[5.0] "It sure was an emotional tribute to someone who died way to soon. The match itself was perfectly fine. There were probably way more tributes in this match than I noticed because I sadly am not familiar with James Castle. I am always a bit taken aback seeing Gideon Grey in the ring because my first impression of him for me was him being a manager. But he is a solid hand in the ring who can go."
[8.0] "A lovely, heart-warming and cathartic tribute match to the late James Castle from two of his closest friends. Commentary did a good job on this one and while the work wasn't perfect, it didn't need to be."
[5.0] "Die Emotionen in diesem Match fallen mir schwer zu beurteilen, weil ich hier nie wirklich involviert war. Das Wrestling war ok, abe hier ging es klar um etwas anderes"
[6.0] "From an objective quality of wrestling viewpoint this was a good match but nothing I would remember beyond this day. On the other hand, was I to rate this match on an emotional scale, I'd probably go 8 and I can imagine how people that had more of a connection to James Castle would go even higher."
[10.0] "This match was a really lovely tribute to the late James Castle. A really emotional and great performance from both guys that Jamie would be proud of."
[10.0] "This was all about paying tribute to James Castle, to rate it as a normal match is a pointless exercise and a little disrespectful for what was being done in the ring. Grey and Magee were two of Castle's closest friends, and despite not setting foot in the ring much anymore they do a superb job in his memory. They both use moves from James' arsenal. The commentary, pre-match speeches and ten-bell salute and Gideon's incredibly emotional video on social media prior to the event about the match will all give you a feel for what an amazing person James was"
[9.0] "Two practically retired guys went at it to honor the memory of their late friend and despite me learning as I go from pre-match ceremony and commentary, they've drawn me into the match emotionally and impressed with the physicality of their match. Beautiful tribute."
"This match was in tribute to James Castle who recently passed away. Prior to the match there was a nice video tribute and a ten bell salute. Gideon and Magee were his close mates and you could see how much this meant to them both. In light of why this match exists, it would be a dickhead move to rate it as I would normally so I won't but I will say it is worth watching. Commentary will fill in the blank spots if you are not familiar with Castle and what he meant to the core roster of Rev Pro or either of these guys."
[6.0] "This was an emotional match to honour James Castle who passed away recently. Both Magee and Grey used Castle's signature moves and did a good job paying tribute to their friend. The crowd was respectable and gave a standing ovation at the end. ***"
