Emma

[5.0] "I mean she was fine? I never saw anything too crazy about her but she definitely wasn't bad from what I saw. She was just too basic and her in ring work felt a little too basic during several times..."

[3.0] "Looks like I'm in a minority opinion here and that's fine. She wasn't very athletic but she could be entertaining with promos so that's why she's not a 0. She really didn't have a lot to offer that one of her peers wasn't doing better. I found it odd that she was one of many to return to WWE on the first thing smoking when they called only to be used in the exact same way as before. I don't know what she or the other thought was going to happen. Anyone with sense can see that you have to have a few years to see if anything changes in the company. To date, very little has."

[4.0] "Emma is okay at best. Her in ring skills have not impressed me much, and I feel like her characters never really delivered either. Her comeback in 2022 was a flop, and I can't think of a moment she had outside of her return match. She was interesting in NXT and that was it."

[8.0] "Tenille is hella under rated. WWE main roster only fans might not know this but there was a time when she's was considered a top prospect for WWE and had probably the best match of Paige's career in NXT that skyrocketed her to stardom, when in all honesty it was Emma that should have been in that spot. Her Impact work helped really get rid of that main roster WWE stink she dealt with and she did better character work then she ever done in WWE. Triple H really dropped the ball on her during her recent wwe return just having her do absolutely nothing just felt like something that Vince would have done to keep her away from other promotions. Firing her on the day they announced a Australian stadium show was really slimy too, it could have been a really nice moment giving her a featured match in her home like they did with Zelina in Puerto Rico. But what is done is done. I wish Tony Khan would sign her, as AEW needs to sign more women, and at least they could run back Sarraya vs Tenille at a PPV or a big dynamite."

[8.0] "Tenille/Emma is a really good wrestler. It's a shame that WWE never properly booked her to see her full in-ring potential. Also, the less said about the "makeover to Emmalina" gimmick, the better. Hopefully, either AEW or Ring of Honor could unlock her true potential should she join one of those promotions."

[4.0] "Emma is an absolute waste of time at any day she shows up on my TV screen at a WWE event. OK at other promotions though."

[7.0] "Emma has been great outside of WWE but her main roster WWE runs have been lackluster. NXT and Impact showed her potential with good in ring work and really good mic skills. In WWE she has been stuck with bad gimmicks that don't allow her talents to show."

[7.0] "Emma is so damn underrated in WWE. In NXT, she was someone really important, her rivalry with Paige sparked the "women's revolution" and had the potential to be an inseparable part of the women's division - just like Becky and Charlotte. But WWE never put her on the podium, she never got her hands on the championship. Instead, she was thrown into random tag teams and missed gimmick changes (Emmalina...). I hope that her return from autumn is not pointless and will finally reach for gold, because after so many years hardly anyone deserves it as much as she does."

[6.0] "Emma has always been interesting to me. I never really followed her in WWE until recently, mostly because I didn't feel like she was worth following. In Impact, she has shown that she has some ability and talent, and I sorta liked her partnership with Kaleb, although the Influence and her Knockouts Tag Title reign was kinda mid. Now that she's back in WWE, and in this weird storyline with Madcap Moss, I'm slightly excited to see what's next."

[10.0] "One of the pioneers of the women's revolution in WWE. She was Asuka's best opponent since her debut. She's a goddess when it comes to taking hits and can be good with any gimmick she adopts."

[7.0] "Pretty good in the ring, could use with a bit more character but she can also add some comedy and fun to her persona so she's well rounded enough to make it work"

[6.0] "Pretty poorly utilized during her time in the WWE but despite that I don't see the hype in her run in Impact."

[8.0] "A very underrated wrestler. She is very good in the ring. WWE could have done something big with her but they still gave her boring storylines like Emmalution or his dances with Santino. In NXT she was much better booked."

[5.0] "Just never really kicked off anywhere. While she has the claim of "innovating" woman's wrestling in WWE to what it is today (which it wasn't) she's really got nothing worth talking about beyond her matches with Paige, just really weak and got noticeably more so when the Horsewomen and the likes of Asuka were in the ring with her. Nothing heel work and boring as a face. She's certainly not the worst of her era but she's not really close to being very good either."

[3.0] "She was so uncatchy and felt like I'd seen her in several previous divas, and I believe she wasn't meant to attract audiences above the age of ten! She wasn't sexy or consistent either, thus her time in the spotlight was shortlived."

[7.0] "Emma was one of NXT's original female projects & she had a degree of success as the bubbly, quirky babyface. But in typical WWE fashion, they took that identity too far, especially when they paired her with Santino & gave her a pink sock puppet to use. Her heel work has mostly been rather uninspired & the "all about me" gimmick feels as basic as you can get. She's good in the ring & pretty to look at, but I think it's safe to say she's in the twilight of her career & she may be remembered as not achieving as much as many thought she would have."

[4.0] "I wasn't watching WWE when she was there, so I can only go on Tenille Dashwood's time in Impact, which hasn't really been impressive. Her ringwork is adequate but nothing special, and her character is pretty one note and repetitive. She's not awful, but I haven't really been impressed at all."

[4.0] "Tenille is a clear example of when your career as a pro wrestler ceased to matter to you a long time ago and is now just a hobby."

[3.0] "I thought that WWE had wasted a very talented wrestler, but I was wrong, the truth is that I think she has not done anything remarkable since her departure from the company and now that she is in IMPACT WRESTLING I feel that her work is mediocre, maybe she lost the love for this sport... only she knows."

[9.0] "Tenille Dashwood has a unique good moveset, great character work if she finds the right story (made so much out of Evil Emma) + a clean and save ring technique. Very likeable wrestler. Her WWE run was unfortunately very unlucky, always in the wrong place at the wrong time, she got very rare spots. The few times in NXT she got a chance, her work was great. Even the dancing Emma, most known for her matches with Paige, was nice till it got on the main roster completely run into the ground as the sidekick of the Marella sidekick. Would have loved to see more from Evil Emma, at least Takeover London 2015 and some other great non-ppv performances stay in memory. Post WWE she had initially a promising indie run with good matches, but with the complete disinterest of Roh about their womens division and an injury that needed surgery also again terrible luck. I hope Tenille can heal further up from the surgery and find after the covid-pandemic back to her strength."

[8.0] "She had great moves. Unfortunately she took a hiatus in her WWE tenure. We never saw her Emmalina gimmick."

[8.0] "Emma is a really great wrestler but many people don't know that because she was booked like a joke on WWE's main roster. Check out her match with Asuka to show how good she is. Passable on the mic and played heel or face well. It's a shame that WWE put a nail in her coffin with the whole Emmalina fiasco but I hope she can find success in another promotion."

[8.0] "I'm very happy that she left WWE. Creative really had nothing for her and the Emmalina gimmick would have been dreadful. Really hope she stays with ROH for a while. Could even see her being a dominant part of Impact in the future."

[7.0] "Seems to be getting her rhythm back since starting with ROH earlier this year. She looks more motivated than she had been for years. Her presence appears to be a shot in the arm for Women of Honor which had a pretty lacklustre 2017. Just don't understand her "it's all about me" gimmick which carried over from her final months in WWE. It doesn't really say much and is kind of bland."

[10.0] "Often overlooked, but she started the women's revolution with Paige. It's a shame that she is far more talented than most of the 4 horsewoman but was seen as nothing more than a joke for most of her time in WWE. Your could tell she always tried her best, which saved her from theach terrible WWE booking. Emma is the standard of what a woman in wrestling should be, hopefully ROH recognizes this and rewards her accordingly."

[8.0] "Emma is a great wrestler it's sad how bad WWE treated her and in fact one of the two along with Paige who started the women's revolution on NXT, I wish things could be different with her and she became a champion and a hell of a heel on main roster with that now only on my dreams but I really wish that this new start for her to be the best time in her carreer on the indies."

[7.0] "I feel bad for emma. She is actually good. However, wwe never takes her seriously. What a disaster her wwe career is ! She debuted on main roster with shitty dancing gimmick and was paired with santino marella then got released because of misunderstanding stealing in shop. She then was hired back and sent back to nxt. Re-debuted on MR in 16 then injured herself again. Everytime she got chances, she got bad luck. Honestly, i don't think she is as good as 4H or asuka, but she definitely deserves better. Hope she will be lucky outside wwe."

[7.0] "It's a shame WWE wasted so much time on the whole Emmalina shtick, she deserves better than that. Hopefully now that she's back as Emma, she'll get some type of push, she's really good in the ring and her heel persona is good as well."

[9.0] "Emma has to be the most underrated woman in WWE. I was never big on her when she was a face and during her initial babyface run in all honesty, but ever since turning heel she's been fantastic. Much improved look, good promos, fantastic heel character, perfect mannerisms and super crisp in ring work. In particular her match with Asuka at NXT London was a highlight. Emma is awesome."

[8.0] "Emma has a good gimmick now. I think she is the most underrated diva in WWE right now. She really has a good future."

[7.0] "Emma, at the time of her debut, was one of the most skilled technical wrestlers in the women's division. Honestly, she still deserves a lot more respect than she gets; she's a good mat grappler with a real sense of psychology. Her booking on the main roster was just awful, but honestly, it paid off in the long run because it got her back to NXT. There, she showed better promo skills and charisma than she'd ever previously exhibited. Talk about an effective heel turn -- it raised her rating in my book substantially by allowing her to show off her acting abilities and her viciousness as a submission grappler. She may not be quite charismatic enough to headline the division, but she certainly deserves her place in it, and she's definitely an asset to the company."

[8.0] "She is so underrated and so overlooked by WWE it's ridiculous. Her match with Asuka at TakeOver: Respect just proves that. That was the match of the night. No one thought Emma would be a threat, but she got in some solid offense that match and made it really intense. She is a really, really good heel, and a very likable babyface. I don't know why she isn't getting called back up to the main roster."

[7.0] "A very good technical wrestler - as you'd expect from a Lance Storm trainee - Emma's path since joining WWE has been a bit of a mixed bag, through no fault of her own. After developing a likable babyface act in NXT, she was brought up for a misguided run on the main roster before being shuffled back to developmental. There she's revamped herself with a heel gimmick and seems to be coming more into her own as a personality. Whether she'll make it back to the main roster or not remains to be seen, but regardless, she's a talented wrestler and a great-looking girl, and will doubtless put on great matches along the way."

[6.0] "I only see Emma achieving limited success in the WWE. She may never get called back up but that is not her fault. She is fundamentally a really sound worker but she is lacking that extra something. I feel that Emma gives to much in the ring and really helps elevate her opponents more then anything. Her heel work is very good though and she owns the bad girl gimmick."

[7.0] "Emma's not an impressive wrestler, but she does her job well. I wasn't surprised when she was picked up by WWE as she serves the "look" that they were going for at the time, matched with some experience under her belt. While she'll probably never be fantastic, she seems to work well with what she's given."

[7.0] "Emma is one of the more underrated women on the WWE's female roster. She's a good wrestler and has a natural likability about her. Her original run in NXT along side Paige and Summer Rae was crucial to the success of women's wrestling in WWE. Of course the Main Roster ruined her on arrival as she was immediately pigeon-holed into the comedy jobber role when she was assigned to be Satino Marella's girlfriend. Now that she's back on NXT as a heel, maybe she'll be able to fully recover and hopefully, someday revamp her Main Roster career."

[5.0] "Only an okay worker, not really getting through to me in promos. Her heel persona is better than the dancey thing she was doing but for the time being I'm not fussed."

[6.0] "Emma is known for being the first Australian female to get hired by the WWE. Not an easy feat, but ever since her shoplifting incident back in June of 2014, Emma has been stuck in the doghouse and will likely be stuck there for the rest of her career. Let's hope otherwise this will change."

[8.0] "Very talented worker, I'm glad she's starting to break out of that comedy gimmick and showcase more of her wrestling ability. One of the best mat technicians in the division no doubt. She could become a dominate force in the division in months to come, great all around worker and arguably the best on the main roster despite . ot showing it."

[5.0] "I like Emma she has some great matches on NXT but on the main roster her matches have been ok or rubbish. Her matches are 3 moves matches (the dilEmma, emmamite sandwich and Emma lock) . She has become lost in crowd and hasn't stood out among the rest of the divas. I blame wwe's booking of her. She should be 1 of the best divas in wwe today but she's not, sadly. Hopefully she can be in 2015"

[9.0] "She was one of the best female wrestlers in WWE, sad she got released for... stealing an iPod phone case? what? ... whatever, she had awesome matches in NXT sadly WWE put her with Santino Marella killing all her chances in the main roster."

[7.0] "Neat wrestler with an interesting gimmick. I'll have to see where things are taken from now on, but I'll definetly keep an eye on her as a singles competitor."

[8.0] "A very good and funny diva. She'll do great things in the main roster."

[10.0] "The Best woman in NXT. Go to the main roster, Emma, GO!"

[8.0] "I've really been so impressed with how far Emma has come along from starting out on NXT as a nobody to becoming somebody in the divas division and one of the top 2 female wrestlers on the NXT roster currently in my opinion! Wrestling wise, there's no doubt that Lance Storm taught her well cause this girl can wrestle, she's good with submissions, and with the right female talent she can put on a very good and watchable divas match! Character wise, when Emma started out with her dancing gimmick last year, at first I thought her character was terrible and I bet you a lot of other people felt the same way but to my surprise, within a short amount of time, she got her character over with the people and ever since then, Emma has drastically improved more and more and has continued to get herself more over than she already was before! She's even improved on her promos too! In the beginning her promos were all comedic and basically whatever, but now she's gained a side to her where she's starting to have a bit of an attitude which has made me start caring about her more and I like that a lot!"