[6.0] "Fine match. It was good in ring action but have seen much better from both of these talented women. Sad to see Hogan jobbing on Dark with her talents."
[5.0] "Perfectly fine for a Dark main event. Hogan hasn't really been able to define herself much since being ousted from the Baddies - this would've been helped with a bit more of a sense of where she was at."
[6.0] "Not a bad main event for a Dark show. It still wasn't anything amazing. Both competitors are capable of better. I would like to see this match up again in the future."
[7.0] "Toni since turning heel has grown on me a lot in AEW and she has been having some of the better matches on Dark recently, including one of Kiera Hogans best matches if not her best."
[7.0] "Solid, hard-hitting main event. Both of these women brought it. Very intensely competitive match. Lots of hip attacks in what would appear to be a "kiss my a$$ vs kiss my a$$" type of situation."
[7.0] "A super fun main event on Dark this week, certainly Kiera Hogan's best AEW match, maybe even her best ever. Toni Storm's heel mannerisms are coming along nicely, looking like she's annoyed she has to be there, so she might as well kill her opponent quickly. She even faked an injury to stuff Hogan's momentum. I'm convinced they're building her towards the rematch with Jamie Hayter at Double or Nothing."