[5.0] "Mickie James was over here and got the crowd behind her as well. Madison did fare a bit better here than in the Genesis bout they had about a month prior. Some sloppy work here and there but, it wasn't too bad and it was fine up until the ending Madison using the brass knuckles to get the win and Madison botched pinning Mickie instead of going for the 10 count instead. Everything else otherwise was fine. It was fine but, nothing too lucrative to go out of your way to watch."
[4.0] "After their first match at Genesis i was expecting cool Last Knockout Standing but unfortunately i feel the stipulation killed the whole match. The action itself was okay but the counts were poorly executed. Concept of matches like this is to make your opponent unable to get up but they didn't use anything throughout the match that would make anyone believe they couldn't. I would've like it more if they would've used some chairs or kendo sticks but without it, it was just a standard TV match with Last Knockout Standing rules. The ending with Tara was unnecessary because Last Knockout Standing in my opinion should end the rivalry not extend it even more. Overall it was really disappointing looking at their previous match and the stipulation they had, the potential was there but nobody capitalized on it unfortunately. **"
[3.0] "Sorry, this match just annoyed me. I really hate the "faces are idiots" trope, even at the best of times, and it's on full display here. During this match, MULTIPLE TIMES, Mickie James has the match won but stops the count somehow. One time she does a crossbody that hurts her more than it does Madison. The other, she DRAGS Madison into the ring while she's hopeless on the outside, which sets up her taking a spill off the top rope. Tara comes in, gets knocked out, but Madison has brass knucks to ensure that TNA's dumbest Reign of Terror will continue for another PPV cycle."