| Timeframe | Title | Duration | Details |
| 21.04.2024 - today | AEW World Champion | 3 days | Matches |
| 26.11.2022 - 08.04.2023 | DEFY World Champion (3x) | 133 days | Matches |
| 13.07.2022 - 21.09.2022 | AEW World Tag Team Champion (with Keith Lee as Swerve In Our Glory) | 70 days | Matches |
| 17.07.2022 - 20.08.2022 | DEFY Tag Team Champion (with Christopher Daniels) | 34 days | Matches |
| 29.06.2021 - 12.10.2021 | WWE NXT North American Champion (as Isaiah Scott) | 105 days | Matches |
| 07.12.2018 - 29.03.2019 | PCW ULTRA Heavyweight Champion (as Shane Strickland) | 112 days | Matches |
| 18.02.2018 - 10.03.2019 | NGW Champion (as Shane Strickland) | 385 days | Matches |
| 16.03.2018 - 18.12.2018 | PCW ULTRA Light Heavyweight Champion (as Shane Strickland) | 277 days | Matches |
| 20.07.2018 - 14.12.2018 | DEFY World Champion (2x) (as Shane Strickland) | 147 days | Matches |
| 04.08.2018 - 28.10.2018 | EVOLVE Champion (as Shane Strickland) | 85 days | Matches |
| 12.04.2018 - 12.07.2018 | MLW World Heavyweight Champion (as Shane Strickland) | 91 days | Matches |
| 08.07.2017 - 13.04.2018 | DEFY Champion (as Shane Strickland) | 279 days | Matches |
| 26.06.2016 - 09.03.2018 | Lucha Underground Trios Champion (as Killshot; with Dante Fox, The Mack and Son Of Havoc) | 621 days | Matches |
| 08.07.2017 - 11.11.2017 | CZW World Heavyweight Champion (as Shane Strickland) | 126 days | Matches |
| 24.06.2017 - 21.10.2017 | WC Ringmaster Champion (as Shane Strickland) | 119 days | Matches |
| 02.10.2016 - 18.10.2016 | wXw World Tag Team Champion (as Shane Strickland; with David Starr as JML) | 16 days | Matches |
| 13.08.2014 - 13.12.2014 | CZW Wired Champion (2x) (as Shane Strickland) | 122 days | Matches |
| 02.08.2014 - 05.12.2014 | VOW Hyper Sonic Champion (as Shane Strickland) | 125 days | Matches |
| 08.03.2014 - 30.07.2014 | CZW Wired Champion (as Shane Strickland) | 144 days | Matches |
| Title | Duration |
| AEW World Championship | 3 days |
| AEW World Tag Team Championship | 70 days |
| CZW Wired Championship (2x) | 266 days |
| CZW World Heavyweight Championship | 126 days |
| DEFY Tag Team Championship | 34 days |
| DEFY World Championship (3x) | 559 days |
| EVOLVE Championship | 85 days |
| Lucha Underground Trios Championship | 621 days |
| MLW World Heavyweight Championship | 91 days |
| NGW Championship | 385 days |
| PCW ULTRA Heavyweight Championship | 112 days |
| PCW ULTRA Light Heavyweight Championship | 277 days |
| VOW Hyper Sonic Championship | 125 days |
| WC Ringmaster Championship | 119 days |
| WWE NXT North American Championship | 105 days |
| wXw World Tag Team Championship | 16 days |
