[6.0] "The women's rumble was really good, it was predictable with Bayley, but nevertheless it was a great moment to see her winning, Liv Morgan was the runner-up once again. This had some cool moments when it comes to surprises, we had debuts, returns, wrestlers from other promotions... it was the complete package and I can't complain."
[9.0] "Honestly I really liked this match and I think Liv or Bayley really could have won this match. I loved the surprises and really legends would have been nice but it was good without it."
[8.0] "Probably the best womens rumble, I loved the story of Damage CTRL all coming in and trying to win as well as Bayley coming in at the beginning and lasting all the way. We also got some good surprises like Grace, Liv and Naomi."
[8.0] "Decent Royal Rumble. Bai.ey going coast to coast with the iron woman spot was good to see although blatantly predictable once she came out first. Great to see Jordynne Grace from TNA make an appearance as well and as a two times bonus, she was both recognised by the WWE Universe and over."
[7.0] "Thought this was a good Rumble. Naomi and Jordyn Grace were great surprise entrances for me. The action was good at the start and stayed solid for the entire match. Truth was funny and Jade Cargill's potential was clearly shown. Bayley was the right choice to win the Rumble this year. This Rumble was very enjoyable with a few memorable moments."
[7.0] "Fun match, it's really hard for me to be totally shocked by things in wrestling nowadays considering the way dirt sheets and the like work, but Jordynne Grace being in this genuinely got an audible "what the fuck" out of me."
[8.0] "I loved this match. For starters, it really showcased how much better the Womens Tag division has gotten in the last year, and there were some cool unexpected entrants in this like Naomi, Liv, R-Truth and his hilarious moment and my personal favorite, Jordynne Grace."