[5.0] "[2.5*] Very fun match that the whole point was about bringing Raquel back and putting her on the match. The crowd was awesome so she had a pretty good pop on her entrance and after she won. This was sloppy sometimes but still a pretty fun battle royal."
[7.0] "I am sorry but this match was fun af. Raquel is back and unexpectedly won, I wish Chelsea, Zoey or Michin won but still Raquel is a good pick. Eliminations were a bit risky too, which I wasn't prepared for. It wasn't great wrestling but battle royals are always fun to me."
[6.0] "Didn't expect Raquel Rodriguez's return here, so that was nice. Glad she's healthier. It did telegraph the ending right away, though. Elektra Lopez and Zelina Vega did good work getting heat for their eventual match. For the love of baby Jesus, please book Vega better in the future - she's great and the crowd loves her. LaRae and Hartwell are back to being fodder. Stark and Bazler looked good but are still booked weirdly. Another weird choice to bring back the Nattie/Tegan Nox thing when they tagged together not too long ago? I guess that's just a beef for battle royales. Still, nice to see Mia Yim make the final four. Chelsea Green had me hooting and hollering. Rodriguez isn't the best choice for the chamber, but is definitely an understandably safe one. This was fine, continued some stories (however confusing some of them are), and re-established a dominant, returning star."
[7.0] "Good battle royale. Honestly thought there were multiple potential winners in this match. Nothing bad in this match that I saw and good win for Raquel although there were more exciting choices in the field."
[6.0] "fun yet in retrospect predictable. Jade ended up not being in elimination chamber so they needed someone with a similar build/move set. its a nice return for her as well. but I cant say I'm not disappointed it wasn't Michin or Zelina Vega."
[5.0] "A decent battle royal. This was for the last spot in the Elimination Chamber. Raquel made her return, nice to see her back. As is the case with every battle royal, it's a big blob of people just hitting each other and someone gets tossed unceremoniously. Raquel dominated and they did tell a story with Shayna and Zoey working together to get to the end. They were the last ones in and Raquel managed to eliminate them both. That looked like the end of the match, but Chelsea ran back in and tried to sneakily win, but Raquel was too smart for that and easily threw her over. Probably didn't need the last part, other than that this was perfectly fine and entertaining enough with the right winner. 5/10"
[6.0] "Average looking Battle Royal with the most predictable result since Raquel appeared. Chelsea Green is someone that is impressing me so much more with her in-ring storytelling than with her segments. She is milking the hell out of her participations and is making herself really noticeable and entertaining. Ivy Nile had also a great performance, lasting until the last minutes and having a good moment beating up both Shayna and Zoey, who were the main antagonist of the match by working together until the very end. Maxxine Dupri being eliminated so quickly was a bittersweet moment, as she being the first one out makes sense since she is so green and they made that part of her character, but I think it's time we see some progression from her and some better bookings for the Alpha Academy and the War Raiders in general. I think sending her to work matches in NXT could do wonders for her. Battle Royals are always easy fun, but I would've appreciated some unpredictability despite keeping Raquel as the winner, making someone look like she could actually win. (***)"
[5.0] "[3.0*] The battle royal was dominated by Raquel Rodríguez, who was built to be very dominant in this match, the eliminations weren't that exciting or creative but the ending was enjoyable and overall the match was decent."
[6.0] "A solid Battle Royal here, but nothing particularly special or memorable, in my opinion. I was thinking Jade Cargill would show up in this, but I'm not upset or anything about her not. I also thought that maybe Hartwell would get the win and get to wrestle in Australia, but I'm not mad at Rodriguez. I just feel like WWE is kind of screwing over people like Hartwell and Bronson Reed in a way."
[6.0] "It was a decent Battle Royal, I wasn't expecting Raquel's win but I like that they're bringing her back into something interesting like Elimination Chamber wrestling. That said, it's not that it's super remarkable, beyond some acting, but it was a decent fight as I said before."
[6.0] "This large Battle Royal suffers from the format of that type of match and the lack of star power. When the line-up was complete, it was pretty clear for me that Raquel would win in her comeback as none of her competitors has been build to be credible to beat her. Though, it was a cautiously written Battle Royal with quite a lot of story being fueled (Zelina vs Elektra, Tegan and Natalya, etc.). Raquel has a strong showing (clearly better that all she had in 2023, even when she challenged for the World title ...) and Chelsea coming back right at the end was a nice spot for her. 6/10."
[7.0] "Fun matchup that helped multiple storylines. My only worry was before the match about who can win this. My only guess was Indi to go and have spot in her home country but wasn't sure because everyone else in the Chamber match is highly more established then her. Thankfully Raquel came to aid and won the whole thing and this made her more than anything she did before her injury. She dominated the match sensibly, Zoey & Shayna looked great and stood out as the possible challengers fornthe future as always. Vega and Lopez got more heat for their ongoing angle, Chelsea is becoming more and more popular everyday and her push is coming as they showed this night again. I really liked Ivy, Alba and Isla's performances apart from the others as they put great athletics and action to this. Other talent did no harm and gave their best unlike the Rumble and that was a plus for this match too."
[7.0] "This was a very nice Battle Royal a ver great surprise with Raquel coming back and winning I also really enjoyed Chelsea Green going all the way until the end it was really fun. The last four not including Chelsea where the right ones Shayna and Zoey are badasses Zoey deserves another rub at the title soon. And Michin has gotten so much better in the past few months. Ivy did great to. Hope they do something with B-Fab she has been working hard with Nattie. And let Zelina and Elektra go at it one on one soon before the Faction match at Mania."
[7.0] "A very solid Women's Battle Royale Match and we saw the return of Raquel Rodriguez who eventually won the last chance Battle Royale to punch her ticket in the Women's Elimination Chamber Match in Perth, Australia. There was some women who shined like Indi Hartwell who I wanted to win so she can wrestle in her home country and it was cool to see Chelsea Green be the runner up for the match as well as Zoey Stark being in the final three. I'm glad Raquel Rodriguez is in the match as the Women's Elimination Chamber Match is super stacked I can't wait for that match."