[1.0] "She doesn't have it. She's definitely a great athlete but there's not much she does well and has surprisingly little control over her body when doing her tag finisher. I also have to deduct points for being anti-vax. Sure, we can only make this about wrestling but some things are beyond overlooking. Here's another one trained by Sara Amato that isn't any good. At some point someone has to notice and assign some responsibility to Amato for her obvious failures as a trainer."
[3.0] "I can't remember a single match I've watched with her or Carter wherein either of them have done anything that have stood out in any way. They are minimally competent in-ring, & I was about to say that they had received belts far too soon, but upon research, to my infinite horror they are an average of 7 years into this thing, making how utterly basic & unremarkable they are completely inexcusable. They both have physique issues & both fail to work around them in an industry built by people that worked around physique issues. She really needs to wield her physical abilities like a katana before I take another chance on watching a match with her in it. The Kabuki Warriors more than deserved to take the belts off of them, & they absolutely deserved to be dropped in the recent budget cuts."
[5.0] "Someone who should be so much better the is you trained the generational talent like Sara del ray Amato but she has none od the skill sara had maybe it it is s WWE work style that robs her of the a Chanche to show her ability that she has learned from elite level trainer. this expands to her very lacklustre match output 55/100"
[3.0] "Other than being in a tag team with someone, Im not sure what they can do with her; shes athletic but thats about it. No character, no charisma, and no personality other than that I have a friend. Usually in this amount of time, you can tell who has potential and who doesnt, and she doesnt."
[5.0] "She's very athletic but that's it.. I may be harsh but other than being in a tag team, i don't see what she could do. I fear for her because in the next 6 months/a year, i suspect that the women's division is going to be stacked with a few callups (Roxanne, Giulia, Vaquer) and it's going to be hard to even stay on the roster."
[5.0] "It's obvious that Katana Chance is athletic, and I sincerely believe that she could make a good team partner. Assisted by a good partner, she can play the card of the fast wrestler who uses her opponents' strength against them. In fact, her team with Kayden Carter is pretty good, solid and they have an innovative chemistry and movepool that's fun to follow. On the other hand, if we're talking in-ring only, her shots and holds really lack impact most of the time. I think his size and stature have a lot to do with this, and you only believe in him when you're doing a precise sequence or a well-written team move. But it's hard to imagine him anywhere else on the map."
[5.0] "Katana Chance is really not good enough in the ring and unable to deliver her finisher quite well. Her selling is pretty awful. She's still new to the scene so hopefully she will develop soon because someone her experience has so much room for development"
[8.0] "Katana is good in the ring and on mic she is alright, but with her move-set she can be a real star in the ring. I like her team with Kayden, but I'd like to see them both have solo runs and see how they can do on their own. I've always thought she was the better of the two so seeing her have a solo run would be cool and I'd be interested to see where she could go. She's also one of those people that are most likely always going to be a face, but if she were to turn heel, with or without Kayden, I think that could elevate her to a new level and make her character more interesting."
[4.0] "Not a big fan of hers. For someone who can't really even hit their tag-team finisher well, I can't give a high rating to, and that's just the beginning. Her looks don't match her name "Katana"... but you know whose name she does look like? "Kaden Carter". Both of them need to swap names (not that that's possible). Plus, on top of that, her extremist beliefs? It's a no from me."
[7.0] "Kacy is an amazing athlete which makes her matches exciting to watch. She has not found a way to stand out on the main roster in her tag team with Kayden. Her size does not hurt her as much as it would have in the past with smaller women like Bliss paving the way for her. Not familiar with her being great on the mic."
[9.0] "I love this girl. I am very happy with his current matches in NXT for the tag title along with Kayden. She's always been good and seems to be getting better now that she's reached the top of NXT."
[5.0] "Gute Athletik, passender Look, aber wrestlerisch und auch als Persönlichkeit sind da noch ein paar Lücken, die sie scheinbar nicht schließen vermag. Mit Carter im Team ergänzt sich das passend, aber auf Solo-Wegen sehe ich keine Chance - pun intended."
[7.0] "Kacy Catanzaro is fantastic in the ring. Her athletic prowess is unbelievable and her energetic personality accentuate this even further. She was previously a bit bland in terms of looks and promos, but she is rapidly improving on both fronts. Alongside Kayden Carter I think they could both be big stars."
[7.0] "Kacy is small but her style fits. She can do some amazing acrobatic stuff. She is in a tag team with Kayden Carter and they seem to be good friends. I think people will get behind them with the proper push."
[4.0] "I wouldn't be surprised if she becomes a big star in a couple of years. But now she is quite green and so far her only strong point is her excellent skills in the ring."
[5.0] "Kacy Catanzaro is an Awesome perfomer, but been such a great and athletic perfomer doesn't mean good wrestler. She's kinda flat in selling and not a good storytelling"
[8.0] "Leider wird Kacy noch nicht richtig eingesetzt. Sie hat sehr viel Potenzial um zu den ganz Großen zu gehören. Ihre Fähigkeiten im Ring finde ich sehr beachtlich und Promos hatte sie derzeit noch nicht und können deshalb nicht bewertet werden."
[8.0] "One of the most exciting new prospects in developmental. Being the first women to conquer American Ninja Warrior, Kacy is a huge get for WWE. In the few matches she's been showcased on, her potential abilities come in spades. Talking is going to be the biggest hurdle for her to get over. Even in her YouTube videos when she's talking naturally she feels stiff as a board. Delivering WWE's scripted lines is only going to make her look worse."
[9.0] "Kacy has only been in the wrestling business for under a year now and typically I don't like to rate wrestlers when they're still green since I think it can be unfair but Kacy really broke the mold on that one. She is incredible in the ring and plays the perfect underdog. Standing at 5" and weighing 100 pounds she is able to move around the ring like no other and can make the simplest of bumps look brutal. Her experience on American Ninja Warrior helps a lot with her endurance so maybe this'll open the door for other ANW competitors to transition to the WWE."
[9.0] "Kacy Catanzaro is a phenomenal athlete, which over and over prooving her natural born in-ring talents. I'm very impressed on her performances at Mae Young Classic episodes. With her large potential and heart-touching American Ninja Warrior's story i see her like a future big superstar in WWE women's division."
