 43 | 17.08.2013 | |
The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) defeat BYOB (The Dynamic Sensation & The Mastodon) WXW C4 Big Daddy Dog Fest - Event @ Hamlin, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 44 | 10.08.2013 |  |
Vintage Tag Team Title: Team Lucha (Jay Cruz & Jay Rios) (c) defeat The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) Vintage Wrestling Summerbash 2013 - Event @ Salvation Army Gym in Sanford, Florida, USA |
| 45 | 04.08.2013 | |
The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) defeat BYOB (August Wright & The Mastodon) WXW C4 - Event @ Veterans Memorial Building in Orwigsburg, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 46 | 13.04.2013 | |
WXW Elite Tag Team Title: BYOB (August Wright & The Mastodon) (c) defeat The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) WXW C4 - Event @ Mountainville Memorial Association Hall in Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 47 | 09.03.2013 | |
Dark: The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) defeat Acid Zero & Ritch Howe WXW C4 - Dark Match @ Mountainville Memorial Association Hall in Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 48 | 09.02.2013 | |
The ExerGuys (JP & Mike Mitchell) defeat Cole Calloway & K'ras VanTasel WXW C4 Vegas Fight Night 2 - Event @ The Moose Exchange in Bloomsburg, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 49 | 12.01.2013 | |
BYOB (August Wright & The Mastodon) defeat JP & Mike Mitchell WXW C4 - Event @ Lakeside Ballroom in Barnesville, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 50 | 03.11.2012 | |
Black Wallstreet (Chuck Lennox & Drolix) defeat JP & Mike Mitchell WXW C4 Go 4 The Gold - Event @ Mountainville Memorial Association Hall in Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
