| 1 | 23.10.2023 | AidanArcher | 3.0 | |
| 2 | 01.05.2022 | WhatIsLooveee | | |
| 3 | 05.10.2021 | texasyosh | 1.0 | |
| 4 | 26.07.2019 | KyleEnjoysWrestling | 1.0 | A perfect example why the Tough Enough system has never worked. It was clear as day that Andy didn't have "it" and then when Austin made him look like garbage right out of the gate, that just sealed the deal. |
| 5 | 20.05.2017 | HC7 | 2.0 | |
| 6 | 24.01.2017 | Wrestling Forever | | |
| 7 | 09.12.2016 | SuperKick123 | 6.0 | Give the man a chance. Ok, he may not be the most talented of wrestlers but he is certainly one of the most dedicated. I have seen him at a few indy shows and he puts on pretty decent matches, he even occasionally does flying clotheslines of the top rope which from the way he lands looks like they hurt him (a lot). Since WWE let him go, he seems to be trying more and more dangerous spots to try and get some credibility yet he still gets such negative feed back online. He tries. |
| 8 | 03.08.2015 | KingKendrick | 1.0 | |
| 9 | 22.06.2015 | PWC | 2.0 | Shortly after being crowned the winner of the 2011 Tough Enough competition, Stone Cold Steve Austin made a mockery out of him with giving him the Stunner on his Raw debut after Leavine was caught with drug issues. Since Austin gave him the Stunner, he was never seen again and likely won't be any time soon. |
| 10 | 15.05.2015 | zackwoowoowooryder | 1.0 | Hab ihn oft genug bei der FCW gesehen und ich muss sagen was zur Hölle treibt der Typ im Ring, denn mit Wrestling hat es nichts zutun. Untalentiert vom Schweitel bis zur Sohle. |
| 11 | 28.11.2014 | Y2J316 | 3.0 | Hab ihn bei Tough Enough gesehen und da war er gar nicht so schlecht, jedoch hat die WWE ihn nicht gerade groß raus gebracht, also konnten wir nix sehen. Hätte gern gesehen wo es mit ihm hingegangen wäre. |
| 12 | 01.09.2012 | Witchfinder | 3.0 | |
| 13 | 03.05.2012 | HHH Pedigree | 0.0 | OMG. Leavine is horrible. He spent months in FCW, also trained with Steve Austin, but when he returned to FCW, he still being horrible. |
| 14 | 05.01.2012 | TAWPTierJustin | 2.0 | I liked Andy Leavine during Tough Enough and I wanted him to win the competition because he was probably the most dedicated contestant on the show besides Martin who unfortunately got injured. I like Andy's drive and determination and motivation to be successful in WWE for his family although that may be questionable considering how not too long after he won Tough Enough, he got suspended for 30 days for violating the wellness policy and he just got into the WWE so that's obviously not a very good start for him. Now moving onto Andy's abilities in the ring, from what I've seen, all he can really do well is a big boot to the face. He can do a sidewalk slam pretty decent, but everything else in his arsenal of moves, he needs a ton of work on. He needs to learn how to perfect clotheslines and not botch them. Also Andy, I have a bit of advice for you. You're a tall guy. Don't ever do a dropkick or go off the top rope to hit a flying elbow or anything ever again cause first of all, you're not good at dropkicks by any means, and two, even though your flying elbow looked kind of good, like I said, you're a tall guy and there's a reason they call it the high risk. If you want to have a long career, change the way you work. Also, he wastes too much time getting fired up for the crowd and I really don't like that whatsoever. Plus, he doesn't move too well in the ring either. Bottom line is Andy needs a ton of work before he can potentially be great and have a good spot in WWE. |
| 15 | 02.01.2012 | jchiofal | 0.0 | Hackman is absolutely terrible. He cannot wrestler, he has no charisma, and his passion for wrestling is practically nonexistent. |
| 16 | 08.12.2011 | Excellence of Execution | | Ja, wo isser denn, der Andy? Wo isser denn? Warum hat man Austin Aries heimgeschickt? Damit Platz für Silent Rage bleibt? Fuck this company! |
| 17 | 23.11.2011 | jjchiofalo | 2.0 | Leavine has the wrestling ability of a stuffed mannequin. He is very green, and stiff in the ring. He also has the charisma of a mannequin too (aka zero charisma). |
| 18 | 07.10.2011 | devilsoldier | | Der Gewinner von Tough Enough. Und Austin Aries wird in der Vorrunde heim geschickt..... Schlimm, schlimm, schlimm |
| 19 | 12.09.2011 | Ryklon Stephens | | Bei der Tough Enough Competition gefiel er mir nicht wirklich und in seinem Debut bei FCW sah er auch nicht wirklich gut aus. Für eine Note ist es zu früh. Vielleicht täusche ich mich und aus ihm wird ein Superstar. |
| 20 | 14.06.2011 | Navid | | Er ist noch sehr jung, hat den nötigen Körperbau und sicherlich auch eine Menge Entwicklungspotenzial. Nur sollte man ihn nun noch einige Zeit bei FCW formen da er keinerlei in-Ringindividualität besitzt. Ich werde an späterer Stelle eine Bewertung vornehmen. |
| 21 | 11.06.2011 | Morrison Rules | 7.0 | Ich finde ihn ziemlich gut für seine Größe, hoffentlich wird er nich in der Versenkung verschwinden. Aber sein Silent Rage Gimmick sollte er ablegen. Dafür ist seine Statur nicht imposant genug. |
#