| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 13.01.1956 |  |
Carl Cooper defeats Joe Benincasa Ad Santel Promotions - Event @ Auditorium in Oakland, California, USA |
| 2 | 05.01.1956 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Bill Melby defeats Joe Benincasa [2:0] NWA San Francisco - Event @ Civic Auditorium in Stockton, California, USA |
| 3 | 03.01.1956 | |
San Francisco One Night Tournament First Round: Joe Benincasa defeats Carl Cooper NWA San Francisco - Event @ Winterland Arena in San Francisco, California, USA |
| 4 | 03.01.1956 | |
San Francisco One Night Tournament Quarter Final: Bill Melby defeats Joe Benincasa NWA San Francisco - Event @ Winterland Arena in San Francisco, California, USA |
| 5 | 14.11.1953 | |
Rocky Brown defeats Joe Benincasa (9:27) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA |
| 6 | 11.11.1953 | |
Joe Benincasa defeats Rocky Brown (3:03) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Civic Auditorium in San Jose, California, USA |
| 7 | 11.11.1953 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Roland Meeker defeats Joe Benincasa by DQ [2:1] NWA San Francisco - Event @ Civic Auditorium in San Jose, California, USA |
| 8 | 18.09.1953 | |
Sammy Berg defeats Joe Benincasa Ad Santel Promotions - Event @ Auditorium in Oakland, California, USA |
| 9 | 08.09.1953 | |
Sammy Berg defeats Joe Benincasa (2:36) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA |
| 10 | 28.08.1953 | |
Tommy O'Toole defeats Joe Benincasa Ad Santel Promotions - Event @ Auditorium in Oakland, California, USA |
| 11 | 25.08.1953 | |
Ramon Torres defeats Joe Benincasa (13:08) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA |
| 12 | 24.08.1953 | |
Joe Benincasa vs. Steve Novak - Time Limit Draw (20:00) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Memorial Auditorium in Sacramento, California, USA |
| 13 | 22.08.1953 | |
Lou Newman defeats Joe Benincasa (12:30) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA |
| 14 | 13.06.1953 | |
Ramon Torres defeats Joe Benincasa NWA San Francisco - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA |
| 15 | 16.05.1953 | |
Al Lovelock defeats Joe Benincasa (16:45) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA |
| 16 | 16.03.1953 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Hombre Montana defeats Joe Benincasa [2:0] (27:35) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Municipal Auditorium in Eureka, California, USA |
| 17 | 10.01.1953 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Roy McClarity defeats Joe Benincasa [2:1] (25:08) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA |
| 18 | 03.01.1953 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Joe Benincasa defeats Chick Garibaldi [2:1] NWA San Francisco - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA |
| 19 | 14.11.1952 | |
Ramon Torres defeats Joe Benincasa Ad Santel Promotions - Event @ Auditorium in Oakland, California, USA |
| 20 | 17.10.1952 | |
Kay Bell defeats Joe Benincasa Ad Santel Promotions - Event @ Auditorium in Oakland, California, USA |
| 21 | 31.07.1952 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Joe Benincasa defeats Jimmy Blood [2:1] (41:30) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Civic Auditorium in San Jose, California, USA |
| 22 | 19.07.1952 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Rikidozan defeats Joe Benincasa [2:0] NWA San Francisco - Event @ Uptown Arena in Modesto, California, USA |
| 23 | 12.07.1952 | |
Rikidozan defeats Joe Benincasa (19:13) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA |
| 24 | 24.06.1952 | |
Dennis Clary defeats Joe Benincasa (12:23) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA |
| 25 | 07.06.1952 | |
Lee Kalima defeats Joe Benincasa (13:44) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA |
| 26 | 13.05.1952 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Mario DeSouza defeats Joe Benincasa [2:0] (25:05) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Winterland Arena in San Francisco, California, USA |
| 27 | 10.05.1952 | |
Mario DeSouza defeats Joe Benincasa NWA San Francisco - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA |
| 28 | 01.05.1952 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: The Garibaldi Brothers (Chick Garibaldi & Gino Garibaldi) defeat Bobby Nelson & Joe Benincasa by DQ [2:0] NWA San Francisco - Event @ Fiesta Arena in San Mateo, California, USA |
| 29 | 08.04.1952 | |
Ramon Cernandes defeats Joe Benincasa (19:00) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Winterland Arena in San Francisco, California, USA |
| 30 | 22.03.1952 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Leo Nomellini & Sandor Szabo defeat Joe Benincasa & Juan Humberto [2:0] (29:00) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Uptown Arena in Modesto, California, USA |
| 31 | 01.03.1952 | |
Vic Christy defeats Joe Benincasa NWA San Francisco - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA |
| 32 | 28.02.1952 | |
Hardy Kruskamp vs. Joe Benincasa - Time Limit Draw (30:00) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Fiesta Arena in San Mateo, California, USA |
| 33 | 26.02.1952 | |
Joe Benincasa defeats Gino Vagnone NWA San Francisco - Event @ Winterland Arena in San Francisco, California, USA |
| 34 | 06.02.1952 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Ivan Kameroff defeats Joe Benincasa [2:0] (31:56) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Civic Auditorium in San Jose, California, USA |
| 35 | 31.01.1952 | |
Bobby Nelson defeats Joe Benincasa (19:52) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Fiesta Arena in San Mateo, California, USA |
| 36 | 13.12.1951 |  |
Jimmy Coffield defeats Joe Benincasa (20:45) CSW - Event @ Memorial Hall in Kansas City, Kansas, USA |
| 37 | 11.09.1951 | |
Hombre Montana defeats Joe Benincasa (5:30) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA |
| 38 | 14.07.1951 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Johnny Valentine defeats Joe Benincasa [2:1] NWA San Francisco - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA |
| 39 | 12.07.1951 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Bobby Bruns & Vic Holbrook defeat Hard Boiled Haggerty & Joe Benincasa [2:1] (28:24) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Civic Auditorium in San Jose, California, USA |
| 40 | 05.07.1951 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Ernie Piluso & Vincent Lopez vs. Joe Benincasa & Len Hall - Time Limit Draw [1:1] NWA San Francisco - Event @ Civic Auditorium in Stockton, California, USA |
| 41 | 03.07.1951 | |
Leo Nomellini defeats Joe Benincasa (2:37) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA |
| 42 | 29.06.1951 | |
Lucky Simunovich defeats Joe Benincasa Ad Santel Promotions - Event @ Oakland Auditorium in Oakland, California, USA |
| 43 | 05.05.1951 | |
Johnny Valentine defeats Joe Benincasa NWA San Francisco - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA |
| 44 | 05.03.1951 | |
Jimmy Blood & Joe Benincasa defeat Brother Jonathan & Jim Lankas NWA New Mexico - Event @ Mammoth Garden in Denver, Colorado, USA |
| 45 | 16.01.1951 | |
Red McIntyre defeats Joe Benincasa (16:02) CSW - Event @ Municipal Auditorium in Kansas City, Missouri, USA |
| 46 | 15.01.1951 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: The Dusek Brothers (Emil Dusek & Ernie Dusek) defeat Joe Benincasa & Mike DiBiase [2:1] (61:09) NWA Nebraska - Event @ City Auditorium in Omaha, Nebraska, USA |
| 47 | 08.01.1951 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Ernie Dusek vs. Joe Benincasa - Time Limit Draw [1:1] (45:00) NWA Nebraska - Event @ City Auditorium in Omaha, Nebraska, USA |
| 48 | 02.01.1951 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Mike DiBiase defeats Joe Benincasa [2:0] NWA Nebraska - Event @ Fairgrounds Arena in Lincoln, Nebraska, USA |
| 49 | 02.01.1951 | |
Six Man Battle Royal: Joe Benincasa & Mike DiBiase defeat Danny Plechas and Ernie Dusek and Joe Roberts and Red McIntyre NWA Nebraska - Event @ Fairgrounds Arena in Lincoln, Nebraska, USA |
| 50 | 01.01.1951 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: The Dusek Brothers (Emil Dusek & Ernie Dusek) defeat Joe Benincasa & Mike DiBiase [2:1] (41:32) NWA Nebraska - Event @ City Auditorium in Omaha, Nebraska, USA |
| 51 | 27.12.1950 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Joe Benincasa & Tarzan Kowalski defeat Jack Conley & Joe Dusek [2:1] NWA Iowa - Event @ KRNT Theater in Des Moines, Iowa, USA |
| 52 | 18.12.1950 | |
Red McIntyre defeats Joe Benincasa CSW - Event @ Forum in Wichita, Kansas, USA |
| 53 | 16.12.1950 | |
Joe Benincasa vs. Red McIntyre - Draw CSW - Event @ Auditorium in St. Joseph, Missouri, USA |
| 54 | 14.12.1950 | |
Joe Benincasa defeats Howard Cantonwine (14:20) CSW - Event @ Memorial Hall in Kansas City, Kansas, USA |
| 55 | 11.12.1950 | |
Joe Benincasa defeats Walter Sirois CSW - Event @ Wichita Forum in Wichita, Kansas, USA |
| 56 | 07.12.1950 | |
Joe Benincasa defeats Walter Sirois (12:00) CSW - Event @ Memorial Hall in Kansas City, Kansas, USA |
| 57 | 01.12.1950 | |
Joe Benincasa defeats Ivan Bulba (10:00) CSW - Event @ Auditorium in St. Joseph, Missouri, USA |
| 58 | 29.11.1950 | |
Joe Benincasa defeats Paul Stafford (15:52) CSW - Event @ National Guard Armory in Sedalia, Missouri, USA |
| 59 | 27.11.1950 | |
Joe Benincasa defeats Dick Raines by DQ CSW - Event @ Forum in Wichita, Kansas, USA |
| 60 | 05.09.1950 | |
Leo Garibaldi defeats Joe Benincasa (15:23) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA |
| 61 | 02.09.1950 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Alberto Corral & Roberto Cruz defeat Joe Benincasa & Tom Rice [2:1] (32:31) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA |
| 62 | 23.08.1950 | |
Joe Benincasa defeats Rey Urbano (18:21) Hal Moore Promotions - Event @ Civic Auditorium in San Jose, California, USA |
| 63 | 22.08.1950 | |
Roberto Cruz defeats Joe Benincasa (27:54) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA |
| 64 | 24.03.1950 | |
Bill Liebenburg defeats Joe Benincasa Ad Santel Promotions - Event @ Auditorium in Oakland, California, USA |
| 65 | 25.02.1950 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Charro Azteca defeats Joe Benincasa [2:0] (26:15) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA |
| 66 | 31.01.1950 | |
Larry Moquin defeats Joe Benincasa (4:21) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA |
| 67 | 17.01.1950 | |
Billy Hanson defeats Joe Benincasa (20:31) NWA San Francisco - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA |
| 68 | 15.11.1949 |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Bobby Becker defeats Joe Benincasa [2:0] San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA | |
| 69 | 10.11.1949 |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: The Mystery Man defeats Joe Benincasa [2:0] (28:00) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Civic Auditorium in Stockton, California, USA | |
| 70 | 09.09.1949 |
Joe Benincasa vs. Len Hall - Time Limit Draw (30:00) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Civic Auditorium in Santa Cruz, California, USA | |
| 71 | 21.07.1949 |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Dean Detton & Polo Cordova defeat Joe Benincasa & Juan Humberto [2:1] San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Civic Auditorium in Stockton, California, USA | |
| 72 | 12.05.1949 |
Fred Wright vs. Joe Benincasa - Draw San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Civic Auditorium in Stockton, California, USA | |
| 73 | 19.04.1949 |
Ted Cox defeats Joe Benincasa (7:30) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA | |
| 74 | 31.03.1949 |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Joe Benincasa & Lee Henning defeat Gino Garibaldi & Juan Hernandez [2:1] (28:00) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Civic Auditorium in Stockton, California, USA | |
| 75 | 24.03.1949 |
Two On One Handicap Sixty Minute Challenge: Joe Benincasa & Lee Henning defeat Gino Garibaldi (60:00) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Civic Auditorium in Stockton, California, USA | |
| 76 | 10.03.1949 |
Joe Benincasa defeats Tommy O'Toole (13:00) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Civic Auditorium in Stockton, California, USA | |
| 77 | 22.02.1949 |
Juan Hernandez defeats Joe Benincasa (14:25) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA | |
| 78 | 31.01.1949 |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Gino Garibaldi defeats Joe Benincasa [2:0] San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Memorial Auditorium in Sacramento, California, USA | |
| 79 | 18.01.1949 |
Pete Peterson defeats Joe Benincasa (8:57) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA | |
| 80 | 15.01.1949 |
Vic Christy defeats Joe Benincasa (24:30) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA | |
| 81 | 08.01.1949 |
Joe Benincasa vs. Miguel Torres - Time Limit Draw (30:00) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA | |
| 82 | 06.01.1949 |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Tommy O'Toole defeats Joe Benincasa [2:1] San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Civic Auditorium in Stockton, California, USA | |
| 83 | 01.01.1949 |
Joe Benincasa vs. Myron Cox - Time Limit Draw (30:00) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA | |
| 84 | 30.12.1948 |
Pat Fraley & The Red Phantom defeat Joe Benincasa & Slim Zimbleman San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Civic Auditorium in Stockton, California, USA | |
| 85 | 23.12.1948 |
Joe Benincasa vs. Tommy O'Toole - Time Limit Draw (25:00) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Civic Auditorium in Stockton, California, USA | |
| 86 | 11.12.1948 |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Joe Benincasa defeats Slim Zimbleman by DQ [2:1] San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Uptown Arena in Modesto, California, USA | |
| 87 | 04.12.1948 |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Joe Benincasa defeats Howard Stockdale by DQ [2:0] (32:00) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Uptown Arena in Modesto, California, USA | |
| 88 | 07.09.1948 |
Felix Miquet defeats Joe Benincasa (1:49) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA | |
| 89 | 24.07.1948 |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Dean Detton & Miguel Torres defeat Joe Benincasa & Ted Cox [2:1] (14:56) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA | |
| 90 | 17.07.1948 |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Joe Benincasa & Ted Cox defeat Bobby Bruns & Vic Christy [2:1] (23:31) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA | |
| 91 | 06.07.1948 |
Pacific Coast Heavyweight Title #1 Contendership One Night Tournament First Round: Dean Detton defeats Joe Benincasa (2:09) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA | |
| 92 | 17.06.1948 |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Gorgeous George defeats Joe Benincasa [2:0] (28:26) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Civic Auditorium in Stockton, California, USA | |
| 93 | 20.04.1948 |
Flash Gordon defeats Joe Benincasa (7:56) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA | |
| 94 | 21.02.1948 |
Howard Cantonwine defeats Joe Benincasa (16:43) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA | |
| 95 | 31.01.1948 |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Billy Hanson & Flash Gordon defeat Angelo Cistoldi & Joe Benincasa [1:0] (45:00) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA | |
| 96 | 24.01.1948 |
Joe Benincasa defeats Joe Campbell (16:03) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA | |
| 97 | 10.01.1948 |
Jimmy el Pulpo defeats Joe Benincasa by Count Out San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA | |
| 98 | 06.01.1948 |
Vic Holbrook defeats Joe Benincasa (12:59) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Coliseum Bowl in San Francisco, California, USA | |
| 99 | 03.01.1948 |
Joe Benincasa vs. Myron Cox - Time Limit Draw (30:00) San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Ryan's Auditorium in Fresno, California, USA | |
| 100 | 01.01.1948 |
Flash Gordon defeats Joe Benincasa San Francisco Booking Office - Event @ Civic Auditorium in Stockton, California, USA |
