[8.0] "The full cartwheel persona is a gimmick that might be difficult to take all the way to the top, but, man, is he good at what he does! Superb athleticism, high-flying stunts, and just a fun character all-around."
[5.0] "It's fine for comedy but it's very interesting to see fans who only know him through WWE's acquisition of AAA and for some reason think he's main event material. The opinion I've usually seen is that he's fun for early card matches but he doesn't offer much else. He probably could because he's athletic enough but he he keeps himself limited."
[9.0] "Surprised to see Jack Cartwheel currently rated so low. I think many are going to change their ratings after his work in AAA. His selling ability and energy is absolutely top notch, and his innovative moveset needs a lot more attention. Excited to see the AEW/Ospreay-like spot-fest (used as a compliment) style in WWE and also excited to see him outgrow Evolve. He's at the top of my list for one's to breakout in 2026"
[9.0] "With his last appearance, he truly solidified his position. He proved that he belongs in professional wrestling and has outgrown Evolve and the indie circuit. It was a great showing. I'll admit, his look--particularly the hairstyle--isn't my favorite, but his physical agility is world-class. Given the ratings other performers receive, a strong 8 is well-deserved."
[9.0] "After watching his triple threat with Je'von and Laredo Kid, I have become a fan. He is extremely impressive and has way too much talent for him only to be on Evolve. He should be on NXT, or even put him on the main roster."
[4.0] "When I first saw that name and his high-flying moveset, I thought he was a comedy wrestler parodying numerous flippy wrestlers in the indie scene. He turned out to be a non-comedy wrestler though, and my enjoyment of him plummeted. But, he's still young and early in his career so there is still a lot of room to improve."
[7.0] "Jack is a very solid indie wrestler with a lot of upside. He's pretty good in the ring. To the people who say he just does flips, you haven't really been watching. He puts together a good match from a storytelling perspective. What he's lacking is depth to his character and development. He never seems serious and that leads to a lot of his matches not having any heat."
[3.0] "had great control of his body and he could be a great gymnast and incanalate well in wrestling but for the rest is only good flip flops. his nickname says all. all of the matches i've seen of him are the same, good carthwheel and stop. this collaborate to increase the flip flop indie stereotypes"
"It's true, he looks like a parody of a 2000's indie wrestler. In the 2000's he would be okay, but now he looked completely generic and out of place. He knows how to wrestle, I don't know much about his psychology. I hope he changes his look sooner rather than later."
[6.0] "Interesting guy. He is definitely made for the spot monkey and more of a comedy character than a star. Fun highflyer that the crowd can get behind. Hoping he can develop into a bigger star type with more of a well-rounded arsenal."
[2.0] "This dude kinda reminds me of 2016 Ospreay but way worse and with even less charisma (somehow). Sure he is a good gymnast, I don't doubt it, but doing lots of flips doesn't make an interesting character or an interesting wrestler, even less in 2023 we've already seen a lot of bland flippy guys. It might sound harsh but to me he's a parody of a modern indy wrestler: all flips and absolutely nothing else to it. Hopefully someday he'll get a clue. Maybe he can change and improve under the right company or management, but for now I sigh every time I see him on a card."
[2.0] "In today's wrestling world you can't be surprised by amplitude jumps, gymnastics - thankfully there is no problem with that and clearly won't be - there is a lot of talent around the world. Another thing is to find a niche where you will be interesting as a character. Right now I think that's a big problem (to be honest, I'm already tired of that flippy-dippy stuff, too many of them) and Jack is a good example of that. "I'm doing a cartwheel, wow, do you want to see it? " - he exclaims upon his entrance to the ring. "NO! " - I shout. Look, I realise you're a talented gymnast, but professional wrestling isn't all gymnastics and cartwheels. It's more than that. Something you don't have (yet). Hopefully, in the future, you will."
[5.0] "His flippy moveset is pretty impressive but there's not really any substance beyond those flips. The guy is still pretty early into his career though so he has plenty of time to improve and find a character for himself."
[2.0] "I can't stand this guy. He looks like a complete chump and does a load of cartwheels and flips with little rhyme or reason. Sure, he's athletic and could one day put that all together. With his body shape and appearance, I kind of want to put him into a Jushin Liger style costume. Maybe he'd be better then. But as it is... a bit rubbish."
[7.0] "Jack Cartwheel is incredibly charismatic for how little experience he has in the ring. He's always a joy to watch, regardless of whether or not he repeats spots in every match (which I assure you, he does). He's overall very impressive, and I can't wait to see what he'll accomplish once he adds a few more techniques to his arsenal of high-flying and flexible offense."
[3.0] "Absolutely no charisma. Silly looking dude doing stupid acrobat stuff with stupid cartwheel gimmick. His matches is very annoying, for the first time it's looks interesting, but when he do it again and again, it's sucks. Get out of wrestling and do athletics or whatever. At current point of time he hasn't place in wrestling landscape for me. His "OMG he done cartwheel, wow, it's so cool" gimmick completely not over with me."
[8.0] "This guy is the future of high flying. He's so slick, so fluid, and every time I see him wrestle, I see him do something I've literally never seen before. I would like to see him maybe cut some promos more frequently since being a good wrestler can only get you so far, but for right now, his futures very very bright"