Jade Cargill

[7.0] "Very overhated - easily doing the best work of her career right now and it's only going to be getting better with King of the Ring and a potential world title reign coming up. her fued with naomi was excellent and like i said, it's only going to get better"

[0.0] "I would love to like Jade Cargill because she's got THE look. She looks like an unbelievable athlete and her gear and style just oozes drip, the sparkle coming off her is enough to blind me. And then the bell rings and her inability to be athletic or competitive or interesting or entertaining makes me want to blind me. Her attitude is mindbogglingly obnoxious considering the lack of actual skill. I mean congrats, I guess she or whoever crafted her worked me, good on you, this is the perfect heel right here. Wait, you expect me to relate with her nastyass and support her? You're joking, right? I hate her body of work and I hate her commitment to not even trying to improve. Every time they announce it's her match it makes me dread the next 10min, cause you know she's going to embarrass herself and anyone in there with her. She makes the whole thing and everyone involved look bad. The wrestling world would be better off without her. The day she quits can't come faster for me."

[4.0] "She had cool presence and great potential, but her current forced push is just not making me accept her at all, as it is way beyond her overall merits especially in terms of in ring work which need others to do carryjob for her. She will be Ronda Rousey 2.0 but worse if they shoved her down too much and too wrong."

[0.0] "I don't know, she still doesn't give me anything. She wasn't that good in AEW and she still isn't good in WWE. Jade just makes me cringe everytime she wrestles. She's so uninteresting that she made Bianca boring for me. Jade is really just one of those wrestlers who tries to give it her best, but fails. Jade just sucks at wrestling and is a prime example of WWE's looks over skill policy, Jade just isn't good at wrestling, I don't get why WWE is pushing her when their's way more talented and skilled wrestlers on the freaking roster."

[2.0] "Bad Promo, nigh near robotic in the ring, Jade Cargill has nothing apart from her look in pro wrestling. To be fair, that has gotten her a lot of success by now. She definitely shouldve had an extensive NXT run. When Mariah may is sent to NXT then why not Jade? The only answer is that WWE want to maximise profits from her before cutting her later when the reactions she got in Saudi become universal. You can only do so much without literally being able to wrestle."

[2.0] "She's a very bad wrestler, like really, unfortunate. She doesn't move well in the ring, she can't do moves for the life of her, botches like a broken machine and her promo skills are mid to bad at best. She's a tremendous athlete, but in order to progress as a wrestler, she needs to wrestle more and an excursion to Marigold would be beneficial."

[3.0] "All looks and no real talent. Think she would also fit better as a heel. Doesn't really get top star crowd reactions either."

[4.0] "Jade Cargill ist nicht ganz einfach zu bewerten. Sie hat definitiv das Aussehen und die Ausstrahlung eines großen Stars. Allerdings ist sie noch zu grün im Ring. Ihre aktuelle Verwendung mit Bianca sehe ich als bedeutende Chance für sie, sich noch deutlich zu verbessern. Kann mir gut vorstellen, dass sie eine große Zukunft vor sich hat und Verbesserungen kann man auch schon erkennen. Zwischenzeitlich leichter Punktabzug. Sie wird zwar in präsenten und vielversprechenden Rollen gebooked, kann jedoch wenn überhaupt durch Ihr Auftreten überzeugen. In-Ring und Promo-technisch durchschnittlich bis unterdurchschnittlich."

[4.0] "Jade Cargill undeniably has star power, her presence, look, and physique are truly standout, the kind that turns heads and makes an impression. She's a compelling powerhouse, and I genuinely enjoyed her pairing alongside Bianca Belair. While she's not completely lacking on the mic, the heavy singles push she's receiving feels premature. Her offense can look awkward, she's prone to botches, and she doesn't yet match the technical skills or athleticism of WWE's top-tier women. Unless that gap closes, she'll likely remain a divisive figure in the wrestling world, more potential than performance, for now."

[4.0] "Not a good wrestler, but she flashes some potential. One of the better looks in the business, she has insane star power. Not sure if she'll ever "get it""

[3.0] "At this point Jade will never be great in the ring only just passable. I feel she would've thrived in the Diva era, but in this era where your actual wrestling ability matters she just pales."

[3.0] "Overwhelmingly bad, Jade cares too much about 'looks' and forget about the important thing of them all, the ring skills which I can very well say that nowadays at least she's blanky like a wall, slow like a turtle, talk to much and deliver very little, every time she's booked in a match, she bring the ratings down to minus five. All I can really give is the 3 points rating which can be told about her mic skills"

[2.0] "I just don't see it at all, I don't like her promos, or her matches, none of her moves do anything for me and her selling is nothing to write home about. Maybe if she had compelling offense I could see her as like femme Goldberg, but not with those non-threatening promos and mid, sometimes sloppy matches."

[2.0] "She has star power and looks like a star. It's just that..... she's not good in the ring or on the mic to follow that up and make good work of it. I thought Jade would develop in WWE but somehow her ring skills seem to have gotten worse. I don't know really, there's potential, but she doesn't seem to want to get better"

[6.0] "Jade is growing on me. I am glad she is working for her spot and not being handed everything. She's definitely improving in the ring. I like her character. I want to see her and Bianca feud now."

[3.0] "She has gotten worse after her are run she is not meant to wrestle in my opinion insane physique thoug."

[3.0] "One of the best looks in wrestling, Jade Cargill is built to be a wrestler. Unfortunately, that stops at looks, as after years in the ring there's no clear sign of improvement in Cargill's skill. Her matches aren't unwatchable, but they're basic and she's usually one of, if not the, worst female talent on the roster in terms of in-ring skill, which made her push in AEW frustrating and the screen time in WWE frustrating as well."

[6.0] "Cargill is a pylon. Oh, she's a relatively attractive pylon. I grant you that. If she doesn't smile. Then, she looks like the Grinch who stole Christmas. With muscles. She's very powerfully built. That's impressive. For 2.5 seconds. Unless you've never seen a girl, or you're the average Fed mark. Then, you just bray like a wounded mule (or a horny goat) for the allotted time (And if it's a Cargille match, you just PRAY there's an Army of talent to carry her! ) and then she goes away. I loathed her on AEW. She came on and she ate all the air out of the room and gave nothing back to the locker room or Company. Compare and contrast that with Mercedes Mone. You know, I sh#t all the f over the CEO in NJPW/Stardom for having done the same thing. Since then, Mone's made me eat my words over and over and over. She's paid back every receipt. With interest. Cargil will never, ever in a million years do that. Because she's NOT a wrestler. She's an oiled up body builder with delusions of celebrity. She wants to be Logan Paul. Unlike him, she has zero physical abilities. And not even negative charisma. I've seen marble with more warmth. But the Fed are giving her the push. Vince would have loved her. "Just look at those muscles! " But Vince she can barely do 3 moves... "But just look at her! " Well, I'm glad HHH is no Vince. Because right now there are two spots left in what's loaded to be one of the greatest women's matches in history. Money In the Bank. And the last f'g person on Earth I want to see, is this plank. Oh, and I'm still giving her a higher than average rating. Because minus all that I said, she is a remarkable specimen. That alone is worth seeing. It's just too bad it's not worth watching. And that there are so many, many, many other girls that are."

[8.0] "An absolute powerhouse with star presence. Jade Cargill burst onto the scene in AEW like a Marvel superhero and quickly proved to be a dominant force. Her presentation, confidence, and undefeated streak made her feel like a big deal. As TBS Champion, she brought legitimacy to the title with a long reign that showcased her as a true attraction. Now with WWE, the potential is sky high if she's booked right and continues growing. She's not polished yet, but she's money. The Next Big Thing"

"As of this writing, we are nearly two years into the Jade Cargill project at WWE. I must admit that at this point, I'm a bit flummoxed as to why they were so quick to sign her after departing AEW, where she was booked as an unstoppable monster babyface, a la Goldberg, who only lost once (incidentally, that loss was her last match for the company). Even Goldberg had to work for a good year before they gave him the belt. Alas, Cargill expressed frustration and chagrin towards the professional wrestling world in her short hiatus - a sense of relief at not being in the "wrestling bubble." Quite ballsy to publicly have this attitude for a shoot, after you've been gifted a career by a money mark and a bunch of talented women who put you over. That kinda soured me on her ever since, and again, some two years later, it's all I can think about when see her delivering the most lifeless generic promos you've ever seen on television. There was a backstage segment she ran with Liv Morgan recently that was maybe the best thing she's ever done - perhaps because it seemed like a real discussion and wasn't in front of the audience. As soon as she comes out with a live mic in her hand, though - it's all downhill. It's kind of the same problem they have with Logan Paul. He obviously can talk - he did it for a living since he was like 15. But when it's time to be a wrestler, something switches. Like he's pretending to be a wrestler as a bit. Jade suffers the same fatal flaw. And sure, they can do all these moves, but they don't know why they're doing them and they don't seem to understand how important the "why" is. To them, wrestling is purely something they are doing because they can. I'm sorry, but that's not good enough. You can have the machine forcing you down our throats week after week. I'll never buy it until I see it in your heart. Until I see that you LIVE for this. That's what separates the "good" or merely "okay" from the Great."

[5.0] "Obviously, a great look but much to be desired in the ring. After seeing her since her return, I do have belief that she can turn it around because she provided us with a pretty solid performance at Mania versus Naomi. We'll just have to see how good she can get throughout 2025."

"The day jade cargill wins one of the women's main titles is the day that brand dies, whether it's raw or smackdown, she reminds me so much of the Goldberg type and not in a good way, only good for power moves on woman smaller than herself and that's about it, every match is slow and you can see that the other wrestler always has to lead the way and sometimes blatantly tell her what to do next. She's the modern definition of just "aura" farming, the women's division in the wwe is shaping up to be the greatest in the world right now with so many talented woman and some of the best wrestlers in the planet and Jade cargill should not be involved in any of it"

[0.0] "genuinely a dreadful wrestler. has a fantastic look but it stops there. for all the muscles that she has her strength does not show in the ring at all. for all that they talk about her Division 1 basketball background, she does not appear coordinated in the ring at all. there is not a single thing that she does well, her promos are inauthentic and tacky, she wants to be a movie star but can not cut a convincing promo. i think the wrestling industry just needs to end the Jade Cargill experience. She has failed at both major companies."

[0.0] "Ich hab noch nie eine so schlechte Bewertung gegeben, aber ich glaube bei ihr ist es gerechtfertigt. Ich beurteile dabei ausschließlich ihre wrestlerischen Fähigkeiten, alles Äußere fließt nicht mit ein. Gutes aussehen macht nämlich noch lange keine wrestlerin. Ihre in ring Fähigkeiten lassen immernoch stark zu wünschen übrig, teilweise sieht es aus wie jemand, der gerade sein 2. Oder 3. Match worked. Sie muss oft überlegen welcher Spot gleich dran ist, dadurch ist ihr Ablauf viel zu langsam und unkoordiniert. Sellen kann sie nicht und sie botched gerne. Ich glaub oft, dass ihr Aufstieg bei aew zu schnell ging. Eigentlich hätte sie sich durch die indys kämpfen müssen, so wie jeder andere auch, damit sie erstmal das Handwerk lernt. So wie mans die letzten Jahre versucht hat, wirds jedenfalls nichts. Auch das Performance Center hat ihr da nicht geholfen. Irgendwann kommt man dann auch mal an den Punkt, wo man vielleicht darüber nachdenken sollte, ob man für so eine Karriere geeignet ist."

[0.0] "The straight up definition of an "Only good because I have a great look superstars". I wasn't too familiar with Jade Cargill until WWE announced that they signed her. When I heard that they signed her since they made her such a big deal, I went to watch her AEW matches and they were all drizzling shits. I hoped that she might improve when she joined WWE but she has been horrible. Mad respect to Bianca for carrying her and make her look like an actual star because without her Jade would be absolutely terrible"

[2.0] "Jade Cargill is a shining example of what's wrong with the "aura" mentality. She's shit in the ring for the most part, her mic work is standad at best, and she does the absolute bare minimum amount of character work to qualify for a personality. She's cocky...that's about all I can tell you in regards to personality traits. But hey, she has a good look to her. That totally justifies repeatedly pushing her in favor of far more talented women, and repeatedly putting her in positions that she's just not ready in. (TK, why would you give a complete rookie the longest winning streak and championship reign in the whole company? Hunter, why would you put her in the main roster as soon as you get her when you flat out say you don't believe her training was complete? ) I'll admit, she has some highlights, but the big reason why she's so low is for what she represents. You don't need to actually do a good job so long as you have a strong presence. Cargill is effectively being made to run before she learns to crawl, and seeing as how, even after 4 years, there's barely been any improvement from her, I don't see the problem going away anytime soon."

[4.0] "Bookers have to be very careful with "attraction wrestlers", and Jade Cargill is very much one of those. Cargill emerged in AEW where she impressed with her bursts of power and short promos, with the likes of Mark Sterling and Stokely Hathaway largely speaking for her. It was however telling that she was never booked against the biggest female stars in AEW like Toni Storm, Hikaru Shida and Britt Baker, but she did business the right way by losing twice to Kris Statlander before she left. Cargill's star power has only increased since moving to WWE, but I get the sense they haven't booked her right, keeping her in the ring for too long and exposing her limitations as a worker. They've even beaten her on TV which isn't particularly great. I'm not saying she's a bad wrestler, as she does a lot of things really well and has got herself over in the two biggest wrestling promotions in the world. She just needs to apply herself a bit more with the fundamentals, and rely a bit less on her opponents carrying her. I hope for her sake that happens, as the potential is very much there."

[10.0] "her debut in WWE was needed I didn't know her before but when I met her I liked her I would like to see her awesome fight with charlotte flair because she will definitely be like that please WWE we want it 10/10 her fights are ok there is no problem unfortunately her best fight I rated was a fight where she didn't appear alone and it was a rating of 7 but her character is generally in command and I greet Victoria if she is here. Generally speaking, I see something in her that some people lack *****"

[4.0] "I am a big Jade Cargill fan and was excited to see what she was able to do with the WWE machine behind her. But, uh, nothing really of note. I know she is a bit green, but she has undeniable charisma and presence. She is currently off TV for probably a legitimate injury but even before hand she kinda just floated around. I think she would have done well in NXT as a force of nature but ah well."

[8.0] "She is a star. Not since Bianca Belair's debut have I been as confident that we're currently watching a future titan in the industry. She makes everything feel bigger by her presence and has already delivered a couple of astonishing performances, her progression is phenomenal for someone who's not even been doing this for two years."

[0.0] "Aside from her impressive look she offers nothing. Still awful in the ring, can't cut a promo to save her life and overall just not a compelling wrestler. Failing to improve or show any sign of spark over two different companies is quite impressive. Years of having squash matches and showing no consistent performances in them should have been really telling about her ceiling. She looks lost in between moves, moves that she fails to execute properly. She has a complete lack of understanding when it comes to fundamentals and it's never going to get better for her. She can coast on looks and ''aura'' which will be her only upside."

[5.0] "[Updated Rating, original review dated January 2023] Jade is still pretty green from an in-ring standpoint yet her charisma and star potential are undeniable. Her reign as TBS Champion has been nothing but dominant and it's pretty clear to me that AEW have big plans. For now though, she's alright. I'm interested in seeing where she is, say, two or so years from now."

[9.0] "Jade was my favorite wrestler that was homegrown in AEW, and I can't wait for her to fully flourish in WWE. Her WWE Women's Tag Team Championship reigns with Bianca were great because they really did elevate the title. I think once she steps out on her own, people will see how great she can truly be."

[5.0] "The Epitome of "Aura Merchant", she really stinks, she has horrendous ring skills, and her mic skills aren't good too, Bianca deserves another singles push for carrying Jade the whole year, it's a shame they buried Alba and Isla and feed them to Jade just to make her look good"

[7.0] "Rating is too low on here. Yes, she could definitely improve, but she's objectively a good wrestler. Obviously she looks like a megastar, and could still be one in WWE, she's only 32 after all. I think she will have a great 2025."

[2.0] "I think she stinks. Quintessential aura merchant. She's big. She's strong. She's got the aura, the incredible look. And then the bell rang. I believe she's a terrible in ring performer who gets special treatment because she's rather large. She's been overpushed and I will never get it. AEW couldn't trust her to go over 5 minutes with Athena on a pay-per-view, and that's always stuck with me. I just don't think she's good. Her heart's not in it, she's said she's doing it to go to Hollywood, and that just grinds my gears honestly."

[5.0] "I think she has an incredible aura and an incredible stage presence when she makes her entrance, but everything overflows when she enters the ring. I feel that she needs to have more self-confidence and trust that her moves will turn out well, but even so, I feel that she will progress little by little"

[5.0] "I think if Jade was presented properly by WWE she would be much more over. She is totally capable of working the sports entertainment style. It's not like Liv Morgan and Raquel Rodriguez are putting on 20 minute mat wrestling classics every week i.e. Jade is in the same realm of in-ring skill as many of the WWE womens division. Her WWE run has been completely underwhelming but I don't think it's entirely her fault. She could've been booked as a female Brock Lesnar but it felt like WWE wasted both Bianca and Jade in 2024 by teaming them together with no truly interesting storylines or feuds. There just didn't seem to be a solid plan for her following her awesome Rumble appearance."

[4.0] "In AEW, her aura was unmatched. Leader of a stable and in-ring talent was progressing nicely. Then she went to WWE and seemingly hasn't progressed at all. Still doesn't have singles matches and being paired with a bona-fide established main eventer has made her aura fade. Such a shame. I can't understand why her in-ring progression has stalled despite having the performance centre and all of the veterans to learn from. Should have stayed as a big fish in a smaller pond."

[5.0] "Jade Cargill still has a long way to go. Her in-ring maneuvers are getting better, but she's still not the best on mic and presently does her best work with Bianca in the tag team scene. It's been a while, now, and I'm beginning to struggle to see a future where she's an important singles star. One may argue that she's the most improved wrestler this year, but one may also argue that she hasn't improved enough, & is merely surrounded by greatness; and from what I hear about how infrequently she's showing up to the Performance Center, I'm beginning to ponder whether the latter is more objectively accurate. We'll have to wait and see."

[6.0] "While she has a nice presence and great athleticism, Jade is still rough around the edges. Mic needs work, in-ring performance needs work. But for someone in the early stages of their career, she is fine."

[6.0] "A great powerhouse that needs to improve her promos. That's one of the worse promos I've ever seen. She has a good in ring and great feuds though !"

[6.0] "Jade Cargill gets sort of a bad rep because she's not the greatest in-ring technician (and with three years experience, it simply takes more reps to get it right.) But she hasn't earned singles and tag accolades by being a slouch. She's got a great gimmick and when given the freedom, she has some of the best in-ring entrances and gear conceived. Don't hate just because she got moved in front of the line, others should work so hard."

[3.0] "Jade is someone I just dont really care for. She admitted in an interview with ESPN this time last year that she joined WWE to help her chances in breaking into Hollywood and since then Ive been quite iffy about her. That sort of statement really makes me think she just sees wrestling as a stepping stone, a means to an end. She doesnt want to be a wrestler, she wants to be a movie star. There are so many stars in WWE, AEW or any other major promotion who are there because they want to be there and are hungry to reach the top of the wrestling business. In WWE and AEW she has been afforded so many opportunities and has been pushed beyond her abilities and to me it seems a little unfair, as she is worst in the ring and on the mic than the majority of the major players in NXT, despite having been in training since 2019 and needing to have her hand held in tag matches in WWE and having very basic, short singles matches in AEW. The straw that broke the camels back for me was the press conference at Bash at Berlin when she was asked how has life been here since leaving AEW and how has Bianca helped you settle in here? . Jade sighs and says with a passive aggressive tone and fake smile that she is tired of answering questions about AEW, despite the question being about how shes settling into WWE. This whole exchange really rubbed me the wrong way, it just made her seem bitchy and disrespectful. But she has an amazing look, presence and physical charisma, so she will continue to be pushed as a top star in the womens division, despite her lack of in ring skills which you need to be a top star in wrestling. If she still seems green 5 years into a career I dont have a lot of hope she will get much better."

[4.0] "She's sadly just looks even though she has/had access to pretty much the best training facilities in the world that aren't based in Japan or Amarillo. It doesn't help either that everyone knows she wants WWE to function as a springboard to Hollywood."

[3.0] "I originally gave Jade a 7, I previously thought she was good simply for her strength and physical capabilities. But as time went on, I felt like shes constantly bringing those around her down; while not progressing herself. Now I feel like shes going to perpetually be green."

[7.0] "While she's obviously still green (she's getting better every week), you can't deny that she looks like a megastar and that will trump her in-ring abilites every time. It's smart putting her with Bianca whether you like it or not."

[5.0] "The problem with Jade Cargill, despite her Star Power, is that we keep waiting for the moment when she's going to make an impact and shine, but it never really comes. Her charisma, looks and attitude make her a character you want to get behind, to root for, but aside from a few weightlifting feats, she offers nothing in the ring and is very bland. Even when paired with Bianca, a monster of power, charisma and athleticism, she struggles to draw us in. I want to like her, but it's difficult. Her place on the map is, for the moment, completely unjustified."

[7.0] "When you look at Jade, she has the it factor that screams superstar. Yes, she's not the greatest in the ring, or on the mic, but WWE have nailed showing her strengths and hiding her weaknesses by pairing her with Bianca, which has massively elevated the women's tag team division in the WWE, it's also because of her that the women's tag team titles have been showcased on PLEs, which is thanks to her and Bianca. AEW did a great job of protecting her in her dominant TBS title reign, but a poor job developing her in ring and on the mic, which meant a lot more work for WWE. People love to bring up her 'botches' or "that she's not ready" but the moves this woman can pull off in the ring are insane and incredibly entertaining. She only has potential to get better and I see a great feud coming when her and Bianca drop the tag team titles."

[2.0] "She always was very weak in promos and in terms of ring skill and still almost nothing changed. She got a little better in-ring wise but she botches a lot and has bad timing in almost every match. She's got an aura of a megastar and a look of it but that's all."

[2.0] "We're coming up on almost a year since Jade joined WWE and she has shown zero improvement whatsoever. WWE is keeping her chained to Bianca, like an anchor, and I'm wondering what the hell is the plan when they decide to make Jade a singles wrestler? This woman was trained by the greatest to ever do it AND a whole team of WWE trainers and she is still bad in the ring. The only thing she has going for her is her looks, she's not even very charismatic. With her significant lack of skills, I can't exactly see her headlining a WrestleMania, well, ever."

[3.0] "Everyone keeps saying she's a "star" but with all due respect, I genuinely cannot understand or see why. She looks cool sure, but that's about it. WWE have propelled her straight to the top of the card without considering that she has extremely little experience, and only ever having her do hot tag spots and squash matches may be a good way to hide that she's still green as grass after 3 years, but it's not gonna get her to improve. I can see that she has loads of potential, but if I was a manager for a premier league football team and I recently scouted a young 15 year old prodigy that has tons of potential, I wouldn't put them straight on the starting 11, that would make no sense, hence why having Jade immediately become a main event level talent makes no sense to me."

[9.0] "Jade Cargill has become one of my favorite wrestlers since she joined WWE, and why she have a such low rate? ! Her skills in the ring have always impressed me. She is one of the wrestlers that really leaves you filtered in the match. She has great movesets and finishers. Her performance at Backlash 2024 proves that. Her theme music is also perfect, and her character is absurdly exuberant. However, I don't like that WWE has been involved in Tag Teams since her in-ring debut. I think this is really getting in the way of her showing the public what she is really capable of doing. That's why I give her a 9."

[0.0] "AEW took great care in protecting her because she wasn't good and that's smart. Then she signs with WWE and it seemed like a guarantee she'd get better. She talked a lot about how much more professional her atmosphere is. I don't know what she worked in the couple of months she had for extra training but it wasn't timing. The fact that she appears to have gotten worse in the ring is very startling and puzzling. It shouldn't be possible. Her face off with Bianca Belair at the 2024 Royal Rumble looked like a litmus test to see if it was a match the fans wanted. They clearly did but there's zero confidence in Jade's learning ability at this point. I still think there's a chance for her to improve but being put in a tag team for the foreseeable future is smart of WWE to do. She keeps getting worse in the ring which should be impossible. She's gone on record to say she wants to use wrestling to get into movies but she better do it fast because she doesn't have a bright future in wrestling. I kept giving her chance after chance and I don't think there's a reason to anymore. I wanted to avoid giving her a 0 because she looks amazing and does have charisma but actually regressing in the ring is unforgivable."

[0.0] "It doesn't matter if she has the presence or the aura, from AEW to WWE she hasn't improved at all, even though she was trained by the best in the world. She's not even good enough for NXT. She's like Goldberg but even worse, she botches practically all of her moves, she's slow and seems lost all the time. Even being part of the tag team division with Bianca Belair, her flaws in the ring are noticeable. And if that wasn't enough, her ability with the microphone is almost as mediocre as her ability in the ring."

"A 7, a high rating for someone only at this for a few years. While lesser prospects across the globe go straight for what's in right now (increasingly tired and sloppily done sequence style wrestling), Jade is a breath of fresh air as a rock solid, charismatic powerhouse. Maybe not hitting the highs of someone like HOOK outside of her debut and a very good, under the radar Marina Shafir match, Jade Cargill excels in individual performances, already knowing when and where to sell as a powerhouse and slowly starting to grow as a babyface alongside Bianca Belair. Jade Cargill is one of american wrestling's most notable prospects, if not the flashiest. WWE's main roster is weirdly where she may grow the most as a wrestler, not being pressured to keep up with what's "in" and establish herself as her own unique wrestler. Jade Cargill has ridiculous potential physically and mentally, let's hope she reaches it."

[9.0] "Jade is a star. Its much easier to rate her if you realize two things shes never gonna be a manami Toyota in the ring & that thats not what she was made for. The girl has undeniable charisma look & aura that makes people pay attention to her & her mic skills are pretty good. In the ring is the only reason she wouldnt get a perfect 10 shes great at what she does power spots brawls and shit that makes her get a big pop because shes a megastar wherever she goes. She is occasionally sloppy but shes shown improvement in that she can recover quickly which a year 2 years ago she wouldve been so lost at it. Shes been a megastar in WWE & AEW & its clear WWE values her as a big star."

[8.0] "Jade Cargill gets a lot of circlejerk hate mainly because of how strong she was featured with her little experience. I am a fan of hers. She is strong and athletic and probably has the best look in all wrestling. She is confident on the mic and much better in the ring than people want to give her credit for. When she has a good showing the haters are quiet, but if she botches they come out of the woodwork."

[8.0] "Jade Cargill has a lot of aura. She has potential to be one of the greatest female wrestlers of all time. She has spots where she can improve, but once she's fully trained, she'll be a megastar. She could truly be on of the greatest female wrestlers of all time. So much potential. 8/10"

[4.0] "She has all the look, presence, and charisma you could ever want in a wrestler but just doesn't seem to have the in-ring ability when it comes to having a match. She looks like she is always just moving to step A to step B to step C etc, and that's when she's not making mistakes that kill the momentum of a match. There's still time for things to click but she's been doing this for several years now and has not made a lot of improvement. There's multiple wrestlers more than capable of putting together a good match that have far fewer years of experience. I'm still hoping for her but the way it's looking now she might go down as one of the biggest busts WWE has had."

[2.0] "It just doesn't seem like she wants to improve. The Nightmare Factory with Dustin Rhodes, Bryan Danielson, and the entire Performance Center team haven't been able to make her better. She has presence and strength, but it doesn't even seem like wrestling is her passion"

[4.0] "No man I just can't see what they see she's just a look not a mic talent or a ring talent there's nothing to look forward to how was she TBS champion for 500 days and didn't even have a remembered match, I really hope for her sake she figures it out because if she doesn't the crowd will lose interest and she might end up being a jobber"

[2.0] "Female Goldberg. Without the charisma. Literally same gimmick. Looks like a million bucks, can't wrestle, can't talk, is a botch machine. Edited to updated the fact while she still can't wrestle she wasn't quite as much of a disaster as I'd have thought."

[5.0] "Jade has an absolutely incredible look, main event charisma, underrated promo ability, off the charts star quality and is clearly very smart and driven... But she just can't seem to put it together in the ring. As others have pointed out, she started training years ago and has been trained/mentored by some heavy hitters -- even all-time greats. She's been through at least four different schools, had top notch coaching on the road with AEW, and after all that she's barely made any visible progress as a wrestler. Already in her early 30s, if all that world class training hasn't shown returns yet, it's unlikely that it ever will. Luckily for her, she's now in a company where in-ring ability is arguably the least important part of her game. It's obvious based on her crowd reactions that she can be a giant star regardless, but she'll never be a ring general. Your mileage may vary on whether or not that's enough for you."

[7.0] "shes an above average wrestler and talker when given the right presentation which she has been given to her cause she just has superstar written all over her. like how Hogan was back in the 80s. she hasnt been in anything promo or story wise that peaks my interest but I am liking what shes cooking with Bianca as it seems like there slowly putting the pieces for friction. nothing yet but whats been given is noticeable."

[10.0] "Jade is so WORTH THE HYPE. Jade is so good for someone that has been wrestling for 3 years. She deserves her fame and this mega push. Think about it she won the championship in her 3rd match. She has gotten so much better than she was at the start of her AEW Career. Jade is one of the most believable badass women ever in WWE. I cant wait to see her and Bianca face off one day, that is literally a WrestleMania Main Event Match. I dont know how they are going to give her a loss but its gotta be Bianca,"

[9.0] "She's gonna be a megastar in WWE. She has the physique and charisma to make it so. I'm looking forward for this next chapter of her career and I'll love to see a major improvement over the criticism about her in ring abilities. Her time in AEW was good, but here in WWE I think she's gonna reach all the potential she has, I hope she'll stay in the PC for a little season before she debuts on the main roster. Now that she debuted, she's proven beyond doubt that she's destined for the spotlight. Her performances in the ring are nothing short of amazing; she executes moves flawlessly and her movement selling has vastly improved. Her partnership with Bianca in the tag team division has been a highlight, and I'm excited to see how it develops into a thrilling rivalry with Jade, especially considering Jade's connection with the fans as a Face. This dynamic has all the makings of an epic storyline that will captivate audiences for months to come."

[5.0] "Jade, to me, is at any time somewhere between a zero and a ten, so I'm rating her at a 5. She has an incredible aura and looks like the next big thing in the WWE's women's division. Her spots, especially in the Royal Rumble this year, made her look like a million bucks. On the other hand, she is still incredibly undertrained and is being hidden in tag team matches, doing incredibly limited in-ring work, and surrounded by far better and more experienced wrestlers. As such she is currently a 5 with room to improve."

[6.0] "Theres very clearly something there. She has an incredible presence and aura about her and her presentation has been perfect since she arrived in the WWE. Her offence is very good and shes making for a great powerhouse and showing some incredible feats of strength. She is still VERY green and often looks slightly uncomfortable in an actual match that isnt just one hot tag. I think with more training this rating could be a 10 one day."

[8.0] "Jade Cargill is a solid 8, pushing a 9 because of how she clearly stands out from women on any other roster. I am a big Jade Cargill fan and her matches in WWE have been well constructed to show off her strengths. Jade Cargill has a ton of potential."

[5.0] "Ehrlich so eine Bewertung fällt schwer. Eigentlich will man jemanden besser bewerten. Anlagen sind ja da und die Bewertung wird sicher besser. Die Vergleiche mit Goldberg sind eher Unsinn. Sie versucht es tatsächlich besser zu werden. Leider wirkt sie dermaßen hölzern oder wie gerade eben wie ein Roboter. Das Timing stimmt noch nicht. Denke in einem Tag Team kann man sicher noch einiges verstecken. Muss man leider auch."

[5.0] "If a 6 is "satisfactory", then I'm giving Jade a 5. The short answer is I expect more out of talent when they are in the ring/mic when you're on TV. As of this rating, Jade has had 70 matches. 67 of them are televised, so we know what Jade is capable of. Jade's first singles match of any note was against Red Velvet, and giving credit to Red Velvet, she did a lot to make Jade look great there. Jade then had a solid 5 months of squashes before fighting Layla and then eventually Ruby Soho in the finals for the first TBS title. Jade is still extremely green in the Soho match and it shows, specifically when Soho hits one of her signatures and has to push Jade down because she isn't selling the move right. Perception being what it is, doesn't help that it came after a 30 minute certified banger in Danielson/Adam Page. This kind of setup does hamper Jade for a lot of her AEW run. She fights Madison Rayne the same night that LFI and Lucha Brothers AND Jericho/Mox put on really good matches and she has the worst match at Full Gear 2022. Her promo work is pretty stagnant too. "I'm the best, you're not, get on my level bitch" only goes so far. Currently tagging with Bianca in WWE. Looks to be forming a tag team with Bianca so she can cover a lot of Jades rougher edges while getting her TV time. Overall, she just shouldn't be on the main roster. She should be in NXT grinding and getting matches in, similar to Lexus King. She needs the work."

"Not allowed to Rate today, but I'll be rating Cargill a 5.0. She's amazing to look at, but at this time I'm getting major "The Narcissist Lex Luger" vibes from her. I don't think a Goldberg streak is a good idea for any wrestler, definitely not one who only has 70 matches. Why is WWE not having her sell at all? She worked normal matches in AEW. That 3 on 3 tag match at WMXL, when she wasn't the first tagged in I knew, they weren't going to have her work anything more than a few offensive spots. Why are they doing this if not lack of confidence? Also, that pin of hers is so lame. Really narrows down every finish she'll work. Sexy-looking but I don't need to be titillated by pro-wrestling finishes."

[5.0] "Could be the female Goldberg. "COULD" being the operative word there. She has all the pros and all the cons of Goldberg, her only benefit is that she's (so far) been booked by good pens. If she continues to be booked correctly she will be huge, but we've seen how every one of these cheap Goldberg imitations has fizzled out. As it stands I don't know anyone could score her above a 7 when, by this sites standards, she only has one singles match with a score higher than 6/10."

[5.0] "Kinda stiff at the little I have seen of her, second match and she did very little moves, but yet I think she has potential. We have to watch her in action more frequently to get a good overview on her wrestling abilities. Currently I am rating her like this since she hasn't prove something more interesting out of her great body and good looks."

[8.0] "Oof, the current rating for Jade Cargill is REALLY harsh. I'm editing this review from my September 2022 rating where I previously gave Jade a 6. I honestly admire Jade. She has the potential to be WWE's top 2-4 biggest stars in the women's division. She carries herself like a big star, and she has a great physique/height that'll always make her a legitimate threat to the rest of the women's division. I think she's solid enough in the ring against the right opponents. I've seen Jade Cargill have good matches against Kris Statlander, Taya Valkyrie (aka their 2nd match), Anna Jay (aka their 1st match) and Thunder Rosa. Her wrestling is easily her one weakness, but she's a solid enough worker who can hang in the ring with better wrestlers. Jade oozes charisma since she's able to connect with various crowds, and she's such a cool dominant badass that makes it easy for us to be enamored by her presence. Jade is solid enough on the mic. HEr promos are generally best when it's short and sweet because her actions speak much louder than her words. Plus, Jade is arguably the hottest woman in the company; so that's just another big bonus going for her. Jade is just Her. She fits perfectly in WWE, and hopefully she continues to improve in the ring. Overall, Jade definitely gets an 8 from me. She's criminally underrated on this site."

[4.0] "Jade Cargill was a cool AEW project but one that couldn't last. Yes, she exudes charisma and a star presence but is far too beginner in the ring to match the AEW style in the long term, she would have ended up going in circles and everyone would have had enough of it. On the other hand, it corresponds perfectly to the WWE style and can really last for a very long term there if it is used well."

[3.0] "TK and PL book her like she's some cross of Andre the Giant, Roman Reigns, Chyna, and John Lennon. In the limited time she's been in the ring she's been outclassed. She has a phenomenal look and she is stupid-strong, but she wrestles like Nia Jax. I see no reason why she gets treated like some phenom. Bianca should be getting this treatment."

[3.0] "Jade Cargill is the most overrated woman (maybe person) in wrestling right now. She has the look and aura of importance and greatness, but inside the ring she is very green and cannot deliver a good match or anything over 10 minutes. I think it's cool how much WWE fans are hyping her, if you've never seen her work in AEW I understand, but if you have I'm not excited at all, she'll probably become a great entertainer within the WWE machine, but in-ring I don't think it should evolve further (I hope I'm wrong). It would be very interesting if they put her in NXT during a period for her evolution both as a character and as a performer, in MR I only see her working being extremely dominant (kicking the roster in short matches) or putting in a superworker to try to carry her to something decent"

[9.0] "Jade is green as grass, but her appearance and athleticism are the ones that don't give me to put a zero for her. She also needs to train her promo skill obviously. Her ring abilities is quite adequate for a rookie, but I think, her work might be better if she begins to love her job. UPD: Her reign as TBS champion is interesting. It shows Jade's potential as a wrestler and right now she became better than any time in her short career (for now). Hope, she progresses more to become one of the AEW's true pillars. UPD2: When she quit AEW and came to WWE, she began intensive wrestling training (I had no doubt that Jade has the IT-FACTOR, I just think that Tony Khan doesn't care about Cargill's wrestling skill) and on Royal Rumble she showed her fruits of labor. I hope she won't stop her progress."

[4.0] "Jade look like a star and behave like one, so I believe she has room for improvement and evolution, but so far she's been pretty bad, completely boring and uninteresting in the ring, almost always the worst matches in the show, definitely not ready for the big moments."

[5.0] "She has a great look and when she debuted in WWE they made her look like a Superstar. Jade still has a lot to improve and they take their time to get her ready. I would blame AEW more for that, because they haven't done much with her, except making her the female Goldberg and squashing people in few minutes."

[0.0] "Jade Cargill hat zwar denn Body eines Wrestles, aber worked nicht dem entsprechend. Macht zu viel auf Diva und ihre TBS Championship "streak" war eine Lachnummer. Damit kann man Jade als weibliche Goldberg abstempeln, die WWE hat sie doch nur unter Vertrag genommen wegen ihren außen. Denket ihr ernsthaft die wird bei denn WWE Fans ein Megastar das bezweifle ich im Gegenteil. Es gibt oder gab doch immer eine Powerhouse wie sie einige mit weniger mal oder mehr mal weniger Talent als Jade, hier ein paar Beispiele: Luna Vachon, Chyna, Beth Phoenix, Rhea Ripley oder Raquel Rodriguez nur das die drei letzten durchtrainiert sind. Sie wird bei WWE scheitern, weil die WWE Fans wollen keine unnatürliche aufgepumpten Körper mehr sehen."

[4.0] "Jade Cargil a young wrestler with good physique and pretty but she is not that good in the ring, she needs to improve. He had a long reign with the TBS Championship in AEW, she did not show much improvement in the ring in her entire time in AEW, Hopefully now that she is in WWE and in the Performance Center she improves her quality in the Ring."

[5.0] "Others have noted that Jade is not passionate about wrestling, but rather about being a star - partly reflected by her disinterest in working outside shows for experience. Uultimately WWE may be a better fit for her. Jade has the look and the charisma that could make her a mega star in WWE, where weekly in ring work is not as important. Also, WWE will presumably force her to work house shows for experience, as she is a competent but mediocre wrestler, and will better instruct her on how to build up her opponents in promos rather than just bury them, which benefits nobody. Her booking in AEW was a mixed bag - she was super protected and did have a few ok stories as she ran through the entire midcard. But she also never moved into the main event scene and ran out of equitable opponents, which resulted in a dreadfully dull streak that carried on for months too long as Tony Khan just seemed to stop caring about her booking entirely. Let's see how WWE does."

[4.0] "She has a fantastic look, maybe the best I've ever seen, she is very charismatic, and she's not bad on the mic at all. Her acting and facial expressions, body language and character work are all really good. Her in ring is not particularly good, although she shows flashes of skill due to her impressive athletic ability. AEW didn't push her to improve enough, and she didn't work indie dates like Skye Blue does, but if she goes to WWE, they'll make her do house shows and she'll probably improve just through reps. She's not passionate about wrestling but she is ambitious."

[2.0] "If what it's true that she will be leaving the wrestling business all I have to say about Jade is this... WHY THE HELL DID WE WAST LIKE THREE YEARS ON HER, She clearly doesn't care about wrestling and I never saw an improvement in the ring, She switched between babyface and Heel constantly, One night she may come out in cosplay hugging her daughter, Next she is attacking someone from behind, She get's 2 stars because she looks like a star but Was never a star on the mic or in the ring and I hope she goes away for like a year and find's the right trainer because apparently Bryan Danielson, Dustin Rhodes, And Heath Miller have taught her nothing."

[1.0] "Looks like a star and then the bell rings. Hopefully the Jade Cargill experiment in AEW is over because she doesn't care about the business, it's just a hobby for her and there are some good wrestlers in AEW who are being horribly misused if at all."

[6.0] "I don't think Jade is fantastic in the ring, far from it, but the hatred she gets seems to be more about how she's book rather than what she is. Her matches are very basic, and she's clearly still green, but usually inoffensive. The problems seem to stem from the last half year of her title reign. It seemed like, at a certain point, it became all about getting her streak numbers up and to hell with the story. She could have been an attraction, but they were content giving her title defenses every week with no build just to pump her numbers up. She's a big, strong, athletic woman who has potential, but I think we are all breathing a sigh of relief that she's spending some time not on our tv's for a while."

[1.0] "Zuvor hatte ich nur einen Kommentar abgegeben und jetzt finde ich es angebracht, eine Bewertung abzugeben. Und ganz ehrlich finde ich sie grauenvoll. Wenig Charisma, am Mikrofon sehr überschaubar und im Ring nur sehr selten in der Lage, akzeptable Matches von zwei Minuten zu worken. Außer ihren Look hat sie nichts zu bieten, wirklich gar nichts, was irgendwie rechtfertigt, sie ins TV zu stellen. Da kann man auch nicht argumentieren, sie sähe doch so toll im Fernsehen aus oder ähnlichen Nonsens. Dann kann man auch eine Bodybuilderen vom Venice Beach ins TV stellen, ohne sie jemals eine Schicht bei einer Wrestling-Schule schieben zu lassen. Es würde aber auch kaum einen Unterschied machen, da Cargill eh nicht gerade vor Talent strotzt."

[7.0] "She's pure potential, but the problem is she's just that, potential. I blame the fact that she has been wrestling like five minutes every two weeks for the first two years of her career, when AEW should be putting her out there in every Dark, Elevation, and indy show that would receive her."

[8.0] "she is improving alot and she will be golden money in the next 5 to 10 years if aew use her right and she dosent get injured"

[4.0] "I can see why there's so much investment in her. She looks like a million dollars and carries herself like a star outside the ring, but that's where the praise ends. She's only a year in, so I don't expect her to be great already. However, if you're going to be pushed as an undefeated champion having open challenges regularly, you need to be able to have good matches, and while I can say she's improved, she's still far from being good, with only two of her matches being what I'd call 'serviceable'. I'm open to changing my rating if she improves, but you can't hide behind the 'she's new and improving' excuse when she's being pushed as a champion."

[6.0] "One could look at Jade's trainers and would assume she is one of the best in the world. She is just mid tho. Not great nor terrible, just mid. Decent 5.5/10"

[7.0] "Jade Cargill is currently extremely popular in AEW at the moment and she hasn't even reached her potential yet (in ring work) so i believe that in the coming months and years we may hopefully see a vast improvement."

[7.0] "Incredible presence, as well as really good promo skills. Her in-ring work isn't quite there yet, although that will definitely improve with time, overall it's speaks volumes that the TBS champion feels way more important then the AEW women's champion as of currently which ultimately speaks volumes about the credibility of her character. Edit: She still has lots of potential but her TBS title reign has gone beyond stale and her constantly squashing jobbers isn't doing any favours for anyone including herself, so until something changes she is going down two points."

[5.0] "As of 2023, it must be admitted that Jade, while definitely still green, can no longer be classified as a 'bad' wrestler. She always had the natural confidence and charisma of a true star that carried her to at least being 'not awful' despite how sloppy her in-ring work is, but over the course of 2022 she's been improving on her athleticism and her displays of strength to the point where, even when working a match that doesn't simply gift her 90-100% control, she can keep the match together and make it look appropriately competitive to a minimal degree. She of course also benefits from literally the strongest booking in all of AEW, being the inaugural TBS Women's Champion of 365+ days with a Goldberg-esque undefeated streak. It's a shame that there doesn't appear to be any long-term plan for where that streak is going (who is actually being built up to chase her? ), but it's undeniable that this booking has made her a big deal, and it will definitely feel major when she is finally dethroned, regardless of who does it. It's also just genuinely refreshing to have someone with such a vastly different look in the women's division, given how relatively tall and immensely muscular she is. Now, Jade could easily go and have an absolute dud of a match any random week that would make my praise of her seem foolish, but I believe she's on a clear upward trajectory at the moment, and I'm excited to see her continue to develop."

[6.0] "10/10 look and improving in the ring. She stands out and has much more star power than most of her peers. She isn't great in the ring but is usually entertaining."

[10.0] "She has worked so hard and has proven just how good her matches can be when given more time to really thrive! The squash matches were good too but more and more lately, she is being given the time she deserves and I can't get enough of her in AEW! Obviously has room for improvement, being such a new wrestler, but it doesn't look like it at all when she steps into the ring! Both WWE and AEW wanted her for good reason and she proves that reason every time she gets a chance! Absolutely can't wait for her future matchups, one of my favourite AEW wrestlers to date!"

[3.0] "I'm not even sure what to rate, to be honest. Her matches don't go more than a few minutes and it's clearly because she's too green to work anything longer. She's charismatic enough on her own, but she's absolutely incapable of turning that charisma into a compelling story. She can't make her opponent look good, and can't build anticipation for her own matches and feuds. I get that she's a very striking figure, but I'm not sure what the point of pushing somebody so hard when it's clear that she's not trusted to carry her own weight in the ring."

[5.0] "She has the looks, she has charisma, but so far she can't wrestle at all. Until this very day I haven't seen one single match where she really convinced me about her ring skills and i hope that will change soon. Otherwise i think her current push is really overrated and i hope she will get beaten sooner than later. Update: She improved a little, her last matches have been a bit longer and you can see that she learned something. Still sloppy in many many parts, but she slowly seems to get better. One point up."

[3.0] "I hope to be able to bump up this rating in the future because Cargill looks absolutely brilliant. She draws you in and you want to get behind her but bell to bell she's still very green. I'm not sure the booking is helping because it requires her to be the focus of the match every week and she's just not ready. She should have been built up in tags and occasional singles matches with experienced workers who can guide her."

[8.0] "She is still a little green, but she has the look and personality of a champion, as opposed to the "millennial sad boi/girl" personalities that is too common in wrestling nowadays. She (and Hook) shows that the Goldberg strategy can still work in the 2020's."

[4.0] "Jade sorta pisses me off. Her in-ring work is mid at best, mostly because all her opponents were made to look like trash compared to her. She destroyed all credibility and prestige the TBS Championship ever bad. If I were to say something good about her, I'd say she gave us a great female stable in AEW in the Baddies, but with Kiera and Velvet being removed from the group, and only being left with Leila, I'm not sure I can really buy into that anymore."

[8.0] "Jade has continued to improve and has reached the point where she can consistently put on an entertaining match. The promo ability is there and she comes off as a superstar. It's time for a classic match with her and a notable talent."

[4.0] "She's all looks and presentation. In the ring she's still sloppy and slow-paced, and looks lost whenever she has to transition between her power moves. For those hyping her because of what they think she might be in a few years, maybe wait to rate her in a few years then. Potential doesn't make someone great until they fulfill it. I've seen tons of rookies who were far better within months after their TV debuts, let alone in the time she's been around. AEW put the cart before the horse with her, and the TBS title seems to have been created specifically to avoid giving her the Women's title while keeping her undefeated. I'm amending my previous rating, because to be fair, she has improved during her Baddies run. But her more talented opponents always have to slow down to half-speed to accommodate her, and that shouldn't be rewarded."

[5.0] "Jane needs a lot more time in the saddle to properly develop. She has all the tools- she looks great, is an athlete, and can talk, though not for more than about 20 seconds. She's already a star, which is hard to teach. AEW give her dumb stuff to say a lot of the time so she'll go from sounding great to sounding really unnatural. She deserves to be in a good developmental, and would benefit from working in different territories. Sadly, she is probably too old for WWE to invest in so unless she somehow becomes a prodigy in the next few years we will probably never see her at her full potential. It's been sink or swim on AEW TV for her and she's done about a 50/50 job of sinking or swimming. Her better matches give you glimpses of what she's capable of, but most are the shits. She also seems like she might hurt someone. 5 is a hopeful rating; someone could make a supercut of her matches and promos and she'd come out looking great. I wish AEW had a better way of developing talent because she could be really good. D worker, A look, C- talker."

[8.0] "Honestly, I'm rooting for her to improve her in-ring skills. She is beautiful, very hot, and manages to attract all the attention when she enters the ring. But that's not enough. It still has to improve a lot."

[6.0] "Jade is improving. Her promo work is already pretty good, and her in-ring is improving. She still adds a degree of spectacle to her matches, which is difficult to rate, but even harder to duplicate."

[1.0] "She has an undefeated streak that the majority of people seem to not care about. She can't even prove herself worthy of a streak like this because every match of hers is a squash and less than 10 minutes. She is a woman version of Goldberg and worse than Goldberg."

[5.0] "Do not dislike Jade but she is still very green. Her in ring work is alright with room to improve. Her psychology and character work is what needs the most work. Still developing so hoping to see her put it all together and be the mega star she is pushed as."

[4.0] "Cargill is just satisfactory at th moment but like a lot of people said she has the look and the charisma if she works on her in ring performance she can be a very good wrestler plus she has less than a year of experience at the moment. A wrestler that have my attention but I have high expectations now that she is the TBS champion."

[2.0] "It is so strange how much they always push Jade on top of other more experienced and established wrestlers in the female division. Jade has very little experience in the wrestling world and I feel as wasting other talent by always feeding new or bigger stars. When you see there is a Jade Cargill Match on T.V, you always know what to expect. Nothing new, nothing exciting."

[4.0] "She always has had the potential to develop into a star but that just hasn't happened yet she is still very green in the ring. Yes she doesn't have much experience but with how she is pushed she shouldn't be this green still"

[4.0] "I will never understand, why people like her. She never had a good match. She shouldn't be a champion in AEW."

[7.0] "I am revising my rating for Jade Cargill, as I felt I was perhaps a little bit harsh. Jade, while not a complete package in the ring, has improved leaps and bounds since her debut in March last year. She has added new moves to here repertoire, and only continues to improve every week she wrestles on TV. Jade exudes tons of charisma and has an incredible look. Her promos are a bit dry but her delivery is solid. Everything about Jade screams "star", and I'm glad AEW is treating her as such. Will continue to come back here to reevaluate her in ring acumen, and hopefully one day, I can rate her a 10."

[7.0] "Her in-ring skills are still a little bit meh, but she is getting better. What makes her a star is her look and charisma. Jade's attitude and promo work are top notch, plus don't forget some Stokely's magic."

[7.0] "The low ratings on Jade are honestly just disrespectful and stupid. People saw her once and never changed their minds. Jade has improved greatly since becoming TBS champion and she's still getting better. Cut the shit"

[5.0] "Jade is a tough one to rate. If I was going solely off potential she'd be at 10, but at the moment she is still very raw. Her character work has improved tremendously since her debut. She's getting better in ring but still seems awkward and uncoordinated. I can imagine her earning a much better rating once she gains experience, but right now a 5 feels more than fair."

"I will admit that she? s not really great in ring worker but man the ways she looks she? s full of charisma and have great loook rating here is bit harsh in my opinion she? s solid seven just based on looks character and mic work and she has improved alot from early days and i seee great progress in future solid 7 from me now and she? s kinda wrestler u love to pay to see in person she? s superstar material"

[5.0] "Current review from 23 June 2022: 5 weeks ago I rated her 7/10 (original review below), that said her ringwork seems to have stagnated (heck and even somehow gone backwards) - case-in-point her dumpster fire of a match on Rampage with Willow Nightingale. I stand by her having phenomenal presence and being great on the mic, but her ringwork is so poor (sloppy and jarring) and sad to say I am now not sure she is going to get much better. For me a great pro-wrestler has the look, the charisma, and the ring skills. Jade oozes the first two, but completely lacks the latter. 5/10. Previous review from 19 May 2022: She has phenomenal presence (like a female version of Goldberg or Lesnar) and is great on the mic. She is clearly a natural athlete and her ringwork is improving quickly. If she can continue to improve her ringwork, the sky is the limit for Jade Cargilll. 7/10"

[5.0] "she's def got "the look" but she's been super green in the ring. hope she improves more in the future! EDIT: I think she's improved from a 5 to a 6, honestly. She oozes confidence. Every single word she says she believes fully, which makes up for her in-ring work. A great asset in a somewhat weak AEW women's division."

[2.0] "Do these people giving out high ratings actually like the wrestling part of wrestling or just watch the entrances and promos and then look away? Because that's the only explanation I can find. She's so bad in the ring, like, extremely bad. She's freakishly athletic and strong but doesn't really have a clear style when she wrestles, she can't really sell a single thing nor do a sequence that involves more than 1 reversal. I won't deny she has the look and the charisma but I can't look past the awful in ring skills. I want to see good TBS title matches and that won't happen until she drops the belt."

[9.0] "Jade's still got a lot to learn and it will take a lot of convincing to make fans who are obsessed with racial bias and the inability to separate things that happen on Twitter to things that happen in the real, functioning world. Where people talk to each other and you can touch the grass and concrete outside. But that doesn't prevent Jade from shining brightly where she's good. Her selling needs improvement, but her work as a powerhouse is developing nicely and she's shown good movement and transition ability and kept up well in her strong (and most technically skilled) test yet in Ruby Soho. I know many who gave Jade a 3 or 2 or 1 or 0 really wanted to see Ruby win, but Jade's n excellent young gun that the audience will be excited to see reach true superstar levels. For now, a 7. She's a hot topic right now, she's working well and she's the inaugural TBS Champion. Let's hope she keeps it up and improves even more. ************* UPDATE: I originally made this review in January and am happy to come back now and bump her up to a 9. She's the most real of deals. Great in the ring, even better on the mic and the addition of the Baddies and Stokely will take her all the way to a 10. Don't be blinded by prejudice as we see a star rise."

[2.0] "She is so sloppy in the ring that it makes it so hard to believe she is championship material and is not a convincing wrestler at all. Her promos are boring and her gimmick is no better. AEW has about 10+ other women that they would be better off pushing."

[7.0] "Jade is leagues ahead of where I would expect someone of her experience to be. She already has the presentation and promo game down and though her in-ring abilities are sometimes hit or miss, she's constantly improving and I'm excited about her future now that she has the Baddies and Stokely by her side."

[2.0] "Eigentlich ist Jade ein Paradebeispiel dafür, was mir sonst in der WWE nicht gefällt. Die Dame hat im Wrestling noch überhaupt nichts geleistet, wird aber alleine auf Grund ihres Looks und der Erscheinung vollkommen überpusht. Ihre Fähigkeiten im Ring sind noch deutlich mangelhaft und sie nimmt Damen den Platz weg, die potenziell deutlich besser im Ring abliefern würden. Sie hat zweifellos gute Voraussetzungen, auf lange Sicht, aber wenn man mehr oder weniger den ganzen Pool an US Indy Damen zur Auswahl hat, ist ihr bisheriger Push für mich schon fast eine Frechheit. Schade, dass ausgerechnet AEW diesen Weg mit ihr geht."

[5.0] "A while ago, the truth was that Jade did not attract much attention to me, but since she won the TBS Championship, I honestly see her as a dominant fighter who could create good stories so that finally, some fighter on the roster wins her in a fight to increase his career, I don't know, but I'm liking his reign and I hope he gives the best he can despite the criticism I don't think they're doing things wrong with Jade Cargill in AEW."

[7.0] "She was introduced into AEW in such a bizarre manner it took me along time to figure out she was actually a new wrestler but I have come to really like her. Outside of wrestling ability which has improved significantly since her debut she is pretty much top-tier."

[7.0] "She looks like a star, talks like a star and acts like a star. She's got the it factor, and she now doubt will eventually be World's Women's Champion. All she needs is to work on her in ring ability, because it seems to be the only thing holding her back!"

"Great money look and loads of charisma. Super athletic and a great role model, she? s only getting better. She? s got the most crossover appeal of any AEW homegrown talent I? ve seen."

[8.0] "She feels very comfortable at the microphone. She is imposing and knows how to sell her character. She seems like a kind and funny person, interested in wrestling and eager to learn. Her only weak point is that she is still green in some selling concepts and she lacks transition moves to make the fights more enjoyable. However, with her motivation, she will end up solving these problems in a few years. Giving her the TBS Championship was a great idea for developing her character. All her shortcomings can be solved with time and training, and the character is already developed, something that is sometimes the biggest problem for the company's women's division."

[7.0] "She's been getting better and better each passing month. She's got the best look in AEW, good promo skills, and, now, below-average wrestling ability. Below average is quite the step up from horrendous."

[6.0] "A year ago she would have been a 2, but she has improved a great deal in ring and is now seemingly getting better each match. Her charisma and potential are off the charts, she has the it factor more than any other woman on the roster. If she keeps improving, I will keep bumping her score up but for now 6 seems fair."

[8.0] "Jade Cargill is very good for a wrestler with only a year of experience. She has a good charisma. I saw her in the top 3 of the best female wrestlers in 3 years."

[7.0] "There's a ton of upside here. Needs to go in longer matches and get more consistent. But she has a good out-of-ring presence, and her mic work is already in the upper-tier - not in the best-of-the-best class, but her promos have confidence that many life-long veterans don't have. In the ring, she still needs some work, but she already sells fairly well and her moves have believability and impact. Her look - face it - she's the character you make in create-a-wrestler. She's getting pushed because she's someone you can build around and you don't want someone like her to get away - what she has done in a year alludes to how many boxes she ticked off naturally. I think the only other unknown here, aside from how much she can improve in the ring, is if she decides that he's not a pro-wrestling lifer and moves on to a different career."

[6.0] "Jade has the look of a star, she's great on the mic, has charisma for days and a real aura and presence... Then she gets in the ring and it all falls apart. I understand she's working hard to improve and I hope she succeeds, because even if she can only attain above average in-ring skill, she could become a megastar."

[9.0] "She made her debut last year and already is a superstar. Who cares she's green in the ring and her matches are usually less than 10 minutes, from what I recall, she's working with Bryan Danielson who is praising her and her will to learn. I don't think she was promoted to be a champ too early. In my opinion, she will be the biggest female superstar in the world of professional wrestling, she's got the looks, she's got charisma, she cuts promos, she's going mainstream, she could be a John Cena or Hulk Hogan of women wrestling, mark my words. She's this kind of performer that we should rate not exactly in context of how good of a wrestler she is, but how she can promote wrestling around the world and how she is viewed by people that are not into wrestling. She's a superstar. Jade is a total gamechanger for AEW's women division and is constantly improving."

[7.0] "Jade was super green when she first started, but both her in-ring work and promos have improved massively over time. Much has been made of her presentation and how she looks the part of a star, and her work in the ring is beginning to match that. Really promising wrestler with a great future ahead of her."

[0.0] "Possibly the worst wrestler I had seen in many years. Over pushed wrestler ( by TK since he has a thing for her and his pet project. Not trolling at all on this. You can clearly see it on TK likes on Twitter. It's really sad.) that looks good, but in reality, is not at all good in the ring. Fans (including YT influencers) keep saying "she's improving", but in reality, she's not. Most of her matches have been botches. If any of her matches look good (ex Anna Jay), it's most likely it's someone she trained with at the Nightmare Factory. The length in matches are either short or if they are long it last a good 8 minutes ( but when it's minutes you have to minus 3-4 minutes because of PIP). Her TBS title reign has done nothing for the women's division nor elevated anyone in any of the matches. I hope Jade's reign ends soon & give the TBS title to someone else with more experience. If Jade Cargill wants to get better, she needs to go to the indies & get some reps in."

[0.0] "I cannot give this woman anything higher than no points, the fact that she's not only still employed with AEW but is a champion at that is the very definition of sunken cost fallacy. Hopefully when Jade finally drops the belt she goes away forever because this woman has no business being a professional wrestler."

[6.0] "Sie hat sich schon deutlich verbessert, ist aber immer noch weit davon entfernt, eine gute Wrestlerin zu sein. Am Mikro ist sie zumindest etwas besser geworden und dazu versprüht sie einfach nur absolute Starpower. Ihre Präsenz innerhalb und außerhalb des Rings ist überwältigend, was aber nichts daran ändert, dass ihre Matches extrem eindimensional sind. Aber das wenige was sie macht, macht sie schon sehr ordentlich. Gute 6 Punkte und ich bin ziemlich sicher, das man in ein, zwei Jahren nochmal ein bis zwei Punkte drauf zählen kann"

[4.0] "Has a great look and aura about her, can cut good promos as well but she's pretty green and seems to struggle in even very controlled, segmented matches structured around her limitations. Her as champion follows basically the exact same premise outside of the bigger entrances. Look, I get the AEW's women's division kinda shot itself in the foot when it came out with a secondary title long before it had the proper roster and setup to do so, but it's no excuse for throwing it on someone who seems to struggle a lot with even the fundamentals. Great power moves, sure, but in terms of pacing and making it look natural, it's just not there. I appreciate that she's wanting to learn from the best possible and clearly has made some good strides in the year or so, but at the same time she's not learning anything from being in Goldberg-lite sub-10 minute matches. Maybe that's to protect her as she does tend to gas up in longer stuff but still. Doesn't help that the competition she's usually facing just isn't giving her any real experience, and are at times nearly as green as she is. She definitely has the foundation to succeed, it's just a matter of actually refining and being able to build up a actual field of work beyond these very limited matches."

[1.0] "Too green. Doesn't even know how to wrestle completely and is already a champion. That's bad because there are way better women than her on roster. She's bad except having some muscles."

[5.0] "As of right now Jade Cargill is a woman with a very inconsistent portfolio of matches. She's had great ones against Thunder Rosa, Ruby Soho, and the tag match with Shaq, but then she has had very bad matches with Red Velvet and Allie. I will give her credit for improving quickly and being able to watch her week to week seeing her pick up a lot. You aren't going to just start off being great, so my real problem is with AEW pushing her SOOOOO heavily. If she worked her way up and was the exact same I think it would be fine."

[3.0] "She's still not that good. She is getting better but she needs a lot more practice. Her being the first TBS champion really exposes this and in my view was put on her too fast. She has star power and a great look but she's not ready yet, at all."

[7.0] "Eine sensationelle Präsenz hat sie auf jeden Fall schon mal und im Ring verbessert sie sich auch stetig. Ein gutes Gesamtpaket mit einer vielversprechenden Zukunft"

[1.0] "Jade has a look to her, but that is litterally all the good I can say when she's booked in the position that she's in. There are women leagues above her and yet Cargill is the first ever TBS Champion' To me, putting the title on a rookie that is still very green instantly devalues the title to almost nothing. Maybe she will get better and maybe she'll be a star, but I do't think she deserves the hype and strong booking that she's gotten when there are others far greater"

[0.0] "It's been several months and I still don't understand what is the "hype" behind this woman, could it be her muscles' her stature' I don't know. And to put her ahead of Thunder Rosa and Leyla Hirsch just because of her looks is absolutely disgusting. We'll see how Brandi and Cody's projects and the unmistakable QT progress. I see she made it to the finals of the tournament for the TBS, well if she wins that championship, sadly the belt is destined to die or be deactivated in the near future. EDIT: At the beginning I rated her with a 1 because I didn't want to be so hard on her but I think this is already too much' Let's see how long has she been training for 2 years' it seems so. Well when you want to establish a championship the most logical thing is to put experienced people as the first champion like Riho, Jericho, SCU and Cody were, whoever likes them they were the first ones and in spite of all the difficulties they did a good job. but here it is different, why put a championship to a rookie that wrestles horrible and since she debuted she hasn't shown any improvement... my god... TK will think people are stupid...' quickly this woman has become the worst of Dynamite/Rampage...I mean there were much better candidates than her like Leyla, Kris. Hayter, Tay, Emi Sakura, Ruby or Nyla (even if people hate her or don't like her because of her sexuality she has shown that she can give a good performance) or even established people like Deeb or Shida but well, here we are seeing the premature reign of terror and the worst in the history of the company. Poor TBS Title. Oh and for things like this people talk horrible about the women working in AEW."

[0.0] "This woman wrestler has nothing good as of now. Seriously, she had some impact in terms of charisma ('), maybe, the rest is a disgrace. Poor wrestling ability, as well as selling, timing, positioning and all..."

[4.0] "Pretty average wrestler. She had an impressive debut in the team with Shaq and now she is the first TBS champion and have a strange streak. Although, it seems to me, she wouldn't be half as good without the help of Mark Sterling. Often her matches are slow with a bunch of taunts, and all the interviews looks same. I wouldn't say she's a bad wrestler, but she's not particularly interesting yet. 4 points."

[7.0] "She's improving faster than some give her credit for. She looks incredible. The whole presentation is on point. She already feels like a star. She's going places."

[2.0] "Looking good is not enough. She is very early into her career but has shown little to no improvements since her debut. Not at all surprising given her career thus far has consisted of practically nothing but minute long squash matches to attempt to build her as some sort of monster character. Unfortunately any match progressing beyond that minute mark really exposes her limited ability in the ring. She often looks lost, mistimes her offense frequently and the concept of selling seems lost on her currently. With the baffling decision to make her the inaugural TBS Champion long before she is ready we really have to hope she can step it up a few dozen notches and fake it till she makes it for the sake of the title itself. That or have someone remove it from her sooner rather than later so she can go back to Dark where she should work longer matches to pick up the experience she so desperately needs."

[10.0] "Stunning physique and very charismatic. Obviously needs more experience but she definitely has the potential to become one of the greatest star in the business. She just needs to work on the in-ring capability and AEW have got yourself a complete and perfect package."

[5.0] "Stunning physique and very charismatic. Obviously needs more experience but she definitely has the potential to become a huge star"

[6.0] "Jade is good given where she is in her career. She is not a great wrestler yet, I don't think anyone can honestly claim she is. But the 0-3 ratings on here are just as false. She's an absolute dream to market for any promotion and 'Smart' Mark Sterling is a perfect foil to help her along. Booked correctly as a champion who thinks they're above wrestling often she can do a great job. Lots of flaws to sort out but way more upsides."

[6.0] "Strange people get very angry about her as they get worked by her character and personality. AEW division had to begin from a standing start and adding Jade helped bring something very different to the division. She is hardly the most polished worker but few wrestlers in history have had develop in such a public environment"

[6.0] "Jade is an extremely high ceiling prospect that hasn't had a true breakout match yet. She is an absolute freak athlete, at least in the strength department, and is looking like she is the next TBS Champion. This next stretch should be a true opportunity to solidify her spot in the AEW Women's division, as she will have no excuse to not perform with the caliber of opponent she will be going up against. The potential is limitless, but she needs a lot of reps to get there."

[4.0] "Uh...unique look I guess but her in-ring skills just aren't there. Even for the little experience she has had, her moves are just glaringly bad and she got pushed way way too fast. Could have used being in a stable of some kind before being pushed to the prominent role she is in, in the women's division. It is what it is and now she seems to be stuck there which is a mistake not on her part, but AEW's."

"She's doing just fine for her first year in wrestling. Has a good look, athletic, and is improving more and more. Give her a couple years."

[4.0] "Stands in the ring and flexes more than actually wrestle. Super basic wrestling skill set, the only thing she has going for herself is looks and that won't get you far in Wrestling."

[3.0] "She has the looks but is bad in everything else, this isn't that bad though because she has plenty of time to work on that and AEW seems to be very confident in her."

[6.0] "Far better than she's getting credit for for her level of experience. The presence and charisma is undeniable, and her promos have a great Dominique Jackson style delivery that deserves more appreciation. She is working simple and clean right now with short matches and it's fine. People will be praising her in the next couple years."

[1.0] "Terrible wrestler. No idea why AEW brought her up to be on Dynamite and Rampage. But she shouldn't be. So many great female wrestlers but she is not one of them. She is similar to Asya from WCW. Has a lot of muscles, but no Ring skills at all. Horrible on the mic and horrible in the ring. To me she does not have a good look or much athleticism either. She is just strong that's it. She needs a lot of work."

[3.0] "She's very beautiful and good looking but these are not enough to give her a high rating. She needs to improve and i don't understand why she still winning squash matches."

[3.0] "She? s definitely got a good look, very intimidating. But she? s super green. If she can sort that out, I think AEW has something good here."

[4.0] "She's adequate as a rookie, but barely so. It seems however that AEW is trying to make a "super rookie" out of her, and this is what is ticking a lot of people the wrong way: I kinda agree on that point since pulling off the whole super rookie thing requires either a phenomenal natural talent (like Chihiro Hashimoto) or Paul Heyman/Rossy Ogawa powers of booking. Unfortunately Jade Cargill is not the former and AEW doesn't possess the latter. Still this doesn't mean she could become a very good wrestler."

[3.0] "Someone Tony Khan signed because of her looks. Hey, reminds me of what Vince McMahon would do back in the late 90s to mid 2000s and we know how spectacular the WWE women's division was back then. I think AEW needs to develop their young green talent somewhere else than Dynamite. Who's interested in seeing someone that can't wrestle fight a jobber for 1 minute and then give a lousy backstage promo that was rehearsed 50 times? Do that away from national TV."

[8.0] "The negative reviews here miss the point by such a degree that it's borderline hilarious. No, Jade Cargill isn't a five star match machine right now. But here's the thing: SHE DOSN'T NEED TO BE. Her look, physicality, strength, athleticism, presence, and charisma make her an instant factor in AEW's women's division. Her one match so far that wasn't a squash (the Shaq match) was a lot better than expected. And also: she's incredibly green. In other words, she will likely improve significantly as a worker. If she does, she'll be a huge star. Even if she doesn't, she'll be very good at filling the role AEW has used her in thus far."

[4.0] "You know in the career mode of sports games, when you sign a rookie who has a really low rating owing to inexperience, but a potential rating of like 95? That's Jade Cargill. She has all the athleticism to be the greatest women's wrestler in the world, I really believe she has that high a ceiling. But as she is now, she's just so green and so lacking in even the basics. I'd love to see her trained in a technical style, maybe work on her striking game. Honestly, her options are endless. She needs the right trainer to mold her into something spectacular, but as it stands, she is top-shelf clay and not much more."

[8.0] "You may say I overrate ? But guys, this woman means MONEY and ENTERTAINMENT. And if you don't trust me, the future will answer us. But her in-ring quite good and her charisma omg. We'll see but i'm confident."

[1.0] "Despite her good athletic appearance, she is absolutely unprepared for her current role in the elite, and indeed in wrestling."

"Puh.... bin überrascht über die hier bislang gezogenen Punkte.... Die wenige gesehenen Matches waren allesamt einfach schlecht, irgendwo auf CZW Dojo Niveau. Das ist in Anbetracht ihrer gerade erst gestarteten Karriere doch auch logisch. Der Body ist vorhanden und jetzt liegt es an ihr, das Handwerk von der Pike auf zu lernen."

[6.0] "A 6 is a very good baseline for her right now. She looks like a million bucks and radiates star quality. Any casual person that's flipping through channels should instantly stop when they see her. She can only improve from where she's at right now. Her promos have gotten much better, and particularly her taped ones are legit. In ring she obviously has work to do (mostly psychology related), but she's solid currently. Hopefully she picks up more power moves in the vain of people like 90s Scott Steiner, Scott Norton, or Ice Train. Honestly, Ron Simmons videos would do her wonders. The sky is the limit for her as long as she stays the course."

[6.0] "For someone who has been training for roughly 2 years or less, I have to say Cargill has a really solid start going off of the April 14th episode of Dynamite and previous matches. Her strong suit is definitely her charisma and her abilities on the mic. She can deliver a decent promo, and she does so with a great amount of confidence off the bat. Obviously with the little in-ring experience Cargill's had, she isn't going to be perfect, but from what we've seen, she has shown that she will get better with further time and training."

[7.0] "She has huge potential, I think one day she is going to be aew women's world champion. She has started so great her career and she looks so strong in her matches. I think she is going to have a bright future."

[6.0] "It feels a little unfair to rate someone who has only had two matches. So consider this a rating of "first impressions" of sorts. Jade is one of AEW's true homegrown talents. AEW has had some issues with debuting new additions to the roster, & Jade's debut was no different. She was involved in a wildly convoluted story with Brandi & Shaq, which ultimately had to take a drastic left-hand turn when Brandi got pregnant. She's confident on the mic & has an impressive physique. Her much publicized debut match tagging with Shaq was much better than it potentially could have been; but Jade's spots were kept pretty simple & was obviously very rehearsed. Her only singles match was essentially a three-move squash match & nothing was bad, as long as you ignored the amount of time Jade played with her hair in between spots. She's clearly still very green, but that can be forgiven when considering the amount of time she's been doing this. AEW's women's division has been horribly handled since the company's origins, so anyone who can add to that division is nothing but a positive. Jade has potential & here's to hoping AEW continues to handle her well & she can prove herself in the ring & as a character."

[6.0] "Dafür das sie erst vor kurzem mit dem Wrestling begonnen hat, zeigte sie in ihren zwei Matches bei AEW bisher eine ordentliche Leistung. Ich bin optimistisch das sie in spätestens zwei Jahren eine große Rolle spielen wird."