Pat McAfee

[0.0] "A contender for the worst full time commentator WWE has ever had. Booker T is horrible but he's on the trainee show. McAfee actively ruined several matches and entrances because he couldn't keep his mouth shut. He adds nothing important, interesting, funny, or entertaining to commentary. It's the thing with this guy in college football too. A lot of those fans who aren't into wrestling also can't stand him. I was never impressed with him in the ring either. He was fine for a non wrestler but a segment of fans were acting like the second coming of Ricky Steamboat was upon us. McAfee wasn't as good as Stephen Amell. Pat McAfee doesn't respect the wrestling business or college football. He respects being a 40 something frat bro who stands during his shows for...reasons...and wears tank tops."

[0.0] "I actually thought he was really good when he first started as a commentator, and he was a decent performer. But over the last couple of years he's become so unwatchable. He tries to make everything about himself on commentary and says just some of the most cringeworthy things I've ever seen. His commentary during elimination chamber 2025 was beyond unwatchable, and if he wants to get better at it, I'd recommend him doing NXT commentary. His performance skills have regressed as well. He had some good performances in NXT, I'm not seeing most of that on the main roster at all. I can't believe they demoted Corey Graves to NXT for him."

[9.0] "Think Pat MCAfee is so super underrated in the ring, and I think he's an extremely entertaining commentator outside of it. Full of funny moments and tidbits, can't really fault the guy personally like..."

[2.0] "Six hundred characters about Pat McAfee is quite a tall task, after all he's basically just a commentator whose gotten between the ropes a few times. Firstly, I try to not rate wrestlers on out of character actions or opinions but I feel due to how he's presented he's exempt from this. Pat McAfee and anyone related to the barstool side of the internet is a cancerous grifter. This guy has absolutely zero redeeming qualities as a commentator outside of the fact that he plays a dipshit babyface. Extremely grating voice as well, veers towards PG era Lawler with how noticeable and obnoxious he is. Awful annoying commentator who hopefully fucks off for good eventually."

[3.0] "He removed so much that I didn't know could be removed from pro wrestling. Turned WWE into a gimmicky snoozefest with his asinine, annoying sports commentary and constant interruptions of promos. He also essentially took away whatever small modicum of respect that I'd gained for Michael Cole too."

[7.0] "While he may not be everyone's cup of tea, You cannot help but admire Pat for his dedication to the business, especially with all the other commitments he has, its clear he loves the job even though he really doesn't need the job. Pat is also a pretty good wrestler when called upon, he checks all the boxes, great talker? Check. Charisma? Check? Wresting ability? Check, so yeah I like him, I know that might be sacrilegious to say according to a lot of the internet marks but I enjoy his stuff"

[2.0] "As of writing this, on the 4th May 2025, Pat is seriously becoming insufferable to sit through. I will give him props for his recent promo on Gunther on Raw, which I'm sure will lead to an absolute barnstormer(! ) at Backlash, however, how can I put this, the dude is such a screaming mark as an analyst that he ruins a LOT of great moments for me. The reaction to John Cena's heel turn on commentary was completely overcooked thanks to his inane shouting and marking out. His repeated knack of trying to get himself over any way he can is incredibly tiring. I'm also not an NFL guy, so a lot of the hype that he has completely goes over my head. Sorry Pat, time to go."

[1.0] "Pat McAfee does not appeal to me as a WWE commentator at all. He was amusing at first, and I can see why some people love him. Still, his outrageous enthusiasm and continuous yelling seem more like a diversion than a benefit for the broadcast. He seems to be striving too hard to be entertaining, but instead, it comes across as forced and grating. His lack of thorough knowledge of the product, let alone wrestling as a whole, irritates me most. Although enthusiasm is fantastic, it cannot substitute real sports knowledge. I love it when Cole and Wade have to side-step him, as he provides no value. Replacing Corey Graves with McAfee was an absolute joke. He will go down as one of the worst commentators in WWE history."

[1.0] "Unbearable on commentary, wasn't too bad in his first run but now he just doesn't know when to shut up and I wish there was an option on Netflix to mute commentary. Unfunny and obnoxious, the worst thing on WWE programming right now, which is already a high bar considering the amount of shit its full of right now. He's better in the ring than on commentary but that is such a low bar to clear. I don't know why WWE keeps him when it seems like few people like him on commentary, he doesn't add anything to any segments or matches."

[0.0] "One of the worst commentators in professional wrestling history. Everything he does is part of a plainly transparent plan to get himself over with what I assume to be his target audience: teenagers who speak in fire emojis and little internet sayings. His vocabulary is limited to that of an engagement farmer on social media. He refuses to be quiet, even during serious moments, and it is never to offer anything valuable. His jokes are never funny, and they kill whatever emotion the wrestler is trying to get out of the audience. It is sometimes just for the sake of just making a noise, like a dog bark or duck quack, because we have to be reminded that he is there. Even down to his little signatures, such as getting on the table as a popular wrestler makes their entrance, or doing his pencil tossing and catch thing that would only truly amuse an infant, he's just so frustrating to watch. He killed key moments like the Cena heel turn, and who could forget Pat whining for an entire show about Canadians booing the US national anthem? He is so attached to the WWE product right now, he feels inescapable. Why is he getting storylines? The less said about those matches, the better. The frat bro persona rubs against my personal taste, but there is a lot in wrestling that is just not for me. What makes Pat a unique case is that he will shout, scream, and "YEET" his way into your consciousness whether you like it or not. I just won't listen to any more of his commentary."

[0.0] "As a wrestler he is ok, but his is one of the worst commenters of this generation. He will ruin serious important moments to make a cheap unfunny joke. Then after that Gunther match he is the only one who really benefited from it, and that just makes me angry. Terrible commentator, ok wrestler but just shouldn't get some of the opportunities he has. I am going to just write about nothing so I can get the character limit reached because I have nothing else to say about this man. As a wrestler he is ok, but his is one of the worst commenters of this generation. He will ruin serious important moments to make a cheap unfunny joke. Then after that Gunther match he is the only one who really benefited from it, and that just makes me angry. Terrible commentator, ok wrestler but just shouldn't get some of the opportunities he has. I am going to just write about nothing so I can get the character limit reached because I have nothing else to say about this man."

[2.0] "As a commentator he is unbearable to listen to and makes me not want to watch as he just says random things during important segments like at Elimination Chamber during arguably the greatest heel turn of all time he was talking about Travis Scott smoking weed. He also doesn't know the name to a lot of moves. If he weren't already famous WWE would have never got him as a commentator. As a wrestler he's ok but really overrated in my opinion and only has decent matches because of who he's in the ring with."

[9.0] "Pat McAfee is everything celebrity crossovers usually aren't. He's authentic, he respects the craft, and he brings an energy to wrestling that's been missing for years. From day one, McAfee showed that he wasn't there for a paycheck or a cameo. He was there because he loved it. His debut match against Adam Cole shocked a lot of people. It wasn't just good for a non-wrestler. It was good, period. He understood the timing, the storytelling, the heat. He knew how to work the crowd, and more importantly, he knew when to shut up and sell. On commentary, McAfee brought back something WWE had lost -- genuine, unpredictable enthusiasm. His banter with Michael Cole injected life into a stale announce team and made SmackDown broadcasts fun again. He's the rare commentator who feels like he's experiencing the show alongside the fans rather than reading off a script. Pat's charisma is undeniable. Whether on commentary, cutting promos, or in the ring, he brings a vibe that feels real. He doesn't try to sound like a wrestler or act like a tough guy. He's himself, and that's why fans connect with him. He brings humor, energy, and heart, and he makes everything feel bigger just by being there. When he steps in the ring, he delivers. His matches at WrestleMania and NXT have shown that he can hang, and his physicality is better than guys with years more experience, shown in his recent match with Gunther."

[0.0] "Absolutely insufferable. His commentary is the shits - all he does is shout over everyone else in a vain attempt to get himself over. Adds nothing to the product and actually takes away from the in ring work. Cannot fathom why anyone would want to listen to the guy. Seems like a right twat as well. Beyond abysmal. Absolutely insufferable. His commentary is the shits - all he does is shout over everyone else in a vain attempt to get himself over. Adds nothing to the product and actually takes away from the in ring work. Cannot fathom why anyone would want to listen to the guy. Seems like a right twat as well. Beyond abysmal. Absolutely insufferable. His commentary is the shits - all he does is shout over everyone else in a vain attempt to get himself over. Adds nothing to the product and actually takes away from the in ring work. Cannot fathom why anyone would want to listen to the guy. Seems like a right twat as well. Beyond abysmal."

[4.0] "When he first became a commentator, he was a breathe of fresh air and nearly everyone loved him. Now, he tries too hard and always tries to speak when it is not needed. PPV commentary teams would be better if it was just Wade and Cole. Pat is good in small doses and I can deal with him for a Raw but he needs to shut up and let moments breathe. In regards to wrestling ability, he's fine. That is it."

[4.0] "Only reason I don't lower my rating for Pat is because his work in NXT was really good and his first year as a commentator was entertaining... But man, does this guy suck now! It's insane to me how bad he is as a commentator, he makes Michael Cole look like Gordon Solie. So many glaring issues with him, always talking over wrestlers, never knowing when to stop talking, constantly yelling for no reason, his stupid dancing during Jey Uso's entrance ontop of the commentary desk, never taking anything seriously, talks over wrestlers cutting promos, making unfunny jokes, bringing an unbearable frat boy vibe that has become more and more annoying as time progresses, clearly knows nothing going on when he's calling the show, I could probably name more, but I'll stop there. All I can say is, if this is how Pat McAfee is like during the NFL when he broadcasts, then I can safely say I'm glad I don't watch football, and I seriously don't understand the love for this man."

[0.0] "The frat bro shtick coming from a dude in his upper 30s is insanely insufferable. He ruins everything I watch from Raw to College Gameday. He tries to make every match or event about himself, and I get trying to play the guy who buys into all the excitement and hoorah of gimmicks and songs, but the amount of times this dude talks over a PPV entrance alone just to steal the spotlight is astounding. Not only this, but even at certain events or interactions with wrestlers/legends you get the sense he doesn't even know when he's going too far. Like you can see everyone's body language basically saying "shut up dude" and he has no clue. Perfect example of my disdain for this guy, was when Gunther choked him out it was the funnest part of the show. Can't stand this guy."

[2.0] "is it fair to say that Pat McAfee may be one of the biggest current flaw's in WWE? truly unbearable on the mic. constantly tries to get himself over and almost talks like a parody of a wrestling commentator more than anything else. he doesn't really add anything TO the commentary thanks to a pretty clear lack of knowledge beyond the base-level talk someone who considers themselves a casual fan may be able to provide (he loves singing theme songs and just kind of saying things about people! ) which can be tough to listen to alongside his other contributions, which mostly consist of yelling. it's funny listening to him with Wade and Cole on the mic because they will often overstep him or exclusively address each other because of just how useless Pat is on the mic. really would love to see him get dropped, but he brings in money... i guess!"

[3.0] "I really don't understand the Pat McAfee hype. He just shouts and shouts and shouts and I find it exhausting. In my opinion, he doesn't contribute anything to the current WWE product and having somebody like Corey Graves in his place would make shows a lot more watchable. I can tolerate him on special occasions like a PLE but on a weekly TV show, I would much rather a calmer presence with knowledge of the stars in the ring and can contribute useful information to the viewer"

[4.0] "Pat McAfee - Started off alright (decent enough in the ring from the few matches he had) but these days his commentary is just more annoying than anything, the hyped for everything act eventually just turns into feeling a bit forced, I don't think his commentary adds a whole lot to the shows anymore"

[0.0] "I literally cannot watch WWE Programming while He's involved. He's so Bloody annoying, infuriating, unbearable, and toxic, i want to vomit when i see and hear him. I can't think of a single redeeming quality about him. He sounds like an overzealous teenage fat headed frat boy, screaming and squealing like a pig, forcing his false excitement over every little thing that happens in front of him, and performing those grating, bordering on racist blaccents, thinking he's so much cooler than he actually is, and the stooges around him cosign it and applaud him for it, because he's an ass-kissing, puppydog clown. He has no jornalistic integrity, no insight on the craft of wrestling, nothing to contribute to any show except his stupid self aggrandizing catchprases."

[0.0] "Hijacks the shows to make awful jokes and often makes everything about himself, the worst commentator in WWE history. I do not care for the banter between him and Michael Cole, I do not care that they are friends I am not here for them. He is often activated by any obnoxious chant like "What? ", "Yeet! " or any loud or animal noise. Arrogant like at the Toronto Elimination Chamber showing a sense of entitlement not just once or twice but throughout the entire show. Now they dedicate segments to him that could be spent doing anything else, I would rather them try to sell me more terrible AI generated Cody Rhodes shirts, will buying one make him go away? I don't see anyone outside of America finding him funny or endearing, not to mention those who are. The shows are better without him, he will likely leave again whenever the American Football seasons start again so thank goodness."

[5.0] "When I started watching in 2021, Pat was great. He very clearly loved the business but I am not even gonna lie, he's kinda become a jackass with the stuff he says on commentary and it kinda annoys me. He can just be such nuasance on commentary at times and he's not enjoyable to me anymore."

[2.0] "Horrid commentator. He was great in the beginning when he started commentating but he's just been awful since he's been back on RAW. A lot of it feels forced and he just starts talking about random stuff during the matches. He lets his personal feelings & self-importance get in the way of a lot of stuff (mainly referring to Chamber and the RAW after Chamber.) I mean, his little beef with Dom is funny but that's about it. Some of his jabs at wrestlers are funny but then he tries too hard and then it's just cringey. I don't like Michael Cole either but he's at least bearable most the time & I actually liked him when he was paired with Graves. But Pat is just not the guy in my opinion, again everything just feels very forced or too much with him."

[4.0] "Absolute disgrace for WWE commentary team. Absolute disgrace for all American people. Awful behaviour at the Elimination Chamber this year. Not only his commentary is very poor and unprofessional, but also he's just a very bad human. I can't stand him nowadays"

"[2.0] "Loud, obnoxious, can occasionally be funny (unintentionally usually) but mostly just gets a grimace from me. Just kind of kills the mood when a commentator is shouting in the background, heel Cole, Don West, even the legend JR could be guilty of this at times but Mark Madden takes it to a new lev-...wait, I'm not commenting on Mark Madden? But I'm commenting on an obnoxious loudmouth from Pennsylvania, who else could I be commenting on? You mean there's two of them? Jesus.""

[0.0] "Easily the worst commentator in WWE right now and this past Elimination Chamber showcased that fully. He always tries to put himself over instead of the wrestlers in the ring, and he actively cheerleads for Jey Uso or some of the other faces when they are wrestling or doing promos. His first run as commentator was good too so I don't know what happened. WWE could easily promote Vic Joseph and he can go back to doing his show or College GameDay which is obviously much more important to him. He also weaseled his and his friends way into WWE 2k24 in one of the worst DLC packs of all time. Even Booker T, who in his own right is very annoying at times, is a much better commentator than he is. Overall the product would be much better if Pat McAfee wasn't apart of it."

[2.0] "Obnoxious, loud, and self important. What the hell do the Canadian fans owe you? Maybe don't support a dude that wants to attack (possibly with the military) a sovereign ally. He thinks he's so clever with his inside terms and gets away with stuff no other announcer could. He is the perfect fit for TKO a bunch of xenophobic creeps. McAfee is someone with no introspection just hears thing and says thing no matter how uninformed the person may be (Rogan, Rodgers, etc.). Perfectly emblematic of the American electorate. He's an absolute pant load that struck lightning on his first introduction to the wrestling world. Ever since then he does little quips that Cole loses his shit over as if he's the next coming of Heenan or The Body. This dude gets high on his own farts."

[0.0] "I am absolutely not a fan of Pat McAfee in any capacity--whether it's his commentary or his on-screen persona. His style is overly loud, obnoxious, and completely distracting from the actual matches. Instead of enhancing the action, he makes everything about himself with constant yelling, forced enthusiasm, and unfunny jokes. His delivery feels more like an over-the-top podcast performance rather than someone providing insightful or engaging commentary. Beyond that, his persona just doesn't click for me. He tries too hard to be the center of attention rather than letting the talent shine. Wrestling commentary is supposed to complement the in-ring storytelling, but McAfee constantly derails the moment with his antics. Overall, I find his work unbearable to listen to, and I genuinely believe WWE would benefit from a more professional and polished voice in his role."

[0.0] "Pat McAfee on commentary is straight-up unbearable. His over-the-top yelling, constant interruptions, and forced energy make it impossible to enjoy a match. Instead of enhancing the action, he makes everything about himself, throwing out random catchphrases and acting like a fan who just snuck into the booth. He barely provides real insight, often shouting nonsense instead of calling the match properly. Wrestling commentary should add to the story, not be a distraction, and McAfee is nothing but a distraction. His jokes rarely land, and his attempts at humor feel more obnoxious than entertaining. He has no real chemistry with his co-commentators, constantly talking over them and derailing the flow. Honestly, he makes matches worse just by being on the mic."

[0.0] "Edit from giving him a 3, to a 5, now to a 0. He clearly works there to give WWE publicity, he is a horrible commentator, constantly verbally fighting with other commentators, making stupid remarks and literally getting under my skin. I'd punch that prick in the face if he talked the way he does to Wade Barrett, a complete child who can't filter what he says. I don't know how anyone can give him anything over a 5. Football, or whatever sport he cares about, season can't start soon enough. I have been watching wrestling for around 15-20 years with lots of historical watching and I have yet to see a commentator trying to make the other commentators as well as the fans mad at him more than he does. Note to myself: hopefully he's gone for good next time he leave for whatever sport he cares more about."

[4.0] "Leave the football (Wrestling) before the football (Wrestling) leaves you, that's all I'm gonna say about him, he used to be really entertaining, but year after year, he has gotten really annoying asf, especially in commentary, he is just really annoying and obnoxious, might be almost as bad as heel Michael Cole, the only good thing about him is that he is a Lyra Valkyria fan, and even then he gets really annoying when he do the woo chants alongside the crowd"

[1.0] "I realize this rating may seem a bit too harsh but ill explain, anytime hes on commentary hes either over the top obnoxious and doesnt actually know anything thats going on or hes slightly more tolerable personality wise but still just has no idea whats going on or who anyone (outside of a handful) is. I feel like its evident in all the lower/mid card matches he calls but i feel its most evident when hes calling a womens match. Also he was one of the ones that immediately jumped on the bandwagon and spread the fake story that Imane Khelif (the algerian boxer from the olympics) was a trans woman. Shes not for the record though this didnt stop him or many others from spreading it and doubling down on it. Leading to Imane getting so much unnecessary hate and trans people once again being vilified for no reason. Anyways, imbeciles like him who stoke culture wars will always leave an awful taste in my mouth combined with the fact i just dont think hes all that good of a commentator is why i rated him so low."

[1.0] "Why this dude has such a high rate here? ! Can we get him out of the commentary business? He has no charisma, a shitty personality, his in-ring skills are bad, his entrances before a PLE or TV Show start are simply unnecessary and boring, everyone is tired of this guy, I think even Jey Uso has had enough of this guy, he tries to be funny in the commentators team but he is simply being ridiculous and disrespectful to the wrestlers, even though they are heels, everyone deserves respect, even more so from a WWE member. Just boring, disrespectful, and annoying."

[4.0] "Pat Mcafee for all intents and purposes isn't a very good ring announcer, he's good in small doses, such as a special guest commentator for a pay per view but when he's on the show week after week, it gets grating and annoying incredibly fast. He's a decent wrestler for a celebrity and can be good on occasion but as a commentator who takes a weekly slot, he's not the best for a show that happens every week, and can get very annoying when specific wrestlers have matches (Roman Reigns especially.)"

[0.0] "As someone who is not American and has no interest in American football It baffles me how he gets as much tv time as he does. I hadn't heard of the guy before he appeared in the WWE but he is bad, not just in ring but on the mic as well. Constantly over positive and extremely obnoxious and ignorant is the best way to describe him. Seeing him rated highly is so confusing to me seeing only his work in wrestling and it makes me wonder if most of his love comes from his background in American football as opposed to what he is doing in the WWE. He constantly makes mistakes when commentating and it really puts me off. I enjoy commentators and such having fun but i cant stand the guy. Its clear he tries but Pat Mcafee is the worst commentator in wrestling today. So American in the most obnoxious way possible."

[3.0] "He may be a nice guy and tries to do stuff the right way. But as a commentator, it really doesn't feel right at all. I'm really bothered by many things he does at the desk. The worst thing may be when he goes Yeet with the crowd... As a wrestler, he was impressive and really tried hard to deliver, which he did during his rivalry with Adam Cole. But as a commentator, he is just low, and not a wrestling expert. I admit he can be entertaining at times, but I just don't wanna see him at a desk commenting wrestling."

[9.0] "I don't want to overreact BUT, Pat McAfee is both a hilarious personality and surprisingly affluent in-ring talent; quite literally the definition of "a breath of fresh air" when it comes to the WWE. He brings a goofiness and reliability to the product that was nigh nonexistent in the company's previous regime. His basis of athleticism was being a punter in the NFL, and his commentating skills come from his natural charisma, hosting his own show and honestly saving ESPN College Game Day from fading into obscurity. People's main complaints about him are he either talks too much or talks out of turn. There are differing opinions on whether this is a bad trait of his or not, and I'm leaning towards good because the WWE can profit off of his banter with Michael Cole and any other remark he makes, being great for business. Pat McAfee being on commentary brings an excitement and a feeling that most commentators can't harness."

[5.0] "Well his time in NXT when he faced Adam Cole and next competed in the wargames was very fun in terms of both storylines and wrestling. On the announcing team he was really fun in the beginning and has nice chemistry with Michael Cole but started iritate me quite a lot."

[4.0] "He dropped big time for me, I thought at one point in time he was an 8. With time.. yeah he's bad right now. His first run was cool, I enjoyed it, since he's returned to commentary he's been absolutely awful. Very very annoying too, his matches are cool which is why he isn't lower but.. yeah he's bad."

[2.0] "He can be very much entertaining and fans can like him but he isnt a great commentator in the grand scheme of pro wrestling. While some of his charm might be his energy and bloopers that can be entertaining it can often lead to being a negative and really gets him over more than getting whatever the main focus is over be it a match or a promo. While he is nowhere near the worst commentator in WWE history let alone pro wrestling history as a whole he could definitely still use some improvement whether that be turn some aspects down and work on or incorporate other aspects he currently isnt doing."

[9.0] "I mean, I think he's an entertaining commentator. He clearly loves wrestling, even if he comes off as a bit of a buffoon sometimes. Besides, his thick Yinzer accent makes me feel like I'm back "dahn'na Sahthside at the Smilin' Moose, n'at"."

[2.0] "The role of a wrestler is to get over. The role of a commentator is to not only help get wrestlers over, but to help an entire product get over. It's arguably the most important job in all of wrestling, so why the WWE is relying on Pat McAfee is beyond me. I have no idea how this man talks for a living because not only is he inarticulate, but he also comes off as unprepared. He knows nothing about the wrestlers or their move-sets, while often yelling out cliche garbage with terrible cadence. Example: "Gunther! He's... a calculated machine! " He comes off as that student in a group project that is completely unprepared and has contributed nothing to the group's success, yet is the loudest to try and mask his awkwardness. I used to watch Raw every week but it's just becoming harder to do while listening to this fool. I considered giving him 3 points but after hearing him call Kairi Sane "Iyo Sky" at WrestleMania, I feel comfortable scoring him as a 2."

[4.0] "McAfee is a very irritating wrestling commentator, and Raw has been much harder to listen to since his return. I don't mind when the booth has fun and jokes around, but with McAfee it's just too much and comes off as insulting to the audience. Wish he would stop talking about "6 star matches" on WWE TV, it's just not his lane and is quite obnoxious."

[9.0] "Legitimately super entertaining to me, I don't understand the hate. I have to ask all the people constantly hating on him: what's it like to hate fun? I can't imagine how unfulfilling that must be. I'm (mostly) joking of course, to each their own, but I always have loved him as a commentator. His chemistry with Michael Cole is awesome, and I think they bring out the best in eachother. And on top of that, a half decent wrestler too! Hope to see him in the ring again sometime in the future. He's no Logan Paul, but he can go, no doubt about that."

[3.0] "As a wrestler during the Kings of NXT story? He was actually not that bad as a complete novice! But as a commentator, which is his main job dear god, he sucks! The entire discourse over "googling" wrestlers who make surprise appearances doesn't make sense at first blush when you consider that, typically, a promotion's play-by-play announcer (in WWE's case, Michael Cole) will quickly give you a run-down, but then it makes more sense when you consider that typically, WWE's color commentators (e.g. Graves, Booker, JBL) have been so bad you want to mute the TV come 8pm, and Pat really is no exception."

[3.0] "All the points here are for his wrestling which has been entertaining enough in his limited spots. Unfortunately he's absolutely appalling and an absolute shill as a commentator. He puts over absolutely everything to such a degree that it's corny and exhausting. I don't doubt he's enjoying himself and plays to that but at this point it's just obnoxious the way he'll get on the table to dance to certain themes, demand Michael Cole acknowledges Roman Reigns, etc. Absolute definition of a jock commentator."

[4.0] "He's pretty avarege as a wrestler, but horrible as a comentator. I can't stand how much he always wants to be the funny guy with every coments he makes, and fails completly at that... In many moments he takes away the tension from the segment with unnecessary coments or jokes. And, sure, this might just be my personal opinion, but he's painfully unfunny. I kinda get the hype for him, since I have to admit he's really charismatic, but he's just not good enough to be every week on the show. Honestly, he's just like Jerry Lawler without the misogyny to me."

[6.0] "Young Patrick McAfee is just another guy, nothing special but such an incredible fan of sports entertainment and knows everything about WWE. Hes a guy living his dream."

[3.0] "Awful commentator. If you needed someone with exactly golden retriever energy on tv, he's your guy. He's starts talking about something going on and stops to focus on something else. He has the commentary style to match cameras changing every second. If you told me he was on an attempt to solely get conspiracy theorists on board with WWE, I would believe you given his espn show. WWE's constant temps to legitimize itself with the larger world comes at the expense of their tv production. Keep him for special events but keep that few and far between."