| Timeframe | Title | Duration | Details |
| 20.03.2026 - 14.08.2026 | WWE Tag Team Champion (3x) (with R-Truth) | 147 days | Matches |
| 07.04.2024 - 03.08.2024 | WWE World Heavyweight Champion | 118 days | Matches |
| 16.10.2023 - 06.04.2024 | WWE RAW Tag Team Champion (2x) (with Finn Balor as The Judgment Day) | 173 days | Matches |
| 16.10.2023 - 06.04.2024 | WWE SmackDown Tag Team Champion (2x) (with Finn Balor as The Judgment Day) | 173 days | Matches |
| 02.09.2023 - 07.10.2023 | WWE RAW Tag Team Champion (with Finn Balor as The Judgment Day) | 35 days | Matches |
| 02.09.2023 - 07.10.2023 | WWE SmackDown Tag Team Champion (with Finn Balor as The Judgment Day) | 35 days | Matches |
| 21.08.2021 - 28.02.2022 | WWE United States Champion | 191 days | Matches |
| 22.08.2020 - 28.10.2020 | WWE NXT North American Champion | 67 days | Matches |
| 16.06.2018 - 29.09.2018 | ROH World Television Champion (as Punishment Martinez) | 105 days | Matches |
| 16.04.2016 - 10.12.2016 | MFPW Heavyweight Champion (3x) (as Punisher Martinez) | 238 days | Matches |
| 26.03.2016 - 11.08.2016 | KPW Tag Team Champion (as Punisher Martinez; with Matthew Riddle as Ultimate Punishment) | 138 days | Matches |
| 05.09.2015 - 19.03.2016 | MFPW Tag Team Champion (2x) (as Punisher Martinez; with QT Marshall as Gifted Punishment) | 196 days | Matches |
| 06.06.2015 - 11.07.2015 | MFPW Heavyweight Champion (2x) (as Punisher Martinez) | 35 days | Matches |
| 19.07.2014 - 14.02.2015 | MFPW Heavyweight Champion (as Punisher Martinez) | 210 days | Matches |
| 16.11.2013 - 22.02.2014 | MFPW Tag Team Champion (as Punisher Martinez; with Brolly as The Legion Of Anarchy) | 98 days | Matches |
| Title | Duration |
| KPW Tag Team Championship | 138 days |
| MFPW Heavyweight Championship (3x) | 483 days |
| MFPW Tag Team Championship (2x) | 294 days |
| ROH World Television Championship | 105 days |
| WWE NXT North American Championship | 67 days |
| WWE Tag Team Championship (3x) | 355 days |
| WWE United States Championship | 191 days |
| WWE World Heavyweight Championship | 118 days |
| WWE World Tag Team Championship (2x) | 208 days |
