[6.0] "A fine wrestler with still a lot to improve. He is skilled in the ring, but being a good wrestler is much more than that, imagine being a great one. For now, he still developing and is an encouraging prospect"
[7.0] "Extremely talented wrestler that WWE has no idea how to utilize. If he was booked better, he'd probably have a match better match catalog than he does now, because he's too talented for the average catalog that he has."
[9.0] "He could be a great underdog babyface, and I hope WWE management sees that too. Another bright star from the indie scene who should shine in WWE."
[7.0] "I have not seen too much of Legacy, but I have been impressed every time I have seen him. He has a great look & seems like he really gets his character in ways that many members of the current Performance Center members don't get theirs. It's too early for me to rate him higher than a seven, but he's someone to watch out for & I would not be surprised if he ends up being superior to this rating sooner or later."
[6.0] "What and unique moveset! But his hairstyle is just GOOFY. He could be an interesting star on the mid or upper-card but i cannot see him on the main roster as someone with storylines or good feuds, also he has to improve his character and promos, at least he has potential as underated star just like Dolph Ziggler, Cesaro or Ricochet."
[6.0] "Sean Legacy is a solid wrestler with a natural baby face personality and a good wrestler look however I have no earthy idea as to why he has so many 10s and 9's. I'm mainly familiar with him from his brief NOAH run where he was fine but didn't fully fit in evidently and his so far few NXT and WWE EVOLVE stuff which has been a better fit for him."
[10.0] "Absolutely outstanding wrestler who deserves all the praise he's been getting, great look and move set along with a name that truly is "Super". No doubt he'll soon be the face of wrestling and will be holding some gold soon."
[10.0] "Sean Legacy isn't just a name -- it's a statement. He's the spark that ignites the ring, the storm every opponent fears. With unmatched agility, explosive strength, and a mind sharper than steel, Sean doesn't follow the standard -- he sets it. Every move is precise, every moment unforgettable. He's the kind of wrestler that doesn't just win -- he steals the show. The crowd doesn't cheer for Sean Legacy... they believe in him. He's not the future of wrestling -- he's the standard right now. Remember the name: Sean Legacy -- because legends aren't born, they're built, and he's building a legacy one match at a time."
"A great wrestler. From the very first moments you can see how much potential he has. I am shocked that a wrestler with such skills was in the background for so long."
[10.0] "My Rating 9.7 Sean Legacy is the future of WWE and the future of the wrestling business. There really isn't anything bad to say about Sean. Everything that I have seen so far has been amazing. I considered giving a full 10 but left some wiggle room. I think one day he'll be a Wrestlemania main eventer."
[8.0] "Sean Legacy is Super! He's definitely the standout of WWE Evolve with his offense along with presentation being so well-done. In-terms of In-ring abilities, he does it so crisply balancing strength and agility and I have hope he'll be a valuable asset in NXT later on in his career!"
[8.0] "The standout of WWE ID/ WWE Evolve so far. Legacy seems like the total package with his look, in ring ability, charisma and mic skills. He has had good runs in Japan before this but now he seems more ready to evolve into a huge star."
[10.0] "Well, good luck doing that finisher to guys bigger than him then. I kid, but what a find for WWE amidst their working relationship with NOAH, his natural charisma that matches with his unique moveset along with his ability for in-ring storytelling, all comes naturally to him and he will go far."
[9.0] "A great lad, he has everything. The look, the size, the charisma, a natural babyface with a crowd popping moverset, good psychology to be the perfect underdog you want to root for. His finisher, massive moveset, relatively young age, and experience in NOAH is gonna make him far. His class is gonna need a forefront and Sean Legacy looks like the guy, a potential top guy if he keeps going."