| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 01.02.2003 |  |
Arrick Andrews & Athena defeat Lollipop & Mortimer Plumtree USACW - Event @ Tennessee State Fairgrounds in Nashville, Tennessee, USA |
| 2 | 25.01.2002 |  |
Horace The Psychopath defeats Mortimer Plumtree SDW Winter Warfare - Event @ West St. Paul Armory7.30 in West St. Paul, Minnesota, USA |
| 3 | 17.08.2001 | |
Elimination: Blood, Danny Dominion, Mini Blood & Rikki Noga defeat Ace Steel, Brad Bradley, Mortimer Plumtree & Primetime (9:00) SDW - Event @ Red Wing Armory in Red Wing, Minnesota, USA |
| 4 | 16.10.1999 | |
SPCW Northern States Tag Team Title: The Montana Extremists (Montana Extremist I & Montana Extremist II) defeat Dan Jesser & Mortimer Plumtree [Replacement for Adrian Lynch] (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! SPCW - Event @ West St. Paul Armory in West St. Paul, Minnesota, USA |
| 5 | 15.03.1997 |  |
JB Trask vs. Mortimer Plumtree - No Contest NPW - Event @ Red Wing, Minnesota, USA |
| 6 | 08.03.1997 | |
2.500 Dollar Eight Man Battle Royal: Scotty Z defeats Dan Jesser and Horace The Psychopath and James Grizzly and JB Trask and Lenny Lane and Mortimer Plumtree and The Chi-Town Thug NPW - Event @ L4.58ake City, Minnesota, USA |
