 # | Name | Promotion | Career Start | Career End | Length of career | Rating | Votes |
| 1 | Looney Lane | 09.1999 | 2008 | 9 years | |||
| 2 | TJ Perkins, TJP | 08.1999 | 27 years | 7.29 | 376 | ||
| 3 | Lita | 09.01.1999 | 2023 | 24 years | 8.34 | 553 | |
| 4 | CM Punk |  | 1999 | 27 years | 9.25 | 2612 | |
| 5 | Aaron Aguilera | 1999 | 2019 | 20 years | 3.95 | 56 | |
| 6 | B-Boy | 08.1998 | 28 years | 6.32 | 75 | ||
| 7 | Jay Bradley | 1998 | 28 years | 5.70 | 55 | ||
| 8 | Rudy Switchblade | 12.1997 | 2020 | 23 years | |||
| 9 | Ricky Reyes | 13.09.1997 | 29 years | 5.55 | 84 | ||
| 10 | Rocky Romero |  | 13.09.1997 | 29 years | 7.42 | 331 | |
| 11 | Christopher Daniels |  | 03.04.1993 | 01.02.2025 | 31 years | 8.66 | 788 |
| 12 | Ace Steel |  | 10.1991 | 34 years | 6.61 | 68 | |
| 13 | Rod Guile | ||||||
| 14 | Draconis | 2018 |
