[6.0] "I wanna rate her more but she's barely used... I absolutely love her look, there's something very attractive in her that makes her stand out. She has a certain aura around her due to her gimmick and entrance music. She's decent enough in the ring from the little we've seen of her (not her fault obvi...), she also does pretty good whenever she's managing KLR. Imo she did the witch gimmick much better than Alexa, it came off natural to Isla and they turned KLR because she was lacking a gimmick and nobody was buying her. So if it wasnt for Isla, KLR was gonna be another Mia, Lyra or other directionless woman who couldnt cut it on her own. Now on the bad. She always plays second to KLR, sometimes she is even excluded from matches like the RR and tournaments, i mean i think it should be 50/50 with both of them getting the same opportunities, not just KLR. And it must be said she has an absolutely horrendous accent, that makes me wanna mute the TV when she talks."
[8.0] "Competent and charming. I like Unholy Union but lets break them up and let her and Alba feud with that white hot intensity they had back in NXT."
[7.0] "Isla Dawn is a really entertaining wrestler with a very interesting gimmick. She has tons of charisma and she's alright in the ring + she has room to improve. I hope to see her and Alba having solo runs in the future."
[5.0] "Isla Down has undeniable abilities in the ring, but she still needs to improve to be more precise and refocused, as well as developing her microphone skills, which are less than exceptional. All the more so as her gimmick requires a great deal of expertise if it is to be convincing rather than bizarre."
[4.0] "Isla Dawn is a below average in ring worker. Her promos are actually give me second hand embarrassment for some reason. She is awful at the microphone. She has been wrestling for over ten years now and she is still not good enough as a wrestler and with no improvements."
[6.0] "Like Fyre she has a good unique gimmick and look. She has a presence in the ring and is alright on the mic but has room to improve. In the ring she has proven to be good as a tag wrestler."
[9.0] "She is a decent in-ring performer, has a unique look, a nice gimmick, and makes a great tag team with Alba Fyre. In regards of her mic skills, just as Fyre she has a very strong Scottish accent that at sometimes makes her difficult to be understanded, but she is average on them, she is confidence while talking and that is something. Maybe she just needs to stop doing those kind of cringy mannerisms with her hands, but out of that she is impressive. Hopefully she gets to be more featured on normal TV programs instead of just Main Event. I will give her a nine cause she overlived almost her entire fellas from NXT UK and one of the reasons are her in-ring skills, and as well she still has potential to grow even more."
[6.0] "Still a bit young with room for improvement. Glad she's working with Alba Fyre, they can learn from each other. Has a lot of room for potential story lines."
[6.0] "She's good enough in the ring, interesting character/look but she just doesn't stand out to me as far as the NXT UK women's division is concerned, she's middle of the pack."
[7.0] "Isla Dawn has the most beautiful creamy skin of any professional wrestler that I have seen and a lovely face as well. Having said this, I do not care for her white witch gimmick with all the extra makeup. As for her wrestling skills, she has powerful kicks and is pretty strong as well. She is one of my favorite wrestlers and I hope that she stays in the business a long time."
[7.0] "I really like her. She's got a great vibe and aura to her, while her ring work is a work in progress. She's getting better and has more of an edge now. Plus she's only 26, so her best days are hopefully ahead of her. I'm biased, but I'm giving her a 7"
[7.0] "I see Isla as a work in progress. I really like her look, but at this point I feel like it is only half there. I think she could do more to get the most out of it. In ring she is still developing. She's not bad, but she could use some more intensity & aggression. I feel like she's sub par on the mic & she just sounds like she's going through the motions. She needs to be careful that she does not fall into being purely an enhancement talent on NXTUK."
[9.0] "Isla Dawn may not be the best wrestler out there, but she sure is quite talented. Her gimmick of a feminist white witch is also very interesting, although I do think it would be more attention-drawing if her character was a more supernatural/sinister character like Undertaker or Rosemary. Nonetheless, Isla is a WWE superstar with a lot of potential, hope she gets a chance to win the UK Women's Championship."
[5.0] "Ich hab in letzter Zeit eine Menge guter Wrestler, sowohl weiblich als auch männlich, gesehen, die aus Schottland kamen, nur kann ich das leider hier von Coutney nicht sagen! Charisma, um mit dem Publikum zu spielen, ist da, es ist auch ein wenig Grundtechnik da, aber da steht kein In-Ring Charakter hinter! Wenn Sie sich alle Beine ausreißt, kann das noch was werden, ansonsten, sehe ich keine große Zukunft für sie!"
