| Timeframe | Title | Duration | Details |
| 12.07.2025 - 22.11.2025 | AEW World Champion (2x) | 133 days | Matches |
| 20.09.2023 - 01.11.2023 | ROH World Six Man Tag Team Champion (2x) (with Matt Jackson and Nick Jackson as The Elite) | 42 days | Matches |
| 13.11.2021 - 29.05.2022 | AEW World Champion | 197 days | Matches |
| 21.01.2020 - 05.09.2020 | AEW World Tag Team Champion (with Kenny Omega) | 228 days | Matches |
| 20.08.2017 - 09.03.2018 | ROH World Six Man Tag Team Champion (as Hangman Page; with Matt Jackson and Nick Jackson as BULLET CLUB) | 201 days | Matches |
| 30.08.2015 - 23.10.2016 | WrestleForce Tag Team Champion (with Corey Hollis as Country Jacked) | 420 days | Matches |
| 05.09.2015 - 17.04.2016 | PWX Tag Team Champion (2x) (with Corey Hollis as Country Jacked) | 225 days | Matches |
| 19.10.2014 - 14.06.2015 | PWX Tag Team Champion (with Corey Hollis as Country Jacked) | 238 days | Matches |
| 07.01.2012 - 05.05.2012 | CWF Mid-Atlantic Heavyweight Champion | 119 days | Matches |
| 08.01.2011 - 20.08.2011 | CWF Mid-Atlantic Tag Team Champion (with Jason Blade as VA Bombers) | 224 days | Matches |
| Title | Duration |
| AEW World Championship (2x) | 330 days |
| AEW World Tag Team Championship | 228 days |
| CWF Mid-Atlantic Heavyweight Championship | 119 days |
| CWF Mid-Atlantic Tag Team Championship | 224 days |
| PWX Tag Team Championship (2x) | 463 days |
| ROH World Six Man Tag Team Championship (2x) | 243 days |
| WrestleForce Tag Team Championship | 420 days |
