[0.0] "An incredibly cringe wrestler. Nothing he does is worth watching. I instantly skip everything he does if I don't turn off the show completely. If he wasn't Nic Nemeth's brother, he would never have made it to AEW or TNA. Plus there was that whole thing with him suing CM Punk and AEW for that BS reason where he played victim when it could not have been any less about him. He's untalented and not worth watching"
[7.0] "Ryan Nemeth is very good at portraying that obnoxious unlikable heel character. Even his voice is perfect for it, and he is very good at promos. His wrestling skills are fine and he's excellent at selling but you won't see fast paced technical matches from him. He's a super solid worker though. Not as good as his brother in the ring but solid character work and good enough to suffice."
[3.0] "Only known because his brother is good. He's bad at quite literally every aspect of pro wrestling and his character is just super annoying honestly. His stuff with Mara Sade at the moment is 2000 WCW levels of bad."
[2.0] "Im somewhat ashamed that this guy is (besides robert stone which isnt much better) the only wrestler i share a birthday with. He had such a great theme in aew too, his post aew stuff has been god awful."
[4.0] "Used to really find his stuff pretty enjoyable, but it has severely dulled over the years and a guy who I once thought was underrated is who he is now at age 40. A lot of his humor revolved around him being pretty self-aware and pushing the 4th wall, but now I think he's trying way, way too hard to be taken seriously even as an obvious comedic wrestler. A very strange path. Never evolved, never really got better. Just exists nowadays. Occasionally he can do something to make me laugh, but that's it. Obviously was always going to be known as Ziggler's brother, but I always held out hope that maybe he could've carved himself a little niche as a comedy guy. Instead the last few years have exclusively been being Ziggler's brother. I truly believe his only chance at redemption, in my eyes, is to find a non-wrestling role to excel at. Whether it be commentary, presenter, writer, something. But in the ring, that ship has sailed."
[6.0] "Underrated. He is not Kurt Angle in TNA or Kenny Omega in AEW but his annoying character and interactions with his BIG BROTHER! Nic make him someone who matters on the show."
[7.0] "Ryan is actually a much funnier dude than most give him credit for. I find alot of his bits to be hilarious & he is a dependable worker in ring. Has proven in 2025 that he has an ability to generate heat in any crowd pretty quickly"
[4.0] "Ryan is okay. He's competent in ring (nothing more, and he's not exactly "fluid"), and has found a nice thing for himself - the little brother heel who usually gets his ass kicked. I'm never excited for a Ryan Nemeth match or promo, but he occasionally amuses me."
[7.0] "This guy oozes low-key Hollywood charm -- like he's always one smirk away from pitching you a screenplay called "Wrestle Beach: The Reckoning." He's got the bleach-blonde confidence, the smarmy charisma, and just enough in-ring talent to make you say, "Wait... was that actually good? ""
[0.0] "Didn't watch him in AEW so I can't say if he was as horrible there. Obviously hired as a favor to his brother in WWE where he had around five minutes of on screen wrestling time; five too many. Obviously hired as a favor to his brother in TNA where he has done nothing of note beyond killing the crowd every time he comes out. I've never seen a crowd so disappointed in a title booking choice more than the Hardy title match. The life sucked out of the crowd is how I feel every time he's on Impact."
[2.0] "The Marty Jannetty of his team with his brother, Nic. No charisma, no personality, no promo skills, barely any in ring skills. He is also a contender for the softest, most hypersensitive man in wrestling."
[5.0] "Nemeth has carved out a niche in the wrestling world, but he's still best known as Dolph Ziggler's younger brother. There's potential, especially with his Hollywood connections and creative interests, but he's yet to fully break out as a major player. He has shown flashes of charisma and athleticism, and is competent in the ring and on the mic, so there's definitely potential especially if he stays paired with big bro"
[3.0] "Wonderful at being a punchy, annoying heel with go home level heat. He can make a crowd go absolutely nuts...the first time. Then you realize it is literally just "Myyyyyy brooooother" and nothing else. He is a immensely sub-par wrestler, and got away with being a fun squash candidate to build up a babyface, but then they decided to have him "wrestle" with more frequency, and his shortcomings were exposed. There is almost always a place for someone who can drive the crowd wild (even in a "get out of the ring" kind of way), but overexposure is not his friend."
[6.0] "Ryan Nemeth is undeniably talented and brimming with charisma. Don't let his "backstage antics" overshadow that. However, his biggest hurdle is a lack of distinction--he's still primarily known as Nic Nemeth's brother rather than for his own accomplishments."
[7.0] "Solid wrestler, i remember his time in FCW and NXT, he needs to improve maybe now in TNA he could earn more wrestling skills becuase as now most people only now him as the brother of Nic Nemmeth."
[5.0] "The person who will benefit the most (relatively) from Nic Nemeth getting released is Ryan Nemeth. A lot of doors are suddenly open for this dude simply by tagging along with his big brother now. Dude's already gotten a match in WWC and had appearances in NJPW and GCW without having to take a bump. And to be honest, he needed it. Ryan is the definition of mid. The most interesting thing about him is his brother. If you need a warm body to get pinned in a match you could certainly do worse, but that was about the ceiling for Ryan until Nic burst onto the independent scene. Now his ceiling will be slightly higher, most likely to get beaten up by a heel on an episode of Impact to send a message to Nic or to eat the pin when he's teaming with Nic. If you're a weirdo and keep track of things like this, I've said Nic's name more than Ryan's so far in this rating. Not intentional on my part but not surprising either. Oh well, if this doesn't work he can always go back to Hollywood doing 4-second cameos as far better wrestlers and slamming Tim Robinson."
[7.0] "I mean he's got talent, I just don't think AEW is the right spot for him. He may need some independent work on the side more often as well.. but I definitely think he's underrated."
[8.0] "very charismatic and has a good look. love his bits on BTE and wish aew would use him a little more. solid in ring worker as well but his best attribute is without a doubt his charisma"
[5.0] "Er konnte wie sein Bruder reden, wie ein Wasserfall und wenn es sein musste auch die Leute besoffen, aber was er nicht so richtig konnte war im Ring ordentliche Arbeit zu leisten, deshalb wäre er auch nie wie sein Bruder so groß rausgekommen und der Schritt ihn zu entlassen vor einigen Jahre war der Richtige."
[7.0] "I always thought of Briley Pierce as a great WWE interviewer cause he shows more personality than the interviewers in WWE do these days! Plus I've watched him wrestle a couple times on FCW TV as well when him and Brad Maddox were the tag team champions and seeing him be on TV as a wrestler as well honestly has convinced me that he can even bring a lot of personality and charisma to the table when he's wrestling again and on top of that, he's a pretty good worker as well! So I think that would definitely work in his favor! Either way, I'm really happy with what Briley is doing on NXT these days and I'll be happy with whatever he does in the future as well as long as WWE lets him be him on TV!"
[6.0] "Fing bei FCW als Intervierwer an und ging dann aufgrund der Fehde mit Maddox in den Ring und musste erstmal schlechte Leistungen und höchstens Standartmoves zeigen. Langsam darf er auch beweisen das er was kann. Wenn er sich so reinhängt wie sein Bruder kann er noch richtig gut werden."
