Giulia

[10.0] "giulia is one of my favorite wrestlers of all time and one of the all time greats. she's the reason i got into more joshi wrestling and why i checked out stardom. her feuds with tam nakano and stephanie vaquer are some of my favorite work from her. i had high hopes when i heard she was coming to wwe and was so excited for her debut going face to face with roxanne perez, but that hype has long since fizzled out. what wwe are doing with her is beyond words and it has made me and others even question why she was signed in the first place. she's gotten buried twice in the past year and creative is always talking about how people who are over get opportunities, but you never GIVE her any opportunities? she split up with kiana james and it has done absolutely nothing for either of them. she's been relegated to main event lately and just wasn't in the summerslam ladder match at all. how do you even fumble someone like giulia? they have completely stripped her of everything that made her the beautiful madness and are acting shocked that she's not over. she is one of their best in ring workers and you wouldn't know it because they don't let her showcase it at all. just so disappointing and i hate even saying it but i hope giulia just goes to someplace she's respected."

"giulia always look like she already won an argument nobody else knew was happening. like the bell ring and she got this FACE that say okay fine i will hurt you now since apparently thats what the schedule says. presentation is excellent, hair is excellent, attitude maybe illegal in several countries. then match get going and she does not wrestle pretty just because she look pretty which i respect ALOT. she will make everything uncomfortable and mean and suddenly the glamorous entrance feel like a warning everybody ignored. sometimes she slow down and stare too long for me because okay yes we understand you are dramatic PLEASE CONTINUE, but then she throws one strike and i forgive the entire pause. i dont always follow the strategy because i am not a wrestling professor. i just know when giulia is mad the match gets better. she has star energy but not clean safe star energy. more like star that might fall out sky directly through your roof. very watchable. probably expensive roof repair though"

[10.0] "Booked like a goddess in Stardom. The final boss in Stardom. She was booked reasonably well in NXT but has suffered on Smackdown. But. I feel it will come. Let her be Giulia from Stardom and you've got a winner and a gem in her. The paring with Kiana James hasn't done her any good. Her US title runs have been awful but she ZERO competition. I'm a huge fan of hers and I just want her on top of the WWE women's division. She should be the face of Smackdown by now and have the division built around her."

[7.0] "I dunno, she just doesn't seem to shine when standing next to the likes of IYO, Asuka, Kairi, etc...."

[10.0] "Some of the reviewers had been commenting on giulia's wwe run, whilst forgetting about her stardom and marigold run. Yes, her main roster run had been a disaster but at least creative is finally realizing that giulia could go over as a face (she is also good as a heel but it wouldn't work in the west), but don't forget that giulia can be a shoot style wrestler who can literally hit people with her head"

[10.0] "I wanted to wait until she got her first real push but with everything they only want to push those showing off their body and lots of skin. This great performer is being held back for being conservative with her body. A better wrestler than many former womens champ we had in the past year. Her time is coming with her new babyface push."

[5.0] "Unfortunately, Giulia being handed a title shortly after her WWE debut has been pretty much it. I care so little about the Women's mid-card and the title never being on PPV means I can't even remember if it's the Women's I-C or U.S. Title. I said her going to WWE was a mistake and that the women's mid-card titles would bomb and sadly, both of my claims have been verified. Giulia was really good on the Indies, like really REALLY good, but now in WWE, she's languishing in the mid-card with a title that seems more like a prop than an actual measuring stick of talent and you can't keep blaming the bookers. I'm not sure if Giulia has even had a promo. I want to root for her, no arguments there, but the way she's been pigeon-holed just rubs me the wrong way. There's also the matter that her 2 reigns as Women's U.S. Champion were forgettable and the cumulative days are shorter than her lone reigns as NJPW Strong and Goddesses of Stardom Champion. I'm sure she has got it, but I have to agree with what the IWC has said, WWE got her not because she was their next A+ star, but only because they didn't want AEW to come knocking."

[5.0] "Yeah, sorry, I just don't see the hype. Giulia really hasn't done anything that stands out since being called up from NXT, and lately she's mostly been the one taking the pin in tag matches. It even feels like Kiana James is getting more of the spotlight over her. I don't really see a big future for her in WWE at this point. She's definitely a solid in-ring worker, but her promos haven't been strong, and she hasn't really connected with the crowd."

[10.0] "Really good wrestler with a lot of talent and aura in STARDOM, Marigold, and NXT that is unfortunately marked by horrendous booking in the Main Roster, two title reigns that ended up with nowhere to be seen and was almost buried by the time her first U.S reign ended due to a short match against chelsea green. I wish she would move back to NXT because she shines better there and has more freedom yet management rushed the hell out of Giulia. Still, she's a good wrestler if they even bother giving her a chance."

[5.0] "Giulia still has so much gas in the tank and she's still young but she's been awful for like a full year now. Probably, she got the same WWE curse every wrestler coming from Japan has had wherever they step foot here"

[8.0] "If this was a year or two ago, she easily would have been a 10. However she needs some momentum in WWE. She has shown many times that she is one of the best wrestlers in the world and is easily better than 90% of the women in top positions in WWE. Her match with Syuri at Dream Queendom 2022 is one of if not the greatest women's wrestling match IMO. It just sucks that booking in WWE doesn't let her shine. She has can also play a great character, but WWE doesn't even let her do that. I just hope creative can find something to do with her before it's too late. An incredible talent who just needs to be given a chance."

[10.0] "One of my favorite wrestlers of all time. Shes the embodiment of a cool charismatic mafia boss. Her in ring work is flawless. Her character work is second to none. Shame she retired in 2024 and never to be heard off again;("

[5.0] "You can tell who has only seen her in WWE. That's a shame. Her work in Stardom and smaller shows around the world told a different story. Sadly in WWE when one person makes up their mind and someone in charge agrees then that's that. As her WWE career progresses however, one of two things is true. She was never that good or WWE makes people worse. She has shown none of the great qualities that made her sought after. I hope listening to Rossy was worth it."

[8.0] "As someone who has seen her best work in Stardom, averaging her rating would be unfair. In Stardom she came off as absolute boss. She put on technically great, stiff, and hard hitting matches. On the Main roster, she's looked like a parody of herself. I can't put too much blame on her though. Getting rolled up by Chelsea green in less than 2 minutes is a recipe to erase credibility from a wrestler. She still has Charisma for days, and while she's getting presented better in 2026, it's clear she's toned down her style for WWE."

[10.0] "Giulia really shines in competitive and intense matches. She can tell a story in the ring and bring real emotion to her matches, and you can see all of that by watching her work in Japan. It's a shame that in WWE most of her matches are short and have interference, but when she gets time and clean matches, you can see how great she is."

[10.0] "Phenomenal in the ring, was used tremendously in Stardom and Marigold (before she injured her wrist) and had some really awesome rivalries especially with Tam Nakano. It's such a shame that WWE severely nerfed her with all the booking as of late. The core audience doesn't know what she truly has to offer for the product :("

[9.0] "Stupidely good in ring, it's crazy how much WWE has botched her on Smackdown. The beautiful madness is a great character, and Kiana James to me does not compliment her as much as I actually like Kiana. Giulia has had some of the most amazing matches I've ever seen in Japan, and her run in NXT while short was very sweet. I think she's a lot better as a babyface than a heel, although she's fine playing both. Her english is also getting a lot better, so in a couple years I'll consider her promo work. Until then she's awesome, wish she would be booked better. 9/10"

[9.0] "She's actually really good in the ring, I love her finisher. I think she's quite charismatic. Seems like no one's feeling her, though. Her mic skills are not good, and I won't deny that. About her weak reigns, I won't blame her at all. I mean, it's not her fault, honestly. The company should be literally acknowledging what she has done around the world. I have no idea how these people are rating her below a 5"

[9.0] "Giulia is so underrated in WWE, she's really good in the ring but can be iffy on the mic. The fans disrespecting her hurts me cause she doesn't deserve the disrespect. Her entrance is amazing and theme is really good"

"Giulia is my favourite Stardom wrestler of all time, Natsupoi a close second. Everything about Giulia is great."

[8.0] "poor giulia she can be a main event , but with that poor booking she become a ramdom wrestler with less of 5 minutes to show how good she is , very sad"

[2.0] "It was very terrible. She is neither beautiful nor crazy. Her poor imitation of dreadlocks is very much like the image of a "banana person" rejected by Asians. The gimmick that WWE gave her is too bad and boring. I initially had some expectations for her performance, but I didn't expect her to be so unmotivated. Julia does not meet any of the criteria for the main roster, and her wrestling skills are far inferior. She is constantly hyped up by the media and fanatical fans, and can be called the most overrated female wrestler in the history of women's pro wrestling. WWE has overly hyped Japanese female wrestlers, making it seem like any Japanese female wrestler can enjoy excellent treatment. She has also successfully dragged the Women's United States Championship down to another level."

[10.0] "Giulia is a wrestler who relies on presence, physical intensity, and in ring emotion far more than English promos, and that is not a weakness unless you strongly prefer WWE's sports entertainment style over a more pure pro wrestling approach. She is a great wrestler and in ring storyteller with a diverse offensive arsenal, a cool and distinctive look, and a special entrance that immediately sets her apart. She is also willing to take risks and perform high impact moves when the match calls for it. The problem is not Giulia. The problem is that she is currently stuck in short five minute matches and taking losses to wrestlers below her skill level, which limits what she can show and is completely out of her control. Even so, in August she gave Zelina Vega one of the best matches of her career, proving that when given time and space, Giulia is still one of the most strongest high level in ring performers in WWE."

[4.0] "I despise how overhyped wrestlers get because they do moves well. Moves is not pro wrestling, pro wrestling is a package, and Giulia is not a good pro wrestler. She is not strong enough, she doesn't have anything very memorable about her look or wrestling style, she can't do good promos in any language AFAIK, she can't do character work, she can't do comedy, she just does moves well and looks pretty. That's all."

[10.0] "She's been criminally booked since going to the career death trap that is the Smackdown's Women's Division. Jade Cargill holding a world title before this woman is absolutely criminal."

[10.0] "Giulia has been my favorite wrestler for a long time, so I won't pretend to be impartial. But even setting bias aside, it's hard to deny her greatness. Since her days in Stardom, she has always had the "It" factor. She improved quickly in the ring, and her ability to portray a powerful, intimidating heel is something that can't be taught, certainly not at the level she reached so early in her career. From the beginning, Giulia carried matches with her crowd control and in-ring psychology, even when her execution was still rough around the edges. Today, she's a complete package: a world-class technical wrestler with crisp holds and reversals, strikes that land with frightening realism, and a jaw-dropping strong style that feels raw, emotional, and violent. Her selling and bumping add another layer of authenticity, you often feel like you're watching a street fight. Her character work is equally exceptional. Giulia doesn't need to rely on cheating to be an effective heel. She exudes menace through her presence, charisma, and stiff offense, convincing fans she's genuinely there to hurt her opponents and ruin their night. And yet, despite being a villain, she's magnetic enough to draw admiration from the crowd without needing to turn face. Few wrestlers can walk that line as effectively as she does. She also thrives under pressure. Giulia consistently delivers in big-match situations and isn't afraid to take dangerous bumps if it helps elevate her opponents. That willingness to give while still protecting her aura is part of what makes her so unique. Her booking on WWE's main roster has been uneven so far. While she's been given a title, the matches have too often involved interference or lacked the spotlight she deserves. Giulia shines brightest in clean, one-on-one contests where her storytelling and psychology can take center stage. When the company puts her against one of their beloved babyfaces, without distractions, the wider WWE audience will finally see the star power that Stardom fans have known for years. Giulia is everything you want in a wrestler: credibility, psychology, charisma, athleticism, and that rare aura of danger. She's unique, fearless, and unforgettable, a once in a generation performer who is already proving herself on the biggest stage."

[9.0] "She's presented nicely when she first arrived in nxt, feels like a big star, i think she adapt well with wwe style from what I've seen from her matches in nxt it's mostly good and can improve even more, but the thing is she needs more tv time and opportunities on the mr, she's the us champ ffs, the booking between us and ic title is very contrast"

[10.0] "Giulia was always a stand out, from her time at NXT to her short Smackdown run, she steals the show whenever she's on screen. She exudes charisma and character with her in-ring work and has an incredible look that's instantly recognisable. Destined for the top of the card sooner rather than later, Giulia is a well deserved 10/10"

[8.0] "Good wrestler with a very unique look. Her in-ring skills make up for the lack in the size and strength department."

[9.0] "Giulia is one of the most compelling and complete wrestlers in the world today. From her Stardom rise to making waves in WWE, she blends charisma, striking looks, and a hard-hitting in-ring style. Her evolution from "Dangerous Queen" vibes to a true main event-caliber performer has been remarkable. Giulia's matches consistently deliver drama, violence, and emotion -- a true allrounder who brings something different to every feud. With her recent transition to WWE's SmackDown brand, her global appeal is only growing. The "Glorious Driver" alone is a highlight reel finisher. Sky's the limit."

[7.0] "I think Giulia is one of the best Joshi wrestlers of the current era. She's super charismatic and is an absolute beast in the ring. She's also part of my favourite women's match ever against Syuri and ger winning the title is one of my favourite Stardom moments. I just don't think Giulia has managed to get used to the WWE style. When they let her go all out, like in her match against Jordynne Grace, she's still phenomenal. But she heavily struggles to connect with the crowd and her in ring performances have been underwhelming. I don't know how much I like her in WWE right now, I'm really mixed. Her overall would obviously be a lot higher but I rate people as how I currently view them so I think 7 is fair"

[8.0] "Giulia is a Joshi star who stands out in WWE. She has a very unique style in the ring that is fun to watch. She is not the best on the mic, but she definitely has a ton of charisma."

[8.0] "A pretty interesting wrestler. She has a very distinct style that not many can adapt too and she also hasn't shown much outside of that style. But when she does go against people that can match her, she does not miss."

[8.0] "One of the fastest rising stars of the current era and for good reason. From the outset, Giulia has carried herself like a major talent, and she works at a level of intensity that makes her work equally plausibly as an underdog who won't go down without a fight and a boss level fighter capable of intimidating others. After a string of some of Stardom's hottest matches of the COVID era, she has arrived in NXT alongside Stephanie Vaquer and immediately re-established that brand as the premiere women's roster on the planet. Already it looks like the equally strong pushes each woman has received has inspired them to strive harder and higher, and provided she can stop herself from destroying her body too quickly, superstardom appears well within reach."

[10.0] "Guilia was my first. First all girls wrestling. Saw Stardom Show with her and Kairi Sani. It was everything I love in Joshi to this day. I told my wife I was in love. Kairi was savage, cold and distant. But Guilia was rage and in your face. I'm her mark. I was with her. From Stardom. Before Marigold went down. And I hated her. And I screaming inside. And I followed her. And she broke her arm. And I was there. And she was in the Fed. And I tried to forget her. Then NXT got Stephanie Vaquer. And then Jordyn Grace. I watched a NXT show that was all female talent. I told my wife, not one girl on it was under a B+. NXT is the best females division in wrestling right now. Grace, Vaquer, Guilia. Keep your four Horseman. That's three Aces'. 93' Atlanta Braves. Now, this week, Guilia faces Rhea Ripley and Iyo Sky. DREAM MATCH! I don't like WWE but Shawn Michael's knows Joshi. NXT should eject the men stage a coup. So I have a secret hope, that Guilia has joined WWE to burn it down from the inside out and free herself of men. That's a heavy lift I know. But if I've got one girl to do it, it's Guilia."

[8.0] "Giulia is AMAZING ! She's so charismatic, she's a great in-ring performer who's for sure will conquer the biggest stages in professional wrestling today."

[8.0] "Giulia reminds me of Kairi, especially in the days of the Mar Young Classic or her NXT reign. Explosive, fast, fun, very talented and with an atypical look and personality. Her physical prowess, intensity and ability to be both heel and face (like many Japanese wrestlers) make her a must-see right now, and a pleasure to follow. Her entire character stands out from the crowd, and shines as brightly as her in-ring talent. She too may lack a little charisma (for a WWE program with a very particular will), but I hope she'll be given the place she so richly deserves, and that she'll be given more respect than Asuka or Kairi. Seeing Iyo Sky's treatment gives me some hope."

[8.0] "Giulia is one of those wrestlers who generates a lot of debate. Some people hype her up as an absolute elite talent, while others claim she's overrated and not as good as advertised. The truth? She's somewhere in between. She's not as elite as her biggest fans make her out to be, but she's also far from being bad. If there's one thing she undeniably has, it's presence. She carries herself like a star, and when she's fully committed, she's willing to take risks with her body, something that comes straight from that pure STARDOM energy. That said, I personally prefer Stephanie Vaquer in every aspect--whether it's wrestling, charisma, or overall presentation. But I won't deny that Giulia is a very solid performer. She knows how to work a match, she can be stiff when needed, and she has that aura of a top-tier competitor. At her best, she delivers high-quality matches, and while she may not be elite, she's still one of the top names in women's wrestling. 8/10 feels fair--very good, but not god-tier."

"She has been like my second favorite wrestler in Stardom, and was proven to be more than capable in the ring. That being said, she's just a megastar in the Japanese joshi economy. The way she fights does not suit the western ecosystem whatsoever. Much like Shinsuke Nakamura or Kairi, their movesets are instantly cut and the safety of those moves are strictly regulated the moment they set foot into the states. Giulia relies heavily on heavy striking moves, as well as some insane aerial movements. But as we already know, you aren't really allowed to do anything other than a standard moonsault or splash once you enter the WWE. It also doesn't help that she barely speaks English, all that charisma and aura goes out of the window. People holds onto her former greatness dearly, and I get that, but she will not be another Iyo Sky. Another classic case of Japanese GOATs being ruined by the rapid change of system."

[10.0] "Giulia quickly became one of my favorites, she's a full package, I love how she mixes hard hitting offenses with agility and aerial mastery, and she also has the look and has the charisma, she'll soon be an icon of women wrestling. Note: if you think she is bad just because she doesn't do flips or flashy moves then you know nothing about wrestling. Sorry"

[5.0] "Today I would not rate her, but leave a little comment on Giulia. I've never seen her outside WWE, but judging her by NXT appearances I can admit she speaks a little English, although she could read her text from the screen. If it's true, such a trick works on NXT, but it won't on bigger brands. To be honest, I didn't feel that aura people talk about when I saw and listened Giulia past week. The only advantage I notice now is her specific look, however, she's not the only beautiful woman there. So as of today I see nothing special, although I'm going to watch her at least two months to rate her without bias. Updated: as of today, she is nothing special to be rated as high as she's been here. She doesn't entertain, gets no reaction, which shows who she is indeed: another woman with a decent in-ring skills who pretends to be a star. I do see no charisma the Net get used to talking about. Her presentation is tasteless, but at least she can do moves like everybody in WWE"

[10.0] "My God, Giulia exudes aura, her entrance, her face, her ability in the ring, EVERYTHING about her is amazing, a star who positioned herself in WWE as a threat, now with her NXT title she will show more of what she is capable of in the ring"

[10.0] "Obviously all the hype around her move to the WWE was going to create a lot of interest around her work and build this massive expectation for her to excel. And, wow, she really came and met all expectations! This is a future "best in the world" talent."

[8.0] "I try not to be overly critical and there are times where I can find myself doing that... This is not one of those moments. I was introduced to Guilia in NXT. I was an instant fan. She has everything. The look and the charisma. She has the aura and an awesome entrance. I also love that she updated that entrance with a mask. She looks cool as hell. One thing she needs to do though... She needs to improve on that English. So she can give us some good promos. There is a reason she has so many nicknames and she proves that every time she steps in the ring. Also congratulations to her for becoming NXT Women's Champion. It was well deserved."

[5.0] "Take off the rose-tinted glasses and go back to watch her STARDOM run. She wasn't very good, certainly was never the best out of the whole roster and struggled to keep up pace. She was also awful at executing submissions. Surprisingly enough, I actually think she's gotten better ever since joining WWE, as despite how low quality their wrestling can be, at least they teach trainees the proper fundamentals of professional wrestling. Over time, she'll get better at doing submissions. And even though the pace will slow down, in this case... It's for the better."

[10.0] "One of the Best Active Wrestlers ever, and I can't wait to see her more and her Title run. She is a natural Main eventer, and I can't wait to see her in the Main roster, but also i would love to see her face the likes of IYO SKY, Bayley, Charlotte and more."

[10.0] "Giulia is a true icon, building a legendary reputation in Japan long before ever stepping into a WWE ring. Her global recognition speaks to her unmatched talent and star power, and as soon as she debuted in WWE, she felt like a natural fit--instantly over with fans. In the ring, Giulia is one of the greatest women's wrestlers of all time, blending technical mastery, hard-hitting strikes, and storytelling in a way that few can replicate. What sets her apart, though, is her aura--something completely unique, commanding attention in a way no woman in wrestling ever has. Giulia isn't just a star; she's a generational talent who elevates everything and everyone around her."

[10.0] "Beautiful Madness! She quickly became one of my favourites coming over from Japan. She was born to be wrestling in America tbh. Her, along with many others will be the flag bearers for women's wrestling in the WWE for the next decade and I hope I'm here to be able to witness it all"

[6.0] "Honestly one of most overrated wrestler in the world today. I have seen her old matches recently and found nothing special about her apart from her look and entrance. She got too much much hype for no reason whatsoever. Her style is quite similar to Nakamura. I doubt she will get any type of success in WWE's main roster."

[10.0] "Having been a fan of Giulia since her days in STARDOM, it's hard for me not to rate her the full 10. Her transition from working the STARDOM / Marigold style into the more relaxed WWE style has been amazing, especially considering she'd spent a large majority of her career being able to headbutt and spike people with little to no worry. I was initially concerned that she'd struggle to adapt to working with less skilled opponents, but her more recent Iron Survivor win, as well as matches against the likes of Kelani Jordan, Lash Legend and Jakara Jackson show that she is having no problem adjusting to the WWE style. She is an amazing acquisition for NXT and WWE as a whole, and I can't wait to see her shine brighter on a bigger stage."