[9.0] "Fatu ist ein Mann, der im Indie-Bereich immer herausgestochen ist. Sieht so aus, als könnte er jedem Normalo dem Kopf abreißen, hat eine großartige Ausstrahlung und ist super im Ring. Ich bin sehr gespannt, was er bei der WWE zeigen wird."
[5.0] "As an athlete, Jacob Fatu is insane. Super heavyweight that flies better than most folks half of his size. His cardio is unreal for someone of his size and stature. He's easily someone that fits in the main event of any company. That being said, as impressively athletic as he is, I can't name a match he's had that has really stood out. I can't recall a promo that stands out. The dude is athletic as hell, and he has a presence but if a smaller guy were doing the moves he does, they'd be a "solid indie guy". I still think he needs some time to wrestle veterans, but he's definitely really damn awesome to watch. I also feel he doesn't exactly have the absolute greatest matches. He has impressive feats and promos, but if we are going to call others spot monkeys, we should do the same for Fatu."
[6.0] "A great look and I like him but his resume of great matches is not exactly considerable, on here he only has 10 matches that would equate to 3.5* plus. I fear he would be exposed hugely on a bigger platform."
[8.0] "Fatu is a beast, he has it all, speed, power, a connection with the fans, and is smooth on the top rope one of the better wrestlers in modern times."
[10.0] "He needs a bigger platform. He has everything you need to be an absolute mega star in the industry, but just needs more eyes on him. Has incredible presence, is crazy athletic for his size, and can hold his own on the mic. Fatu is absolutely the real deal"
[10.0] "Jacob Fatu is ridiculously good. MLW doesn't deserve him, he'd be a national league superstar anywhere else. He's athletic and has an incredibly intimidating presence. You can look at this guy and just know he kicks ass."
[6.0] "Fatu is one of those guys I think who gets hurt by the hype. He's okay and could very good wrestler someday. But I hear people act like he's the biggest name out there on the indie scene or some must sign prospect. He's a agile big man doing a meh savage gimmick"
[10.0] "Jemand, den ich absolut gerne zusehe im Ring. Ein Powerhouse, der fliegen, brawlen und wrestlen kann. Ich kann bis dato einfach noch nicht glauben, dass dieser Mann unter Vertrag bei einer Top-Promotion steht. Denn dieser Typ ist eine Maschine und hat eine super Ausstrahlung. Setzt ihn einen Manager an die Seite und du hast dein Face of the Promotion."
[8.0] "Fatu ist eine absolute Maschine und beherrscht seine Rolle derzeit wirklich gut. Die Ausstrahlung ist da, die (High) Impact-Moves sitzen und so ist er als MLW Heavyweight Champ eine wirklich gute Besetzung. Bisher kontne er nicht zeigen, dass er vielseitig ist und dass er wirklich gut am Mikro funktioniert, aber seine Rolle ist auf den Punkt."
[8.0] "Great intensity and moves really well, everything he does looks like it has purpose. Has a great looking moonsault. CONTRA is quite a bad gimmick but it does not affect him."
[9.0] "He's a really exciting wrestler to watch, a big man who can brawl and fly at times. He comes off as a killer and knows how to portray himself to the fans."
[9.0] "Maybe the best Samoan wrestler ever. His moveset is amazing and he has one of best moonsaults ever. Has so much charisma. Can do almost everything in ring and can wrestle good match with every other style wrestler, because he can alter his own style on the rebound to match other wrestlers style."
[9.0] "Vom Stil irgendwie wie sein Onkel Umaga zu seiner besten WWE Zeit. Nur ist er keine Samoanische Dampfwalze sondern eine Werwolf. Bei MLW ist er eine Gefahr auch mit Contra Unit und auch bei PCW Ultra und sonst wo verbreitet er Gefährlichkeit."
[9.0] "Based on his work in MLW, I think Jacob Fatu is a star in the making. He pretty much has it all: he's a good worker, can brawl and fly, can talk a little, and has the aura of a monster heel. He's a bit of a big fish in a small pond in MLW, but I think he could succeed in a bigger company as well. In fact he might do better once he moves up from MLW due to better booking."
[8.0] "Fatu has easily established himself as one of the best current top heels with his extremely crisp ring work as well as commitment to his character. He went from being just another big guy that can do a moonsault to someone I genuinely am excited to see on my screen via MLW each week in a relatively short amount of time and seems to have an incredible upward trajectory as it's already been stated that WWE and other larger promotions have shown interest in him."