[8.0] "I'm glad he's been booked like an actual threat because everything he did in 2025 was so forgettable and bland. The booking was bad but 95% of the stuff he did was shake his head and say "All gas no breaks" which is unfortunate because I think he's one of the few wrestlers in his family that is actually good."
[9.0] "He's the kind of Samoan I really like; as a fan of Umaga, we're clearly on a higher level here. Right now he's the best in WWE alongside Roman, though we know Roman is part-time. I see a huge future for him, obviously if he's booked properly. I also know that unfortunately in WWE being "good-looking" plays a role in success, and looks aren't really on his side but he can't just be handled as a generic monster heel, because Jacob has much more to offer. Still, it's incredible how he's taken over the main event in just a few months."
[4.0] "How many more Samoans can we watch in WWE. This guy only talent is being part of the family while being undoubtedly bad in the ring . The only reason I didn't get his rating even lower is because his mic work is ok"
[8.0] "Jacob is freakishly athletic for his size and he's just great in the ring. His kid skills are good, but sometimes he's just screaming in the mic about stupid shit."
[7.0] "Vor einer auszeit war Fatu vielversprechend, explosiv und zog ordentliche Publikumsreaktionen. Seine Fehde gegen Solo war Mist, wie so ziemlich alles, was mit Solo Sikoa zu tun hat. Sein Comeback hat man ebenfalls vergeigt. Hoffentlich kriegt man mit diesen Charakter die Kurve."
[9.0] "I hope WWE gives him more freedom and lets him work on the mic. He was great at it back in MLW. Everything else checks out. He's ready made material for a major star."
[10.0] "Insane moveset for someone his size and weight. Among the 5 most complete wrestlers on the WWE roster right now. Like Umaga, but even better and with mic skills."
[1.0] "I dont see the hype, he doesnt do it for me, I'd much rather see a different person be indestructible like he is. But his catchphrase is kinda catchy, I dont like his hair, idk maybe im too harsh but comparing him to others, he is worse"
[10.0] "Absolute Maschine! Seine Aura sein Charakter es passt einfach. Sein Moveset ist einfach krass. Wenn es WWE richtig macht haben sie hier einen Diamanten und zukünftigen world Champion. Er hat so viele facetten Comedy oder Harter Hund. Hoffe das wir in den nächsten Jahren einen großen Push sehen."
[9.0] "Fatu is a very interesting wrestler. He plays his gimmick so well and the companies present him as the monster he plays. His wrestling style matches his gimmick and he has a good promo for the character as well. UPDATE: Jacob Fatu overshadows Solo and eventually became the true star of the Bloodline now done with that and on his own. Honestly, he has been one of the brightest stars in WWE right now."
[10.0] "Charismatic, good at mic, great in the ring. Jacob Fatu - is one of the most young talented wrestlers in the world rn. Definetely future of WWE"
[10.0] "He's the total package, he makes every promo intense, every match a spectacle, and he's such an easy character to get invested in, and so young!"
[9.0] "Definitely one of the best in-ring performers right now. Great promos, and just overall an incredible wrestler. Definitely a future world champion."
[9.0] "Fatu is another guy who I just liked since the moment I laid my eyes on. He's one of the best monsters in wrestling as he looks like one, acts like one and is presented like one. Fatu is Extremely professional, he does everything right, down to the very little things. He's also a very good promo despite his promos being just catchphrases in WWE to the point. Jacob might be the best In ring worker out of every Samoan. He's almost like Umaga with a better presentation and better creative. He's a phenomenal talent"
[10.0] "Jacob Fatu is amazing! I truly think he could be the face of wrestling in the future! His in ring work is sooo good! He is so incredibly athletic and connects with the crowd so well!"
[7.0] "I think his rating is a little high, he has the little things down, he carries himself a certain way which is more than most wrestlers, I don't buy him as the powerhouse he's booked as, he's a moderately large, atheletic for his build guy that they book as if he's a monster, he's just not fitting the bill, he can do a moonsault but we need to see more from him before we judge, I think the internet loves him a little too much for what he's done and is capable of, would be happy to be proven wrong"
[9.0] "He was the guy in MLW. Now in WWE, he's being positioned as the monster of the roster & has so many things & directions he can go in. Someone I definitely want to see more of. Obviously he's also great in the ring."
[7.0] "DUE TO CHANGE* Let's not get ahead of ourselves. He shows unbelievable promise but his moveset is also as limited as other Bloodline members. Ride the wave. If the E push him too quick it won't be long before a lot of peers here and watching turn on him. We know he's capable of greatness but a world title at let's say Summerslam 2026 should be the earliest for me. Ride it out, let him face other talent, hold the US or IC maybe then again does he need such belt? The belt doesn't make the wrestler. The wrestler makes the belt but is he someone who should dedicate to something like the US title? Probably not for me. I think he would look super odd with it. A world title, different but his gimmick etc. Seems like he should give a toss about the secondary titles and work towards that world title in 2026 but let's not rush this."
[10.0] "Put the US title on him, put the IC championship on him, put the undisputed championship on him, put the world heavyweight championship on him. He is absolutely amazing. I truly hope that WWE sees what most of the fans see. Surprisingly, a very good technical wrestler as well, as seen in his matches in MLW. I absolutely love him, this dude will be a HOF in less than nothing."
[8.0] "Dude is a star in the making. Instead of yeet merchant Jey getting a huge push, it should be Jacob Fatu. I can't even remember the last time I've seen anyone as big as this guy with the same level of athleticism, probably Keith Lee, someone I dearly hope Jacob doesn't end up getting ruined like. While Solo isn't downright terrible at the moment, he undoubtedly gets outshined by Fatu, I'm actually surprised he hasn't won the US Title given the fact that he's been around for about 9 months now. He can talk too, he reminds me of black hoodie Uso Penitentiary promos from a time where we didn't have to hear yeet or no yeet every week. Simply put, Jacob Fatu is easily the best active Samoan and possibly the best Samoan ever in-ring, it's hard to believe that Jey is related to this beast lmfao"
[10.0] "Jacob Fatu is my favourite wrestler of this current era. His monster look, his physique, his energy, his athleticism. This guy is a jack of all trades, his explosiveness in his matches makes them every bit exciting. Hopefully WWE take care of him because Jacob Fatu is a rare treasure that they cannot afford to lose."
[9.0] "A fucking rottweiler with crazy intensity and a great moveset. Forget Solo Sikoa, Lance Anoa'i or, Zilla Fatu... Jacob is the next Polynesian beast."
[8.0] "Jacob is extremely good, I usually don't like the Wrestlers of the Anoa'i family, because they are generic, they all use the same Moveset (Superkick, Diving Splash, Hearbutt, and a little more). But Jacob is different, he can excel above all of them, everything is fine. Good that has more matches per individual than by Tag Team."
[8.0] "**insert the HE'S HIM meme** because that's exactly how I feel about Jacob Fatu. HE is everything WWE wanted Solo to become. The guy just has it, the charisma, the look, the in-ring ability, I don't think there's anything he can't do. Might seem like I'm overreacting, but just look at how he wrestles and the aura around him, you can tell this guy is a star. Now, is he going to become the top star in WWE? Who knows, it's really hard to say at this point as he hasn't even been in the promotion for a year. I will say, he has all the tools needed to be the top star, only time will tell if he can live up to it. **02.02.2025** bumping him up from a 7 to 8. The guy is just incredible. Can talk the talk and walk the walk. Great in-ring, great on the mic, has a great look, what more could you ask for? Need to see what he can do in the main event scene as a singles guy before I come back and change my rating. But as things stand, there's literally no stopping him. Will be WWE's biggest star if he continues down this path."
[10.0] "I LOOOV U SOLOOOO. A beast in the ring. Untapped mic potential. He's already a massive draw in the WWE within months of his arrival - that's some serious star power that they'll definitely make wonders with in the future."
[8.0] "Jacob Fatu has only been on the WWE roster for 7 months, but it truly feels as if he is among the biggest attractions in the company. He really does have the aura of a legit badass who can rip your head off. He has an outrageous moveset for a man of his size. I am so excited to see what his future holds, I do feel as if it could be multiple WrestleMania main events, especially when you consider he is still only 32."
[9.0] "I LOVE JACOB FATU! The best wrestler by far in the Anoa'i family, insane wrestling skills, unreal charisma, great in the mic, WWE Should let him have more singles matches so he can show even more how good he is"
[10.0] "Spectacular talent who can do anything he wants in the ring. That pop-up Samoan drop is nasty, as is his version of the BME. You believe every word when he cuts a promo because he's intense and he seems unhinged. Just waiting for him to get his own push instead of just being the enforcer to a less interesting guy in Solo."
[8.0] "Jacob Fatu is an amazing athlete. He may be a big guy, but he can fly through the air with ease. We might see him become a big deal in the future with WWE."
[9.0] "This guy is just incredible. Being really solid in the indys doesn't always mean that your value will follow you while your time in the big leagues, however Jacob Fatu astonished and teared out the door with its frame. I'm really interested what after Bloodline story is waiting for him."
[8.0] "He's booked like a god and he should be because he's very good and the scary thing is that he could be even better. Solo Sikoa looks like a fool next to him, but maybe that's the goal. A future world champion, no doubt."
[8.0] "Jacob Fatu feels like the next big thing. He has all the qualities youd want in a star. His character is engaging and jeez his wrestling ability is top level. Im very excited to see what he brings to WWE in the future. He could very well become one of the greats."
[10.0] "So many good things to say about Jacob Fatu, Incredibly talented and very good at what he does, he makes any match he's in exciting, he has a big, big future in WWE I don't doubt that, if he continues wrestling at his current level, he may be one of the best by the time he retires. Very incredible wrestler in general."
[8.0] "Reminds me alot of his Uncle Eddie Fatu as in he's built like a brick shit house and moves like a corvette. Jacob is an absolute beast of a man with intensity and charisma that's through the roof. He will be a major player in WWE within the next few years"
[8.0] "Jacob is an absolute unit, he can be both a great powerhouse and is very athletic. His run on the indies was amazing and his run in WWE has also been good, already holding tag team gold. Hes relatively young, so he still has most of his career ahead of him. I would bet anything that he will be a world champion in the near future."
[8.0] "Built like a Jeep. Moves like a Rolls Royce. Endless potential, still got a lot to see but impressed so far, give it 2 years this rating will probably be a 10."
[10.0] "I have seen several clips of his work on the independent circuit, including some of his matches in MLW, as well as a video of him tag-teaming with Zilla Fatu. His talent is evident, and now he has made his way to WWE. Based on his impressive debut and his jaw dropping badass entrance theme, I believe he has the potential to become a Omega level star, on a par with The Rock."
[9.0] "With such an indie environment that look upon an anthetic big guy, no one has someone do it better than Jacob Fatu. The Somoan look is always impeccable, his dives and moonsaults are effortless and can always pull something insane occasionally (double jump rope bounce moonsault, Fosbury Flop, etc). actually solid promo he cut in MLW. Really slept on because where he was for the majority of his career up to this point and i dont think that will change anytime soon. edit: well i speak too soon, Roman Reigns your time it up LFG"
[8.0] "Jacob Fatu is a guy who could produce massively on the grand stage of the WWE. Fatu carries a rich legacy, and his performances in MLW have cemented his reputation as a formidable force. His ability to execute high-flying maneuvers and his intense, almost intimidating persona make him a unique asset in any wrestling promotion. His series of matches as World Champion really showed how good he is inside the ring. He can work well with a variety of opponents from Tom Lawler to Hammerstone to LA Park. I see Jacob being molded into the Umaga of this generation honestly and thats saying a lot. The only downside to Jacob is the lack of generating emotion from his interviews however a great manager could fill that void for Fatu. If he stays on his own then he has to improve in that aspect however he delivers in the ring and has the look to be a big star."
[9.0] "This guy is an awesome athlete. Cant wait to see him in WWE. He is so much better than Solo Sikoa in both wrestling and look. He looks like a legit monster."
[9.0] "Fatu ist ein Mann, der im Indie-Bereich immer herausgestochen ist. Sieht so aus, als könnte er jedem Normalo dem Kopf abreißen, hat eine großartige Ausstrahlung und ist super im Ring. Ich bin sehr gespannt, was er bei der WWE zeigen wird."
[5.0] "As an athlete, Jacob Fatu is insane. Super heavyweight that flies better than most folks half of his size. His cardio is unreal for someone of his size and stature. He's easily someone that fits in the main event of any company. That being said, as impressively athletic as he is, I can't name a match he's had that has really stood out. I can't recall a promo that stands out. The dude is athletic as hell, and he has a presence but if a smaller guy were doing the moves he does, they'd be a "solid indie guy". I still think he needs some time to wrestle veterans, but he's definitely really damn awesome to watch. I also feel he doesn't exactly have the absolute greatest matches. He has impressive feats and promos, but if we are going to call others spot monkeys, we should do the same for Fatu."
[6.0] "A great look and I like him but his resume of great matches is not exactly considerable, on here he only has 10 matches that would equate to 3.5* plus. I fear he would be exposed hugely on a bigger platform."
[8.0] "Fatu is a beast, he has it all, speed, power, a connection with the fans, and is smooth on the top rope one of the better wrestlers in modern times."
[10.0] "He needs a bigger platform. He has everything you need to be an absolute mega star in the industry, but just needs more eyes on him. Has incredible presence, is crazy athletic for his size, and can hold his own on the mic. Fatu is absolutely the real deal"
[10.0] "Jacob Fatu is ridiculously good. MLW doesn't deserve him, he'd be a national league superstar anywhere else. He's athletic and has an incredibly intimidating presence. You can look at this guy and just know he kicks ass."
[10.0] "Jemand, den ich absolut gerne zusehe im Ring. Ein Powerhouse, der fliegen, brawlen und wrestlen kann. Ich kann bis dato einfach noch nicht glauben, dass dieser Mann unter Vertrag bei einer Top-Promotion steht. Denn dieser Typ ist eine Maschine und hat eine super Ausstrahlung. Setzt ihn einen Manager an die Seite und du hast dein Face of the Promotion."
[8.0] "Great intensity and moves really well, everything he does looks like it has purpose. Has a great looking moonsault. CONTRA is quite a bad gimmick but it does not affect him."
[9.0] "He's a really exciting wrestler to watch, a big man who can brawl and fly at times. He comes off as a killer and knows how to portray himself to the fans."
[9.0] "Maybe the best Samoan wrestler ever. His moveset is amazing and he has one of best moonsaults ever. Has so much charisma. Can do almost everything in ring and can wrestle good match with every other style wrestler, because he can alter his own style on the rebound to match other wrestlers style."
[9.0] "Vom Stil irgendwie wie sein Onkel Umaga zu seiner besten WWE Zeit. Nur ist er keine Samoanische Dampfwalze sondern eine Werwolf. Bei MLW ist er eine Gefahr auch mit Contra Unit und auch bei PCW Ultra und sonst wo verbreitet er Gefährlichkeit."
[9.0] "Based on his work in MLW, I think Jacob Fatu is a star in the making. He pretty much has it all: he's a good worker, can brawl and fly, can talk a little, and has the aura of a monster heel. He's a bit of a big fish in a small pond in MLW, but I think he could succeed in a bigger company as well. In fact he might do better once he moves up from MLW due to better booking."
[8.0] "Fatu has easily established himself as one of the best current top heels with his extremely crisp ring work as well as commitment to his character. He went from being just another big guy that can do a moonsault to someone I genuinely am excited to see on my screen via MLW each week in a relatively short amount of time and seems to have an incredible upward trajectory as it's already been stated that WWE and other larger promotions have shown interest in him."
