[5.0] "[2.5*] I enjoyed this match more than Sammy vs Ricky. The quadruple suplex spot was very good and despite the action being kinda slow and sloppy sometimes it was actually a lot of fun and I enjoyed very much the finisher sequences until Anna Jay got the win for Brodie."
[5.0] "Beside of the incredible suplex spot, not a lot of interesting things about this match... it was just an average showcase with some cool things, pretty acceptable for me. It's great that Anna Jay got the pin - {**1/4}"
[3.0] "I'm kind of consistently amazed that people can be like "well, this match didn't really have anything interesting happening in it, so I am forced to ONLY give it a 7 out of 10." This match didn't really have anything interesting happening in it, so I'm giving it a 3. Some matches are just 3's."
[6.0] "Matches like this where everything and everyone keeps moving do a lot to hide the weaknesses of the greener members of the roster. There are things in this match which I think would stand out a little more in singles matches, but for what this was, I thought it was actually okay and didn't drag. Skye Blue screaming in pain during a rear naked choke finish is a bit odd, though. Even if you could scream while being choked (you can't), it wouldn't cross your mind to do so."
[6.0] "While I didn't like this as much as the 8-Man Tag Team Match earlier in the show, I still thought this was a solid match and I think, just like the Men's one, everyone involved had a good amount of time to shine and get their moves on. Much like Preston Vance earlier, Anna Jay getting the win for her team was a bit of a forgone conclusion, though it also didn't really take anything away from the match itself."
[4.0] "[2.75*] The match was a bit boring the action in the ring wasn't bad, everyone had their moment to show something but it just wasn't exciting, the end of the match was cool with everyone sharing the spot with a suplex and Anna Jay having her big moment in tribute to Brodie Lee."
[9.0] "I liked this 8 man more than the men's on the same show. It was a great exhibition and display of the diversity that exists in the women's division. Lot of wrestlers of different ages, experiences and backgrounds. Everyone got a chance to shine, the pacing was great, and the crowd was hot for all of it. There were two really great parts. FIrst being the 8 women suplex which popped everyone. Second, there was a 50 second exchange where each woman hit the other with some of their better moves and that was all well done. An enjoyable match."
[5.0] "5.5 - They did an eight-woman suplex spot and Julia Hart went to the wrong side, one of the funnier goofs I've seen in a long time but it did take away from this division showcase. The finish spotlighting Anna Jay was great, she's definitely good in a limited spot."
[6.0] "This match was a little uneven (especially in the first half) with respect to waiting for spots/strikes instead of fully committing to the sequence, but it picked up nicely and closed with some crowd-pleasing spots and a tidy finish. Willow and Statlander stood out for me in this one with their higher-impact moves, and you've gotta give Ruby credit for taking so many credible bumps in the first half of the match. The quadruple suplex was a predictable but super-fun moment that they pulled off nicely (though I got a chuckle out of seeing Julia go to the babyface side of the suplexes before quickly correcting herself)."
[5.0] "I don't know why, but this filler women matches heavily lack smoothness. The athleticism is there, the characters, the stories, but the little lapses between one sequence and the other are always kind of awkward. That's very detrimental for the match and affects the overall result, which should be much better."
[4.0] "Of fucking course this match had the spot where all the women do a suplex, does AEW know how to have a multi woman tag match without one. Outside of the closing moments this was incredibly boring."
[7.0] "Good match, everyone had a moment and it was never boring. Saraya looked good here. I really liked the quadruple suplex spot. Anna Jay winning with the queen slayer was a nice tribute to Brodie Lee."
[5.0] "The 8-woman match was decent, allowing each competitor an opportunity to distinguish themselves. Nothing remarkable came from this match, but it advanced some storylines."