Sarah Logan

[0.0] "She's horrendous at just about everything. I saw her as the worst member of the riot squad and I think I was pretty spot on. She's got the charisma of dry paint and can't even put an average match. I don't think I've seen her cut a promo in years which is an issue considering she was literally the manager of a tag team. Her work as valhalla was very bad and only held back what I think is a pretty good tag team. Her most recent gimmick was having antlers that got Michael Cole to be excited whenever she worn them. That's pretty bad if you ask me, even if it was somewhat funny during a few times."

[8.0] "Definitely deserved a lot more of a push and crfedit for her work as Valhalla, but even before that sarah logan showed a lot of promise and it's a huge shame that she's no longer in WWE, as she's someone who can add a lot to any women's divison she's in"

[3.0] "I dont know why is Sarah in WWE, she didnt do anything in NXT, she didnt do anything in Riott squad and she didnt do anything as Valhalla aside from a brief feud with Maxine. Was that the peak of her career a 3 matches feud with Maxine... ooof. She's definitely not bad in the ring, she's just weird and they dont use her. And back when she got signed as Crazy Mary I was so excited and happy she joined NXT."

[1.0] "She's neither a good manager nor a good wrestler. She lacks charisma, personality, reality and in-ring ability. There's nothing driving or impactful about her, and when she's not annoying, she's a pain. Her stint in the Riott Squad gave her a platform and allowed her to melt into the group, offering what she had to offer. The dissolution of the latter left her no chance to shine, if she was even capable of doing so (which I seriously doubt). Her Valhalla character is caricatured and so naive it's heartbreaking, if not totally off the mark."

"She seemed to have some potential back in her Crazy Mary Dobson days, but she's consistently been at the bottom of the pack in every faction and program she's been involved with since getting on television. Her current incarnation has a striking entrance, and she's generally a decently charismatic physical presence, but that of course does not negate the fact that she's been a bad promo forever and a notably subpar in-ring worker for as long as she's been around in WWE."

[7.0] "Very good indie wrestler but went to WWE and got buried just like many other indie talent to be jobbers"

[0.0] "She was marginally better as Sarah Logan but even then she was the least interesting member of the Riott Squad. She was never in a match where I thought she had the skills and potential to be at the top of the card. She can't cut a promo either so that removes the two most important aspects of being a successful professional wrestler. Now she's called Valhalla which is where Norse people go when they die so, interesting choice of name. It would be just as weird being called Heaven. It's very generic. She also chose to go barefoot even though historically Viking women wore almost the same type of footwear as the men. Oh, she has an antler hat even though Vikings aren't believed to have worn anything like that or helmets with horns on them. So now she's not only a boring wrestler, she's not even historically accurate in her appropriation of the culture."

[1.0] "'Valhalla' was better as Sarah Logan and even then she wasn't that great. Sarah had the potential to be a beast with her strength and wrestling skills but they were wasted. She did a nice job in her role as the powerhouse of the Riott Squad, but once they disbanded she kinda just got forgotten about and was always the third wheel for that group anyways. It would've been nice to see Logan & Morgan hold the tag titles together at one point, but that's in the past. Her work currently as Valhalla is alright, I think she should stick to the manager role as all the matches since her return have been bad. She can be an intimidating and strong force in the division if they decide to make her a full time wrestler again, they'd just have to give her a re-packaging because the current product isn't really doing it."

[5.0] "Logan was good in the ring. She never had the mic skills or charisma, but she was very good in the Riott Squad. Her second WWE run as Valhalla has been poor as she only competes in battle royals or with Maxxine Dupri"

[1.0] "She was acceptable as Sarah Logan, even if not that great. I never liked the Riott squad and found absolutely no point in them. She can be passable in the ring but I don't think she also got any good match in her life. Valhalla is...something. Edit: I watched back some of her matches from 2019 and WOW! I never realized how BAD she was. What was I thinking giving her a 3? She's slow, just does the most basic things and even as Sarah Logan she had nothing going for her, even when she was on control of her matches"

[2.0] "She sucks. Her not being the lowest rated member of the riot squad in fact being tied with Ruby is disrespectful to both Ruby and Liv. She was probably good at one point, but she hasn't been good in years at this point."

[4.0] "seemed solid enough in the ring but largely forgettable, and had a generic look, will probably be more suited for indys than big promotions if she tries wrestling again. Update: she's back and an interesting new gimmick but she's been kept away from the ring for now."

[5.0] "Pretty mediocre, her new gimmick is weird, she's just always been fodder in the locker room unfortunately, not great in the ring or on the mic"

[5.0] "Average in the ring, did not stand out at all on the women's roster given that many other superstars were far ahead as far as wrestling is concerned. Terrible look and not a good promo by any means"

[2.0] "Just no, she wasn't a good wrestler. He never had a good gimmick and didn't provoke any kind of reaction from the public. In addition to extreme desire to sleep while she was in the ring. She shouldn't have returned, many names deserved to return in her place."

[3.0] "An extremely ordinary and subpar wrestler with no memorable events. What she do in the ring is not interesting, and she doesn't have much microphone skills. She was the weakest link in the Riott Squad."

[10.0] "My favorite out of the Riott Squad. She had a unique look, and a uniquely charismatic presence. I really hope after the Royal Rumble this year she comes back to wrestling full-time! When I first started watching women's wrestling, she was one of my favorites."

[3.0] "The weakest wrestler in the riot squad. A very ordinary in-ring. His gimmick worked fine with the riot squad but his gimmick didn't work solo. She was doing okay in the riot squad but solo she was boring."

[2.0] "In her 9 year career, Sarah Logan just didn't wrestle long enough to accomplish much. Her time in WWE was largely uneventful, really being the third wheel of the Riott Squad. All the best in retirement!"

[5.0] "Logan is a young talent with early experience in Indy extreme matches. Not afraid to land on her own skull in order to give fans their money? s worth, she lives sold well, throws stiff shots, bumps theatrical and has great facials. Unfortunately, the facials she has mastered are the faces of a complete loser. In the annals of wrestling history, no wrestlers have been given a more ignominious send off when being fired for real than Sarah Logan in Feb 2020. After a year spent crouching, squatting, leaping and losing as a member of the Riott Squad (racking up a main roster record of 11-152 with no televised singles wins), she was subjected to a shameful send off at the hands of Bayzler. The Dale Wolfes and Steve Lombardis of the world were jobbed out hundreds of times but I do not recall anyone ever being forced to cry like a boy with an unusually low threshold for pain who just took a front-back kick to the satchel. Wins and losses matter, and The Riott Squad were the Washington Generals of the WWE. The cumulative efforts of all three were so lacking that they were not even a credible threat to a Natalya, a middle aged mid carder. In a ? real? sport, Logan could not be permitted compete in the ring as she was completely unable to defend herself. And the Riott Squads efforts at cheating always backfired, demonstrating how they were booked as being mentally deficient as they were physically weak. Why were they booked as being weak in body and mind? I think we have a good snapshot into how Vince views alternative lifestyle looking women who are outsiders and not cut from the mold he likes. He views such women as pathetic cretins, too foolish to comport themselves properly and improve their appearance, too puny to compete with their betters. If it is was worth Vince? s time, I? m surprised he didn? t book Logan to lose get squashed in the center of the ring by 12 year old beauty pageant winner. Perhaps a flying cross body where she crashed into the ground like a heap of garbage could serve as her lone high spot, driving home the point that she is being booked as an incompetent. After being overpowered, dominated and outsmarted by a more conventionally beautiful child, who could then spit in Logan? s face and slap her until she cried again, the fans could pelt Logan with rocks and garbage before before the child overpowered her once again, stuffed her into a garbage can and kicked it into the arena dumpster. That is not fantasy booking. This how weakly Logan was portrayed during her WWE. Sadly, this is her story until she has a chance to redeem herself. But it won? t be easy. WWE wrestling storylines may lack continuity but fans still have to view wrestlers as a credible threat. After a year of getting clowned, they will need a pretty good explanation as to why we need to take her seriously the second time around."

[3.0] "Alright wrestler but least interesting in riott squad. Character is cringe and the howling is bad. Shame she got released I would have like to have seen her with the Viking raiders. Hopefully she does well on the indys."

[9.0] "I, like many others, slept on Sarah Logan for a long time, and man do I regret it. Her moves are not the most unique, but they're certainly very solid and she performs them quite well. I do think that with some more practice and working on mic skills, she might have a hug potential. Some people are mad that she was the first to defeat Ember Moon in the Main Roster and the one who eliminated Asuka in the Women's Battle Royal, but I'm glad it was Sarah the one who accomplished this, and not an overrated, less talented superstar."

[6.0] "I like the Sarah Logan character more than the Crazy Mary one. But Sarah has been greatly misused since joining the main roster. She pretty much went straight from developmental to the main roster, so unfortunately she really did not get any significant time in NXT. The Riott Squad is terrible. I know the girls are friends in real life, but as far as television goes, they do not mesh well at all. I like Sarah with the sort of woodsy woman character, but WWE has not flushed that out whatsoever. Now she's stuck in the Catering Division with no signs of being used. She not my favorite, but she could be an asset to a thin women's division, but I'm not sure Vince will ever see her as a worthwhile investment."

[9.0] "Sarah Logan is about a solid of a female wrestler as he can get. Unfortunately, I feel that WWE is aware of her in-ring presence and she may be stuck putting people over, I kind of like Natalya. On the positive side, that means she'll probably have a job with WWE for years to come. Personally, I like her work quite a bit and she's someone that doesn't botch very often. She's someone that could handle having a title."

[6.0] "I try update wrestlers rating every year , so i don't think about their past , i just think about their 1 last year , i know promotions can make wrestlers years worst or awesome too but it is what it is..... So at 2018 till now Sarah Logan was fine , but she need practice more about her in ring skill and promos."

[5.0] "I have no interest in her in ring work. He promo skills are bad and see no appeal to her character work."

[6.0] "I do feel Sarah could survive in WWE, but I doubt she can survive alone. From what I have seen, she and Liv Morgan are an odd-ball pair but it works. Keeping her with Logan or possibly having her work as a manager for the War Raiders if they're ever called up is a possibility. Her on her own wouldn't work."

[5.0] "I enjoyed her matches when she has good opponents. I didn't enjoy her performances, when she is around not so good opponents and partners. Overall I Sarah Logan her as a solid performer that will neither screw things up nor elevate things into magic."

[4.0] "Making her names on the indies as Crazy Mary Dobson, Sarah Logan has always had an element of strength to her style and it compliments her well. She also had a tendency to pull some outlandish gimmicks and somehow make them work. In WWE, she's in a weird spot, she had two very bad and unintelligible promos, I'm not sure what her gimmick is other than stereotypically South and she hasn't gotten to show much in the ring. Hopefully, the Riott Squad can branch out after they've run their course."

[7.0] "I haven't seen much of Sarah Dobson, but what I've watched of hers is pretty good. She is a strong wrestler, and the fans absolutely adore her, it's her gimmick, however, that I just cannot get into. It's something different, and I don't doubt it's what got a lot of folks talking about "Crazy" Mary, it's her wrestling though, that I prefer."