| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 09.11.2025 |  |
Street Fight: VGS (KC Payne & Tommy Jackson) defeat Playtime Mafia (Billy O'Keefe & Jayrow Lewis) Wrestle Island Train To Birkenhead - Event @ St. Annes Parish Centre in Birkenhead, Merseyside, England, UK |
| 2 | 05.10.2025 |  |
Billy O'Keefe, Jayrow Lewis & Sammy Blue defeat Andrew Jepson, Dan James & Evan Bishop BHW Aftershock 2025 - Event @ Guiseley Theatre in Leeds, West Yorkshire, England, UK |
| 3 | 14.09.2025 | |
Three Way: Playtime Mafia (Billy O'Keefe & Jayrow Lewis) defeat Dangerous & Royally Charmed (Charlie Mayne & Dan Pesek) and VGS (KC Payne & Tommy Jackson) Wrestle Island All The Angels Are Gone Son There's Only Devils Left - Event @ St. Anne's Parish Centre in Birkenhead, Merseyside, England, UK |
| 4 | 03.08.2025 | |
Playtime Mafia (Billy O'Keefe & Jayrow Lewis) defeat Ian Creed & TC Thorne BHW Hold Your Nerve - Event @ Guiseley Theatre in Leeds, West Yorkshire, England, UK |
| 5 | 06.07.2025 | |
Tag Team Tournament Semi Final: Playtime Mafia (Billy O'Keefe & Jayrow Lewis) defeat Cremus (Ian Creed & Remus Caine) BHW Show Some Heart 2025 - Event @ Guiseley Theatre in Leeds, West Yorkshire, England, UK |
| 6 | 21.06.2025 |  |
Hack N Slash (Brandon Butcher & Jay Vertigo) vs. Playtime Mafia (Billy O'Keefe & Jayrow Lewis) - No Contest BPW Beyond The Championship - Event @ Turf Moor Stadium in Burnley, Lancashire, England, UK |
| 7 | 27.04.2025 | |
Three Way: Chocolate Candy (Candy Stan & Chocolate Thunder) defeat Playtime Mafia (Billy O'Keefe & Jayrow Lewis) and Metal Mersey (Abaddon & Big Geno Ramsey) Wrestle Island Defying Gravity - Event @ St. Anne's Parish Centre in Birkenhead, Merseyside, England, UK |
| 8 | 24.11.2024 | |
Tag Team Battle Royal: Joseph Conners & Kai Daniels defeat Charlie Brennan & Drill and EJ Walsh & Riley Thee NBF and Playtime Mafia (Billy O'Keefe & Jayrow Lewis) and The Lost (Abaddon & Gorgon) Wrestle Island In A World Of Pure Imagination - Event @ St Anne's Parish Centre in Birkenhead, Merseyside, England, UK |
| 9 | 13.10.2024 |  |
MoonKrug (Krug & MoonBear) defeat Playtime Mafia (Billy O'Keefe & Jayrow Lewis) TWA Tenacious Anniversary - Event @ Crown Paints Sports & Social Club in Darwen, Lancashire, England, UK |
| 10 | 28.09.2024 | |
#1 Contendership Tag Team Rumble: Crashboat (Jack Bandicoot & Jake Silver) defeat The Zubaweights (Jack Baron & Philip Michael) and The Freakshow (Axl the Klown, Gentleman Jim Maguire & Luca Brigante) and Playtime Mafia (Billy O'Keefe & Jayrow Lewis) and The Nashverse (JG Nash, Lucha Nash & Wing Commander Nash) and Money Mountain (Franco Fate & Sash) and Made To Last (Leon Grey & Ryan Thorn) and The Horde (Gorgon & Solomon) BPW Big Burnley Bash - Event @ Burnley, Lancashire, England, UK |
| 11 | 15.09.2024 | |
Elimination: Aria Check, EJ Walsh, Josh Galla & Max Brooker defeat Billy O'Keefe, Drill, Jayrow Lewis & Sean Only Wrestle Island Sekai Taikai - Event @ St. Anne's Parish Centre in Birkenhead, Merseyside, England, UK |
| 12 | 28.04.2024 | |
Four Way: Charlie Brennan & Max Brooker defeat Dave Birch & Woody Anderson and Playtime Mafia (Billy O'Keefe & Jayrow Lewis) and The Lost (Abaddon & Big Geno Ramsey) Wrestle Island Minus One - Event @ St Anne's Parish Centre in Birkenhead, Merseyside, England, UK |
