| 1 | 28.02.2025 | crs285 | 2.0 | On tough enough she proved to be overly green but had a personality the fans got behind enough for her to win. Retired shortly after because she wanted to have children. Overall she could have improved greatly if she kept training. RIP Sara Lee |
| 2 | 09.07.2023 | dwight | 3.0 | |
| 3 | 23.05.2023 | AidanArcher | 5.0 | |
| 4 | 20.08.2020 | WhatIsLooveee | 1.0 | As always, the participants achieved more in the company than the winners. Really hoped to see Sara in action in the ring. it's a pity that everything turned out like this |
| 5 | 09.08.2019 | KyleEnjoysWrestling | 0.0 | Yet another formula change for Tough Enough & another instance of them getting it all wrong. Sara Lee wins because she had a likable personality. That's all there is to it. She was one of the least skilled athletically & was a bumbling mess on the mic. A complete waste of everyone's time & WWE's money. |
| 6 | 20.01.2018 | divafanatic | 0.0 | Absolutely awful. The only reason she won Tough Enough was because she didn't have the model look. There's a reason why she didn't even have 10 matches in her career and got released soon after. She was abysmal, she had nothing to offer, always smiled through promos/matches, couldn't bump, do moves, nothing. |
| 7 | 07.09.2016 | Ice | 5.0 | Not a very good wrestler, but has insatiable babyface psychology. This is the sane middle opinion to the extremist ratings. |
| 8 | 05.09.2016 | WWEfanchampionship | 10.0 | Some people may dislike Sara Lee because they think she won Tough Enough out of popularity, but since training in the WWE Performance Center and competing on NXT house shows, she's proved that she really did deserve it. |
| 9 | 24.05.2016 | KO FanGirl | 10.0 | |
#