[4.0] "Only going off his WWE run, seems like I'm not missing much outside of it, I remember this guy for his "White Boy Challenge" he did. While unintentionally funny, wasn't good besides that. Boring matches, boring wrestler, boring character, no charisma, etc. Only gets a 4 instead of a 3 because of what I remember him for."
[4.0] "in terms of believability, as far as looks go, i'd put him right up there against anyone. that was one thing that rodney definitely had going for him was that when you looked at him physically with his build, rugged look, tattoos, piercings, and what not, you would immediately believe that he was a pro wrestler. that's also why, in my time of watching him anyway during his WWE stint, that he was put in to the roles that he was put in to. however, his lack of personality caused him to suffer, as well as get outshined by several of the people he was put to work with, because it made it seem like they were doing all of the work, and he was kinda just there for the ride.he suffered from a lot of hand me down gimmicks too that didn't help matters."
[4.0] "He wasn't terrible and worked when paired with Teddy Long and Mark Henry when they had that little stable for a short time. Never went anywhere and was just another body on the roster."
[4.0] "Ever see a guy and think "you don't look like you're going to amount to much" and then. Yup. Not much! Career Highlight: Whi-NOPE! Enhancement talent on Smackdown! Here Comes The Pain. I will say this though; his wife: mega talent and attractive on multiple levels, so you know the man is no dummy. EDIT: Ok, so he's not *that bad* (I first gave him a three) however, he's not *that good* either. 4.25"
[3.0] "Rodney Mack was very dull and boring in the ring and had your typical OVW callup moveset, full of punches, kicks, and restholds, and lacked charisma and mic skills. His gimmick also hurt him, as it was basically playing the race card."
[2.0] "I don't think that he was the absolute greatest in the ring ever. He had a great size to him. But he was bland and generic. He's a nice guy IRL from what I've heard. He just was kind of a humdrum talent."
[4.0] "Basic moves and a cool looking finisher. Probably most remembered for the white boy challenge which was entertaining. Wasnt a good talker but Teddy Long did a good job of covering it. At best hes a solid mid card heel"
"hard worker thats been in the business for a hot minute. reasonably reliable worker sand is known around the southern indie scene for quite some time"
[7.0] "I really believe that this guy could have been a really effective upper-midcard heel. He had the look that promoters like, He's solid in-ring and has a legitimacy that would be great for getting heat. I don't understand why he wasn't pushed further with Teddy Long as his mouthpiece."
[2.0] "Boring look, boring matches, didn't do anything significant during his time in the WWE aside from the "white boy challenge" which more or less put Teddy Long more over than Rodney Mack. Glad the guy got shafted back in 2004. No potential."
[2.0] "Was die WWE nur an dem fand um ihn im MainRoster einzusetzten ist für mich unbegreiflich. Der Typ hat eine Ausstrahlung wie eine Kalkwand, von den Fähigkeiten her unterster Unterdurchschnitt. War wie ich fand ganz annehmbar im Tag Team Bereich und daher keine 0 oder 1 sondern etwas besser."
[8.0] "Also ich fande Rodney Mack war eigentlich ein gutes Gesamtpacket. Die White Boy Challange war amüsant und auch seine Fehden waren fande ich recht gut. Das einzige Problem war nur, dass die WWE ihn nie wirklich "weiterkommen" ließ aus meiner sicht. Hätte ihn gerne auch öfter am Micro gehört und ihn mehr in bedeutenere Matches gesehen."
[3.0] "Pure Langeweille, er hat weder das können noch ist er besonders begabt im Ring. Mich wundert es das er es überhaupt in die WWE rein geschafft hat geschweige denn so lange da war. Er jobbte zu recht bei Heat"
