[7.0] "While not the greatest presence, the man is pretty good in the ring. His mic is limited, but not bad. His best work is certainly as a tag team wrestler, as he can't quite shine all by himself. It's not needed to look far for a proof of this. Bobby was a great compliment to the Undisputed Era."
[8.0] "A solid wrestler who was part of one of the best tag teams in ROH history and one of the best stable in NXT. Solid in the ring and while he was moving towards the end of his career, AEW dropped the ball in not reuniting the Undisputed Era under a different name. Bobby was lost in the shuffle due to the bloated roster. Whether as a trainer, a stable mate to Kyle or my preferred option of gradually moving him to a manager role, you can see the value in Bobby Fish."
[2.0] "Bobby Fish fand ich immer extrem langweilig und erinnere mich an keinen coolen Moment oder Match mit ihm. Im Ring leistet er ordentliche Arbeit, aber das tun alle anderen auch. All die Jahre hatte er nie ein Gimmick, Charakter oder auch nur Storyline die über absolutes 08/15 hinausgeht. Das einzige Wiedererkennungsmerkmal ist der Schnauzer. Vor allem seine Zeit bei AEW habe ich gesehen und da war er als Sidekick von Adam Cole in einer angemessenen Rolle, hat aber auch nie eine Duftmarke hinterlassen können."
[4.0] "Bobby Fish is a good wrestler but he lacks the size, look and personality to be anything more than what he is. He's best as part of a tag team or apart of group, he doesn't have the capabilities to be a singles competitor at all. He's also injury prone and QAnoner"
[6.0] "Was a solid veteran and one of the shooty bros I love so much. However, he is very weak on the mic and should be a 4-5 rating, but is one of the cleaner looking MMA technicians in wrestling still to this day and was doing it years before others did it."
[6.0] "Bobby Fish is one of wrestling's biggest has-beens, if we're being harshly honest. His stints with Kyle O'Reilly in reDragon and with O'Reilly, Adam Cole, and Roderick Strong in WWE as the Undisputed Era were fun. His AEW stint was fine. After that... not much. As of now, he's taking any booking he can, from places like Impact, MLW, and NJPW to the Crash and any indy fed he can find. His ring work was fine. Not much to talk about."
[2.0] "Im Ring ok, aber sonst so farblos, dass es fast schmerzt. Einen Charakter hat er nicht, Charisma ebenfalls nicht und am Mikrofon ist er einfach untragbar. Zu mehr als Midcarder in den Indys taugt er einfach nicht. Das sieht man an seiner Promo bei Impact, die im Internet zum Meme gemacht wurde, aber eines ganz deutlich zeigt: er ist ganz einfach kein Star und wird es auch nie werden."
[5.0] "Perhaps the pinnacle of average in professional wrestling. Size? Average. Ring work? Average. I cant recall a terrible promo from him and I cant recall a great one."
[5.0] "He's fine, pretty much average. Not the best promo or worker, but certainly not bad either. I will say the "where's the lie" promo will be a meme forever though lol."
[6.0] "Fantastic in the ring. Most memorable in tag team matches or in factions, especially with Kyle O'Reilly and the Undisputed Era. Unfortunately not very interesting on his own and while he's still a good singles worker, he's never had a standout singles match that I'd call memorable"
[4.0] "Bobby Fish is a capable wrestler and that's the best I can say about him. He's good in tag team matches, but the memorable singles bouts he's had I can count on one hand and they're all accompanied with wrestlers who are leagues better than him. reDRagon was amazing, but Kyle O'Reilly is the Shawn Michaels to Bobby Fish's Marty Jannetty."
[6.0] "The other half of one of the best tag teams ever. He's a solid worker and plays a good heel when by himself but after that he's pretty meh. I liked some of his promo work in roh where he was just Kyle's dad and shit but he's nothing special. One of those cases where he's a good enough guy to have around by himself but is wayyyyyyyyy better when with his tag partner"
[4.0] "Yeah Fish is an injury prone midcard wrestler. O? Reilly is definitely the more talented of ReDRagon. He can't seem to get a job without O? Reilly"
[6.0] "Bobby Fish has had a long career in the business, who's been a great tag specialist for all of it. Bobby Fish, who is best with KOR, is solid in the ring, though isn't a great promo -- though he doesn't really need to."
[7.0] "Großartiger Tag Team Wrestler, im Singles Bereich nur ordentlich. Funktioniert mit ReDragon und Adam Cole wunderbar. Veteran im Ring, der weiß was er tut, am Mikro aber nicht mehr als okay. Hat seinen Platz bei AEW gefunden und erlebt einen guten Karriereherbst."
[6.0] "The best way, and apparently an already widely accepted way to describe Bobby Fish, is as a "really solid hand". The dude will never elevate a match to greatness level on his own, but he's at least capable of preventing a match from dipping below being 'alright' at the very least. His MMA-inspired style is cool, with all his strikes connecting with strong impact and his submissions looking snug. His technique isn't on the level of his long-time tag partner Kyle O'Reilly, and he doesn't have too much of a character outside of being rather smug and generically heelish, but he's a performer who dedicates time to making his matches look realistic and competitive, which I appreciate. Maybe him, O'Reilly, and Cole can bring the hype of Undisputed Era over to AEW and thus elevate Fish further, but he's already in his mid 40s, and he's had a successful enough career already, so I'd content if he simply remains a skilled veteran who can be called on for a good match every now and then."
[7.0] "Really really solid hand when it comes to his in-ring work. His look isn't that bad either the mustache suits him. But he is kind of boring and needs to constantly be in a stable or tag team to remain relevant and not floundering like a fish (yes bad pun I know). Either way, you can put him in a match with someone and expect something good to come out of it, and that does make a difference at the end of the day."
"8.0 Veteran finding his stride, and his mojo as of late. Move to AEW and MLW suits him. Proving he is on the same level as his former Undisputed Era stablemates"
[5.0] "His best in-ring days are behind him and that's all he ever had to offer. He is the least interesting person in a stable with Roderick Strong. Theoretically that shouldn't even be possible, given that Strong is as vanilla as it gets."
[6.0] "A relatively solid worker, even if most of his best work is in tag bouts. Fish however has nothing beyond in ring skill to showcase: he's really not remarkable in any way and lacks a gimmick to actually utilise in the ring, so there's nothing much to discuss. By far the weakest member of the UE by a good bit."
[7.0] "Sehr starker Wrestler, gut im Ring und am Mic. Für mich, kann er sein ganzes Potential nicht ganz ausschöpfen bei NXT. Da geht vielleicht noch mehr."
[9.0] "Fish is insanely underrated as a performer, he probley is the weakest member of the UE. However your only as strong as your weakest link and Fish is a fantastic wrestler."
[8.0] "Bobby Fish is a very good wrestler, he is very good at tag team matches, and reDRagon is one of the best tags today, and as a solo wrestler he is good, his singles matches are not MOTYC, but they are very solid, and perfect for the Mid Card."
[7.0] "Fish works great with O'Reilly and just as well as a part of Undisputed Era. Unfortunately, he's getting up there in both age & in the injury department. I hope he continues to be a player with UE when they make the move to the main roster, but another injury might lead him to more of a managerial role in the future."
[8.0] "Bobby Fish is very good and have a nice look, but I think he's better at Tag Team Matches, just like Akira Taue. But don't get me wrong, his singles matches can be very good and awesome, like the one against Katsuyori Shibata."
[6.0] "Solider Tag Team Wrestler, der aber etwas schlechter als sein Tag Team Partner ist, daher nur 6 Punkte für Bobby Fish! Wenn sich das Booking der amtierenden NXT Tag Team Champs verbessern sollte, sehe ich auch Potential nach oben."
[9.0] "Bin vermutlich einer der Wenigen hier, die Bobby Fish marginal stärker einschätzen als seinen reDragon-Kollegen Kyle O'Reilly. Herausragende und stiffe In-Ring-Arbeit, haufenweise Charisma und toller Mic-Worker, all around nur knapp an der Höchstwertung vorbei. Bin gespannt auf seinen NXT-Run mit Cole und O'Reilly."
[9.0] "Ein weiterer, harter, stiffer Wrestler der mir super gefällt. Hamoniert mit Kyle O'Reilly perfekt als reDRagon. Wie O´Reilly hat mich auch Fish bei Singles Matches absolut überzeugt. Hat Charisma, spielt aktuell seine Heel Rolle super. Sein Wrestling Stil ist hart und gnadenlos für den Gegner. Ein Edit: Ist nun auch bei PWG angekommen und auch da hat er gezeigt was er kann. Edit 21. 12. 2017 Bei Bobby ist ein Update man sowas von nötig. All das was die letzten 3 Jahren passiert ist werde ich nicht nochmal aufzählen. Ich finde es gut das es mit ihm Kyle und Adam nun auch bei NXT bestens klappt."
[8.0] "Bobby Fish ist einfach ein großartiger Performer! Ich finde ihn Unglaublich Charismatich, ganz gut am Mic und sehr Gut im Ring. In der Tag Team Divison an der seite von Kyle O Reilly wohl eines der besten Teams der Welt, aber auch im Singles bereich überzeugend! Trotzdem finde ich persönlich O Reilly besser."
[9.0] "Great talker and could be a great heel in ROH. He proved me wrong with his wrestling skills. He has been able to put outstanding matches with the likes of Shibata and most recently Cole in Manhattan Mayhem."
[6.0] "Acceptable wrestler, acceptable promo. I like his kick based offense but I don't go out of my way to watch a match of his. I don't buy him as an ROH upcarder but soon they might not have a choice."
[5.0] "Average defines who Bobby Fish is. Average in mic, average in ring, average in selling. Just doesn't have much charisma. Is useful to ROH's midcard and as a partner of Kyle O'Reilly. Fish is for Kyle O'Reilly what D-Von is for Bubba."
[9.0] "I'm really impressed by Bobby Fish, and i dont know how people dont see it. He is charismatic, great on the mic, good on the ring as well, and his tag team with Kyle is one of the best in the world right now."
[8.0] "bobby fish is a good wrestler i believe he fits the spot he is in better than anybody in any spot in the world i believe after 13 years of wrestling he deserves the tv title and he needs to keep it for a while and i hope he gets a little main card push on down the road"
[7.0] "Bobby Fish is very good as both a singles competitor and as a tag team competitor with Kyle O'Reiley. He has a very impressive move set and can do a lot in the ring. He is fair on the mic but has no real gimmick but I personally dont think he needs one. His tag team with Kyle O'Reiley is great and they always put on fun matches."
[8.0] "The man that started wrestling at the age of 27, and made it to the top of the independent wrestling and ROH, so fun to watch with all that strikes and submissions, congratulations to the new TV champ."
[10.0] "Bobby Fish is great, he is so much underrated. He has an amazing technical style. His tag team with Kyle O'Reilly is no doubt one of the greatest right now, but he can be so much more then just a tag team wrestler."
[5.0] "Bobby Fish is a solid wrestler, not great, but not bad either. His tag run w/ Kyle O'Reilly has been pretty fun (so far), and they've had some really good and even great matches together. And his match vs. Bryan Danielson is without a doubt a classic."
[10.0] "Einer der seine Rolle liebt, egal ob Tag Team oder Single, Face oder Heel, er spielt nicht, er lebt es! Mit dieser Glaubwürdigkeit, kann noch einiges folgen!"
[7.0] "Bobby ist ein solider Wrestler, der für auf mich aber zunächst sehr unspäktakulär wirkte. Erst beim zweiten hinsehen fiel mir auf, dass er in ausgewählten Matches mehr als nur Standart zeigt, beispielsweise kürzlich in seinem Match gegen Nick Jackson. Für sein Team mit Kyle und seinen coolen Stache gibts die 7."
[9.0] "It's always cool to see a local boy made good, and has Bobby Fish ever made good over the past few years. As half of reDRagon with Kyle O'Reilly, he has effectively owned the ROH tag division, holding the belts for the majority of the past two years. While he's excelled as a tag wrestler as of late, he's also more than capable as a single, with a mix of technical skill and striking ability as well as some great charisma. A great talent who's finally getting his due."
[10.0] "When Bobby Fish debuted in Ring Of Honor back in late 2012 as a babyface and then turned heel the same night joining Kyle O'Reilly forming a tag team that would later be known as ReDRagon, I never saw any of his work before coming to ROH and I wasn't completely sold on him yet at that point in time. But now after watching Bobby Fish for almost a year and a half, he slowly but surely became one of my favorite wrestlers to watch in Ring Of Honor! I'm really so entertained by his character personality as a heel in ROH that he has convinced that I think he would still be a funny and entertaining heel if he wasn't teaming with Kyle O'Reilly! Not only that but in-ring work wise, he has impressed me so much as well and he's had some incredible tag team matches in ROH since he's been there."
[6.0] "Seitdem er sich diese neue Frisur zugelegt hat, ist er vom oberen Durchschnitt ins graue Mittelmaß abgedriftet. Kein Glatzentyp, und Glatze haben heute auch viel zu viele Wrestler."
[7.0] "Bobby Fish ist in den Indies immer ein garant für ein gutes Match. Klar hat er nicht die Ausstrahlung eines Austin Aries oder Bryan Danielson, aber er liefert konstant gute Leistungen und seine Tour durch Japan hat ihn nur noch weiter nach vorne gebracht. Ich erinnere immer gerne an die absolut starken Leistungen bei EVOLVE gegen Claudio, Hero oder Danielson, 7 Punkte."
[7.0] "Der Mann ist schon gut. Natürlich hat er eine Ausstrahlung wie ein Sack Mehl, aber das ist in den Indies auch nicht immer so wichtig. Da zählt Leistung für mich und die bringt er konstant."
[7.0] "Klasse Worker mit gutem Body! Hat mir bei Evolve bisher sehr gut gefallen! Leider habe ich keinen seiner NOAH-Auftritte gesehen, darum erstmal nur 7 Pkt."
[5.0] "Technisch wirklich beschlagen, aber leider mit einer ähnlichen Ausstrahlung "gesegnet" wie Chad Collyer oder John Walters. Ich würde ihm für seine Leistungen im Ring gerne mehr Punkte geben, aber irgendwie .... kann ich mich einfach nicht dazu durchringen."
