Brandon Cutler

[7.0] "Excellent comedy geek, who was joyful to watch whenever he was featured in AEW. Not sure if he would have succeeded in any other role."

[6.0] "The clutched pearls over Cutler have turned to dust. The stooge gimmick worked to perfection because he was able to really rile people up. Before that he was a solid if uncharismatic worker and even though he got a job because he was friends with the bosses, he was never pushed to a level on the card he was unworthy of."

[7.0] "This poor guy got his entire reputation destroyed when he switched to that god-awful face mask gimmick in AEW, but he has been slowly inching his way back into his old gimmick. Your mileage on the D&D gimmick may vary, but I love it and always though it fit into AEW pretty seamlessly (the long wizard beard he has now fits the fantasy vibe shockingly well too). Gimmicks aside, Cutler is a solid wrestler with a lot of lucha influence and really solid promos. Overall solid wrestler, and I despise what AEW did to his character."

[2.0] "Man, talk about him in 2025 is widely crazy for me. I don't know what to say about him, honestly. He is quite funny, entertaining and can provide some good segments. Do I want single matches of him? Fuck no."

[2.0] "inadequate wrestler who belongs on the indies and in the VFW halls of Rancho Cucamonga and not on national TV in front of a nationally televised audience. He's friends with the Bucks and that ilk so maybe they see a use in him that I can't seem to see."

[0.0] "The absolute worst professional wrestler of all time hes an awkward dork who couldnt draw money even if you gave him a green crayon and a piece of paper he has no carisma and cant work to save his life he is a back yarder at best and is only in AEW because he is the buckaroos best friend the goofy shit with Cabana must stop they are killing the business and AEW crowds reflect it he needs to go back to wrestling in VFWs in Rancho Cucamonga Brandon Cutler is the absolute worst ever. He has done nothing positive for the business other than have a wife that can make cool gear for the bucks other than that he has no business being a professional wrestler he should have retired before he even started he is change the channel bad the absolute worst wrestler ever no joke"

[1.0] "Pretty dreadful all round. Not the best worker and absolutely zero charisma or star quality to go with it. His best quality seems to be holding a camera and that is incredibly off-putting and small time to see on a primetime national TV show. I've never seen anything from him that was remotely good or interesting. He'd be quickly forgettable on the indies so for him to last so long in a national promotion is absolutely incredulous and is honestly a pretty bad look on his friends that work so hard to keep him around."

[1.0] "Too corny of a gimmick, has not proven himself worth of being at aew, his run in aew dark with peter avalon was great but overall the guy has not improved a bit since then."

[5.0] "Cutler has a role that he does well in as jobber. He is good enough in the ring and on the mic to get over in that role or as a comedy guy but not good enough to warrent a mid card push."

[10.0] "People hate on Cutler, but those people are just jealous that they aren't as slick as this dude. Man, how can you beat that Cucamonga strong style. He always comes out rocking that sprayed cold air, he is not just riding the hype train, he is the fucking conductor. In the ring yeah he dances around and gets dizzy but that's part of the charm, man. You gotta love it. Brandon Cutler rules any day of the week and my boy Mezzo Mike always meyer enormouses for that track suit legend."

[4.0] "Frankly, I'm embrassed for this guy, although he's part of the elite he may as well not be, there's virtually nothing memorable about him as he just walks around with a face mask and has absolutely zero good matches to his name. Edit: I think while he is still fucking useless, he also helps make BTE entertaining as fuck so he gets 4 points up."

[9.0] "Hilarious and charismatically goofy. Brandon Cutler reminds me of a Looney Tunes character that actually has a place in pro wrestling. I love me some Brandon Cutler. Long live The Cutman."

[5.0] "In the ring, he's surprisingly athletic and crisp-- he doesn't do a wide range of moves, but his stuff looks good.His program with Peter Avalon was riveting. Otherwise, he's pretty funny as a comedic goofball, but switching to that character has kind of buried him as a legitimate wrestler."

[6.0] "I'm giving him a +1 just due to his comedic acts during a Match. Just like the guy said below me, you don't always gotta be a Champion to stick out. Cutler always gets a decent reception. And not knocking at the guys Wrestling either, but if I was judging just based on that he'd definitely be a 4 or 5."

[9.0] "Not everyone needs to be the champion. This guy just gets comedy in wrestling and is cast perfectly in his entourage role with the Bucks."

[3.0] "Absolute waste of a roster slot. He and the rest of the Elite's entourage do nothing but bring the rest of the stable, they're already all-star talent in their own right, why do they need stooges. And as far as this guy's in-ring work goes, it's atrocious. Cutler's character was literally just a DnD cosplay, he rolls a dice, then proceeds to lose every match. AEW does not need guys like Cutler when there are other job guys who can at least put on good matches and make the talent look good."

[10.0] "An absolutely essential part of The Elite, and I mean that with full sincerity. A hilarious comedy wrestler who doesn't mind being the butt of the joke, but very athletic; like Orange Cassidy, the role wouldn't work if the guy wasn't good. From BTE to Dark to Dyanamite, the guy is an essential part of AEW, whether the anti-fun police want to admit it or not."

[4.0] "As someone trained by the Bucks, Cutler is predictively a more a character-based "comedy" worker than anything else: he's worked for 16 years yet still is a bog-standard indie style wrestler with no real big matches under his belt. He got the chance early to show his stuff against a host of top talent and didn't really make any mark at all. As expected, he's turned into a low-card comedy jobber that feuded with other low card comedy jobbers in alright but fairly nothing performances. He's found his niche now (it's a pretty small one) that allows him to feud against top talent as he's always going to take the fall. That said, I see him as being a guy that does have a sell-by date as gimmicks like his tend to eventually run their course; he's not too far from doing so. I would say he's fine as enhancement talent but he doesn't really have much to enhance people with."

[7.0] "Some have given him low ratings, when, this just shouldn't be so, he pours his heart into any gimmick given to him by AEW. He also has come a long way, I also suggest checking out some of his earlier stuff in PWG alongside Dustin Cutler as the Cutler Brothers. Is he a jobber? Of course. Is he great at it? IMO, yes."

[5.0] "Is he a good singles worker' no, but he has been involved in some great singles matches. He is also a very good jobber/stooge character, and the cold spray gimmick is legitimately funny to me. AEW has not over-leveraged him, as he is used the way he should be."

[10.0] "Managed to set the mold for guys like Fuego to get over by losing. His D&D gimmick was incredibly dorky but he was so enthusiastic and committed to it that you pretty much had to cheer for him sooner or later. As a stooge, he's practically reinventing the wheel and turning it into a jet engine. The guy manages to steal the show in matches with freaking Kenny Omega. He doesn't need a belt; he's just entertaining as Hell."

[0.0] "I hate this gimmick. It? s supposed to be funny, but it just comes off as awkward and painfully unfunny. I just want him off my screen as soon as possible. I haven? t seen him do any serious stuff, so my rating is just on him in AEW at this moment."

[2.0] "Not very good, friends of the young bucks is only reason he is employed with AEW. Matches are boring and gets upset when veterans of the buisness offers advice."

[4.0] "He has that "nice guy" vibe that just makes me feel sorry for him. He doesn't look completely out of place in the ring, like many of AEW's other jobbers. But at the same time, I have not seen anything remarkable from him."

[6.0] "Going to be a jobber forever but he is above average in ring. His feud with Avalon was entertaining but since then he is just another guy"

[7.0] "Cutler might not rise higher in his career, but if this is his height, it'll still be a fine run. His mic skills are fine, but he excels in the ring, and the long term booking has been a boon. His feud with Avalon on AEW dark has made him a mascot for the youtube show, and his current win streak will hopefully build to a payoff TNT title shot or equivalent. His biggest assest and weakness is that he always feels like a white meat babyface."

[7.0] "Cutler is good in the ring. Not a ton of charisma or mic skills, but he's acceptable in those areas. His storyline in AEW, feuding/tagging with Peter Avalon over who's the company's biggest loser has been a lot of fun, and has made Dark a lot more entertaining to watch. I'm hoping it eventually leads to a single match between the two with Cutler finally going over (and maybe winning the affections of Leva Bates as a result)."

[7.0] "I feel like he has a lot of talent and really good in the ring but his booking is kind of bad right now. The Avalon vs. Cutler "rivalry" in BTE is pretty good but if booked right (in AEW or any other company), I think he can be a star. Until that day though, I think he's only ok."