[4.0] "Not a fan by any means, I think a lot of what she does is forced. It's like she pushes herself beyond her means for a pop. Her start was promising without a doubt but in my opinion now it's gone stale."
[6.0] "Used to be very high about Tiffany Stratton, very good athletism, great in ring as well, but seems on the main roster, she turned off or something, she just doesn't do it for me anymore, even though WWE will keep her untop, and she isnt improving"
[6.0] "Tiffany Stratton has had a very promising start to her career, but her recentrun has been disappointing. The athleticism, presence and upside are still obvious, yet her execution has become much less consistent and her in-ring psychology often feels weaker than it did earlier in her career. I also think the babyface presentation suits her far less than the arrogant, larger-than-life heel character that originally made her stand out. There is still plenty of talent there, but right now she feels like someone who has taken a noticeable step backwards."
[4.0] "(2024): At first, I was never a fan of Tiffany Stratton just because I thought her gimmick wouldn't work and she was highly irritable, and it just didn't seem like my top television character to watch, but watching her over the past few weeks she has really grown on me especially with her Elimination Chamber performance. She is a great wrestler and, for sure, an upcoming name for the future generation. A star. She is solid on the mic but has unlimited charisma within her gimmick; she plays it very well. She is very athletic and probably has the best moonsault in WWE currently, in my opinion. I might raise my rating higher in the future which normally I finalise what I put down but this will be an exception. (2026): Fast-forward two years later, boy I was insanely incorrect. She has gotten so much worse, she's regularly botching in matches, she wrestlers like she's back to basics, her promos have weakened. I was looking forward to knocking this up as I don't tend to revaluate my reviews unless necessary but this is a fall from grace. She has won a few titles, trash matches and weak title reigns. She is now a 2x Money in the Bank winner and already self-proclaiming herself as the first women to complete this feat, just shows that she has no actual interest in learning about WWE's history either. Such a shame."
[7.0] "Tiffany was incredible and on the top of the world just one year ago. She was one of the best newer talent to come to NXT and I love how quickly she got the title and didnt need years upon years to get that push. Unfortunately since winning MITB and her feuds with Nia and Charlotte, she went down the drain. Even her US title run was bad, all she did was treat the title as an after thought and tried challenging for the main title. I hope she manages to get back in the main title pic again and it's not done and mid card for her."
[6.0] "I hate having to rate her so low, because I used to be huge on Tiffany, but ever since she returned from injury this year, she has noticeably regressed. I don't think it's entirely on her, and yes she could be doing things better in ring, but I think whoever produces Smackdown matches just has no idea what they're doing. We've seen it with other good wrestlers too. That being said, she absolutely needs to work on move executions and in ring psychology. She used to be so good at this, but now she seems like a shell of her former self. I mean, this woman was pulling out the End of Heartache on a 50 year old Trish Stratus, now she can barely hit a swanton without botching it. Her character has also regressed. She was at her best when she was a heel Barbie like character or the "Daddy's Rich Girl" gimmick. I just don't think she works well as a face. I hope things improve for her because I don't want to dislike Tiffany or see her regress any further."
[4.0] "I had to rate her low, simply because 2026 isn't her year at all. She was originally advertised for wrestlemania only for her to fuck herself up during a swanton bomb on giulia. I noticed that Tiffany has seem disinterested in wrestling, hence why i rate her this low. As long as she improves for the remander of 2026 or in 2027, I can't have faith in her."
[1.0] "(EDITED) I don't get how people like her. She's just horrible. She's a mess and unbearable on the mic, and botchy in the ring. Her feud with Charlotte was just horrible and made me less interested in watching their WM match. She absolutely had no right to go off-script and create tensions on TV. But that's not my point. I think she's repetitive on the mic too. She was actually better in NXT, but she decided to let go of some of her moves which she used in NXT. I would like to also say her character is also boring as hell. And once again, her gimmick back in NXT was better. I was hoping she would improve in the future but I don't see it at all now. Also, I agree with that person below, Kelly Kelly actually can do what she can do in the ring, but way better for sure. I think she should've never been pushed this early or ever turned into a horrible babyface. Giulia, Blake, Candice, and Kiana do much better than her and deserved way more time than her"
[5.0] "She fell off after losing the WWE title to Jade Cargill. I don't know what's going on with her but she peaked in NXT and gradually got worse after her main roster debut. Maybe it's a lack of passion for the game and wrestling just isn't that important to her anymore."
[4.0] "my Stratton rating went from a 7 (she was promising and exciting for a while! ) to a 5 (long bad stretch after a certain point) and now it just keeps dropping and it makes me kind of sad. has just straight up not been good in the ring for at this point almost two years and if anything just somehow keeps regressing. also pretty grueling on the mic. you can only ride off your success from NXT and early main roster for so long before it's clear there just isn't much there and that's kind of where Stratton is right now. it is unfortunately no longer Tiffy Time."
[5.0] "She's had an insane fall off. No idea what happened. I gave her a 10 back in 2024, which was maybe a bit of a stretch, but I was so optimistic about her being a future star. Now she's lost in the shuffle, and really seems to have lost a step in the ring, like she doesn't care anymore, clearly lost a lot of her muscle mass. I seriously don't know what happened, it's like watching a totally different wrestler now"
[0.0] "Extremely overrated. Kelly Kelly could do everything that tiffany does in the ring 20 years ago. She is terrible on the mic, and the racist post that she posted about Jade was really weird, fans only support her because of how she looks. A big charisma vacuum. We expected a lot from her but the harsh truth is that she fooled us all. The fall off was very predictable, wwe universe rallied behind her but she just does not look like she wants to be there. She's not hungry as all. She considers this a job gets the job done and gets out. People who rate her over 5 are truly marks or tribalists and it's a shame what professional wrestling has turned into. In April 2025 everyone turned on Charlotte flair for Tiffany Stratton but even if everyone else will deny the truth, I will say it. Since Tiffany won the women's championship, thats since when it's been dead. If Charlotte flair took the title at wrestlemania, the championship would be in a better condition right now. She was fed Charlotte, Bayley, Trish, Nia, Jade, Candice during her run and still not memorable. You give any other wrestlers this feat, they would take that run and make it legendary. My opinions of Tiffany Stratton may be really harsh but it's the truth pills that most wrestling fans need to wake up. Her Gimmick is not working anymore. It already stopped working in 2025. The only reason fans kept supporting her is because they all hated Charlotte Flair and Nia Jax and Jade Cargill."
[5.0] "Tiffany fell off the wagon and even with a title she can't seem to get herself back up and back on the ride. Her muscle mass completely vanished out of nowhere like she gave up on training and doesn't care anymore about wrestling. To me it doesn't make any sense at all because she used to be ambitious and driven. Where did all of that go?"
[5.0] "Yeah, hum... She fell off, terribly. I don't even know how that's possible, but it is actually crazy that none of her matches since early 2025 have been good. Genuinely not a single good match. She had a great NXT run though. Also, her mic work isn't awesome and she has good moves with a good arsenal but nothing crazy."
[8.0] "She was fantastic in NXT, one of the top women's performers they ever had in the ring and on the mic, and so good that based on her work there I'd be tempted to give her a 10, but unfortunately she has regressed somewhat in the ring since her main roster callup. Whether that's because of personal issues, distractions outside of wrestling, injuries, who knows. I'm still giving her an 8 based on how good she's been and how much potential she has if she can get back on track, and she's still very young too at only 27, so I definitely think we shouldn't give up on her yet. That's a long way off, let's see where she is in a couple of years."
[10.0] "One of the best athletes in the Women's division I've seen in a long time. I really enjoy Tiffany matches and I hope WWE keeps pushing her and putting her in top storylines for years to come. It's now and forever will be TIFFY TIME!"
[7.0] "Used to be an 8 or even a 9 in just the past year or so. She seems to be a little more unsure of herself in the ring at times, and her character doesn't really seem gelled down properly as I honestly, can't tell if she's trying to be a babyface or a heel -- in her more recent matches. I blame that partly on the fact that the Smackdown Women's division in 2026 is pretty weak with no real big names worth noting about, or if not, her opponents are clearly past their prime. Her matches are fine for the most part but, nothing too crazy to go out of your way with watching. Her 3-way match in NXT from a few years ago with Indi Hartwell was a reminder of why, some matches don't need to be 10-minute-long affairs -- at all. Pity 7 for my score but, I can't help but feel that maybe some kind of change to her snotty character, would do wonders or come up with some kind of new finishing move from her would be nice."
[10.0] "Tiffany Stratton has everything you'd want in a professional wrestler. The looks, charisma - on point. Her wrestling skills are those expected of a world championship calliber wrestler. She is really a great in ring talent. She's currently US Champion and I believe she will do great with it. Many more world championship reigns are coming the way of this spectacular wrestler."
[0.0] "Tiffany was one of the best heels in NXT and did pretty well on the main roster for a bit too. Then she fell victim to the generic babyface turn that WWE does for many. Her in ring work is not as good as it once was and I'm not quite sure why that is. She also seems rather unprofessional as we've seen and doesn't have the best reputation. Her feud with charlotte flair simply proved that she wasn't ready. She got embarrassed by Charlotte since all she knew how to say was that it's Tiffy time and that she never goes away, and her response to that was going off script on live tv in the most disgusting way ever. That doesn't scream main event caliber at all to me. The in ring work has declined and she also seems to have stopped using a lot of the moves that she used in NXT. She's someone who has the potential to be good but is still very green in quite a few aspects. I can't recall the last time I saw a match of hers where she didn't botch."
[0.0] "What once was a promising name in the WWE, seemingly has lost her footing. She botches a move every other match, looks like she doesn't even want to be in the ring (which based on some of her views regarding the industry of professional wrestling, seems accurate). Her promos are amongst the worst in the company, and as a character she's completely lost. She's not a great babyface, wish the WWE would see this and try bringing her back to her old "buff barbie" gimmick which actually was entertaining and believable. Nowadays, she only says "tiffy time" and doesn't wrestle good enough for me to justify giving her any points, currently."
[3.0] "I am honestly not a fan of Tiffany Stratton, face or heel. She is certainly better as a heel, but she's still not good. Her promos give off a cringe vibe and it feels she'll say anything for a cheap pop (example includes her TNA jab at Naomi during the build to EC 2024). It also feels like she doesn't care about wrestling anymore and that she's only continuing to wrestle in order to have an easy road to Hollywood. I can bet that Tiffany Stratton will be gone by 2030."
[8.0] "Definitely a female wrestler that cares about wrestling. It's clear she puts the effort into what she does, especially in her matches and promos. Definitely not someone who goes through the motions every night (as for right now, but who knows in the future)."
[8.0] "The reason why Tiffany Stratton is higher on here is because, while good, she has done enough to get by, but she's had some lackluster title defenses as Women's Champion. On NXT, she killed it, and was arguably one of the best heels on that show. I wasn't too upset with her being a Babyface, except they should've went all in with it. Nevertheless, I think she's still young enough to find some traction in WWE."
[6.0] "I liked her quite a bit in NXT but I think she's a much better heel than a face and suffered on the main roster because of that. It feels like they put the title on her and then stripped away anything that made her unique and interesting."
[6.0] "I feel really sorry for Tiffany because I think the crowd forced her to have to be ready so much earlier in her career than she needed to be - down in NXT she was brilliant, but since coming up to the main roster it seems she's lost a lot of the spark that made her a great performer in NXT, turning her babyface was natural but even her heel work on the main roster just felt really forced too. I understand the company is pushing the catchphrase "it's Tiffy Time" but the way it's written into promos or even delivered just feels really inorganic, which isn't really Tiffany's fault, but I do think it's had a detrimental effect on her wrestling ability, especially with her booking since wrestlemania, maybe she's been cut off by management for the Charlotte flair comment but it just seems like everything she's doing now just reads really false, which is unfair to Tiffany. Another year in NXT honing her craft would've made her, rightly, unstoppable!"
[6.0] "People need to realize Tiffany is just 25 years old and she arrived to the Performance Center only August 30th 2021. For less than 3 years of training, less than 100 matches under her belt including the ones meticulously crafted and rehearsed she is unbelievably good. She already has the charisma, a defined gimmick, knows how to use her talents well and already can pull of a fantastic match with a great worker. Can you imagine how good she will be in three years? For my money she's already one of the best in the world in-ring (top 50 for sure), and there is SO much more in her future."
[3.0] "i cannot and dont think i will ever buy into the idea of tiffany stratton, shes a very good athelete no doubt, but shes not a good wrestler, all i see in her is a catchphrase ( which she just cant stop spamming during matches), an entrance and a decent moonsault, outside of that theres nothing to her besides a pretty face, and her current title run is one of if not the worst title run in modern wwe"
[9.0] "I think many people in the reviews don't understand what wrestling is all about. Stratton commands your attention when she's on screen. Her moveset is very fun and works perfectly with the wrestling fan of today. In just a few years into the business, Stratton has transformed from a promising prospect into a true main-event-caliber performer. And as of today, she's only 26 years old. Most of the main event talents of today on the womens side weren't even close to the level she is at, at the similar age. Flair and Belair hadn't even had a match yet at the same age. Stratton has areas to improve for sure, but she is well on her way to a long career with many accolades."
[9.0] "Perhaps the biggest compliment you can give Tiffany is that she feels inevitable. She has the "it factor" that separates good wrestlers from true superstars. Every match and segment she's in raises her profile, and she continues to improve at a pace that suggests we're only seeing the beginning of her rise. Are there wrestlers who have cleaner performances? Sure. Very few of them are as "must see" as Tiffany."
[9.0] "Tiffany's rating being lower than even a 8 is more a symbol of how anti everything life has became than her actual talents and wrestling performances. Her talents alone makes her one of the top 5 most promising upcoming wrestlers, her ability to perform inring against stars the size of Becky Lynch and Charlotte in what was both bangers, and her personality being one that you cant miss anytime when she is on tv makes her arguably the most promising upcoming womans wrestler as a whole. Added to that she has a NXT Womans World title reign and is the current WWE Womans World title and is closing in on 300 days in that reign. Maybe on the surface that doesnt seem like all that much but then you have to consider she has only been doing this FOR 4 YEARS! But ofcourse because of her looks she triggers just about every single X addict and therefor is victim of this sudden mass negative ratings push due to the fact that WWE has been lacking with booking her ? The few chances she had she showed without a doubt she is not the issue, even managing to outshine Charlotte Flair and get a Cody esque reaction leading up to their Wrestlemania match, with Flair getting booed out of buildings and closing up one of the shortest builds to a important Mania match off arguably outshining a 10+ year veteran in a great match. Everything she gets involved with turns gold. HHH and his lazy booking for the last 2 years not giving her anything to work with does not fall on her. Stop pushing this anti everything agendas and start rating wrestlers based on actual performances. Maybe then we wont be in a world where Becky and Tiffany is getting review bombed while Karrion Kross gets pushed despite being the most generic and boring wrestler in recent memory, maybe since the era where Big Show and The Great Khali shined. She is great and will be great for the coming 15 years. Due to her talents and looks she will probably never get her flowers but haters are gonna hate I guess. 9/10."
[7.0] "I have to lower my rating for her, just because her persona is becoming very bland with the "Tiffy Time" moniker. With that said I can't agree with the critics about her in-ring skills, because how are you supposed to evolve if the only matches you get are against Nia Jax and Jade Cargill ? The problem with her reign is a probem with the whole Smackdown roster: the booking just sucks. The people I think she would have great matches have almost 0 credibility (Piper Niven, Alba Fyre, Candice Lerae) and the roster lost a lot with Bianca Belair injury and Naomi departing to Raw. Even if Giulia, Bliss and Charlotte could wrestle her, the matches could harm the respective championshiops that they carry."
[5.0] "Oh dear oh dear oh dear. At the beginning of this year, I'm ashamed to say I rated Tiffany Stratton an 8/10. Eight months down the line and I can see that I was terribly mistaken. I'm not saying the natural talent isn't there. Clearly it still is but everything else has been a total mess. Promos have been god awful and not believable in the slightest. Matches have been mediocre at best due to the fact she still struggles with the in-ring psychology side of things. Making her a babyface and putting a world title on her so soon has been incredibly detrimental to her career. Hope she can turn things around."
[8.0] "She is really good in ring, I love her she is a real barbie but with more muscle. I dont get it why people hate her ? Yeah she been champion for a long time but she fight for the title frequently and she deserve it."
[7.0] "Originally I'd given Stratton a 10, but after the past year I feel like I have to lower it. Stratton's time in NXT was the highlight of her career so far, which is unfortunate considering she's Women's champ and has been undefeated so far this year. I feel Stratton could be one of the top women's wrestlers of all time, but she's still growing as a competitor. Her in-ring work hasn't been up to par this year. Yes she's had good matches, but I still feel like we're missing out on her full potential. It's also unfortunate that she's been stuck in a never-ending cycle of facing Nia Jax and now Jade Cargill who are both not the best wrestlers in their own rights which in turn causes Stratton's in-ring credibility to take a hit."
[4.0] "Overrated wrestler with cliche blonde barbie gimmick which I don't see her hype at all. Her mic and act are very bad. It took a lot for me to enjoy her in ring work unless she is pairing with consistent and etilic wrestlers like Becky, Bayley, Bianca or Lyra. She has been pushed too soon due to the pop she got from main roster arrival. Hopefully she lost her title soon, her women's championship reign is dreadful."
[4.0] "Has clearly been pushed too fast, too early. She's not a natural babyface at all, she cuts promos that are all exactly the same tiktok-narration cadence that makes me mute my phone/TV whenever she is on a promo segment. People talk about how WWE are pushing Jade Cargill like an unstoppable force of nature, when Stratton hasn't lost a single match this year. If anyone deserves the 'Hogan' moniker in present times, it's her. And as a wrestler, she's fine, and the commentary always try to oversell how devastating her moonsault is. But the main problem I think is WWE's booking of her. As I mentioned, she's not a babyface, she's booked to win every match, she barely defends the title on SD, and she keeps getting into feuds with Nia Jax every few months, because the Women's Championship title picture is made up of literally 3 wrestlers, all of which aren't very good at actual matches (Stratton, Jax, Cargill)."
[2.0] "She can't cut a promo and her great wrestling is one moonsault. The rest was created by cosmetic surgeons. I'm shocked at how much work she has had done at such a young age. She has the appearance of a person who is 45-55 years of age trying to look younger. It's really unfortunate. I've seen enough of her matches to recognize a pattern and that pattern isn't good, or even plaid, it's bad. I've seen her in a decent match a couple of times which is why I'm not rating her a zero. I heard so much about how great she was in NXT and right away I knew EXACTLY why some fans anointed her the greatest female wrestler in the history of the known universe. She makes pants tighten. How nice for them but it sadly doesn't make someone a prodigy."
[5.0] "Tiffany Stratton is really a good wrestler but her title reign is awful tho, i am preety sure that she is better than that. By now i will give a 5 out of 10 but i hope she improve durante the time as champion."
[7.0] "Tiffany is very good but she's still missing some things. Her character work has fallen off a lot since turning face. She still needs to improve on the little things in ring as well, her matches are usually juts a spot after a spot with no breathing time."
[6.0] "Tiffany Stratton is one of WWE's current rising stars. Staring off in NXT, She was saddled with a "Daddy's Girl" gimmick but that didn't last too long and it became about Tiffy Time! She slowly became a fan favorite in NXT because of her heel attitude which oozed charisma and her consistent in-ring work. She was so impressive that she was eventually called up to the main roster and things were looking good, Hell! She won the Women's Title and became the leader of the SmackDown brand and then the cracks started to show. Her storylines have been mind-numbing because she's being booked as a face even though Stratton is a natural heel and it feels well...unnatural. She lacks charisma as a babyface to the point where it's almost like a vaccum. They basically took away 3/4 of what made her gimmick interesting when she turned face and she now feels unfinished."
[6.0] "Great athlete, ok in ring worker who can be very good if things are laid out right but isn't very good when she has to go too far outside of what's been planned. Not good at all on the mic when she has to do more than say her catchphrase"
[10.0] "Tiffany is an absolute standout in WWE right now. From the moment she walks out, she just has that star quality--confident, flashy, and totally magnetic. Whether she's playing the heel like she was in NXT or the face she has of late, you can't take your eyes off her. In the ring, she's seriously impressive. Her athleticism is next level, and she makes big moves look easy--especially her signature moonsault, which is arguably the best in WWE. She's strong, fast, and getting better every single match. You can tell she puts in the work. She's also got a big personality that fits WWE perfectly. Her promos are fun, sassy, and full of attitude. As she keeps refining her promos -- she's a little loud on the mic, and that is difficult if you have a high pitch voice, like she does -- She'll truly become the face of the women's division as she checks every other box."
[5.0] "decent wrestler probably gotten worse since nxt, terrible baby face worse in the company in my opinion. pushed way too soon which in no fault of her own but yea she should've had a baby face run in nxt. (which all call ups usually has both which is odd why she didn't considering everyone else called up in her class had more experience then she does.)"
[4.0] "One of the most overrated wrestlers I have seen in my life, she is a good athlete to do gymnastics but she is far from being an excellent wrestler as they want us to believe, apart from making spots in stipulations matches, she has no great match, it is very average in the ring, the match against Charlotte confirmed my opinion, some consider her one of the best wrestlers of her generation when she is not even top 10 in WWE, so in the world we can EASILY place 100 more talented and better wrestlers in the ring"
[7.0] "Pushed way too early storytelling still needs some work & her current title reign has proven that she is not ready for the spotlight, mic skills also could use some work but people tend to overlook it cz she can do cool flips whoop de doo she's still young & there's plenty of room for improvement"
[6.0] "A good wrestler who is still young and has lots of potential. Tiffany is very athletic, can be stiff at times, and works well as a heel. However, she has many areas that she can improve in. In my opinion, her matches since being moved to SmackDown have been hit or miss, she isn't a good talker, and has no idea what her character should be like as a face. I think Tiffany will get better, but as for right now, she's closer to being an average wrestler than an elite wrestler."
[6.0] "Tiffany Stratton is a rising star in WWE, known for her athleticism, strong character work, and rapidly improving in-ring ability. Debuting in NXT with a "spoiled rich girl" gimmick, she leaned into the role with surprising confidence and charisma for someone so new to the business. While early on her presentation felt a bit one-dimensional, Tiffany quickly proved she was more than just a character. Her athletic background translated well to the ring, allowing her to perform visually impressive moves with a level of grace and precision that's still developing but already impressive. Her reign as Women's Champion shows real promise. She carries herself like a star and began putting together more complete matches, holding her own against more seasoned talent. Tiffany still has a lot of room to grow when it comes to match psychology and consistency, but the potential is clear. With WWE clearly behind her push and her continued improvement, she will be a major player in the women's division. Right now, she's not fully polished, but she has all the tools to become a standout if she continues on her current trajectory. Personally, I think it was a little soon to give her the title as opposed to the intercontinental or US championships, but she's definitely getting there and way over with the fans"
37x
73x
126x
81x
52x
11x
9x
3x
2x
1x
3x
