[3.0] "Got "downgraded" to Evolve right after winning LFG season 1, which honestly makes me feel really bad for her because she was supposed to be in NXT, not Evolve. In my opinion, I don't think she had any good matches and I always saw her as a suplex spammer. If I'm going to be honest, she should've never been in heatwave because she's not at the level of other developmental wrestlers. Her gimmick is horrible too and I wish it were never about her being an Olympic gold medalist. Alas, she could've stayed longer in development imo and got better moves. I feel bad for her for losing her job and as a newbie, she had the potential"
[1.0] "I almost forgot about her. Crazy how she won LFG, came to NXT, cut one of the worst promos of the year, got booed as a BABYFACE on a PLE, and then got demoted to evolve lol. I think her in ring work is meh but that isn't even the primary issue. She's very green personality wise and is in desperate need of improvement on the mic for sure. When you're a Babyface and you get booed on a PLE when you're so new to the brand, then that's an issue. It's not something that the creative team caused either. I have no clue how she was able to win LFG in the first place. She's still new so giving a zero would be a bit harsh but I'm not impressed at all."
[4.0] "She's just 'meh' for me. She's not terrible in the ring, definitely a lot of athleticism, and certainly some potential, but she can be a little sloppy. I struggle with her character though. Very inconsistent. She's trying to play a bubbly, eager, gold medalist hero and a egotistical, bone breaker, heel, but instead of having a complex character, both sides fall flat."
[3.0] "She has room to grow, I think a excursion to Marigold or other joshi company could do wonders for her. The in-ring is adequate, but the persona and gimmick won't connect her with the audiences (Kurt Angle did it but as a heel and well, we are talking about freakin' Kurt Angle). I hope she can do better because there is some raw talent there."
[3.0] "People who began their training at the WWE PC and only there are consistently poor performers. They're all interchangeable as far as look, move set and promos go. Intentional I'm sure but it's not doing them, the fans, or the sport any favors."
[3.0] "There's a reason she was essentially demoted to evolve right after winning LFG. No real charisma, can't cut a good promo, and just thoroughly unimpressive all round. Will amend rating if she begins showing out on NXT."
[3.0] "Thus far she is brand new to the business & has only worked on the WWELFG training show. So take that into consideration when looking at this review. Sorry to say, but I don't see it working for her. Having her gold medal gives her a leg up, but if Gabel Steveson taught us anything, it's that being an Olympic gold medalist can only get you so far. She seems totally lost to me on most every aspect - from the in ring, to the promos, to the basic idea of what pro wrestling is."
[7.0] "Still very green but already she seems to have a bright future ahead. She has good looking offense and seems to understand how to lay out a match and psychology well. Think she is a more natural babyface than a heel. Mic skills are alright but can be worked on."
[6.0] "Out of everyone on the LFG cast, I think she has the most potential. She has the gold medal which can suggest either a Kurt Angle or Gable Stevenson, but what will separate her from the latter I believe is there's some crazy energy hidden in there that screams mega star to me if they can get it out of her. We did see a bit of it in that worked shoot promo she did an episode or two back but as the show's going, they've been throwing out her being a heel, which is exactly what she needs to be to get that presence in the ring. She's decent but as they've said on the show, she has to incorporate more of her wrestling as that's what makes her different from everyone else in the ring."
[8.0] "A lot of potential. She has shown a lot of upside I liked her matches on NXT Level Up I genuinely think in a couple of months she will debut in NXT Main Show and shine she's a very good talent who has unlimited potential and a high ceiling."
[8.0] "With only 1 televised match in, it's definitely too early to judge, but no one can deny that that debut match says everything you need to know about the phenomenal talent that is Tyra Mae. Even without the Olympic gold credentials, her personality, her technique and her focus during the match already demonstrates the potential of a future superstar. I will be watching this career with great interest."